Everything else equal, will a recommender who is an alumni from the school you’re applying to be better than one who is not?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yes, but there is no such thing as everything else equal... pick the one who knows you better and will write the better recommendation letter over the alum.

likehelpful

Yes

Related Posts

I left my job about a year ago to relocate, make sure it was the right decision and start a side business in the mean time. Now I’m actively looking for a new sales position, have tons of experience, but am struggling to even get a response from job apps. I am wondering if this is because of my employment gap? I don’t have my side business listed on my resume because I don’t feel like I have enough positive “stats” to report yet given it’s new. Any advice or recommendations?

like

OMG! Why do recruiters go dark on you!? I had a great conversation with a hiring manager who said things like I can’t believe she (recruiter) found you, you are so polished, I want you to meet with the girl on my team -like I had it in the bag. The conversation with the girl on the team went well and told me how excited the hiring manager is and called her right away…. I email the recruiter to ask about next steps and nothing……

Is it appropriate to email a hiring manager for an update? I emailed HR on Monday. I had an interview two weeks ago (the third interview) for a position I really want. I haven’t heard anything and I keep checking the status and I’m not rejected yet. I thought about emailing the director who I initially interviewed with today since I haven’t heard from HR.

like

Hi Fishes,
I recently got shortlisted for a Product Manager position at Tracxn. There’s also an IPO coming up which is the reason I had applied.
But I have read some horrifying reviews about the company on Glassdoor, indeed and other forums.

I’m wondering whether it’s worth going through the interview process and I’d also like to hear opinions from anyone who has worked with the company or is aware of the company culture.

Thanks.

Pwc ac bangalore Hr interview over on 12th July , still not received offer letter. Can I wait or join other offer ?
Yoe 13
Skill set Java spring boot ? Please suggest ..

like

Why do recruiters insist on introductory meetings even when you say you aren’t looking? Do they think they can trick you into taking a position somewhere else? Or do they really think that intro meeting will mean that you come back to them in a couple of years to use them?

Just getting tired of saying no on the cold calls and them insisting on talking to me.

like

Hi All, After 8 interviews at Jp morgan finally received a call 2 days back to submit payslips , does this mean i am finally selected and whats the hiring process, can someone plz help

like

Hi Fishes, I'd be glad to know below I formation as I have. 1) Insights about Salesforce Engineer position at Nokia 2) Interview process and difficulty level for 3+ year Salesforce Developer. Salesforce Amazon India Accenture India Google Deloitte

Hi! I have an interview tomorrow for an Employer Of Record startup. The startup is about 1 year old. What questions should I be asking specifically for startups?

like

I think I am bombing final interview as I am not asking the "good"questions and content I used in earlier interviews. I also don't want to be repetitive. Any info on how you Ace the final interview or how you handled this issue? I feel like I should be more repetitive even if I know the answers since each interview is with different people. Thanks

like

Hey folks, any ZSers on here willing to share some input on interviews? I'm an industry hire with a 3rd round interview for Bus Ops Consultant coming up in about a week. I got through the 2nd round (behavioral/structured .ppt case) just fine. Should I prepare differently for the next round?

like

What should I expect in a lateral interview? I haven’t interviewed since law school.

like

Hello in Infosys careers portal my application status is Scheduled interview showing I last 5 days. So is there any one suggest me what is next ??

like

KPMG Transformation Delivery interview coming up! Need advice ! Hi. Currently a Sr. Tech Risk Consultant at EY. I have mostly done IT Audit, SOC, and 2-3 channel 2 consulting work assignments. and I am about to have my first interview with KPMG from their Transformation Delivery practice. The team is project, program and portfolio management. How’s the work? Is it better than IT audit? If its PMO related then is it IT/Technical prog mgmt? Any Data analytics involved?I have technical skills too

HCL interview questions
YOE 7
Handle exceptions thrown by a thread?
Can JVM (through class loaders) load same class twice ?
Why only in synchronised block we can have wait and notify method ?
Which one will you choose : Soap or Rest ?
What is CI/CD ?
Row Mapper v/s ResultSetMapper
describe Oauth flow

likehelpful

Hello there! I have applied to so many jobs at Tesla (like 10 no kidding), and I don’t even get to the phone screaning part… I have a Master and a lot of certificates, any company would be lucky to have me, is there a secret I don’t know to get an interview at Tesla? 😁

like

Anyone work in the area of Nurse Practice Development? Nurse Educator. On my last interview and was told there is a cap on salary. Want to negotiate. In Texas.

like

Is anyone familiar with the case study interview at AArete and how it goes?

like

I have 1.3 years of experience as a manufacturing associate in a biopharma company. Looking to expand my domain by applying for research associate positions in process development or QC. How do you suggest I can make that shift? And if there are any positions available to your knowledge please do let me know
Thank you

like

More Posts

I am an elementary school teacher. My oldest son is feeling drawn to ECE. He loves children, loves to help in vacation bible school, wants to work directly with people to help them. Thoughts?

13 LPA now, will get a hike in April not idea how much ctc is gonna increase. Yoe 2.5, my aim is to get 30 LPA domain is Bigdata.
What are all the companies I can try where they offer good ctc considering knowledge irrespective of experience.

Please suggest.

likefunny

Has anyone used Volvo car subscription? Planning to get xc60 using Volvo care program. Please share any review or experience using that. Trying to make decision lease vs subscription for Volvo.

like

Welcome to creative content marketing!

likeuplifting
like

Having 1 yr 8 m Yoe in CTS as Qlik Replicate Developer, 6 months of Sales Yoe, 1 month as machine learning intern Overall Experience : 2 yr 2 months Previous BDE CTC : 10LPA [7 fixed + 3 Variable] After PGDM in Data science from manipal got placed in CTS as a lateral Developer Domain CTS CTC: 7.5 LPA [Fixed][April Joined] 1st October Appraisal 8.18 LPA CTC, 2nd October Appraisal : 9 LPA CTC What could be my next CTC after Switch? I don't want to change company how to get hike in CTS?

Let go from PwC Energy/Commodity Advisory after being there for many years. Looking for opportunities. Like to chat with firms.

9/21 check-in: What are everyone’s plans for today?

For me- treadmill, chest, shoulders.

likeuplifting

Has anyone travelled to and from India recently? Thinking to visit India (home) in November. I have a stamped h1b until July 2021. Wondering if it’s safe to travel from a visa perspective?

like

Tata Consultancy Infosys Cognizant Wipro I have completed all the technical and HR rounds and salary discussion, documents submission also done. But all of sudden got mail from hr saying that my profile is kept on hold. Any possibility that I will receive offer letter or it will be in hold forever? Meantime can I attend interview for other positions in hcl?

like

Has anyone attended the Holiday Hi-Light Festival? Is it worth doing?

like

Hi guys, I am kinda new to Sales and am wondering what it would take to become a top performer as an AE? I know this would depend a lot on the company and industry you are in but just wanna get some general tips from you guys. Thanks so much!

likehelpful

Hi fishes, What is the CTC I can negotiate for C05 role in Citicorp? Current CTC is 4.8L with 3 years of experience

like

How do you all put your job description on your resume in terms of your renewals? Retention rate. Premium increases. Etc.

like

Saw a few folks asking about Gold/Silver, so thought I would post the charts. I had been following SLV more closely as the technical set up was a bit more bullish, but noticed we had some good technical price action on GLD last few days. See charts within:

like

Hey all, I'm aspiring to get into real estate, currently making good money for my age, around 50k gross starting in November. And I'm living off about half my income, is there anyone in the Dallas area that I can talk to that is a professional landlord so I can learn about how to get started? Pitfalls, traps, what to look for, etc.

like

Folks , any idea about AllPay company. Anyone working

like

What's Deloittes WFH policy Incase one visits their home country for a few weeks?

P.S- Working in the US, home country is India.

like

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

If I’m doing a PT MBA in fall 2021 would it look bad if I left my current job for another in early spring?

like

If you indicate that you have firm sponsorship on your apps, are you not considered for scholarships?

like

Anyone already got or knows when GSB sends out interview invites? I know it’s throughout all of February, but would be cool to know when it really starts and if there are key dates

like

Bloomberg new grad ranking ...UVA Darden is 5 now?

likefunny

Okay to exclude class rank from Booth application?

like

What kind of scores do folks target for the AWA section of GMAT? My writing is way below average (like a 2/6 on a good day), so just wondering how much time I should spend on AWA compared to other sections

like

Anyone got connected to your Booth interviewer?

like

Trying to decide whether to pursue an MBA, a masters in something else, or stay where I'm at given the cost. Curious about those who made this decision, what motivated you in that direction and did it pay off?

I'm making 150k, 10% bonus, 5 yoe, business role in tech with a business undergrad. Trying to weigh the opportunity cost!

like

What is the benefit of a part time mba? I want to get one but I don’t see much recruiting perks so what is really being achieved here..further advancement of current job?

like

I have two GPAs:
1. 3.06 (includes all UG courses including transfer credit & some major courses)
2. ~2.9 (only UG courses taken at my 4-year university)
Which one will adcoms use for admission?

like

Wondering if I should start a business supporting b.school applicants. FWIW I graduated MBA2014 from London Business School, interviewed 20+ admits and helped countless more breakdown their application approach (identify unique selling points for essays, review essays, should they resit GMAT, how to get off waitlist - which I did, etc). What do you need the most help with? What would you be willing to pay? How much support time do you think you need?

like
like

Does not getting a call by the decision time imply that you weren’t accepted?

like

Any recs for insightful and well written books on entrepreneurship? Friend is trying to launch his own startup so I’m thinking of sending him a relevant book as part of a thank you gift

like

What are some questions you wished you asked current students or alumni before selecting a program?

likehelpful

When does CBS merit / financial aid come out?

like

Any white/Asian males get into a T15 school like Johnson/Tepper/Georgetown etc with a sub 320 GRE?

like

How is Yale SOM for IB?

like

Hey guys, I am sending 3 applications: SDA Bocconi, IESE and INSEAD (Jan 2021 Intake).
I would prefer INSEAD, but what if Bocconi or IESE accept me while INSEAD selection is still ongoing?

funny

Have any white males on here broken into an M7 with a 690 GMAT? Hoping to accomplish this feat..

like