Generally, is it harder to take or defend depositions? I started doing deps this year and I find defending deps to be a lot more stressful!

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

100% harder to defend

like

Clarification: not the actual defending - it’s then mostly out of your hands of course - but the witness prep that goes into it is harder. Assuming you’re always or nearly always representing defendants, anyway. By contrast, taking depos is the most fun part of the job!

like

I would rather take a deposition than defend one. Especially when opposing counsel is a dick. That said defending a depo from a Co-Defendant is far less stressful, especially when we’re aligned against Plaintiff and the cross-complaints are indemnity claims.

like

I find taking harder, because I have to think in the present and also several steps ahead. When defending my brain hurts by the end, but once I get a feel for the person taking the depo I don’t feel like I’m trying to do two things with my brain at once.

Depends a bit on the deponent though. Taking expert depos makes me want to set my brain on fire. Taking the depo of a third party that isn’t angry at my side is less stressful than defending many depos.

like

Defending is stressful. Taking is fun.

like

Totally agree

I’ve probably done 100+ either way. My opinion: Defending is much harder because the stakes are higher. If things go south while defending, you could lose your case quickly. If things go south while taking, you may lose an opportunity but you’ll probably have another one with a different witness (or at trial).

like

Exactly this

Defend. Especially if your corporate clients (like mine) want a pretty detailed recap of the depo before the transcript is out!!

like

That’s what the rough transcript is for!

Taking is way harder, especially if you’re limited in time like with federal depos. Defending is basically just enforcing rules of evidence through timely objections. However, defending feels much more taxing because you’re constantly trying to make sure your witness is sticking to the strategy.

like

More mentally taxing in the moment to take it because you have to constantly think of new questions and ways to get an uncooperative witness to reveal information. But I think preparing to defend a deposition especially a corporation PMK witness is more taxing overall because of the witness prep involved and because the stakes are higher if the witness says something bad.

like

I have never left a deposition that I’ve defended with sweat stains, red eyes, and utterly exhausted. Only taking depos has that affect on me.

like

Taking a depo takes a loooong time to prep. But once I’m in the depo, I ask my questions, follow up, and frankly don’t feel too personally invested in what they say.

Defending doesn’t take as much time hours wise, but sitting in the depo with no control over what a witness is saying is hell on the nerves.

like

Depends on the depo. I generally think taking them is more often than not harder because you have to cover a lot of substantive ground. However, defending can be sometimes more difficult. I find that 30b6 witnesses can be hard to defend (can’t object based on lack of personal knowledge, often hard to keep the other lawyer from staying in the scope of 30b6 questioning), along with former managerial employees (murky and unclear law around A/C privilege, when and to what it applies).

I’d add that some witnesses are incredibly difficult to prepare (doesn’t care, doesn’t understand the case, has a temper, etc), and that’s part of defending a depo.

Defending fact witness depos is much harder than defending expert ones because experts are usually more seasoned/less likely to go rogue, etc. Fact witnesses often ramble off-topic and fall for OC’s traps.

Taking depos does require more prep up front, but the actual taking of the depo to me is much less stressful than defending.

Taking depos by a long shot. Defense is ridiculously easy.

Taking stresses me out more. Defending, there isn't much in my control, I tell myself and my client we can prep but most of the time we just got to ride with it and we're going to feel like shit after even if it wasn't as bad.

Related Posts

Isn't it possible to have a conversation with hiring manager in Amazon before joining. I tried to have a catch up with him regarding my roles and responsibilities, but my manager denied. I was told , that I will be only able to interact with him after joining. Now I am starting to give a second thought about joining Amazon.
Should I drop the offer?

Well why’s this my life

Post Photo
likesmartfunny
like

Do you guys completed GIP advance training. I am a new joiner and it is a mandatory course..I have gone through the material but it seems many pieces are missing and that's why not able to solve all the assessment questionnaire. Any one have dumps for the latest.please help

likehelpful

My Salesforce administrator exam is suspended.
Any one help me on this.

like

Recruiter reached out about Hatch Advisory Energy and Infrastructure practice. Anyone have an idea regarding compensation and bonus for Hatch Engagement Manager?

like

Adventures of an all female team:

"You totally have sex hair.... I'd look like that every morning if I had a boyfriend like yours"

Client and coworker bonding over period flow colors.

likefunnyuplifting

Hi there! I’m looking for a role as a technical project manager. Preferably at a bank but I’m willing to look into healthcare as well. Please let me know if your company is hiring and you can provide a referral :)

like

Does anyone that has returned back to the office find it more distracting than ever or is it just me?

likehelpful

Anybody interested in a volunteer opportunity? I need help editing videos for YouTube & social media and would love some extra hands

funnylike

Is selling feet pics an unethical side hustle?

likefunny
like

Any one received offer from Walmart in Data Strategy & Insights department?

like

What’s the best handheld steamer for travel, any recommendations?

Hello everyone,

I am in a bit of confusion, i have a job in hand and i am on a notice period in my current organization. Another company called me qnd said that will you join us if we give you a better offer. I may get a good raise but will it be ethical to do this ...
Please help

like

Any ideas about the type of “healthcare” roles in Amazon, Best Buy and Walmart? FYI - background is strategy consulting in health.

like

Hi Sharks,

I have recently joined new organisation where my offer is 18fixed + 1.8variable.

I was having CTC of 8lpa in my previous organisation.

How could be the tax calculation for this year? How the tax is computed with 2 different CTC's? In which tax slab I would come under as per old regime?

I have joined in Oct with new organisation. Till Sept I was with old organization.

like

4 years today. #grateful #keepcomingback

like

Anyone a part of Soho House? Is it worth it, thinking of joining

like

Nice polo recommendations, and work leather belts?

Additional Posts in Law

When your firm requires billable hours, how are they calculated? Actual vs realized (I.e. what you put on your billing sheet vs what is billed to the client). Does your firm differentiate? Which number do they go by? My mind is somehow not comprehending how some big law hours are under my small firm requirement?

like

Easier to go from litigation to transactional or transactional to litigation? I’m currently in litigation but wondering if I I could make the switch later in my career.

like

Any recruiter recommendations for LA / SoCal?

like

What is a high paying JD advantage job? I have 3 years of experience as an attorney

like

The amount of people, even attorneys, who can't separate out the policy merits of abortion from the issue of whether it is a constitutional right is disappointing. I consider myself pro-choice ---I believe states should allow it, that the federal government can pass a statute to guarantee it, and that FDA statutes and regulations will preempt any state trying to ban chemical abortions through FDA approved drugs. Dobbs at its core is a case about the Due Process Clause, not the policy of abortion

likesmart

Anyone have any stories where you thought you failed the bar exam but ended up passing? I’m a retaker anxiously waiting dc bar results. They’re out tomorrow.

like

I’ve been in house my entire career (6 years) and I am thinking about transferring to big law. I feel the experience would sharpen key skills and compensation wise would work out better. Has anyone made this transition before? Is it too late?

like

How do you interview for a new position without alerting your current firm that you are looking to leave?

likehelpful

Would poor law school grades disqualify me from NYU’s tax LLM program (firm will pay for it).

likehelpful

Small firm: boss, myself, paralegal. Paralegal’s family lends paralegal $ for a transaction. Paralegal pays it before other party holds up their end of deal. Paralegal needs $ because family needs it back & think she still has it since deal isn’t done. I let paralegal borrow money (cover my a** with documentation). First payment is weeks late and only made on demand. Month 2 not paid. Month 3 is overdue a few days. Should I file suit? Loop in my boss? Other options? It’s 2/3 my total savings.

likehelpful

I use ring central but people keep saying they're having trouble hearing me when I'm on my the mobile app. On the computer it's fine. Does anyone have suggestions? Any better service provider?

like

Looking for a job in Omaha. Appreciate any leads!

like

Plaintiffs counsel took my clients deposition today. He mentioned that he would likely be ordering the transcripts and I suggested we split the cost of them (in front of court reporter). He got pretty defensive and said absolutely not, it’s unfair to the court reporter, and that it is frowned upon in the industry to do that. Each party orders (and pays for) their own copy. I’m in my 2nd year of practice, never heard such a thing. I’ve actually split the cost before! Curious for insight on this…

likefunny

Has anyone watched The Practice? Just came across this 90s legal drama show on Hulu and I love it!

like

Is there a market for lawyers to add expertise In crisis management or reputation management? My goal is to counsel clients on how to respond to media inquiries without saying or posting something detrimental to a potential litigation while still maintaining communication with their client base. If so, how to break into that industry? Courses? Books? Certifications?

like

Advice requested: When you were a legal intern or a summer, what type of projects did you like best? What was most helpful to you when you received a new assignment? Anything you wish your mentor did/didn’t do? I’m working with my first ever intern and trying to structure projects so they know that the work is important and relevant to the business, and why, and to provide enough background info on the area of law so they don’t spin wheels on the basics. What else should I be doing?

likehelpful

For small firms - What was your billable rate in 2015 and what is it today in 2022. Please provide your practice area too, if possible!

like

2nd year associate working in employment law at a big firm. I think I might want to make a move into HR eventually. Has anyone done this? Is it tough to find job opportunities? How much firm experience should I get first?

like

I took adderall while I was studying for the bar and it really helped. I don’t have a prescription but am wondering if this likely means I have undiagnosed ADHD but don’t know how to bring this up to my doctor. I definitely have trouble focusing in general and have always been pretty dozey/aloof but have somehow gotten by and am now a third year associate who is doing okay without it. Do you think getting Aderall could help even though I’m doing fine? Maybe I’ll go from good associate to great

like

What do you all get your boss for the holidays? I’m thinking a bottle of good whiskey should suffice. Would like some input on this subject.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal