{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Are demand letters ever successful? I have like a 0% success rate with them but a 100% demand to sue rate. I would hope my reputation makes it clear I will sue.", "post_id": "61e93c58b7f31700348c9bea", "reply_count": 17, "vote_count": 7, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d052", "bowl_name": "Law", "feed_type": "crowd" }

Are demand letters ever successful? I have like a 0% success rate with them but a 100% demand to sue rate. I would hope my reputation makes it clear I will sue.

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at



Depends on whether you provide the carrier with all of the needed information. As defense counsel, I love ripping plaintiffs attorneys to shreds during a mediation when I pick apart their pre-suit demand and point out all the info that’s missing and have documentation that the carrier requested the info but counsel refused to provide it.


They can be successful. It depends on a variety of things. How reasonable is the debtor and his counsel? How friendly is the underlying law? What do the contractual terms look like? I do some Landlord/Tenant practice in New Jersey. The laws tend to be tenant friendly. In security deposit cases, they allow double damages, attorney's fees, and some other enhancements, that encourage Landlords to settle.


II laugh at them and generally skip to the ridiculous demand at the end. Then I read their version of the facts and begin an investigation. Short answer though is no, a demand letter. Is rarely successful unless I was not aware of an issue and then discover a bad situation. I generally don’t care if you’re going to sue me. It’s a cost of doing business and that’s why I have a job.


Also, I’m mostly dealing with labor and employment

I don’t really have auto or premises cases or any cases under high six figure/low 7 figure value, but I rarely ever see demand letters. The plaintiffs lawyers just get all their experts/ducks in a row and sue your clients and serve discovery. They are 5 steps ahead and set the tempo

You would think that and to an extent you are right - the pi cases are just sort of cost of doing business. There will be insurance money for the PI case. But I’m actually comparing cases for the same self insured health care clients (revenues with way more than a few mill). It’s like everyone is just so angry about the little commercial spats.

No one is scared of your letter or cares about the attorney who sent it.

Only if you demand or plan on taking way less than your case is worth at trial

Oh that’s odd. I always get a response or respond myself, even if just to deny

A reasonable and well supported demand can be every effective. Itemize damages, include the law, apply facts to the law. Don’t embellish. If there’s a contract issue cite the provision that’s been violated. I’ve gotten results more than once by doing this. My honest opinion is that many lawyers don’t try to be problem solvers in pre-suit negotiations because billing a few hours to a demand letter is way less revenue than litigating a case to settlement or trial.

Just sent one out, so, please, yes. Please.

Additional Posts

Hi everyone, I am going to post an honest issue I've been having and I am hoping to get some advice. I left Amazon in July '21. I'd been there for 5 years, was being paid below market rate for my salary. I have completed so many assessments, data analytics tests, and been interviewed no less than 120x for 30-40 different companies. DoorDash, Bird, Coca-Cola, Uber, Flexe, GoPuff and plenty of others moved me forward for final interviews, but I have not gotten selected. What am I doing wrong?


What do you all think of what the best core HRIS is, Workday, Oracle, SuccessFactors...?


Are we disadvantaged for B school applications as consultants? I heard that all schools have a consultant quota, and that your application has to be significantly stronger, higher gmat etc than the median. Got 740 on gmat and concerned it may not actually be high enough... am I being an idiot?


How is KPMC project in Accenture? I'm really scared to join accenture after reading reviews? Joining at level 8 Associate manager. Skill machine learning


I’ve been working as a mortgage professional for over 3 years now and have found it unfulfilling and draining, even with the industry where it’s currently at. Would returning to school to pursue an MBA or other masters degree afford me the opportunity to make a switch to PE? Have had a few friends in PE and some in consulting say the same. Currently making 180-220k a year as a MLO, but the work is stale and looking for a potential exit. Any advice?


Staying at a few St. Regis properties for my honeymoon. First time staying there. What can you use the butler service for?


Hey guys when I joined Cognizant 9 months ago, I received a joining bonus and it was mentioned that if I leave the organisation within 1 year, I should repay it. Considering my notice period is 3 months and if I resign now, would I still be asked to pay the joining bonus?


EY folks, Interviewing with EY for a Senior Consultant in FSO enterprise risk in Tampa with 4 YOE. What should i mention as the average expected salary?


Who writes Amazon Prime video content previews. This one says: “Brad Williams possesses something that everyone can agree is funny; a disability…” Seriously?!

Post Photo

Looking for a clean, open source ppt template that I can use for a side hustle. Any recommendations?


My bonus this year was patently absurd, so I used a bit on some heat: AMM 3s, Parra Air Max 1, and the black Union 4s. Hate to let the resellers win. But at the same time I worked my ass off and wanted some kicks lmao


Sensitive topic. How often do you have sex? I have been with my boyfriend for 6 years. We used to do it almost every day at the beginning. Now, after 6 years and a 2 years old child, we are averaging once a month. We both work in consulting so we are both tired in the evening, and in the weekend our child gets all our attention. We love each other and find each other attractive, we just don’t have sex so often as we used to. So I am curious, does this happen to you too?


Twitter Pros: - worked there for 8yrs had a very positive experience (GSO supporting TCS) Cons: - bullying and toxic culture - HR is no help, ppl need to get lawyers involved (from someone within TCS)


Current role - FAAS EY GDS( CURRENT TEAM DOES NOT SUIT MY EXPERIENCE) CTC- 7,98,000 YOE- 3.5 YRS Alliant group Lp OFFERED ROLE - SENIOR ASSOCIATE CTC OFFERED- 10 L Should i switch?? Got my hike in feb 2022 in EY mid year rise


Hi Ladies, I recently have decided to try something new and was wondering if there are any part time or volunteering gigs for events planning or helping a planner with events co ordination. I tried looking online but all of them seem to be full time jobs which is not what I m looking for. Anyone have any leads or suggestions where I can look them up?


I know my path isn’t in corporate america but am struggling to find things I can do to make good money outside of it. Has anyone pivoted from corp amer to something completely different? Please share your stories.


Been offered a Recruiter Coordinator role at a company that recently acquired two other companies but is also splitting into two companies. 25% raise, contract to hire at any time, no health/pto/sick benefits until I am made fulltime. I am in a stable long term contract where I am not miserable, just underpaid. Should I make the jump?


We just had our first week of at-home school. Not sure if we will need extra help. Does anyone have any tips/advice/things that work for them?


In cities like Boston, NYC, SF etc.. where do you net out in renting vs buying? Do you find your net worth increasing faster with buying, despite the associated transaction costs, HOA, PMI, maintenance, property tax, opportunity costs etc.?


Whats actually a hydrafacial? I called up multiple places and all of them told me different procedure at different prices. Some of them had a chemical peeling, some not. Some had use of an MDM machine, some dont


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or