For what reasons have you seen a summer associate not receive an offer at the end of the summer?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

My practice group has been lucky enough to avoid this (knock on wood), but attitude/personality and work product are huge. If you come across as entitled and unwilling to help or to put in the time as a summer, or are generally unable to put yourself in a team mentality, that is going to go over like a lead balloon in most places. Poor work product that is symptomatic of a lack of diligence/care/effort, or poor work product that doesn’t seem apt to correct through training is also a huge red flag.

like

One of my closest friends didnt get the offer after being a summer in his pinnacle dream role because he simply "didn't buy in enough" to the practice. Which I believe is code for "you don't work that hard and you're difficult to work with."

Oof, that is cold. Duly noted.

Recent IconRecent

Plagiarism (ironic, I know), bad work product, lying to third parties about being an associate, personality issues (arrogance typically), etc...I shake my head each time because the firm is literally over-paying you to be good for 12 weeks in order to give you a high six figure job that we have no idea whether you will be good at and people seem to still not act right.

like

"You're pre-fired!" - Dwight K. Schrute, California State Bar Board of Admissions

likefunny

It was 2009.

likefunny

😥

like

Only worked a strict 9-5 and thought the other summer students were stupid for working “hard not smart.” Also thought he was entitled to work with the high ranking partners and would turn down associate work that had come from those same partners.

likefunny

And his work product was terrible because he never spent enough time editing or researching. I’m amazed we let him continue for as long as we did, to be honest.

I’ve seen multiple summers cold offered for not respecting female attorneys. Nothing super egregious, just a pattern of doubting the ability of female attorneys and being insubordinate to them no matter how senior. Hard to feel too bad for those guys.

One of

like

It’s unconscious bias that the rest of us have become all too aware of. Once you learn how to spot that pattern it’s pretty hard to not want to sit other male associates down and ask
them wtf they’re doing.

Usually there is something socially wrong with them.

Their work just should be passable, not over-the-top good. But if they have a social dysfunction, they are not getting an offer.

One summer from Stanford Law didn’t get an offer because her work contained a lot of grammatical errors, she said she took caffeine pills to get going in the morning, and she was too bubbly to the point it was obnoxious.

Another from Hastings Law, claimed he turned in an end-of-summer assignment, but he did not. Then he emailed it in later, apologizing, but the metadata in the document said the document was created after the summer associate period ended. The implication was that he had forgotten to do the assignment, and did it after he was reminded, and then lied about it.

Things like this result in no job offer.

In one assignment, it told an equity partner that I thought her legal analysis was wrong. I was a 1L summer telling a 30-year practitioner and co-owner of a biglaw firm that she was wrong. I still got an offer to come back for 2L and I was offered an associate position after law school.

like

Dysfunction is a strong word, but generally I think this is referring to people who (for example) take their stress out on support staff, make inappropriate jokes, and generally make others uncomfortable to be around. Let’s be honest, most lawyers are at least a teeny bit socially awkward, so our tolerance for similar social awkwardness is high.

It veers into dysfunction when it impacts the ability of others to work with you or generally be around you. If it’s going that way, I genuinely suggest seeking a therapist, as there are definitely strategies to deal with severe social anxiety or other issues that can make it all a little easier. Ain’t no shame in therapy. So many people see therapists is almost a badge of honor (and to be clear, pretty much everyone could use a therapist at one point or another).

Hope that helps! Slight awkwardness just makes you one of us. *insert chant here*

like

To not get an offer, you have to break Rule Number 1. Rule Number 1: don't be weird. Lawyering can really suck. We need to hire folks we won't want to strangle at 10pm on a Thursday when we're already 60 hours into a crappy week.

like

I'm seconding this. Be likable and do good work.

I’m relieved that none of these answers have anything to do with 2L grades/rank dropping. We haven’t gotten grades back yet, but I am sweating, as always, after finals.

like

Love to hear that!! Thanks A2

like

I see you're at patent agent. What is your technical background?

like

That’s interesting. I’ll have to see if they’re willing to let me bounce around next summer, it’d be great to try it all. I kind of owe it to the IP lit chair for getting me the job in the first place, so hopefully he doesn’t try to monopolize my time all summer.
Appreciate the feedback, A3!

like

Only one person in my summer class did not get an offer. Never answered emails or phone. Apparently the work product was fine, but just never, ever communicated with the partners or associates.

like

Not sure this qualifies, but here’s a good one: I assigned work to this guy at 10AM. At 3PM, he sent me half the assignment and wrote that “(someone else entirely unrelated) will send you the complete assignment”. He then proceeded to disappear for the next hour (he probably knew I would want to throw my keyboard at him or he was completely oblivious to what he’d done and went to Starbucks)

It takes guts to do that. I wonder what a partner would do to me if I delegated work that was delegated to me and peaced out at 3 PM.

I’m not sure this qualifies as a response to OPs question because for some reason I did not report him to the partners and instead gave him
a very stern talking to. And told Unrelated Person A to not accept work from people in their same category unless under specific instructions from someone more senior. But it’s a great example of what not to do.

like

Uh

like

Getting too drunk* around someone who doesn’t drink that much, or around someone who is insecure about how much they drink.

*not an objective value, depends on how much people, including the person you are drinking around, like your personality to begin with.

Alcohol abuse is so rampant in the profession that I find it both unhelpful and dishonest to pretend that there is an objective line that can be crossed when it comes to acting inappropriately with alcohol as a summer associate (or even as a real associate). But that’s how hiring committees talk about a summer drinking “too much” if it happens. If you don’t know the people you’re working for well enough (hint: you don’t) it’s best practice to drink a couple soda waters with lime and make sure you’re never the last (and also never the first) summer associate to leave an event.

like

Attitude.

Not as summer associate, but was contracted as a freelance lawyer (mostly 40-50hr billable/week) and renewed for 2,5 years consecutively. When applying for an associate position (=taking a large pay cut and doing the same work with more hours, but opportunity to take the traineeship necessary for the bar) they didn't make me an offer because of 'lack of analytical skills'.

Two days later I get a contract renewal. In other words: hiring you as an employee gives you too many benefits and worker protection since our firm operates under Dutch law. Fine, I'll just keep billing hourly—double for overtime and weekends—and look somewhere else in the meantime 🤷‍♂️

That’s a truly odd system man

like

I’m pretty sure you have to be credibly accused of murder and/or sexual harassment.

That’s double hearsay

like

We had a summer associate no-offered a few years ago because: she had two assigning partners - she told each partner that she was too busy to take on an assignment because the other partner was keeping her so busy. She was able to avoid doing much work over the summer but when the partners happened to speak, they found out each had barely given her work because they thought the other one was and they didn't want to overwhelm her.

Related Posts

I am on my third IUI and it didn’t work... have been trying for 1.5 years and we are unexplained. I am not sure whether to continue with IUI or go through IVF route... Anyone in a similar situation, can you share what did you do and why you chose one vs another option?

like

Exl offices not opening anytime soon right ?

like

Disability assessments - anyone work for Medical Resource Group doing disability exams?

like

In this Assurance-Consulting split, where would the SaT and Tax service lines end up?

like

I recently discovered that my nanny told my 2 month old that God will watch over her and I'm concerned. I want to be the one that introduces her to religion, and I'm worried that this indoctrination is just going to confuse her. Should I fire my nanny?

funnylike

Hi,
Good morning..
I joined Ey gds last week.. YOE- 4 years in KPMG. KPMG may take me back with better hike and promotion. I'm not sure. But a few got call back. So, what would I do? Accept the better package and promotion or be in EY? OR is it possible to resign within one month from EY?

Thanks folks

like

I haven't really been paying attention. Can somebody let me know what the covid vaccine actually does? Does it just surpress the symptoms for myself, or does it actually stop the spread?

like

Hi,
Can anyone refer me for the position of Selenium Automation Testing.
Total 8 years of exp Relevant 5 years.
kindly respond if you have any openings.

like

Delta medallions who flew last Monday - do we get 20k points instead of the $200 dollar voucher or do we get both? Points hit my account but no voucher.

like

Has anyone here skipped a level when jumping between firms? As in I’m C level now (on deck for SC), but have enough YOE for M level roles at other firms (I came in as an experienced hire C).

like

Has anyone successfully lightened darker knees? If so how? I want them to be same color as my legs

like
like

How long does it typically take for a company to reach out to references? I gave mine a week ago after the whole interview process and they still have not been contacted.

Hi guys. I have a query with regards to the Income tax proof submission.

So I have claimed exemptions on the following-
1) HRA
2) 5 year term deposit(fixed deposit) under Section 80C
3) Interest on education loan under Section 80E

I have also provided previous employment details.

Guys I didn't know that we have to submit declaration forms as well. Can you please tell me which are the declaration forms that I would need to fill and submit??

Thanks in advance :)

like
like

Interested can share profiles to ltireferrals@gmail.com or DM with job roles and email id to apply

Post Photo
like

What is the general consensus on online I/O psychology programs? I’m looking to pivot into HC consulting and am strongly considering USC’s online MAPP or Harvard Extension School’s I/O Psychology graduate program.

like

Hello fishes, I am working at IBM and currently on bench. I will be resigning today as I have a better offer in hand right now. Wanted to know if I have to serve entire notice period of 90 days even when on bench or IBM gives early release ?

like

Hi Fishes,

Does anyone know about TE-DL Data Platforms Team/Project in KGS. My joining date is 11th April and I will be part of this team.

Additional Posts in Law

What’s your take on Lydecker? What is the culture? Market salary? Expectation on billable hours? Mentorship? Etc.?

like

175 billables a month - exhausting or manageable?

funnylike

Does anyone feel their practice area is fun and/or exciting? I’m a commercial litigator and yes I have a wide variety of cases but it’s becoming kind of redundant. I’ve always had an interest in business, finance, investments etc. (private equity and stock market) and was wondering what practice would be best to merge the two?Any suggestions or comments on what you find to be an enjoyable practice area?

like

In Corpus Christi. Solo Practice. Business plummeting. Does TWC pay laid off employees?

like

Tips for starting a new job in the virtual environment?

likehelpful

My company forces all employees to submit an email every day with an hour by hour summary of what they did. Any other companies other than firms doing something like this?

likesmartfunny

For small firms - What was your billable rate in 2015 and what is it today in 2022. Please provide your practice area too, if possible!

like

When you’re about to give notice but they are bringing you on new client project’s…. Sorry…

like

Which books would you recommend to a product counel for tech startup about strategy, management, and leadership?

like

I took adderall while I was studying for the bar and it really helped. I don’t have a prescription but am wondering if this likely means I have undiagnosed ADHD but don’t know how to bring this up to my doctor. I definitely have trouble focusing in general and have always been pretty dozey/aloof but have somehow gotten by and am now a third year associate who is doing okay without it. Do you think getting Aderall could help even though I’m doing fine? Maybe I’ll go from good associate to great

like

Besides reporting it up the chain, advice for an associate in dealing with a support staff whose lack of motivation is affecting cases negatively?

like

Is anybody in the house at one of the big four accounting firms? They keep advertising legal counsel roles and I'm just curious about what the work is like/ what the work life balance is. I'm primarily interested in non tax rolls if they exist in that organization

likehelpful

I’ve gotten great reviews and great work from my firm. One partner I just hate working for, though. She micromanages and sometimes it feels like she’s trying to embarrass me. Any advice?

like

My current job does not give me opportunities to write legal memos or briefs. I am applying for a different job and do not have a current writing sample because of this. Any recommendations on what to do?

like

FL fish - any insight on Hill Ward Henderson culture? Specifically the construction & design group?

like

2015 grad currently at a startup and like it, but feeling increasingly anxious about loans and have thought about applying to firms. Is it even remotely possible to be considered for big law at this stage in the game, or has that ship sailed? Thanks!

like

Does your firm provide an automatic raise each year of practice? Would you request for a raise if you have done exceptionally well and are paid below industry standards or is it just not the year to do so due to the pandemic?

like

Hi folks. Mid level corporate associate thinking of making a move into the tech industry (preferably in a legal-adjacent or non-legal position). Any thoughts on how to make the move, such has what types of folks to network with and skills I should obtain?

like

I am trying to create a list of matters for the last 3 years for a conflicts check (firm requires listing every single party involved) and it is QUITE the process. Any ideas on how to make it less burdensome?

like

California attorneys — I am having difficulty finding authority concerning the use of a rejected (partial) settlement offer to claim that a party failed to mitigate their damages. I.E. plaintiff could have mitigated if they accepted the (partial) settlement offer. Defendant offered to settle one claim (without affecting the others). Plaintiff rejected. The value of damages has increased over time and now defendant claims that plaintiff failed to mitigate because they did not accept the offer. TY

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal