{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Dinged via email (no phone call) after MBB final round. Is this normal?", "post_id": "605245f12db957001b5069cb", "reply_count": 10, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "5d7901c370a602001eff88c8", "bowl_name": "All Things MBB" }

Dinged via email (no phone call) after MBB final round. Is this normal?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’m sorry to hear this. That’s not normal

like

We are at least cool enough to give you a five min phone call, global recruiting policy

like

Rejected by Bain after final round via email, but McKinsey final round rejection was a phone call

like

Upon reflecting, I was mistaken. It was a voicemail by Bain not email. Everyone I spoke with at Bain was super helpful throughout the recruiting process

Really not normal for us

like

Received email as well :/

like

Which MBB? Not normal for us.

Yours

Not normal. I always do turndowns by phone.

That’s not normal. I would highly reco contacting recruiter for a feeeback cal. Sorry to hear OP

Related Posts

What is the difference between an Associate Consultant role (in MBB) vs. a Consulting/Business Analyst role (in McK/Big 4/ACN)? Would the former be a step up from the latter, or they are lateral?

like

Looking for mentors in FAANG, MBB, and other Big 4. DM me please. 😀😀

funnylike

How to do stop comparing yourself with others? I struggle a lot with my path in life and my career choice. I didn't come from a wealthy family, and was a bit of a late bloomer. Even on fishbowl there seems to be a focus on a great career is MBB, Investment banking or tech company vibe.

like

Just took a shot and applied to MBB online. Anybody know how long it generally takes for them to get back? It’s been 2 weeks and it’s my first application since UG, not sure how long I should wait.

like

Has anyone ever used one of the online case coach services? I’ve got a final round for an MBB and am considering using one for additional perspective.

like

How would you rank the non-MBB strategy shops? Including strategy “divisions” within larger firms

like

Mgr at D & hoping to move over to MBB for a variety of reasons. Should I target Manager or Associate level? Hear it’s tough to build up a network the M level at MBB and that consultants move 1 level down when moving over. Is this truth to this or just disguised elitism lol?

like
likehelpful

Anyone from OW (or anywhere not MBB) willing to pass on a UG resume for a Black female looking for full-time? (assuming recruiting for FT is still open)

like

Hello fellow MBB fish! I had a question I am hoping to get insights on. I accepted an offer from McKinsey in NYC and was supposed to start in March, which I now pushed to May.

like

Would you rather be a MBB partner, senior partner, or F500 C-suite. And why?

like

How difficult is it to switch for someone with a Big 4 experience (within United States) to MBB in a different region (Europe or Asia)?

like

So T1 is MBB and T2 is Big4?

funnysmart

Folks I am from Germany. I have seen MBB hiring culture is very diff than from the US/UK. For consulting roles whether be strategy/implementation/sector-specific they prefer folks with Masters or Ph.D. rather than MBAs from top B schools around the globe. Is it true?

like

What are MBB bill rates? Rough estimates?

like

MBB consultant here post-MBA (started pre-MBA). What are the best PE Ops roles (other than KKR Capstone) that like consultants? And at what entry point do they target consultants (e.g. Consultant level, manager level, etc.) and what level are they brought in as?

like

Thoughts on Accenture? How do they compare to EY and Deloitte? Have offers from all 3 but not sure which one to choose. Would ideally like to get my MBA in a few years and get into MBB. Is there a better/more prestigious choice between the 3? TIA

like

I know many people do an MBA after 2 years at MBB. Can you do a PhD instead? Does the firm encourage its employees to pursue a PHD? I am currently prepping for interviews, and I am wondering whether I should mention or not that my long term goal is to pursue a PHD and that my experience at MBB will allow me to gain more industry knowledge and identify the biggest problems faced by companies/governments

like

Looking for a referral at MBB firms. Have VC and finance background. Anyone open?

like

Why do so many people want to work at MBB? Is it the money, prestige, exit opps? I guess I’m entering the stage of life where WLB is most important to me...

like

Additional Posts

Has anyone appeared for Mckinsey's hiring process for Data Engineer???

like

In your opinion, $135k salary = what type of role/position/title/area of focus/years of experience/etc? If you are contextualizing to COL please share.

like

Have the final round of interview for the Manager position in the workday implementation. How much does the final year manage make? I have been promised that I will be promoted in a year to senior manager if I meet my performance goals.

likefunny

Anyone renting in a luxury condo ever Airbnb their place while on vacation?

like

Hey fishes, Capgemini is having below SAP openings, if interested please let me know.

like

What is the difference between an Associate Consultant role (in MBB) vs. a Consulting/Business Analyst role (in McK/Big 4/ACN)? Would the former be a step up from the latter, or they are lateral?

like

Anyone took workday certification courses remotely? Does anyone have the link to the course books used during certification?

like

Recently started at Bain (post MBA), but was given opportunity to join a first time fund ($200m AUM). Pay is 50% more. Ideally would like to stay for ~2 years at Bain before making a switch like this to buy-side. How likely are opportunities like this to come down the road? Don’t want to jump the gun and forego having a Bain credential. Help!

like

Hypothetical situation - if your client is a health provider and you get an email from the CEO that says all health workers can get the vaccine. But you know that you will never see a patient and work from home at a computer. Do you get the vaccine by using your client ID or wait for the general public rollout?

funnylike

Thoughts on Prosci or SHRM-SCP certification? Which would be considered more valuable or highly regarded? Currently focused on Change Management but have a HR background (industry experience / area of study in college).

likehelpful

MAGA friends, why does every conversation with you about COVID and the US Covid response include a claim that it’s China’s fault? Let’s say I grant your premise. How does COVID being China’s fault make the Trump response seemingly better? There are a number of things the president has to respond to that he did not directly cause - are you suggesting we don’t want someone capable of responding to events they did not have a hand in crafting?

like

Any Kearney fish with insights on the Southeast Asia offices? Specifically interested in culture, compensation (compared to the US consulting)

like

My mother is having elective surgery today and expects me to take her to the hospital, be there, pick her up etc. We are in CA, the virus is very much here! Thanks for letting me vent!

like

dos anyone have any advice for public health grad student graduating in 2022 who’s is trying to get job in healthcare consulting?

like

EY Audit senior with CA and CPA - 5YOE, $65k offer to xfer to the US Assurance practice. Also interviewing with other companies: industry and boutique. What is the salary range and role I can aim for

like

OH (from a colleague) at the Warriors game in the beer queue: "they say that's $60, I say that's 60 SPG points." 🏀🍻

like

Lol my firm halted all sales travel but continued client travel. Just waiting for someone to get sick so I can sleep in my own bed for more than 8 nights a month

likefunny

What’s the compensation expectation for a senior accountant role/job offer in the DC Maryland Virgina (DMV) area? Years of experience is from audit/public accounting 7 years.

like

Any Salesforce AEs here? Applying/looking, and curious if there is a “preferred” business unit to sell to? They are obviously different industry sectors, just curious WLB/happiness levels and salary differences A few options below: Insurance Marketing Cloud Data & Identity Manufacturing Retail

like

Trump supporters, do any of you really believe Louis Gohmert got coronavirus from wearing a mask?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal