Experienced trial attorneys, litigators, law clerks: Does your experience suggest that motions (or even cases) are won or lost on the quality and persuasiveness of briefs? I’ve been practicing for 7 years and seen hours and hours of time poured into “perfecting” briefs, and I’m not convinced it makes any difference. Seems like just lots of time/money spent on wordsmithing and nitpicking for little or no ROI. We’ve all seen “great” briefs lose and “bad” ones win. What am I missing?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Honestly this is something I've thought about alot. I clerked at the district Court level and while good briefs made my job alot easier, I often felt like the briefs didn't matter because I would essentially just do everything from scratch. The briefs were mostly helpful for their facts sections. Now that I'm back in practice I am slightly depressed how much time is spent wordsmithing and making tiny changes that are not completely irrelevant to the eventual outcome.

like

Don’t federal courts put more resources into the effort? I don’t think most state courts do everything from scratch when evaluating a motion and may rely more on the briefs.

like

All I know is they don’t matter near as much as the in-house counsels littering my papers with irrelevant commentary in track changes seem to think it does.

likefunny

I think it depends on the type of case, the venue, and other circumstances. The writing seems to matter more in federal court than state court in my experience. Sometimes good motions or briefs can preserve issues for appeal or narrow down the parties or scope of claims and give you an advantage later during discovery (and hence at trial or when it comes time to settle the case). Remember, the end goal is to add value for your client. That doesn’t always mean getting a verdict or an outright dismissal. You do what you have to do to get the best deal by winning as many of the small battles in the war as you can sometimes.

Sometimes the more obstacles you throw at a plaintiff and the harder you fight, and the more prepared snd capable you are, the more likely it is that they’ll settle for less than what they wanted, or they’ll foolishly charge into trial out of greed and lose because you are better prepared and postured, or because you have protected the record well.

But other times it’s just pissing in the wind, and an exercise in futility - Fighting battles you know you’re not going to win or derive a real benefit from just isn’t helpful. Or sometimes you are just in a crappy state court venue and nothing is going to go your way. No matter how crappy the other side is, they keep their case alive and it doesn’t even matter what you file. So you may as well just not file certain motions and avoid telegraphing your positions. You may as well just lay as low as possible, protect the record and try to win at trial.

Other times your case just sucks and you have to cut a deal without wasting time and money.

There’s no right or wrong overarching answer because it just depends. But either way, it’s work and gets you a paycheck.

like

I think you need to how your court and judge functions and what types of motions are successful. For example, you can have the best written demurrer. But a California state judge is unlikely to grant the motion with prejudice, especially in particular types of cases.

You also need to define success. Sometimes the purpose of the motion is educating a judge. Sometimes it’s to narrow the focus of trial. Remove damage issues. I think on all of these fronts, good briefs matter.

like

Briefs are for the appellate court. Lots of trial judges don’t read them. They’ll have their clerks read them and then summarize the arguments for them. You should still submit good briefs, but be prepared to educate your judge at oral argument as much as possible. If you get the sense your judge doesn’t read the briefs, ALWAYS ask for oral argument.

like

As a former clerk, I agree with what A1 and C1 both said. A well written brief made life easier. But I don’t think a well written brief will “win” the brief especially at the district court level. I will say that a poorly written brief can cost a party. This is because poorly written briefs are often accompanied by poor arguments. Additionally, if you fail to tie the argument to the facts and the facts are unclear, the court could miss a fact the party needs to prove. And a court is not obligated to search the record for facts.

Now that I practice, I do nitpick the minor details of my briefs. But I don’t do so because I worry about the court seeing a little error. Small mistakes are likely to be ignored or missed by the Court. But I strive to catch all the little mistakes because I find that if I and my staff are engaged at the level that we’re catching the little mistakes, then we’re much less likely to make larger mistakes. If I’m not focusing on the little mistakes, then I find me and my staff making bigger mistakes. So I think there’s a benefit to focusing on the little things, even if that benefit isn’t in Court.

like

I find judges are just as biased as any normal person and will rule based on those biases no matter how good the brief. What is most frustrating, though, is their opinions sometimes make it abundantly clear they didn’t read the brief and didn’t even care and restate the law incorrectly. I have a bunch of respect for judges in that they can become very knowledgeable in all areas of law, something I could never do. But when they get a brief from a lawyer who has practiced solely on that area their entire career, you would think they would take the time to read what that lawyer has to say, because as smart as that judge is, the lawyer probably knows more about the law in that case than the judge. But they don’t even bother and just write their opinion based on what they think the law says.

like

I clerked at a state trial court and the written submissions from attorneys were beyond helpful because I didn’t sit in on the trials and hearings (assigned to multiple judges at a time) so I needed the background info. Plus, half the judges told me what they wanted the end result to be and I created the decisions to back them up while the other half left it up to me to write the judgments and memos deciding a case. While there was no one memo/post-trial submission that won the case, I can say that the credibility of one side can be helped by well-written pleadings.

like

Judges can be unpredictable, and I find the vast majority are decent people who were good lawyers. However many trial courts have district judges field a variety of cases beyond what they practiced, so the judges sometimes don’t wholly understand the complexity of issues in front of them (I.e. a judge who only ever worked as a prosecutor presiding over a qui tam case or a products liability class action). Thus, judges who are not well versed on some areas of law will sometimes pick the winner of an issue based on who has the simpler explanation and/or more digestible writing, even if that explanation isn’t painting the whole picture of an area of law or accurately applying the law. Or, if they are unsure about an issue, they will often rule in the manner least likely to be flipped on appeal.

Related Posts

How is BUSINESS ANALYST -APPLICATION OWNER -DEPUTY MANAGER BAND II in ICICI Bank?
Also growth and WLB in technology division and anyone had similar offer with ICICI Bank.

My current title is Associate Operations Manager but my daily responsibilities show I’m working as a Senior Operations Manager. What salary increase can I expect/should I fight for during reviews?

like

Question for PMs who deal with hiring / managing creative freelancers. What platform / app do you use for having all your freelancers contacts info in one place. Do you have a company wide database or you just create your own spreadsheets for that? Thank you!

like

Anybody have suggestions for help to get a HLR done?

like

Hi Everyone! Happy Friday! I’m new to Fishbowl. I’m an experienced EA with a diverse background seeking a new role with competitive compensation and benefits. I’m located in South Florida but I’m open to remote, on-site, or a hybrid position. Feel free to reach out and connect!

like

Model y ?

like

Are deal sizes a proxy of your candidacy by any means? Looking to recruit Buyside but only have deal experience sub 200 million (carve out of assets)

like

Someone please tell me where in tf I need to drop my Hinge location in the DMV area to find my person. I’m in Baltimore and am getting frustrated/losing hope after only finding guys whose time would’ve been better spent focusing on themselves to be emotionally available and ready to date rather than dating as a distraction. I’m convinced I’m going to die alone. And if you have a single guy friend in that area who is a genuinely good person, please let me know 😂

likefunny

Buying our first home and from a friend, we are both not using realtor. How do you got about doing this, does some have a playbook I can use?

Attrition rate for other SBCs-

Infosys (28.4%), HCL Technologies (23.8%), Wipro (23.3%), Tech Mahindra (22%), Tata Consultancy (19.7%).

Post Photo
like

Hii fishes, I'm currently working as a Business Analyst (Tech role) with 2+ yoe and I'm on notice period (lay off like situation) without any job offer. I'm seeking the job referral in similar profile in Delhi-NCR preferably, if anyone can help. Advices and suggestions are also welcome. Thanks.

Interviews need to be monitored and recorded. I can’t tell you how many disappointed dreams I have been sold. It is a complete waste of time to really wait around to be wishful of a call. Gathering up 10 potential applicants to narrow it down to a top 3 and only make one offer is not acceptable. Much like jury duty, applicants should be compensated for their time.

like

The whole market is on sale fellas. What are y’all buying?

like

Relocating to work in NYC, and looking for a place to live with an excellent school system. Willing to commute up to 2hrs. Any recommendations (cities, counties, zip codes, etc.) will be much appreciated.

3 tips I always give to first-time home sellers that make my work easier:

1. Try professional photos. You have one chance to impress possible buyers. Use it wisely.
2. Be flexible with home showings. Maybe your possible buyers won't appreciate your house's potential if there are dogs running around or too many people inside.
3. Respond promptly to a purchase offer. Some people don't have much time to wait for an answer. Be quick and responsive!

like

Buy/lease now or defer to Q1-2023?

My car broke (engine seized, 10y old). I am interested in 530i ($62k price), however 3year lease is $1,000+ monthly (with $5k down). Monthly lesse payment is 50% more than bmw advertised offers (“south FL dealers are not participating in the program”)

Q to car gurus/experts- should I defer purchase/lease for 6 months? My logic, the impending recession will reduce demand and we will go back to more balanced market (lower prices with negotiation).

like

Hey Guys, Any referrals for 9+ yrs exp - Sr. Business analyst/Product manager - digital transformation roles with ux consulting background.
Kindly DM plz..
Thanks

like

I feel like all the gays are going to Puerto Vallarta for New Years

likefunny

Hi everyone. I'm in the process of building a SaaS startup. Someone with SaaS experience has advice on marketing the product for B2B?

like

Anyone got ideas about what this is? Screenshot of a video call so it looks like I took this photo on a TI-30…

Post Photo
like

Additional Posts in Litigation & Arbitration

Is there a page limit for motions in Florida state court? I know federal is 20 but can't find a rule for state. TYA!

like

Is having too much “attention to detail” a bad thing?

like

At what point do you begin to feel numb (if ever) when you’re done trial and prepping for another trial in a span of 3 months, while mains full caseload of other active litigation cases? Should I be worried that I’m going from engaged and stress to numb and slightly indifferent? Or is this what it feels like to power through? I can’t gauge it anymore? And can’t impose judgment one way or another either.

like

I feel bad because I think I left money on the table. I demanded something (as a plantiffs PI) and the OC actually thought it was reasonable. This why we come in so high sometimes. Ugh.

likefunny

Anyword on whether ny courts will be limiting jury trials? Nj has already issued an order.

like

I’m a sr litigation assistant at a boutique firm. I have been task to recruit, interview and hire new talent. I am shocked to hear that non-attorneys are seeking hourly rates and annual salaries higher than post-bar law clerks and first year attorneys. Is this the new norm???

like

I want a book to help me think more critically about structuring sentences, paragraphs, and legal arguments - and to eradicate poor grammar. I want to improve my legal writing. Any recs? I’m a litigator.

like

Looking for a family lawyer in Australia who either works on contingency or on the legal aid panel with respect to an access and property settlement case.

like

Deadline to Answer was missed, judicial default was entered, then a Default Final Judgment was entered without a hearing. Would this be an additional grounds for a Motion to Set Aside/Vacate? Assistant forgot to the calendar deadline, and when judicial default was issued, assistant was assigned to file the Answer/Counterclaim, but did not. Soon after, she quit. Was first put on notice when DFJ was issued.

like

I’m a Civil Litigation Paralegal in Florida. I have over eighteen years of experience with a team driven vision and hunger to provide superb customer satisfaction

Anyone taking the ride share (Uber, Lyft, etc.) misclassified as Independent Contractors mass arbitration cases? I have 150+ people to refer. I need to find a home for these folks. 😑 Thank you!

like

Just started at a new firm today. Yearly billables are 1900. Since I started 2 months into the year, do I need to hit the 1900? To recoup the first two months of the year means billing 190 a month.

like

Anyone know a firm that’s still taking the ride share arbs (workers being misclassified as independent contractors)? I have approx 150 potential clients and have no home for them. States include IL, MA, CA, NJ, and NY. Called LLR in MA but they aren’t calling me back. 😑 Would love to refer these people to someone. Thanks in advance! 🚗

like

Chewing Out New Guy - I got chewed out today because a disclosures deadline was not calendared in one of my cases and although I don’t handle the calendar, it’s my job to be aware of all deadlines and procedures. I got lectured for about 20 minutes. For context. I live in Texas and we just had a hell of a week. Is my management awful or am I sensitive rn?

like

Public entity defense- what are some interesting issues that arise in cases?

like

What’s everyone’s recommendation for a cost effective software to make a case timeline for trial?

like

Anyone have a good website vendor? My firm is looking to change the website design

like

I love a sassy email, especially if I’m only copied because attorney-client privilege attaches 😝

likefunny

Any insight on Amundsen & Davis? Salary, billable requirement, culture? Specifically looking at the Chicago office.

like

What is the best way to work with ornery opposing counsel? Been dealing with a guy that is known to be extremely hard to work with and he’s living up to that. My personality is to be assertive in this type of situation, but as a first-year, I don’t want to do/say something I’m not supposed.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal