Do you think H1B visa holders are being for the most part underpaid?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Don’t think so but I have seen Americans climbing up the ladder easily in comparison. H1B holders have to work harder to reach the same level in many cases. I think that’s how the immigration system is expected to work. No complaints when it comes to compensation for the designation I hold

like

Correct. Your opportunities are reduced since many employers won't sponsor, in addition to the admin overhead.

like

Less so on pay, I think it’s more on freedom & mobility to try other opportunities/companies

like

Not necessarily. If you were not an immigrant, you have the liberty to do something completely different that may not be financially motivated any time, eg, quit job to run a business, change career/role, take a sabbatical etc.

Only Indian origin companies treat their employees differently based on their nationality as far as the compensation goes but rest of the companies are fair with everyone wrt pay and I also agree on what EY1 stated on “the climbing up the ladder” part.
Although it’s not fair but we tend to forget that we signed up for this when we submitted the H1B application.

like

Yes, I have had the first hand experience - Treatment is utterly poor and discriminatory on so many levels.
It is very sad and sickening to say being indian that I don’t want to work for any Indian or Indian origin company.

like

The ones that work for the WITCH companies sure are. The rest - Not generally.

like

But how come DOL is unaware of this issue for so long. Afaik this has been going on since time immemorial. Don’t even want to get started with the visa abuses they do.

like

Not really

like

Don’t forget that vast majority of companies don’t have an ability or desire to sponsor H1B visa

Absolutely they are. I've seen many H1-Bs scared to rock the boat. Labor mobility is one of the best ways to increase one's total compensation; when that power is neutered it undoubtedly affects not only the H1-B's salary, but all of their peers as well.

like

Maybe those that work for some shady body shops but in general no.

Not really compared to other workers at same job/level/company…but compared to workers with same education/experience/other stats just not on a work visa…? Maybe.
Although I will say! I’m ROW, but the other people in my grad school program who started at the same level at my same company but are Chinese, they have job hopped a lot. GC is far off for them, so they would rather job hop to increase that TC as their priority.

I think so. They had to bump up my pay when they started the h1b process and their explanation was they had to show that I was paid the same amount as my peers. So basically for 2 to 3 years I was underpaid even though I was a high performer.

Not in my experience. Prevailing wage determinations usually come in above my non-H1B visa employees resulting in H1B visa holders making more than my non-H1B visa holders or we raise the entire market so that all are making the same.

No

Related Posts

What are some of the common exit options for the manager level? Looking for TC to be close to or over $200K. I know it’s heavy tech in the US, but what does that translate to here?

like

Can anybody let me know bands,salary range and positions in CRMNext.

My director is looking to add a few new members to our team (currently only 2 of us) to help lighten the work load. How do I convince him to just give me a raise and keep the load I have now?

like

Does Fidelity Investments Canada pay well? I am in Learning and Development domain.

like

Hi everyone! I am a Registered Behavioral Technician (RBT) and have been with my company for a bit over a year and a half. I am one of the few that has stayed this long, 1 of 2 bilingual techs, and there’s been a high turn over rate in technicians since I’ve start but it has increased drastically lately so in light of that I was thinking of asking for a raise. I currently get paid $21/hr. Any recommendations how I should go about asking for a raise, how much more I should ask for, etc.?

like

Working at Deloitte India as SM ( due to be D) Digital Consulting.. offers from 1) Adobe Consulting as SM/Principal (Digital Consulting US shift), 2) BCG as SM/Principal (digital internal role not consulting) 3) Accenture Tech as SM (digital consulting) . Salary wise adobe( including RSU) >bcg>accenture>deloitte . Which one to pick for better WLB and career prospects. Please help .Adobe Accenture Boston Consulting Group Deloitte

like

Is the grass greener on the client side?
My agency work is feast or famine with nothing in-between. Is this still a problem client side? Im sick of having to chase down work during slow times.

like

How much salary freshers are getting currently. Hoping it's improved considering the current inflation.

like

Hi All,

I joined new company and my current salary is 11lpa(10L fixed + 1L variable pay).
I don't know about tax calculations and all.
They didn't deduct any TDS in my first month salary.
So when will they deduct TDS?
I am attaching my slip here.
Please suggest for investment plans.

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes,

I have got the offer from Marvel Semiconductor for staff engineer position. I have 5 years of experience what is the salary i can expect from marvel?

like

Looking for an entry level remote tech position. Honestly not picky, current TC is 111k anything close to that would be appreciated.

Hi folks , can any one please suggest what will be the in hand salary for the below salary structure.

Post Photo
like

One dbt, regarding the PF both Employee and Employer contribution deduct from our salary ? eg: if PF mentioned 5k in offer letter ,how much deduction will occur ?

like

Hi Fishes,

What would be ideal salary range for an automation tester with 6 yoe?

Thanks in advance

like

Reasonable Expected salary for 5.5 years of experience if I make a switch now
Tech stack :Angular , React,Node.js with 1.5yrs exp
Currect ctc :12.5 lakh including gratuity employer etc.
Along with company

like

Hi Fishes, please use the chart to calculate your in-hand salary. Tata Consultancy Cognizant Accenture India Infosys EPAM Systems EPAM Anywhere 🇮🇳

Post Photo
likesmart

Guess my pay.

I have 15+ years of experience.
I am an individual contributor. I do not manage people.
I have never been a manager.
My job title is "software engineer".
I have worked at multiple FANG-level companies. Currently at a FANG.
I work between 30 and 35 hours a week.
I am remote and can work from anywhere in the US.

For precision I will use my 2021 W-2 gross and include my company's 401k match.

Comment with a number and I'll tell you if my pay was above or below the number.

like

More Posts

Working in middle management was traumatic (especially during COVID-19). Does it get better at the executive/C-suite level?

like

Is everyone in EY still working from home? And if yes for how long will EY allow WFH. Like for those not in their base location by when do they need to relocate?

like

Have an interview tomorrow for a senior UX designer 🙂

How do I answer these questions
Any advice would be greatly appreciated

1. What was the breakpoint for design
2. Did you design the components and design system?
3. How was your handoff to developers (I've never one that)
4. Wht was the most challenging part of this project.
5. What is something you would re-design if you were to go back.

like

Does P&T do anything for promotion day? Seems awkward for us on virtual teams to go to a celebration where we don’t really know anyone. But also sorta lame if we just don’t do anything that day or treat it like a normal workday… Not planning to attend since I only know a few people in my office, but if they organized something where we can meet people in P&T and celebrate together I’d be more inclined to go.

like

Hello All,

I have job joining in UST in next. However, I'm having some concern. Could you please advise me on this.

I have some matrimonial disputes going on in court. Does it affect my job joining in UST?

I believe it's the employees personal matter and nothing to relate on job prospects (this is what i got as a reply from my previous employer)

Do I need to inform about my matrimonial disputes or should I keep quiet? How does background verification team consider this.

like

Hi everyone! I’m an S1 in tax at a Big 4 in NY (only been here for a few months). I was recently offered a chance to join a long term engagement (at least one year) for a massive new client. I’ll only be focusing on the tax provision aspect for them. They’re building out a team just for this client from scratch. Do you think this is a good project to be on? Any negatives or drawbacks? Thank you all! I’d appreciate any advice!

like

Is the pwc New York fdd practice hiring? Senior associate level

like

My new Seamaster 😍

Post Photo
like

Hi Fishes,

I joined MS Bangalore office last month. In my offer letter it is mentioned that I'll get 2.5 lakh (gross up) one time relocation allowance. Can anyone tell me, when can i expect that money to be credited in my bank account ? I have already received my 1st month salary along with all other allowances.

P.S. i have also not received any goodies/welcome kit from MS ☹️

like

Who’s hungry for some African meals?
Please like and comment so I can gain access to DMs. Who knows, I might be able to send you the recipe :)

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting
like

I'm new to Fishbowl - Looking for referral or advice on how to apply through USA Jobs site, specifically for positions with AmeriCorps.
I think I need likes in order to dm??
Thanks!

like

PSA: The past tense for lead is led. Please, for the love of god, stop using lead as the past tense for lead.

likefunny

My joining date in DXC Technology is on June. But i received laptop from DXC yesterday. Why the company is sending laptop so early and reason? DXC Technology

like

“Well, I guess I’ll take myself to YouTube University and figure it out.”

“YouTube University is better than most college degrees.”

likefunnyhelpful

Hi guys,

What is the in hand salary in Mphasis for 11LPA(including variable)?? I heard Variable pay will be paid quarterly... So, can we expect 1000% variable or is it based on performance??

Has anyone gotten their real ID? Which DMV location is the best to get this done and do I need to retake my photo?

like

Does EY allow CPT during a masters program?

like

Is anyone familiar with northwestern Segal design institute? Would love to learn about the influence and opportunities

like

MBB fish. Is a London -> NYC move easy? American so don’t need a visa

like

Additional Posts in Global immigration

Hi All, I'm a complete newbie here on H1b.

Are we allowed to buy or trade stocks and crypto currency on h1b..?

like

Hey anyone that completed Global entry enrolment interview recently? I have mine tomorrow AM. But one problem, I recently moved to a new address in the same state & do not hv an updated address on DL

like

Did anyone get a H1b transfer recently? What was the time frame for lca and h1 to get approved? My law firm mentioned that it could take 1-2 months for the receipt notice to arrive due to covid😅 Damn you covid!

like

Is anyone on the H4 and how long does it take for the process?

like

How long does the Prevailing Wage Determination step take nowadays? Is there anything we can do to speed it up? The stress is killing me…

like

Anyone know the current processing time for H4

like

Has anyone paid for premium processing for their I-140 out of pocket? EY filed my I-140 in June 2021 and is working on my I-485 now. I asked if I can pay for premium processing since the Texas processing center takes 11-13.5 months but I am not sure it will be worth it if the I-485 takes a long time. Thanks!

likehelpful

Has anyone who submitted their application with premium heard back?

Will H1b transfer impact my pending EAD and I485 applications? They both have been pending for over 180days.

like

Are there chances of 2nd H1B lottery this year like last year (2020)?

like

My visa officer entered a date of stay on my h1B stamp only until Jan 23 but my visa stamp is valid until Sep 24.
What are my options? How do I get this fixed? Do I need a new I797 petition to be filed for extension and need a new stamp after Jan 23?

like