{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Do companies generally asks to provide a copy of a competing offer letter during salary negotiations?", "post_id": "6065a30248693d00211f3f13", "reply_count": 8, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting" }

Do companies generally asks to provide a copy of a competing offer letter during salary negotiations?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If you say you’ve got one, you should be able to back it up.

like

I’d just leave it as a verbal this is my other offer and what you are competing with. Let them decide if they value you for the same or more. Be prepared to accept the results. I don’t like the ethics around showing an offer from one company to another. Think about if a client shared your price/proposal with a competing firm asking them to beat the number.

like

Yes

like

I wouldn’t provide. If they don’t believe you then tough luck. Be prepared to walk though, don’t lie.

like

You’re almost definitely not allowed to share it due to confidentiality. But obviously you shouldn’t lie and you need to be prepare to accept the offer if that’s the card you’re playing.

like

Ehh, not necessarily true. It’s pretty common to ask for proof of offer - even if that means leaving out some of the specifics

like

I team can I apply analyst position but I have not completed graduation

Hard No

Related Posts

2nd year manager at KPMG strategy current at $205k base (w/ top 10 MBA & 7 yoe). Offered $215k base 10% bonus for a Transformation Director position with a PE backed fintech. WLB is fantastic. Company positioned to go public in 1-2 years or be sold. Should I wait to see if I make director this year at KPMG or jump now? (I have 2 kids under 4 and wife is big law attorney so WLB is key)

like

Anyone have an insight on salary for Monitoring & Testing Program Manager role at Facebook? I have an initial call with recruiter.

likehelpful

What is the Average salary of a software engineer 1 at Adobe ?

like

Salary range for Data Science Associate consultant at ZS. Thanks

like
like

What are the best consulting firms to work for in Chicago right out of undergrad based on salary and perks?

like

Does anyone here know the comp range for a data engineer at Accenture?

like

~2 YOE post undergrad in LS consulting, 150k base + 75K target bonus at life sciences fund that does a mix of VC investing and growth buyout. Thoughts? Wanna stay in the life sciences ecosystem in the future (industry, consulting, buyside). How much do other VC funds usually pay?

like

I’m curious of everyone’s views on job hopping. I’m on my 3rd job and have ~3 years of sales experience. Each job change has been an increase in comp and has shown clear career progression. At this point I’m working for a well known public company in SaaS, in their SMB segment, which has been great. But I’ve been approached by a smaller startup offering to double my base salary, 2.25x my OTE, and equity for an enterprise rep position. This is very enticing, but would I look like a job hopper?

like

About to get an offer from Capgemini Invent. Manager level out of Philadelphia area. Any insight on what I can expect/negotiate for on salary?

like

Hi, To share my experience who are looking to exit. I am a director at KP, YOE consulting 12 years at 200K base 15% bonus: TD / RBC AVP, 160 - 170K Base 50% bonus + stock, etc. CPPIB D, 150 - 170K base 50% bonus CPPIB MD, 180 - 200K base 100% bonus (yes, 100%) Magna, MGR 175K base max SAKS Off 5th (US), D, 190K Base 15% bonus MLSE D, 140 - 160K, Kainos, architect, 190K base max. I ended up with a US based HR tech firm, Architect: 230K CAD 15% bonus stock options. Hope this helps!

likehelpfuluplifting

Amazon Web Services Currently looking into a role as Senior Customer Solutions Manager with AWS. Does anyone have any information about the role? What to expect from the firm, compensation, etc.?

like

How much time it takes for TCS to release offer letter from the day HR call and salary negotiation, salary discussion done on 6 January current ibegin status - evaluation in progress.

Salary range for a senior designer/art director in Denver CO? Not necessarily in advertising - I have more experience in branding and corporate design

like

What’s salary range of an associate or associate VP at Morgan Stanley?

like

Hey folks, hope you’re all having a not-so-blue Monday. I’m new to EY and was wondering if the firm does annual raises? I joined as an SC and wondering if my base salary will be adjusted annually by a fixed % for inflation or a variable % based on performance? Or if the only way to increase my base pay is to get promoted to manager? Thanks for your help!

How accurate is Glassdoor when it comes to Deloitte Senior Manager salary? How are signing bonuses at that level?

like

What is the highest comp increase for consultant to senior consultant at Deloitte Advisory Analytics this year that people know of?

like

What is the salary for Deloitte Senior Consultant (Corporate Strategy Program) in New York or Los Angeles

like

What’s more valuable mba or masters of analytics? Within the terms of value that can help the business. Not in terms of personal compensation.

like

Additional Posts

2nd year manager at KPMG strategy current at $205k base (w/ top 10 MBA & 7 yoe). Offered $215k base 10% bonus for a Transformation Director position with a PE backed fintech. WLB is fantastic. Company positioned to go public in 1-2 years or be sold. Should I wait to see if I make director this year at KPMG or jump now? (I have 2 kids under 4 and wife is big law attorney so WLB is key)

like

Are covid tests (rtpcr) reimbursed in USI? If yes, through what mechanism

like
like

We have a team to promote diversity in our department...everyone on the team is straight and white. This really blows my mind.

likefunnyuplifting

I recently joined Accenture - my SO is a PHD student and was on my insurance. The university wants to charge us 3K for their insurance since we can’t provide proof of insurance until the new benefits go through. New benefits are supposed to be in effect but we enrollment has been delayed because Accenture lost my Domestic Partner tax form and I had to resubmit. The issue should be resolved by Friday but the school is charging us tomorrow without exception - do we have any recourse?

like

Anyone know what the deal is with Trump's travel embargo to Cuba? What does this mean? Already have tics to go in December and trying to see how this might affect my travel?

like
like

Just recently, we exceeded 1 million covid deaths on record globally. When the pandemic started, did anyone actually believe that the situation would become this bad?

likefunny

Anyone have an insight on salary for Monitoring & Testing Program Manager role at Facebook? I have an initial call with recruiter.

likehelpful

Can you show with more than one homeowners insurance broker? Just in case they use different sources? Or is that not wise to do?

like

What are some education /degree or course options for someone with this profile? - 45+ age with mba - consulting cloud/IT - has AI/Math background - already has cloud certifications Goal is to bolster up the resume as well as potentially learn something new at the same time.

like

Any positive job changes after becoming a mom? I'm having a bit of trouble deciding which direction I want to pivot my career. Yes I want to do work that is fulfilling but I also want to find a role that allows me to balance my life as a mother, especially during Covid. Being at my current agency does not offer that and I assume is the norm for most agencies.

like

Just went through 2 months of interviews to find out I was rejected by all of them :( I just wanted out

like

Aaye Yo! Deloitte is Hiring! Come, join us and excel your career! Message me with your email ID for job description in your inbox.

Post Photo
like

What is the Average salary of a software engineer 1 at Adobe ?

like

I am currently on maternity leave but really worried regarding layoff. I want to start looking for a new job and was wondering what’s the typical policy for number of months/ days one has to work after maternity leave to avoid paying back maternity leave benefits to the company.

like

Imagine if the count POTUS was doing everything in his power to keep down was the COVID case count 🤔

likesmarthelpfulfunny

Salary range for Data Science Associate consultant at ZS. Thanks

like
like

Any United Global Services willing to upgrade my K class economy flights in December? I am 1K and have 5 GPUs but can’t use them on K class. Appreciate it!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal