Fellow šŸ  in MBB - there is a belief in a few consultants that being a part of MBB is the main goal at any cost. Being on the inside and having seen, through this application or your networks, what other firms do, do you think this belief is healthy? Would you consider your work to be just as enjoyable at another firm? If not, where do you think other firms fall shy of the MBB.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Consultants tend to put too much effort on career and income. MBB should absolutely not be the main goal at any cost.

Career-wise, I can talk for BCG compared to ATK (worked there) and all big 4 (worked with), that BCG is a very different league (sport even if we want to use cliches). And as such offers much more developmental opportunities, super smart people to work with (also making it all more enjoyable), better projects/part of projects, better exits opps and last but not least, better comp and benefits.

likehelpful

The work is one thing (likelihood of more exciting and impactful projects is higher at MBB), but the biggest reason to want MBB (IMO) is the prestige and exit opp potential. I know Iā€™m going to get flak for the ā€˜prestigeā€™ bit but my opinion is that it matters A LOT when youā€™re younger/first starting out in your career or right after the MBA (begins to matter less over time), because the brand name of MBB allows you to have the best exit opportunities (be it b school, PE, or others) right out of consulting and for years beyond that.

likesmart

Sure you make more money but you also work a hell of a lot more than partners in say Big4, and would have sacrificed a lot more to get there. Essentially trading your life for $$$

like

The belief is 100% not healthy. Itā€™s largely driven by the constant credential culture and everyone wants the next badge (or the hedonic treadmill). Also, only young consultants tend to get worked up about this vs. the rest of the world. It is funny how often our senior clients interchange the firms (not so much their person).

I think all consulting firms are so big now that the overlap of work is higher than folks realize. Ask anyone selling, weā€™re all competing with each other. We often say the project a consulting firm does for the first time this year is an industry commodity two years from now. And guess what, there is no single firm doing cutting edge project day after day.

One other part, if any person letā€™s say from b4/boutique made this post, youā€™d dismiss it as sour grapes. If someone from mbb does it, then youā€™ll challenge them and say, then why do they pay xyz or some anecdotal point which in their view signals value. In reality, all the firms are structured differently and that definitely changes its nature, economics, wages etc. However the work itself or projects sold are closer to each other.

like

Appreciate your perspective on this. I am definitely one of the younger consultants that is obsessed with the credential culture. I have self reflecting a lot and asking myself as to why, hence this post.

I guess for me it was about enjoying work and remaining driven. MBB sounded like the holy grail to me and I am unsure when and why this obsession came into place. Perhaps glances at LinkedIn on other peopleā€™s career had me feel inadequate by comparison.

That said I am still driven to become a partner. I think it is because I like the role a lot. It is sales focused with a heavy emphasis on strategy and flexibility. I like the challenge of that role. Maybe I am wrong but I guess there is only one way to find out.

Principals cominā€™ in hot. Nice work

like

I turned down T2 offers and would turn down MBB any time - earning 30% less but have a work life balance

like

What about small boutique? Couple friends there also had great exits.

like

Even at MBB/Big4 it is somewhat unfair to generalize. But impossible at the ā€œall boutiquesā€ level. Dependsā€¦ whatever makes you happy šŸ¤™

like

Iā€™ve worked at Big4 and there is so much overlap in the work we do. A lot of the time we are competing directly with Deloitte etc on tenders. More often than not they win due to rate differences. We seem to place too much esteem in MBB. I can say at Big4 as I was even more challenged as I often had little support and had to get more done with less firepower due to the variability in capability and motivation in junior team. Also limited help from leadership. At MBB everything is put on a plate for me. But the brand does signal to the market that I am good enough for MBB. Thatā€™s about it

like

May I ask what you mean by motivation in the junior team? Do you mean that B4 teams tended to be less aggressive in pursuing skill sets/assignments vs MBB teams?

Iā€™ve been obsessing over MBB for the last 14 years. Itā€™s absolutely not healthy; but itā€™s also necessary because thatā€™s what the job market demands. Literally every job post I see for even entry-level roles wants 10 years of relevant industry experience or 2-3 years at MBB. For those of us who werenā€™t born and raised in big tech, pharma, CPG, etc., MBB has become a mandatory prerequisite just like college or even an MBA. Iā€™ve been rejected from over 500 jobs for this very reason. So itā€™s not always young people seeking prestige; industry leaders have also created systemic barriers to entry.

There was no way for me to know that these application were before Deloitte, and I have personally never heard of "MBB or bust". If a hiring manager told me that, I'd walk straight out of the interview because that speaks volumes to their poor culture and arrogance. I would be genuinely interested to know what companies/industries are like that.

like

Related Posts

Career advice: have 8 years in account management(social focus) and feel kind of maxed out. I am very strong in media though, so do I pivot towards a media focused role or stick with accounts?

like

Anyone work in any of the MBB and do security work? I am shifting over and would like some insight. Thanks!

like

Looking for a career change, which career path has a higher salary?
Computer science or computer engineering?

like

Interested in applying for the SAP Tax Senior role @Deloitte. Essentially have 4 years background in Tax and would like to shift to a more technology related role. Thoughts on whether Deloitte would even entertain my background?

like

Hi,
I have an offer from Shell India Markets Private limited. Can anyone share me details about WLB, Career Growth, Hike and other important aspects that i need to consider.
Any inputs are highly appreciated. Thank you

Role : Software Engineer - Endur
YOE : 2.1 Years
Tech Stack : Core Java, Spring Boot, Sql

like

Does anyone have strategy book recommendations that help with coming up with frameworks and just general strategic thinking for corporations? Looking for helpful material to help me level up at my new job.

like

Hi, i will be joining a startup soon to work as a product manager. What are some good books/materials/courses I can read in the meantime to prepare myself better for the job?

like

Hi fishies! Considering an internal big 4 move from Western Europe to Dubai. Not sure about WLB and whether thereā€™ll be enough growth and learning opportunities after reading some of the threads here. Anyone up for sharing their experience? Especially concerned about sexism / racism as a WOCā€¦and whether moving back to Europe in a few years will be difficult because the ME experience wonā€™t be considered valuable.

like

Hey How is EY GDS work culture in terms of WLB, Senior management, growthā€¦ ? I see lots of negative reviews in quora and glassdoor ā€¦ anyone from GDS pls suggest

like

Hi all! I am looking to transition from an administrative job to an HR position, and it seems impossible to find something because most job postings require years and years of HR experience, and I canā€™t even make it through to the interview stage despite my 6 years of administrative experience. Any advice?

like

What exit opportunities are there in London that pay as well as consulting? Specifically in life sciences?

like

Hello everyone, I am a fresher and I recently joined a management consulting firm(3 months) with 12+LPA and I realised MC is not for me.
I tried giving it a shot for the first 2 months but then I am just dragging there after. Anyhow yk how it's in MBA, campus placement leli without a thought plus lack of experience in everything. It's tough out there.
I am desperate to switch to creative/marketing/branding/advertising. If anyone could help/guide/refer me in the right direction that'd be great.

like

Got offer from BCG for ECT. Read numerous comments about ECT being not attractive compared to Generalist track. Also heard challenges about billability/utilization. Any views/ guidance appreciated!
I am not super keen to become a partner (selling) and main reason to join will be working with different clients, smart talented people and a good brand. End goal (at the moment atleast) is to stay for few years and return to the industry. 15 YOE

like

Hi fishes, I have 2 offers-
Thermo Fisher for Data Engineer in AWS and Python and Ameriprise as Lead Developer for Informatica Powercenter. Ameriprise is offering 50k more in my monthly salary than Thermo Fisher. My preference is to join in where I can grow and get a good learning for future career growth. Also, work life balance should be good in the organization.
Please help me with making a clear decision. And i have 8+ YOE.

like

MBB folks, need some advice.

I am a Senior Con at Deloitte Tech (18 months in through a top MBA). I am 33 and have a kid. I am moving to Canada and exploring options. I have been advised by some ...

like

At what point in your first role are you actually expected to contribute vs learn on the job out of undergrad?

Iā€™m burnt out from job hopping but Iā€™ve never liked my current job and after a year in the role, I really want to get a new one. Iā€™m finding it hard to get a new one as a creative and Iā€™m running out of ideas of where else I should look. Thoughts?

Whatā€™s your gpa out of college - looking for those with lowest gpa, how easy was it to find a job? Also, anyone broke into t1 mba program or law school with the 2.0 gpa? I go first - 2.1 gpa out of t4 state college in 2002. Didnā€™t even try mba due to fear of rejection.

like

I am a Manager at a big 4 international tax considering switch to M&A Tax in another big 4 or a prestigious firm International Tax group but with more structure work. Which one is better for a long-term plan (~2 years) of going to private with a mid/upper management position that is not compliance oriented? As for me, I was heavy on compliance until recent and wanted to focus on getting planning experience and management skills forward. I am a CPA and an attorney, but not a JD.

like

Hi fishes,

Does anyone know about HR Path company. Is it a good company to join as a SuccessFactors Integration Lead ?
How about the work culture, work life balance, compensation and benefits?

Please help out a poor fish trying to move for a better life. @HRPath

like

More Posts

Where do all the under-30s go out in Philly?

Kindly drop me a mail with your resume at shaurya.gupta@sharechat.co if you fit in any one of the posts below

It only allows one photo a post so I will be posting more soon

Also feel free to dm

Post Photo
likehelpful

Is it difficult to switch from HCP to DTC or OTC? I feel like my skill set would be better suited for those areas. Since I started off in HCP will I always be seen as an HCP writer?

like

Iā€™m a financial services regulatory / Fintech lawyer in Singapore, have you heard of foreign lawyers in the financial services regulatory space in US? Iā€™m looking to move into the US market

like

Since weā€™re all posting photos of how beautiful it is here now. Guanella Pass 2 weeks ago. Should be perfect for a trip this weekend all. Stop in Georgetown for a bite to eat afterwards.

Post Photo
like

Has anyone been able to incorporate robotics into their science curriculum using NGSS standards? I have 5 vex kits and they aren't getting used!

Hello Iā€™m new to this app. And Iā€™m looking for interview tips. Right now Iā€™m interviewing for CX/CS roles. Let me know what are your thoughts.

like

Whatā€™s a reasonable amount to ask for in a pre-nuptial agreement where the guy makes a lot of money?

like

Interested in relocating to San Fran - what are the good spots ??

Anyone have any experience as a franchise owner? Looking to diversify....

like

Opinions welcomed:

V5 Legal Assistant here (2 years in industry, started at current firm in late April). Iā€™m on pace for 2700 billable hours / year. To boot, that rate is going up because of all of the 65+ hour weeks lately, and the first month being billed around 40.

I was just told that I may not qualify for any bonuses because I havenā€™t been here for 1 year.

Is this normal? Am I crazy for thinking that I should be getting a *significant* bonus for all of the crazy hours and deadlines?

like

Who hasn't cursed their email? Totes guilty here.

Post Photo
likefunny

Which Big4 firm has the biggest presence in Deals/FDD in philly?

like

Anyone financed a new car purchase in the last month or two? What rate did you get? Particularly interested in BMW, who isnā€™t publishing finance offers anymore. Are we over 5%?

like

Do I need to inform the USCIS/DHS I gained another citizenship? FYI I'm on a working visa specific for a certain country.

like

Am I the only one that doesnā€™t like the smell of essential oils? Theyā€™re always touted as refreshing, relaxing, magical, the best scent for home, etc etc. They all smell the same to me: medicinal and crunchy. Tried countless and never found one I like. Guess Iā€™m destined to breathe in toxic artificial ā€œmidnight sandsā€ fumes.

like

Hi fishes,
Has Any one have joined recently or anyone about to join with in this month. Kindly acknowledge. I have some queries related to joining.

Thanks

like

Hi All!

Can someone please refer me in Mastercard?

like

Iā€™m really glad someone made is bowl. Iā€™m sick and tired of all the Cole Haan and Banana Republic posts on Consulting in Style...

likefunnyuplifting

Hey is anyone up for a quick 2/3 hours of assistance to help list some vacant properties for rent on the rental sites like Zillow Avail. Turbotenant for just 3 hours and get paid $50 for this . Pls send a message if you can help with this Asap thanks

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

When, besides funerals, can you wear a black necktie?

like

consultant keeps making spelling mistakes on every document, including when they just need to copy and paste text directly from email instructions. when they send me work they now say ā€œlet me know if you find any spelling errorsā€ - and while i always check work because itā€™s a team effort, i feel like these careless mistakes could be avoided. english isnā€™t their first language (nor mine), is it insensitive to ask them to double check their work? or is there any other way to handle this?

likefunny

Desi Consultants!! - who all are thinking of hiring Sima Taparia (after watching Indian matchmaking on Netflix) for finding your future significant other?

likefunny

After 2 miserable years in this horrible company, I'm out! Resigning Monday.

like

I've been googling but please help!!! Anyone know of a way to erase txt messages.?!? Mgr and bf have same name sent the wrong pic to the wrong person... so not trying to get fired!!!

like

Which is best in Los Cabos? Hyatt Ziva (all inclusive), Westin, or Sheraton

like

Uber driver is driving like "nah, you can miss your flight it's okay"

like

Got a verbal offer from Capgemini almost 3 weeks ago. Any chance of getting an offer letter anytime soon lol? Job's in Krakow, Poland.

like

Where can I buy a tux? Looking for good quality without paying too much.

like

Do you all recommend monogramming your Tumi products? Yes or No?

like

I wasted my youth being responsible.

like

Does anyone own a motorbike? Where do I start if Iā€™m interested in looking? Also - any places that rent? FYI - I live in NYC.

like

Any Deloitte members have insights on any internal Supply Chain Consulting positions for someone with 1YOE.

like

Any idea of Deloitte's policy for booking AirBnB instead of a hotel room?

like

Looks like their may genuinely be a DHS ban on electronics (other than phones) on board planes coming soon. If so, I understand and respect the decision,though it will have a massive opportunity cost

like

Had a meeting with my counselor yesterday and I got a 2. She thinks I should've gotten a 1 but with this new YE format, she could not suggest/defend a rating. Bummer!

like

TFW when you are dressed for an ugly sweater party and strut through the Westin lobby to stares #LikeABoss

like

What is maximum amount you can submit for cell phone bill reimbursement ?

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but Iā€™m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Anyone real estate investing? Looking for good podcasts /books/resources on non-commercial multi family in particular.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a previewā€¦
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what itā€™s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See whatā€™s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal