{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Anyone have experience shifting from brand strategy at a creative agency to a PR shop? Would you do it again? Pros and cons? (note: options on the table include Edelman and Zeno Group)", "post_id": "60f86a4f36932800223c28e5", "reply_count": 4, "vote_count": 3, "bowl_id": "58eed54c016cce0010bbe9fa", "bowl_name": "Strategy & Planning" }

Anyone have experience shifting from brand strategy at a creative agency to a PR shop? Would you do it again? Pros and cons? (note: options on the table include Edelman and Zeno Group)

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Not all PR agencies are created equal, and Edelman is the first PR/comms agency I’ve worked at, so this answer is specific to my own experience (I spent a decade at large, holding-company creative and digital agencies.) Yes I would absolutely do it again. The biggest shift is that comms and PR tends to have a slightly higher metabolism than advertising. Shorter lead times, smaller scopes, faster turnarounds. Comms clients are used to dealing with media and responding to events in real time, and the depend on their agencies to work with them at the same pace. As a strategist, you really have to lean into your comfort with ambiguity and working without having all the answers. If you are precious about process and doing things “the right way” it might not be a great fit (and I personally wonder about the implications of that for training junior strategists). Another adjustment is that Edelman is much further along compared to a few years ago, but there are lots of traditional PR pros who don’t have experience working with strategy and creative, so you will have to do more teaching and explaining of the process. The upside is that you can quickly add a lot of value by doing basic strategy tasks well. Overall I love it and would not leave Edelman for any equivalent gig at another agency. I could go on but feel free to message me if you want to chat in more detail.


Strategy is undervalued and often pointless because PR has a limited set of tactics it uses to solve client briefs.


I switched from a brand consultancy to an experiential agency, although not the size and stature of Edelman but I've heard strategy in PR shops is similar... You don't have much time for it, and all the account people often act as strategists and creatives. It can get very messy... On the other hand, this can also be fun.


Not personally experienced but I have heard that strategy at PR agencies is different and it can be hard to switch back into a creative shop. I’ve seen this topic pop up in different bowls every now and then

Additional Posts

18 months into my first role at a Big 4, had a great first year, but recently my PML has become a stressed hot mess and is treating me like garbage (+3 weeks). What are my options if this keeps up?


Friend didn’t get promoted (actually a friend) and is now trying to switch to another big 4 to get the promo. Ideas of reasons to give for making the switch?


So i have sent an email stating the counter offer for Cognizant. For salary revision Havent heard anything from hr? Anyone having experience on this?


Been working for 4.5 yrs, at my second consulting firm. I really want a to ask for raise &when I look at other firms the comp convos are $15-$30k+ where I’m at. I’m not ready to switch firms - CONT


TFW when you dash 34 gates at DTW and make your flight by 60 seconds 🙌👍🍾


Can anyone provide compensation expectations for M1 in the EY Los Angeles office in the People Advisory service line. Currently 3yrs senior consultant, MBA, 8 YoE. Thanks!


Looking for exit as data analyst/data engineer in a tech company in the DFW area. Anyone has any insights

http://nypost.com/2017/07/11/man-checks-single-can-of-beer-as-luggage-on-flight/.. just checked in a loose bottle of soda on Delta flight, will it make it 2 flights??


MBB folks at Google Cloud S&O- how do you like the work? Is the work too much Ops focused?


Stayed at a Marriott last week. Booked using United points (had a bunch I needed to use). Will I get points or the nights for the stay?


Unpopular opinion: I think an MBA is a waste of money for practising lawyers. Let me run before I get fishbowl stoned to death 😂😂. FYI - for those who might want to attack me for lacking an MBA. It's true, I don't have one. But actually have 2 postgraduate degrees in Law.


I am applying for a job at a consulting firm and it seems like the role I am applying for is a step down for me. I am really interested in moving from my current organization but wondering if I should first go through the process for the role advertised and then try to elevate it or rather bring it up front during the initial discussions with HR/hiring manager. Thoughts?


I currently work at a very ”hyped” food delivery tech company. I’ve been there for 1,5 years now, but the pay is low, bad company culture and I don’t feel appreciated for the work I do. So i’m overall not to happy there, and looking for a new job. However every interview I’ve had so far ask why I want to leave such a ”great” company after less than 2 years? I don’t want to shittalk my job but it’s really makes me feel like i should stay another 6m just so I don’t look bad. What would you do?


Nyc 🐠- I am looking for a civil surgeon to complete the immigration medical exam. Any pointers for a cost effective option in NYC? Also, I don’t have my immunization records and guess i will have to undertake all the shots again 😩 Last thing I want to do is go into a medical facility during Covid but here I am.

Are you supposed to exhaust your PTO if you get covid?

Hello. What's the best agency so far to go to when it comes to diversity and actual inclusion for a POC creative? Im pretty done with POC creatives being put on banner projects and the white teams getting the bigger stuff.


Can i expense airbnb if I choose to stay there?


I am planning to put my papers without any offer, and then look for offers in the next 3 months. Is it a right decision? Please guide me on this 🙏🏽


To the Big 3 and Big 4 consultants who have worked in consulting 2-3 years after undergrad: If you were to exit into an 9-6 industry role, what kind of base salary would you need to consider leaving?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or