Got an offer externally for 100k small company 5% bonus and 2% 401k, health benefits are same, although it’s hybrid 3 days in office and a 1.5 commute one way. My current employer offered a counter of 82k 10% bonus 5% 401k match, fully remote though. What would you do in this situation? Upwards mobility is on the table at current employer but not guaranteed, at other employer doesn’t look like it will be any time soon. Thoughts ?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

If they aren’t even willing to get close on the counter offer I would assume the only upward mobility is for your workload.

funnylike

Pass. The commute isn’t worth a 100k job. Unless you plan on moving closer.

like

Is the 1.5 hour commute because of traffic or distance? I would be worried about some serious wear and tear on your car if you’re doing 100+ miles round trip per day.

like

Traffic, 40 miles (suburbs to inner city)

like

I'd try to negotiate the external offer down to 1 day per week or fully remote. Worth a try.

like

Thanks for input, tried that and they won’t budge on it, apparently Collabaration can’t happen remote lmao

I think this decision depends on how you feel about the commute. 9 hours of total commute sounds brutal. In your place, I’d look for other opportunities because clearly you’re valued so there shouldn’t be an issue finding something else that’s more suitable.

like

401k match is not a consideration. It’s entirely a tax write off for the company. I don’t invest in the company offered pretax 401k plan or recommend it to others unless my client is a business owner looking to save and build morale from the uninformed, none financially educated. There are way better options out there for a self funded retirement plan in my opinion. You end up paying it all back and more in taxes later. All you have to to use look at the historical tax rate to make an educated decision on that. Let the IRS tax my seeds today and never bother me for money never EVER again is my preference.

likefunny

I lost brain cells reading this..

like

The key here is twofold:
- the commute is costly with gas prices and wear and tear (not to mention 9 wasted hours a week and the toll on your sanity in that much traffic)
- upward mobility is a HUGE factor. It may be a slightly lower salary now but if there’s no room to grow at the other place, it’s probably not the right move to progress your career.

like

Definite pass.

like

Not sure where you live but the difference between 82k and 100k after tax is probably negligible when you factor in your additional fuel, car maintenance and then food costs working away from home. Then consider is the extra money even worth the commute time.

like

Related Posts

Hello guys,

For 3.8years of experience KPMG is offering me is 10lpa, in my current company I am getting some 7.8lpa

like
like

Thinking about just taking a shopper marketing job. Haven't really made anything I'm proud of in traditional agencies so I figure get paid better and let go of frustration. What do you fishes think?

like

How is Capgemini in terms of job security and work culture?
How much CTC to expect from Capgemini with 10 years of experience in QA domain?
Capgemini

like

Hi fishes,
I will be promoted to A from this Oct . Pay scale will change from Oct . So will I get yearly hike or they ignore it ?

like

Should I be reducing my contribution to my 401k at the moment? Based on the drastic 🐻 market?

likehelpful

I currently work in Atlanta for a healthcare management company that is local to the area. I just got into the healthcare industry and have my bachelors degree in health science. I work in a position in the revenue cycle and I am looking to possibly get a new job in a more established company. I want more stability and opportunity within a company. Does anyone know of any places in/around Atlanta or remote that may fit this criteria? Sorry for the vagueness. Thanks!

like

My SO plans to have dinner with 3 friends at an outdoor restaurant. This upsets me, since I haven’t been in a restaurant or met anyone else without a mask since March, and I thought we weren’t going to dine with people we didn’t live with. Am I being unreasonable?

likehelpfulfunnysmart
like

First time posting here! I have been tasked with creating a military leave differential pay policy and was curious if anyone would be willing to provide any resources. Thanks!

Working remote with next to none human interactions, masking and social distancing in public. When will this end 😩

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi, I wanted all your opinion I have got
offer from ADP & Thoughtworks almost
both are paying equal. Which company is
better from learning perspective, Job
security wise & benefits ? My skill set is
Automation Testing - Selenium Java.
Please let me know your inputs. Thanks in
Advance

like

So this might be a better place to post this and ask this question: Uncle D has announced explicitly that most people won’t get a pay raise & bonus this year except for those promoted and high performers. Amid this crisis, are companies including other big 3, MBB, FAANG, boutique consulting firms still giving high raises and issue stocks? Can you share the impact from your firm?

like

Hi Everyone,
1.I had two offers one is with Cognizant with 11.55LPA fixed + 45,000 variable pay. I was offered L1 position(designation - Associate).
- Only day shifts(no rotational weekoff's) + I get afternoon shift allowance around 5k per month.
-As per the Manager mention it's mostly WFH we need to come to office at least one month in every 6months(duration).

2.HCL offered L2 position with 10LPA(Around 1.5 Variable pay is included)
-No shift allowance
-Rotational shifts including night

like

Does any of the big4 firm allow working remote from Canada/ overseas? Any policies that restrict that?

Hi Fishes, I am working as a Senior Manager in Sales in an edtech startup in Noida, it was quite a great journey. I have learned a lot, its been 2.4 years i am working here and got promoted here.
Now i am looking to switch to an MC to explore new culture, learn new things and work life balance. Looking for a WFH job. Please help

like

People who are happy that the office is become WFH should reconsider. You stop building meaningful relantionships at home and things just become transactional

like

Does Adobe still offers WFH

When negotiating, how much above minimum salary would you ask for? I don’t want them to rule me out altogether, but also don’t want to sell myself short.

like

More Posts

like

What is the highest CTC offered for 7B band in IBM for niche skill ?
Also how much joining bonus can we ask?

Thanks.

like

Pet owners: I have a friend cat/house sitting for me this weekend (three nights). What is an appropriate thank you payment? She’s my friend so it feels weird giving her cash? I was going to leave a few bottles of wine, maybe a fresh baked good?

like

Hey guys ,
I was a fresher when i joined wipro
My manager has given me rating 1 in confirmatory appraisal on may 18 may which happened after completion of 1 year at wipro.
I raised the issue of rating with my manager immediately , he convinced me not to worry , ratings are already submitted , I asked him to resubmit cause i don't deserve rating 1
So he said he will look if that is possible but didn't changed .Now after 3 months they are pressurizing me to put a resignation,what should i do?

like

Any insight on Aesthetic Medical Device Sales? Interviewing this week.

like

How do you invest and save for your children? I’m thinking about setting them up with custodial brokerage accounts but don’t want them to have a heyday at 18. Did you create irrevocable trusts or?? They are too young for earned income and I don’t own a business so no IRA investing opportunities here.

like

Senior Program Manager / Director looking for EU based remote work. Planning to relocate back to the EU on a permanent basis in the next 4-6 months. Open to work & would appreciate any kind of referral!

like

Worst and best consulting companies to work in for Real Estate?

like

Hi Fishes, Can someone help me with my in-hand salary?

Post Photo
like

What is the cell phone reimbursement plan for RSM?

Did anyone recently receive an offer letter from deshaw hyderabad?

like

What is your preferred HRIS Platform and why? Here are the options:

-Workday
-Oracle
-SAP
-ADP
-Ultimate
-Ceridian
-Other (if other, please name the system)

like

Business Performance Manager role what level is this targeted at?

like

Helo everyone, I had an interview scheduled with Cognizant on last week of Jan 2022 but due to technical error in Verification code I couldn't join interview lobby. I reported the same to the HR and I was told the interview will be rescheduled. Now there's no update from the HR. Could you please guide me how can I proceed or any email address to which I can inform to take the rescheduling process further.

Thanks in advance

like

I just got promoted at A.con level and when my manager asked me salary expectations I told very less pay wherein as per industry standards it is quite high. Would I get salary as per industry standards or as what I expected?

like

I have been waiting over 3 weeks after my loop for the result. Is this normal?

Been thinking about a career switch. Am a lawyer with top experience in energy and construction transactions and have industry specific insights and knowledge. Wondering if the management consulting firms would be an interesting place to go. Also have MBA for what it’s worth. Thoughts?

like

Got a client who’s asked for a POV on how covid-19 will affect buys across ALL verticals & channels. Of course it’s urgent. Can we please share what our companies are saying? Teamwork time, folks.

like

Question for yall. How likely is an offer once a company decides to do a reference check? I know I am in the final 2, from context clues in interviews. I just dont want to get my hopes up.

like

Got the outcome call from my interview with Amazon and the team moved on to another candidate but they want to show my resume to others hiring managers? Any tips ? Recruiter said I won't have to go through the full loop again but just a call with the hiring managers I am interested in.

like

Additional Posts in Finance

Vice Presidents and up: Is it easy to predict which analysts just won't last the long haul?

like

Which firm hires the dumbest people?

like

Does anyone have an idea on compensation for JPM Wealth Management Division?

Associate
V. President
E. Director
Mgng. Director

like

Does anyone know what the base salary increase is going from Analyst to AVP at Barclays in the UK is? Front office trading role

like

Has anyone done the GARP Financial Risk and Regulation course? Was it educational? Did you do the FRM after?

You know what? I'm 31 and I don't think I should have to courtesy flush anymore.

like

Who here actually owns a car and what kind of car is it?

like

Suggestions for good coffee in midtown? I don't care for the ambience, don't care if there's a little wait time. Just looking for good coffee. My current favorites are Cafe Grumpy and Blue Bottle.

like

Moving to Boston, anyone got any experience there?

like

Did Blackstone halt recruitment and hiring? I know most firms have for now.

like

fellow monkeys - how do you stay up during shitty team meetings where all you can think about is GTFOing?

like

What's your Sunday routine to get ready for work on Monday?

like

How long do Citi background checks take? Do they send you an application once you sign the offer?

like

Tips on dealing with being on a team who thinks it’s normal to work 7 days a week in the office until 9/10 pm because “this is the business”?

My boss’ boss wants to catch up on how things are going; I changed groups 6M ago for a more fast-paced environment but have only partially gotten the transaction/networking exp I wanted - any advice?

like

Looking into preowned watches under <$10k resale value...patek, vacheron, or rollie?

like

Transitioning from line of business familiarity (understanding financial statements) to... real(?) Finance (bonds and cap markets and other debt sales) any advice on books or resources to learn really from step 0?

like

If the IPO market is dead, does that mean M&A is next?

like

Is it just me or has there been a noticeable brain drain in banking in the past few years? Analysts are not what they used to be.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal