Any tips on being a good mentor for junior writers?? First time having someone under my wing.

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

1. Support and develop their voice. Don’t try to force yours on them.

2. Remember, there’s always another way to say something. Even if you wouldn’t have said it that way, read the words with an open mind.

3. Give them a few chances to get it right before you step in. And, when you do step in, explain why you made the changes.

There’s plenty more. But, I’d say the fact that you’re even asking how to be a good mentor is the most important one of all. It means you care and that will take you far. Good luck!

likehelpful

^Hope my old boss is reading this

funny

So much of writing happens in the head, then we end up wondering if what we just thought up is "good enough" to verbalize.

Try to approach the page as peers, no levels, no ego. Your writer might feel very intimidated or have imposter syndrome. They might freeze. Create a safe space.

Get the diarrhea out and out of the way.

Write together. It's fun if you're jamming headlines. If time permits and you have the luxury, go over feedback together and edit together too so they can see the process live and you can hash it out.

Articulate how you approach a concept or different POVs to get to a line before you craft it. That's key to learning. The crafting comes with experience and isn't easily taught. Especially style, show by example. Yours or lines you love.

New writers tends to overthink and overwrite like new designers tend to overdesign. I've found the best tip for that is to write it two ways: super straight and what passes for "copywritten" in the writer's head. Then find the middle.

New writers will throw every trick in their arsenal on a page of long copy until it gets too cute or too much. Like ending every paragraph with a quip.

Cadence is usually fixed by reading copy out loud, watch out for too many syllables etc. Simple words.

Edit with a light touch for clarity and simplicity, not rewrite, not for style. Every writer hates having other fingerprints all over their work.

Some supervisors mark up a copy deck with so many comments and rewrite asks it gets paralyzing and crushing for the new writer.

Always always edit with changes tracked. The onus is on the writer to observe and learn, ask if they don't get it or want to push back.

If something is unclear, ask what they're trying to say. Suggest alts.

Ask what their favorite lines and phrases are. Add it to your selects if headlines are being picked by another CD. Create space for your writer's input so you don't become the sole arbiter of what passes for "good", let your writer own something and have a win.

You learn as much in the process. Mentoring helps make you a better writer too. I enjoy it greatly, nah I love it. Especially if you have a junior who's open and receptive and love language as much as you do.

I try to be upfront and transparent with my juniors. I feel a lot of this is subjective and I let them know. Style is really just personal taste.

Ultimately just as copywriters should be invisible when taking on a brand voice, you too should be invisible. You're here to polish the diamond in the rough.

likehelpful

Remember why you hired them. They have something you don’t have. Perspective. Energy. Youth. Voice. Experience. (Or an unjaded lack thereof.) Use it appropriately. I believe in “each one, teach one”, so show them how the sausage is made. Sometimes juniors have to be there to soften the beaches, but try your best not to re-write and flex on their work.

like

@creative2 — you got me there.

I make every young Copywriter/Intern start every new brand they touch with 20-25 belief statements. Not only is it a great exercise for understanding what the brand they’re working on stands for, it also gives them the opportunity to flex some creative muscle by stating these things in the most creative way possible, which 9 times outta ten ends up becoming the starting point for headlines for whatever project they’re working on. Sounds stupid, but I’ve found it super valuable in teaching young writers how to think through and communicate what a brand is all about.

like

A really big tip: make every piece of writing an opportunity to be as creative as possible. Post copy, banners, email. Those seem like throw away assignments but are great exercises for junior writers on how to make something they can be proud of out of something insignificant. Even if it’s not a portfolio piece, it can be well crafted.

I urge juniors or interns to do that. Find a way to be clever, always.

likehelpful

@CW3 — that’s why you teach them “straight & great”

Following because my agency is making me give copy feedback and teach juniors. We don’t have a creative director 😖

like

Mentor them how you would want to be mentored.

Always, ALWAYS, give rationale to why their writing should be changed. Everything should be a teachable moment.

Don’t be an asshole when editing their work. Give them the freedom to figure things out themselves, even if it’s a time crunch.

Tell them the tricks of the trade. Take them to post production so they can learn things early. Give them the opportunity to present so they get good at it.

like

Be like the mentor you had or always wish you had. I was working account management for years but a senior CW took me under her wing and taught me about her craft but always pushing me to perfect mine. It allowed me to get freelance work, hustle on agency projects and ultimately get me an opportunity to do it full time. She now co rubies that mentorship on the daily with open and honest feedback but also tells me that if I truly disagree with her that I need to convince her because that’s how I have been establishing my voice, by defending my work that I believe in. Always room for compromise but the thuggery has to be there.

like

Wear deodorant.

Don’t look for them to solve things your way. Help them solve it better their way.
#chewwithyourmindopen

when i was an intern, i wished people realized that i was completely new to things and sometimes i had no idea what they were talking about. remember to break things down as much as possible. and honestly, translate agency/work talk to english because they most likely have no idea what different acronyms mean. be patient.

Related Posts

like

What is the probability of selection if I am shortlisted for second technical round in HCL

Post Photo

Does anyone have information on what a 6th year attorney should expect as a salary range from an offer at Lathrop GMP?

like

Better to take a small pay cut (10k) to work with people I know mesh well together at a smaller start up, or stay on at a larger company with higher pay but a team that has absolutely no camaraderie and struggles to work together on the daily? Been denied a team transfer twice in 2 years, and I feel trapped, but this isn't a great time to be transitioning to a less stable position. Thoughts on what I should do?

like

Hey everyone. Are any partner/MDs/directors able to share some knowledge on the following:

i) what is the precise path to partnership after director? Is it true that typically once someone is promoted to MD, that you’re generally not on the path to partner? Ive seen MD’s make partner and ive seen directors make partner. What is the difference in these paths and why?

ii) what is the compensation range for deals Managing Director in a Tier 1 city (NYC, etc.)

Appreciate all insight in advance!

like

What’s the earliest one can get a decent offer in house? Say you’re a first year. Asking for a friend…

like

What is up with Elephant? (/Huge?)

like

Hi All,
I have two offers, please help in deciding which should I go for.

Amazon web services- 20.5Lpa+ 5lpa (singning bonus)
Cisco- 27LPA+ 4.8lpa joining bonus

Yoe-5
Profile- Cloud engineer

Thanks

like

Planning Europe trip in summer for about 10 days. Any itinerary recommendations? First time visiting the continent. Prefer cities over countryside, but not strongly. Thanks in advance!

like

What is the average salary package PA for a Salesforce Architect with 15 years of experience in India?

like

Looking for a men's watching ~$350, any suggestions?

like

My school is 100% remote for the foreseeable future. How are you keeping your first graders engaged in remote teaching?

like

I got a full time offer from the company I interned at this summer. However, I have been applying and interviewing at various consulting firms so far. Some of them I won’t hear back until September/October. Is it wrong to accept the offer and then reject it if I get a better offer? I don’t wanna burn a bridge with this company since I really enjoyed my experience there but I have to be smart with my decision since I graduate in December and need an earlier work start date.

like

4 years ago, I left Global Consulting to start my own shop. It’s been a wild ride ever since. I’m looking for strategic partners interested in strategic management and organizational development gigs.

likeuplifting

HIIT or long distance running to slim & tone?

like

What are some good resources for airline status match/challenge? I’m Elite on Turkish and I want to get matched to an US carrier.

Made a brand video for a client would love some brutally honest feedback.

like

I am too indecisive for streaming services like Netflix. I don't like picking what to watch, which is why I like having cable. I need the randomness of what's on the cable channels.

like

I feel so lost! I graduated college over a year ago and am in a job I hate, with people that don’t care, and no true direction on where I want to be next. I want to leave the company but don’t know...

like

Additional Posts in Copywriters

I’m good at conceptualising — but how can I become a better writer?
I saw some copywriting courses on ‘42 courses’. Does anyone have any experience with their courses? Or have any other recommendations?

like

Did a fair bit of copywriting before I became an AM to get my feet wet in the ad industry. Has anyone here made the switch from account service to copywriting? Continued in comments—

like

How common is it for writers to go to the video shoot they co-wrote? If they aren’t invited, and the CDs go instead, is that a leadership perk or an insult?

like

Any advice on how to go about asking to switch partners? I've only been here six months. We don't vibe and I feel like it's limiting our abilities to make great work. A month or two ago I asked them..

like

Any book or copywriting resources for an entry-level copywriter? Looking to try and learn more in my free time, whether that be through a course, website, book, etc.

like

Has anyone made the switch from agency to editorial? how did you do it?

like

Hi friends. Freelance Senior CW (7-8 years) here, currently negotiating a 2 month freelance contract at mcgarrybowen. They want my hourly rate which is always tricky in my opinion. My typical day rate is 800/day (Atlanta, Chicago). I'm thinking of saying $100/hour, but want to be competitive. Thoughts?

(For context, I have no idea whether this is for their NYC or Chicago office.)

like

Howdy writers, what’s your process for developing a TOV?

like

I spent the first few years out of school working in music before getting into advertising as an account person. Quickly realized it wasn’t for me. Busted my ass working with the creatives on the side until I was able to build a decent enough portfolio for an agency to take a chance on me as a full time CW. I think I’ll be a Senior CW soon, but it feels like most folks my age (30) have been in that role for a bit or already past it. Since I can’t turn back time, any tips for catching up?

like

Do y’all know any good podcast interviews with copywriters? Preferably some which go into their career trajectory.

like

Billboard copy word limit? 7 words is my go to but I’d love the industry pulse on what CW’s think is acceptable in terms of how many words should go on a billboard.

like

Agency copywriters (in Toronto): what’s your pivot/exit plan after agency life? Client side seems to be crap work & bureaucratic, are there other creative options I haven’t thought of yet?

Whenever I’m assigned something to write or concept, my brain just panics and shuts down. I struggle with writing the simplest things, this started happening about a year ago—long before the virus.

Does anyone have any tips on what I can do to fix this?

likehelpful

Any copywriters here working for Apple? Currently considering a role and keen to hear about any and everything - culture, WLB, comp etc

like

What are questions I should be prepared to answer in an in interview for an Associate Copywriter role? I used to be in project management, so the questions were different...

Hi! So yesterday I pitched that we take every article in our real estate magazine and basically copy and paste it into a blog section on our website. I really don’t know anything about blogs except that they can help boost SEO. Do you have any advice on how to do tweak it to be more “blog like” or is my idea ok?

like

Book recommendations for helping to re-light the fire under my ass for big ideas/remembering why you got into copywriting?

likesmart

I have an interview for a copywriter position with an Atlanta-based company this week. I work in UX and content writing so this role would be a pivot for me. Any advice to prepare?

like

Currently at an agency I don’t like, but the work is fun (although uninspiring). Have an offer at a much better agency, but the work would be with a traditionally un-fun client. Do I make the jump?

Anyone here ever written a white paper? How common is it in our industry?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal