{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Anyone successfully negotiate their salary with Uncle D after receiving an offer from another firm? Or unsuccessfully?", "post_id": "586d84c61bd904001283b405", "reply_count": 10, "vote_count": 3, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting" }

Anyone successfully negotiate their salary with Uncle D after receiving an offer from another firm? Or unsuccessfully?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Was earning 98k as SC, got offer for 140, and I got bumped to 135. But they also REALLY wanted to keep me

like

I tried it and was successful. But I was also under paid by 30% by market standards. Try to say as little as possible in the negotiation – just I got this offer, I love Deloitte but the offer is compelling, can you help make this decision easier for me? They deal with this all the time and will do what they think is best for them, which may be to give you a bump and may be to risk you leaving.

like

(By the way I realize that 135 is still low for SC)

like

Who do you negotiate with?

like

I tried this at PwC months after getting a 1 and 16.5 % raise. Partners in my practice asked to try to delay offer because they did not even have control to bump me, but were willing. In short it is a faceless shared services cabal that will likely have to approve this I would assume.

Did you guys have to show the offers you received?

No, but like D1, I also undercut base by 5k.

D1 did exactly what I did. $180k to $225k. Thinking about doing it again.

Yes, I did

The practice lead

Related Posts

Can anyone speak to the Technology Strategy Consultant role at Accenture and the Technology Strategy and Advisory practice? Is this a part of Accenture’s core strategy group? How is the comp / opportunities in TS&A? TIA

like

Former colleague received this offer: VP role; 265K base; 45% bonus; 30K cash sign on bonus; 100K RSU award at signing; 100K RSUs annually; Midwest location - technology consulting. Thoughts on this?

like

Hi all. I have offer with Capco and HCL Capco: 30.8 fixed+ bonus 0to 10%+ JB 1.5 Lakhs. HCL- 32.8 CTC. Experience:13 yrs BA(Banking-Payments) Pls suggest which one is good to join. .

like

Moving from big 4 tech implementation to boutique strategy firm for huge comp increase. Long term goal is mbb. Would this move help or hurt mba admissions and mbb recruitment?

like

1-year MBA in lieu of working worth it? Context: MBA cost is $100k (Emory), current salary also 100k. Been at the SC level under a year.

like

What salary should I expect from EY as a senior consultant / ERP implementation? 9 yoe, MBA, PMP. Thanks!

like

ACN Strat or D S&A? Comp and level are more or less the same

like

Hi Londoners, Just wondering if you aware of salary bands/what is the expected salary at Accenture Strategy and Consulting (London office) Potential Join at Cusp of Highest Consultant level/early manager promotion within 6 months. Getting varied responses from glassdoor/other people so any Insights welcome thank you :) Or If you could suggest a range I should be asking/negotiate

like

How much salary can a cyber security analyst with 3-4 yrs experience expect in TCS ( Tata consultancy services) ? #tcs #salaryexpectation #cybersecurity #security #analyst

Deloitte 🐠, I’m applying for a Consultant role in a mid/low CoL city and the recruiter asked me to set an expectation of base salary. Can you help me pinpoint what would be high/low for the C level?

like

Other than salary, what other monetary benefits we get in ibm gbs

like

Currently at Big 4 management consulting post-MBA. Have offers with MBB and FAANG (strategy). Similar comp. Which would you take?

like

I have interviews with both Facebook and Amazon. Can anyone speak to the culture and compensation differences between the two? I have a solid grasp on the Amazon comp but less clear on FB’s. Is FB also heavy equity? What about exit options from each? Are all FAANG gigs created equal?

like

Have two packages to decide between, please help My exp: 3.5 yrs as Business Analyst Deloitte US 17.2L fixed + 10% variable+ 2L joining bonus Role: Business Experience Design Consultant (Product Management- Implementation) KPMG global services 16.7L fixed + 25% variable Role: Consultant CIO Advisory (IT / Agile/ DevOps/ Enterprise Architecture/ Organizational Hierarchy/ App Rationalization Strategy)

like

S2>S3? Ratings and compensation for PwC? Anyone know anything?

like

What is expected comp for associates in LMM and MM in LCOL (Florida, Texas, Tennessee) I was told 150k all in is average?

like

Requesting sign on bonus to be converted to base? Offer 165k + 40k sign on. Can I request it to be 205k base with 0 sign on?

funnylike

What is the highest comp increase for consultant to senior consultant at Deloitte Advisory Analytics this year that people know of?

like

What’s the best approach to negotiating comp without scaring away recruiter?

helpful

You’re billing an agency at a day rate but they still make you track your hours for internal purposes. If you only work a few hours and you’re billing for a half day do you enter 4 hrs or only the 1-2 hrs you actually worked?

like

Additional Posts

I leave for vacation in a few days and instead of being excited, I’ve been crying all night. I think my mind is finally processing that Im actually stepping away from work for once.

like

which banks easily file Green Card in non technology functions? i know Morgan Stanley is one.

like

Want referral to top companies? Google / Amazon / Microsoft https://join.refspark.com?kid=1ZWP3E

like

Looking for opening in General Management or Human Resource Management . Comes with 5 years experience with real estate and project man agent company and 9 years from biotech industry . No industry preference . Open to work for start up to matured organisation . Immediately available to join . Currently attending eMDP with IIM

like

Looking for creative ideas for a healthcare technical presentation! A start up I’m interviewing for is asking to present on anything. I‘m trying to find ideas that I can present that can show analyzing data (excel) and my presentation skills. If you were to present on anything what would you chose?

like

I'm looking for a product manager role in a product company. Tech products, FinTech, Health, SCM are preferred domains. YOE: ~8(7y 10m) CTC: 12.6 Expected: 20+ I am working as a product manager in a NBFC, but it's more of a transition role(they call it PMO, but it's not a PMO role. Because I have been part of PMO previously). I want to break into a full-fledged product role. Have worked as a BA/Project Manager earlier. Any referrals would be appreciated. Thanks.

like

Hello! Any tips on entering mid/big law upon graduation. Currently, a 3L at a New York school (not top ranked), 3.17 GPA. I do have great work experience working as a state judicial law intern, member of a hybrid SA program between my school and a big-law firm, and currently as an intern working on Smart Contracts and a legal advisor to the company’s CLM team. However, its been difficult to get my foot in the door and I am worried its because of my grades. Can anyone provide some advice?

like

In a Big4 deal Analytics group that’s not premier with no path to partner... should I try to move to MBB/T2 to gain traditional consulting experience or try for tech/FAANG... I just wanna make money

likefunny

My job let’s me choose between NYC and SF. I’m a young guy - from a dating perspective is one better than the other? I know people talk about the gender inequity in SF but my sense is during the pandemic a lot of guys have moved out of the Bay Area to cities like NYC, LA etc.

like

Anyone had bronchitis after COVID? ANY suggestions to relieve the bad cough?

like

Do we know if there is a sponsoring partner that oversees this benefit/ program that I could have more of a heart to heart conversation with? Not getting too far with the general email box and admin contact. From the benefit policy documentation, my understanding is that EY reimburses employees for surrogacy / adoption related expenses up to $50k lifetime. However, anything related to IVF or medical procedures has to go through insurance (also limited to $50k lifetime benefit). Continued…

Is Finance Transformation becoming more popular in consulting? Do MBB or other consulting firms have finance Transformation teams beside big 4?

like

Does anyone know of any places in NJ that do same day covid PCR testing?

like

Anyone work at Uber and can refer a laid off consultant? Thanks in advance

like
like

Can anyone speak to the Technology Strategy Consultant role at Accenture and the Technology Strategy and Advisory practice? Is this a part of Accenture’s core strategy group? How is the comp / opportunities in TS&A? TIA

like

Decided to actual invest in tech and furniture to make WFH be more pleasant. What are your must haves for a good home office set up? I’m thinking of buying a larger monitor and a better camera. Anything else you guys love?

like

If i did two separate stays at the same hotel to do a promotion would they know?

like

Former colleague received this offer: VP role; 265K base; 45% bonus; 30K cash sign on bonus; 100K RSU award at signing; 100K RSUs annually; Midwest location - technology consulting. Thoughts on this?

like

Thoughts on using an offer from another big 4 to transfer groups within your current firm? How often does your firm tell you to just leave vs. granting the transfer?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal