{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Edward Jones is charging me $40 for a good knight account. The client refused to close the account a year ago and it is only worth $60. Is that even legal??? Thoughts", "post_id": "5c099c927e492e0017786da0", "reply_count": 14, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "599feb177c057d0010be0554", "bowl_name": "Financial Advisors" }

Edward Jones is charging me $40 for a good knight account. The client refused to close the account a year ago and it is only worth $60. Is that even legal??? Thoughts

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You have the right to sell Investments to cover yourself. The account agreement says so.

smart

They threatened my license if I would sell without his approval

helpful

Connection isn’t available yet in my region lol but I agree

like

Is the account closed now? Have you already seen the fee hit your books? I have a few of these accounts from my Goodknight and I was talking to a rep in HO and they said we still (post DOL) can’t close accounts without express permission of the client. I said, “So am I going to be on the hook for an even bigger fee next year when this is resolved?" She indicated that there would be some solution available.

Sure, but when the account is all cash and it’s getting eaten away $40 per year in annual fees that doesn’t really help if we can’t unilaterally close the account. Why is a semi-client going to answer the phone (when they haven’t for years) to agree on $135 of fees to close an account that will net them nothing? Not very logical.

Who cares if they do or if they don't? I've never seen the financial advisor on the hook for a closing fee when they account runs out of money. The client knew what the annual fee was when they signed up for the account.

Welcome to the reason behind why the $10 monthly fee is going to start in January 2020

HO policy is that the advisor is on the hook if there is less in the account than the amount needed to cover annual fees and termination fees (combined $135). If there’s only $50 in the account the client isn’t going to be willing to pay an additional $85 to close an they haven’t cared about in years. Kind lame that it seems to be the practice of some vet advisors to put these net negative accounts in their GoodKnights instead of just cleaning up their book of business themselves.

Here 18 years. Never been charged the way you describe to close an account... they just took what was left in the account.

Ouch. FA1- “Kinda lame”?? First of all, this isn’t the veteran’s fault that this policy exists. Secondly, be careful about bad mouthing the hand that just fed you some assets. I know when I started in the business, I was super appreciative for everything I received from a small asset sharing program ($9 million).

If it was in one mutual fund it would sell automatically but because it is in a combination of funds that is not possible. I could close the account but would still need the clients permission. $40 isn’t much but why am I on the hook for it? Last year I paid $200 on similar accounts from the goodknight. Starting to get frustrated!

Related Posts

Interior decorator or designer experiences to share? At what project budget does it make sense to hire one in the city?

like

Salary for FIS Client Experience Analyst

like

I was just recruited into a management consulting practice at a big4 and my first project is staff aug. Is this a bad sign?

like

I got laid off and am putting together my CV. I’m confused and would like advice on how to structure my resume given in consulting we move across so many different roles and type of project work. Would anyone mind sending me an example of their CV? I’m targeting FAANG and start ups at the moment for product management roles. Background is in human capital consulting though I’ve had technical roles in the past and one traditional product management role in a short project.

like

New to the Bowl, greetings to all. I have a question for the sales leaders in the group about the design of sales comp plans. We are in professional services and our customers are about 50:50 retained and project-based. As such, we have an appetite for steady new business acquisition in addition to a need to provide excellent account management. Our gigs are usually in the 150K-750K range. Our BD process is very consultative, 99% of our leads are inbound. <more...>

like

Current project is very chill and management likes me/gives good reviews but I’m not challenged and do not lead others. I’ve considered switching projects to go up early (SC year2). I am six weeks pregnant, first pregnancy at 33. The other reason I wonder about going up early is that I’m not sure I want to be going up during year3 after being out on maternity leave and life drastically changing. I started my professional career late so feel like I’m playing catch-up too, any advice? Thanks!

like

Where do people buy API3? Read about the project’s backers and I’m looking to buy the dip. TIA!

like

Does anyone work for McKinsey within their Digital Arm as an architect? I was told this would be on the expert path. Can anyone tell me how the project dynamics would differ? Another thread I read mentioned that experts are utilized across multiple projects. True?

like

My manager just agreed to a massive scope creep made by a different client team that has to be done by this Monday. Looks like no weekend for me!

Post Photo
like

New to the team. One of my juniors on an engagement I am sort of leading don’t seem to respect me and probably dislikes me. He’s has an existing relationship with the client and (Cont..)

like

Any idea about at&t project? How is the overall project and work experience? Do we get any onsite opportunities?

like

What to do if you were hired onto a project that is just not a good fit for you?

like

Major client found sig. errors in report. Manager blamed me for faulty work. Partner offered 1mo PIP or 2 mo severance. Have written proof work was manager’s, partner didn’t care. What would u do?

likeuplifting

Bored out of my mind at work. I’ve asked for more responsibilities but there isn’t much to do on the account itself. Im essentially being paid (industry standard) to do nothing. The account is a big name, internal team is friendly, client annoying but manageable as any other. Sounds ideal on paper, but I feel restless and like my brain/skills are stagnating. Any advice, or am I complaining about nothing?

like

Anyone at Deloitte in Financial Services Ops Transformation willing to chat about their project experience as well as the interview process? 1YOE in Consulting doing FS Strategy & Ops

like

Hi, Does anyone have any idea about xoriant? Is it a product or service based? How's the job security, WLB? And do they send employees to work from client locations?

like

LTI vs TTL in terms of SAP implementation project Total 5.5 YOE LTI offered 19lpa grade P3 TTL 19 lpa designation TL

like

How to you tell your manager you’re leaving? I see her as a mentor and has done much to help my career, but I’m ready to try a new company. (She thinks I’m ready to start her new project next week) This is my first time moving companies so any tips appreciated!

like

Have you guys ever dealt with anxiety when it comes to leading discussions with a client? I know that’s literally what this profession is but how have you guys dealt with it?

like

Hi, Does anyone have any idea about xoriant? Is it a product or service based? How's the job security, WLB? And do they send employees to work from client locations?

like

Additional Posts

Hi fishes,Can Employer PF is part of CTC ?I guess no where I have seen the employer PF inclusion in ctc breakup like below. Also why they are deducting Employee PF contribution from the ctc and calculating net salary? Is this correct approach?

Post Photo
like

Sad day for SPG again ... Sigh

like

If you’re an analyst and ur project doesn’t want to give u OT, isn’t that illegal? Should I go to HR?

like

My utilization has been so low since COVID closed off the offices. Should I be worried? Should I reach out to my relationship/career coach? Change to another group/line of service??

likesmart

If Leaving FDD (deals advisory) for an FP&A job at the senior associate level, should I expect a base salary decrease?

likehelpful

Looking into switching into a new company for my same role as a sales compensation analyst. Wondering if anyone had any insight on pay at other companies

like

Anyone have insight into comp for experienced hire Senior Manager for Bain in London?

like

I’m waiting on approval for an H1B petition (using the balance of a previous visa, so cap exempt & I’m cautiously optimistic about approval). I’m a dual NZ and Canadian citizen currently resident in Canada. I’ve heard (deep in the internet 😂) that Canadian citizens don’t need visa stamping - just present all the documents at a port of entry. Can this be true?

like

What’s the hardest question/hypothetical you ever got in an interview?

like

Hello! HR Business Partner looking to pivot into Human Capital, any advice/best practices? I have almost seven years of experience, Masters in HRM,SHRM certified and previously worked at B4 firm.... No consulting experience so seeking advice on how to break into HC consulting. Thanks!

like

SEA team- how do I figure out my notice period? Don’t want to write to HR.

🐠 Help me out please. Need a new job that is WFH/travel split. I could report to a DC area office if needed. 2 YOE mechanical engineering and 2 YOE consulting. Happy to chat with anyone who is hiring/referring in order to find the correct role and have all of my application documents ready to roll. Lots of interests but would like generic MC, PE, Ops, or a generalist role. TIA

like

What is a good percent pay increase when moving from St Louis to San Diego?

like

I have my first round McKinsey phone case interview today and honestly feel nervous enough to throw up. Anyone done this type of screen before/have any tips or pointers to pass?

like

How to get over guilt when calling in sick??

funnylike

What is the best form of exercise in terms of health and fitness and convenience? I've heard swimming, rowing, running and biking are the best. Each has pros and cons

like

Hi, I currently have experience in TA and Business Partnering role with 3 years of experience. How do I start my journey to the HR Transformation side?. I also have a good experience with implementing SuccessFactors and DarwinBox in the companies I have been in. Any tips😄?

like

Would anyone be willing to answer a couple insurance law questions via DM please? I’ll get ya back with any corporate law questions you might have 🙏

like

Anyone use any kind of coaching service for interviews. One too many rejections sending me into a spiral so I need professional feedback.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal