Got admission at Booth, Sloan, Tuck, and Kellogg in R3 last spring. Deferred one year at Booth (chose it bc it’s the best of those schools and I also got a scholarship). Then applied to H/W this fall—rejected at both without interview—but am determined to re-apply to H/W in fall 2021, probably along with Columbia. Is it crazy to let go of Booth? Not feeling excited about going there. 760 GMAT, 3.3 GPA, Top 10 undergrad, 1.5 years in Econ consulting and 1.5 years at MBB (promotion coming up).

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yes. Covid, recessionary pressures, and the rise of 2+2 programs will make sure that you have worse odds than you did in the 2019-2020 cycle (which was abnormally easy that cycle). Take Booth and don’t look back.

like

OP have you considered Kellogg? Its a phenomenal school with a great fit! I have heard amazing things from lots of Bainies who went there!

like

Based on rankings but agreed best is a subjective word open to interpretation. Deadweight anyway and not material to my decision at this point.

like

To answer your actual question, if you really don't feel the pull at Booth as much as the others, that's fine. Doubt you see that much difference in outcomes from one to the others, so prioritizing fit makes sense.

like

So are you saying I should re-app to H/W? Not sure I understand your answer.

If you were denied without interview this year your chances for next year aren’t great. You still have time to apply to Columbia for rolling admission though. If you’re really not feeling Booth then fine (even though it seems like a great program to me) but don’t sacrifice a bird in the hand for one in the bush, so they say.

like

Follow your heart. If you’re gonna live with regret from not going to HSW, you gotta do you

like

“Booth” being the best of those schools is subjective.

like

The argument should really depend on your post-MBA goal. I got admissions at Kellogg and Booth ($) and eventually went with Kellogg given its focus on marketing and networking. All the K alum I talked to are passionate and willing to share info and refer you to others/the job. Booth across the street is more academic (aggressively) and finance concentrated. Now I keep interacting with Booth students and finishing my first quarter at Kellogg and still no big regret (course bidding is a pain at K). So I don’t think Booth is “clearly better” than the others, it really comes to what you want for your career path after MBA.

like

Any thoughts on why you got dinged no interview from W with a 760 and MBB experience? How compelling is your story? Curious bc I also have a 760 and am applying W R2 this year

like

Your story is a huge part that can't be overstated. If it's compelling you still have a shot

like

Is it unethical if someone defers and then reapplys to HSW, gets in and goes there? I know you’ll lose the deposit, but if Booth finds out, could someone get their HSW offer rescinded?

like

Yes it is unethical. Some schools explicitly state you cannot even apply elsewhere in the deferral agreement. Not sure on Booth

like

I already turned down Kellogg, Tuck, and Sloan in R3 after being accepted. To be honest I don’t think I would be happy anywhere but H/S/W, or maybe Columbia

Okay well then if thats the dream, go for it! CBS would love someone like you (with your high GMAT). Just make sure to show them the love in the application. If you are applying next year consider doing it ED! For H/S/W its really just a crapshoot and I totally resonate with not understanding why you didn't get interviews. But a couple of ideas:

(i) Have you critically looked at your rec letters - they can serve as a true differentiator particularly for Wharton (who care about them a lot)

(ii) For HBS - can you somehow demonstrate extraordinary leadership outside of work? Anything you are passionate about? Maybe start a foundation / club etc.

(iii) For Stanford, they really care about people being drawn to a 'social cause' and demonstrating through your work/EC's that you are making a difference in that space. For most people this is the hardest to curate (particularly if you are just a consultant)

like

Related Posts

Any good situational questions for an Associate Program Manager interview?

like

Any idea of timeframe in which mckinsey and company responds. I was interviewed for a role which company found suitable for me, and they wanted me to join. McKinsey & Company

like

Hi guys!

What do they ask in 2nd round of techno-management interview?? Any tips would be greatly helpful...

like

I completed my Loop today and I think it went well but who knows. It was not as terrifying as I had expected. I really have no idea how it went as I have had "final interviews" and felt I did well and then did not get the role. Let the wait begin!!

like

Has anyone Attended a interview for Automation tester with 3 - 4 yoe?
Please share the reviews like what they expect and what all to prepare.
Thanks in advance.

like

Any advice to help prepare for data science analyst role at top consulting firms (McKinsey & Company EY Boston Consulting Group etc)? Any materials, open source platform recommended to take on freelance data science project? When should I start actively looking and applying? I am a new grad who is working in tech as a marketing analyst I’m looking to pivot to marketing& sales data science consulting next year. Would like someone with similar backgrounds offer some practical tips.

like

What are your long-term goals in pharmacy? Do you want to just max out your possible salary or will you move onto another career path/move?

likehelpful

Any body working in tech here? I just started Coursera project management certificate and wondering your thoughts

like

I am an advertising professor studying how people’s identities shape their experiences in advertising. I am interested in interviewing LGBTQ+ folks to learn whether and how your identity shapes your experiences and perspectives on advertising and the work you create and produce. If you’re willing to chat, email me at kwindels at UFL dot edu.

like

What are the best consulting firms for strategy that are non-MBB? Not implementation and such

likesmart

I have completed 1st round (technical interview) and now they've scheduled 2nd round in CGI .HR said it could be techno managerial round.. Anyone who attended it can share review about it and what kind of questions will be asked? CGI

like

Dear Fishes,

Can you help me give a bit of description of EXL? How is it in terms of WLb Job security and Growth and hike?

YoE - 5 years

like

Good day all!

I am interviewing for a FP&A Manager position in Proserv UK. Could you please disclose the initial salary that I could ask for?

Thank you in advance!

like

Anyone doing data science roles in Dallas, particularly at IBM, willing to chat with my brother? He’s a recent Physics masters graduate at UTD looking to pivot to the field. Thanks in advance!

like

Currently in finance, but finishing my MS Accounting and prepping for the CPA exam. I’d love to work in audit since I am also studying for my CIA exam as well. Any advice on transitioning to audit?

I have an interview for a Senior Cloud Architect role with Capgemini but didn't really get what level would that be. Any thoughts? thanks

like

Hey folks, I want to exit into industry by year end, and ideally I’d like to target associate director or SM roles at biopharma (thinking corp strategy, Portfolio planning, BD&L). I have roughly 2 YOE with a PhD. A large proportion of the companies I am interested in (cell and gene tx) are based in Boston, but I’m wondering how the opportunities are in New York, since I might be moving there to be closer to my S/O. Will I have more or less options, and will remote options be here to stay?

like

Finally heard from Facebook RPM!! So pumped, just to get in the groove of interviewing

likefunny

Can I raise resignation request from workday in Accenture? Or is there any step before that for manager approval before that? Accenture Tata Consultancy Infosys

like

Anyone an MLT MBA Prep fellow? Recently got accepted to the program, but am wondering if the cost is even worth it. Would love to hear about people’s experiences!

like

More Posts

Anyone here work for or heard of Crexi?

like

Can I get 15 likes so I can DM please!!??

likesmart

Partners, were you always recognized as a top performer throughout your career?

likehelpful

Tomorrow is payday fishes!!!!

like

Has anyone done an m&a tax case study for industry jobs? Heard most jobs have them as part of the interview process. Anyone have any insight they can share? Misty dd or structuring? Domestic or international? Thanks!

like

Im using Azure Devops what is the best tool to prepare road map.

Need suggestions. kindly help.

uplifting

When I’m online at 10:30 on Sunday night, that doesn’t mean I’m working and you can ping me about some BS that can wait 12 hours until we’re on the clock.

It means I’m watching the Asia open and updating my watchlist for my personal trading account.

Pls fix.

likefunny

Looking to connect with a recruiter (or anyone) that’s familiar with strategist / brand manager roles. I feel a bit lost and hoping for some advice on job search and feedback on my resume

like

Hello,
I work in insurance but I am trying to pivot into tech sales. I am having trouble explaining my metrics during interviews. For us, our KPI is based on a quota issued to each state. Ex Ma being 143%. Throughout Ma, we have multiple offices but my office, in particular, is currently at 260% of quota. I have brought in 60,000 of sales for our team. Since I don't have a quato, how can I demonstrate my performance. Many thanks!!

like

Has anyone had any conversations with their manager regarding the accelerated salary increase? It's supposed to be communicated in July.

like

How much salary should I expect as an Automation Engineer (Python) if I switch. Current salary 23LPA, 5 YOE.

like
funnylike

This is really funny. What are they smoking?

Post Photo
funny

DM for referal !!

like

I am looking for a switch in Business Analyst role. I have 2.5 years of experience in Managed Services and currently pursuing MBA - Distance Degree. Please help me with any referrals.

like

We just picked up our wedding rings and I don’t wanna take mine off! I keep wearing it around the house 😍

like

How is TSC(Tractor Supply Company) project in Infosys, is it US shift or we can b free by 7??

like

Hi,

I left CG in June and when I'm trying for PF transfer in unable to because CG has not marked my exit in the UAN portal.

Can you please give the contact of pf team or fnf team to reach out

Thanks

like

Why have the waterfront areas not been developed for public recreation in the Silicon Valley/ South Bay area like it has been in San Francisco or New York? Seems like a big missed opportunity!?

like

Officially 3/4 of the way there! Got my FAR result back this morning.

Score of 84 using Becker. Focused the most on the assets, liabilities, and gov. chapters. Took two practice exams.
Mock 1 - 65%
Mock 2 - 75%

like

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

I want an MBA, but I have way too much debt from doing an out of state undergrad program and I know scholarships are great but unless it’s close to a full ride I don’t think it’d be enough for me. I’m the trailblazer in my family so I really just have myself to rely on. I’d like to hear about everyone’s experiences with (or plans for) funding their MBA. Please also include any amount of debt you currently carry from undergrad + the cost and length of your MBA program.

like

Random question but does anyone know if Wharton provides MS Office licenses/subscriptions to students?

like

Applying to HSW R1 with my significant other. Anyone else in the same boat or have any tips?

like

Anyone an MLT MBA Prep fellow? Recently got accepted to the program, but am wondering if the cost is even worth it. Would love to hear about people’s experiences!

like

What’s the best thing to do with my 401K when in my MBA program? Should I roll over to a traditional IRA and then do a back door conversion to a Roth IRA?

like

Anyone have experience with Forté?

like

I’m seeing some people get into Harvard and MIT MBAs with 0-2 years FT experience in random corporate banking, random sales operations role at a small tech company, etc. Am I missing something here?

like

Has anyone had success leveraging an athletic scholarship to gain admission into business school? I played quarterback for a power 5 football team and still have a year of eligibility. I obviously didn’t make it to the NFL but would likely be an upgrade at QB for any of the M7. Odds a football coach having my back influences adcoms?

like

What percent of Columbia applicants get an interview?

like

Don't own a personal laptop; always use my work laptop for everything. I see people recommending Dell XPS or Lenovo Thinkpad but do you really need that for school? My plan was to just get a run of the mill laptop to use for excel and ppt...what else do i need it for?

like

How do we prep for Wharton fellas