{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Coronavirus... SARS... H1NI... what if China & the world just stopped eating meat altogether? Why can’t our species go beyond consumption of animals? It’s causing chaos! Or am I oversimplifying this?", "post_id": "5e2f7dd6fd44a6001c3e11fe", "reply_count": 100, "vote_count": 33, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting", "feed_type": "crowd" }
null

Coronavirus... SARS... H1NI... what if China & the world just stopped eating meat altogether? Why can’t our species go beyond consumption of animals? It’s causing chaos! Or am I oversimplifying this?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Meat is generally more nutritionally complete, healthier from a metabolic and macronutrient standpoint (i.e., lower postprandial insulin and glucose response), and is delicious.

We are higher on the food chain for a reason, and most animals preferentially eat meat when it’s available (even deer)—because it’s more nutrient dense.

Meat consumption is what allows our digestive system to be small (go compare to a gorilla or a cow—four stomachs!), so that we can divert space and energy consumption to our brain, and to enable endurance running (for hunting... meat!)

Sure, you can get similar levels of nutrients from plants, but you would have to eat a massive amount more in weight (go google how much a gorilla eats in pounds per day), deal with the negative effects of high carbohydrate intake and oxidation-prone polyunsaturated fatty acid intake, and then you’re still left with lower protein *quality* (amino acid profile) and lack of micronutrients (e.g., B12)

Show me an obese population of humans that eats primarily meat and animal foods (80%+ of calories). Go look at the Masai and Eskimo. Now go look at populations that eat lots plants (carbohydrates)—generally overweight, unhealthy, and experiencing diseases of modern man (heart disease, diabesity, extensive cancer, tooth decay, etc.)—a whole chapter in Sapiens is about agriculture—go read.

Just eat animals that eat plants. What do you think happens to the nutrients in the plants that e.g., a ruminant eats? Just be a second order vegetarian, you’ll be fine

likesmart

Love the phrase “second order vegetarian”. Stealing for my own (carnivorous) use, thanks!

like

Sustainable meat consumption is good. The problem is China being an authoritarian regime that cares more about maintaining its public perception than having any quality standards and caring for the wellbeing of its people

like
Recent IconRecent

Yes, you’re oversimplifying to the point of disappointment.
Pls fix.

likefunnysmart

Must be a partner from Guidehouse

like

What if our species die of malnutrition then...

likefunny

Matt Ridley is full of bull

Yes, you oversimplifying this.

like

Zoonotic diseases exist independent of human meat consumption.

likesmarthelpful

Post Photo
likefunny

I’ll make it as simple as possible, but no simpler:

Because animals are delicious

likesmart

The word is short on resources and people are suffering. What if we just make half the world population disappear? It’s causing chaos! Or am I oversimplifying this?

~Thanos

likefunny

As a Brazilian I find this offensive

likefunny

A1 tread carefully. You already got them triggered, you don't want their brain to explode.

like

Also remember the e coli in romaine, so remember to exclude that too

like

You understand that the ecoli found “in” vegetables is actually due to contact with animal sh*t runoff, from what? Farming animals.... this comparison is disingenuous at best and egregiously incorrect at worst. Ecoli doesn’t exist “in” anything besides colons and their products (sh*t)

like

You are oversimplifying this. I’m all for cutting down on meat consumption and practicing sustainability as much as possible. However, there are plenty of people in this world who do not have the luxury of choosing to cut out meat consumption.

likesmart

There are also plenty of meats and ways of cooking them. Next we will be hearing from you that computers have viruses and security threats and we therefore should stop using the internet and only use our devices offline rather than mitigating those issues.

Yes, Scott, you’re oversimplifying yet again.

like

They are so delicious.

like

Is it your hypothesis that if we stopped eating meat we’d stop getting these viral infections?

I can think of a lot of advantages to a meatless world. I suspect we’d like still keep getting flus and other viruses.

likeuplifting

Also nature has limits on how many animals or can support. In some areas when a type of animal gets overpopulated disease can break out amkng those animals like CWD in deer.

Really?

like

Humans are omnivores. The reason we enjoy meat and vegetables is because we're supposed to. Now if you want to go 100% veggie no one's stopping you. Just stay the heck away from my steak, bacon, salmon, wings, and pork chops.

likehelpful

You work at McK?

like

Lettuce, cabbage, and spinach have all been great vehicles for e coli outbreaks in the last decade. Vegetables are just as if not more dangerous.

Also, yes the world is eating too much meat. But there are also patches of land especially in developing countries where the easiest thing to grow is grass for cows to graze on. Not all land is created equal(ly fertile).

So yeah you're oversimplifying this.

like

Stop eating bats and snakes. Or at least cook it. Meat is fine.

like

As part of the evolution its very common that when a population of a particularly species grows too big some (usually the weakest) gets wiped out from a disease...

like

Additional Posts

Best skills to develop or things to do while on the bench that can buff your cv for a different job?

like

Hey, hiring managers! Had 30 minute screening call for Accenture SM. Next up~> Interview with the hiring manager. (Career pivot. 15 YOE) How would you answer this?
“In their first round Zoom interview with me, __________ distinguishes the best candidates.”

like

Has anyone recently travelled to India and back on a visa? What’s the process been?

likefunny

Tasked with planning a surprise pool party for a friend. Anyone want to pitch in some fun ideas? My list so far: yard pong, slip&slide, drinking, and spike ball.

like

40 min ride to airport at 5am couldn’t get any “better” when the Uber driver talked nonstop. Great lady tho but come on, it’s 5 am 🤪

like

Have conversation with hiring manager on offer details. What should I say once offer is laid out? I’d like to keep room for negotiations. How can I also let other firms kno I now have an offer.

like

Quick tax question, if you only have a form 1098-T and tuition is greater than scholarships received, do you need to file a tax return?

Anyone else feel like there is no rhyme or reason to who you get assignments from, the level of instruction you receive, whether you are expected to contact the client directly, the level of discretion you’re expected to use in determining the issues, etc etc etc? I’m sure there is some reasoning behind it all, but being kept in the dark about all of the above sure makes it challenging to know the expectations, let alone meet/exceed them!

like

Can someone explain Deloittes cyber groups? At PwC we are all in advisory under the same umbrella

like

What type of work/careers can you do/pursue after being a consultant and only work on SAP Implementations ?


I am just curious

Has anyone focused solely on AML compliance? I did one engagement and I seem to like it better than external audit. Is this a decent field to branch off into or am I closing many doors?

likesmart

Can we go to client worksite for a proposal meeting? No SOW is signed so can’t file H1b amendment. But wonder if this is ok in general.
Thanks for any insights.

Hi 🐠🐟🐡 - I’m a F new to Houston. Any recs on activities, events, networking/volunteer opportunities? Probably gonna start w/ golf & indoor rock climbing but wanna know what else others do for fun!

like

Dreaming of a copywriter who has experience/interest in Google and is very systematic. Mid-level only, please! Join a great, talented team. Hit me up!

like

How much does KPMG pay to associate data modellers (light house) out of grad school?

Is it fine if I put down paper without offer in TCS?

like

How much does the EM equivalent at MBB make? And the Associate Partner equivalent? Salary and bonus breakdown would be appreciated.

like

Feeling conflicted about a potential move to Silicon Valley from Philadelphia for a job. I have a great community and support system here - I’m afraid I will be very lonely. How do you cope with fear of not having any friends near you ?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal