{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Had an interview with a recruiter from an agency. Seemed like it went well. However, I got a rejection letter and have been seeing the position still up on job boards. Asked for feedback none received", "post_id": "5cc71a1bdff027001b54b09e", "reply_count": 3, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "5aeb9912dc065200189b7584", "bowl_name": "Ask A Recruiter - Advertising" }

Had an interview with a recruiter from an agency. Seemed like it went well. However, I got a rejection letter and have been seeing the position still up on job boards. Asked for feedback none received

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

At least you got a rejection letter

like

Has this happened to anyone? Will they not give feedback?

I had something similar happen. I had a great phone interview with a recruiter, whose only concern about me being a fit for the job because he knew the hiring manager wanted someone more junior that they could mold (story of my life), but he said the hiring manager specifically picked my resume out and told him to call me. A week later, I got a rejection email, so I followed up to ask for feedback, and nothing.

like

Related Posts

like

Hi everyone, I was Just informed that an offer will be extended for a TAS - business valuation role. Just wanted to have an idea on what the salary ranges are for this position. Btw this for an experienced associate role. Any insight is greatly appreciated. TIA

like

I have two offers: 1. a strategy and ops role at a late stage startup, pre ipo (think databricks, Stripe) 2. a data science role at a bank. Comp is roughly the same at 270k TC. I’m much more interested in data science long term, but have FOMO about missing out on pre ipo shares. Any thoughts would be appreciated. Thanks in advance!

like

Hello 🐠. Is your H1B extension dependent on the length of the contract that the company has with the client? The lawyers are hell bent on applying for an extension that is less than 4 months 😒

like

How many hours of pto is paid out after exit from usdc?

like

My position is showing as DMO Senior Associate at HCL. Can you help me guys what is this DMO?

like

There are multiple platforms that provide data science interview preparation courses? Are they really worth it for someone who is trying to switch to a data science career or self study is more beneficial. Please share your opinion and recommended platforms you have been benefited

like

How do MBB PE exit opps differ by office ? Given the global staffing model, can a McKinsey & Company BA pursue SF/ NYC/ BOS PE if they are tagged to any American office?

like

Recently i got an offer from HCL tech. The scheduled only one round of interview and then HR discussion happened and offered me around 45% from current package. My question is usually for experienced candidates there will be atleast 2 rounds of interview right? So after joining will they put me in bench and i will have to attend interviews there? Pls pour your views

like

Can anyone give more color on the difference between what the “focus” interview and the “behavioral” interview entails for a consultant . Coming in laterally and recruiter didn’t provide much detail! thanks

like

I have appeared for nagarro interview. I cleared first 3 online rounds (Aptitude,technical,coding). After those rounds they took 4 in-person technical rounds. Generally they take 2 technical rounds but in my case they took 4 rounds. What could be the reason behind that ? I had 4th round today and waiting for the result. YOE - 8 years (.Net full stack)

like

Hello everyone, I gave first round of interview on Saturday after clearing hackerrank test for JPMC. I got this mail yesterday, does this mean I'm selected for consecutive rounds or can it be anything (including negative). Please let me know if anyone had been in similar situation. Thanks

Post Photo
like

several interview rounds. Positive (glowing) feedback all around. Im then told "they" just need to check w/the CEO...a short time later "sorry, we've decided to go in a different direction"...

like

Is it wrong/bad to accept a job offer for a position which you have gone through the interview process for that requires 2 more years of experience than you currently have? It is for SC at B4. I just recently became C.

like

I finally got a data scientist interview and the amount of preparing and studying you have to do is crazy

like

MBB folks: when you refer a candidate what do you look for? I feel that I have a strong background and I just need to land on that interview to win

likefunny

I have an interview scheduled for this Friday but I’m feeling very unprepared. I need more time to think through my professional experiences and how that translates to the role in question. How does it look if I move the interview to next Friday? Would that raise eyebrows?

like

Thoughts on exiting to a FAANG L6 Strategy role or waiting until July for my impending promotion to manager? Do we think I can push the start date out to August?

like

I think I bombed my Facebook interview 😭😭😭

like

at Google, Design position which is the best mode to work: annual or hourly mode of employment?

likehelpful

Additional Posts

How are MBB maternity/paternity leave?

like

Brutal 2 weeks. Weekend of work. SM micromanaging. Pick up someone's slack and they 🔨 your head. What is wrong with this people?

like

Hi Guys, I am a consultant for EY India and have been shortlisted for PWC India Senior Associate profile. Can anyone here help me understand what salary bracket should I negotiate in? I am currently at 12 Fixed. Also does being from EY make my chances of getting in better? Anyone who’s been through similar experience, please share your stories. Interview experiences and tips would be appreciated too. Thanks

like

Hi, I was contacted for a role and had phone screening interview. First interview with HM was set after one hour: - what is the process from there? - there are in person interviews or is everything remote? - what LoB privacy program manager belong? - how the privacy work looks like? - I've 11 yoe, masters, doing PhD and tons of certs. What can I expect?

like

I’m interviewing for BCG and had a principal reach out to me for a zoom chat. Is this normal for principals to reach out or is this a positive sign?

Is it just in my experience or are recruiters/hiring managers really reluctant these days to discuss salary bands for a given role? My logic for asking is to determine if I should consider a given role or pass if doesn't meet my salary requirements rather than continue additional interviews and find out later. Thoughts?

like

Am I an attractive candidate at all? Or is it silly to think I could jump soon for a comp increase? 1 yoe BAH fed (7 yoe in nonprofit sector before that), currently at 90k. Have some generalist certifications (agile, prosci, working on instructional design). Non-technical, no master’s. Resume is mostly attractive bc of extensive international/cross-cultural experience & DoS experience. Am I still too “meh” with only 1yoe & no tech skills?

like

Signing bonus Q - has anybody had to pay a signing bonus back because of leaving less than the time stipulated in the offer? What was the mechanism for the company to claim the bonus - take it from your last pay stub/PTO balance/can they request a check if you don’t have a remaining ‘Accounts Payable’ balance with the company? Wondering if this is an empty threat.

like

I hate my ex-mentor - just putting that out there. Should’ve been promoted last cycle but he held me back so now gotta suck it up and take on next level role which clearly I was ready for while getting paid $65K less than my colleague

like

Hi Fishes , How should I ask Deloitte USI HR to skip my interview for Bangalore location as I just got referred by my friend for gurgaon location. Is there a way so that i can skip Bangalore and attend gurgaon interview. Note : My Deloitte USI bangalore interview is on tuesday and for gurgaon referral i have just received the survey link.

like

Just learned from a colleague that they were selected for GS-13 off the street without an interview. Is this common?

funnylike

Has anyone left for a local firm and bounced back to top 10/big 4 or top 10? I've been interested in working at a local firm for some time, have an opportunity, but want the opportunity to get back to something larger if I learn I hate it.

like
like

Have an upcoming case study for a Sr FP&A role. Any recommendations for FP&A specific resources to prepare?

like

Hi all! For an experienced hire as a Human Capital Consultant at Deloitte, what should I expect the salary/sign-on bonus to be at a MCOL city? I have approx. 3.5 YOE (non-consulting), MBA and MS degree (non target school) and also SHRM certified (which is probably irrelevant for the role but thought I’d share anyways). Already did my research but the range is kind of all over the place for experienced hires so just want to have a ballpark. Thanks!

like

Would you get fired if you edit your department partners’ picture and send it to your colleague?

funnysmart

Does staying at a job too long make you less marketable? A CFO who worked at a company for over a decade and was fired because of cut backs was hired for temp work. An accounting manager of 6 years was hired for tech support. How does this happen?

like

How can I email SPG customer service? Don't have an ambassador.

like

Anyone at RSM or any other midsized firm know what the average pay for Senior Transaction services is? I would also assume the hours are a bit better than big 4 FDD? Looking to decide between industry or give another few years to public accounting. Also for the Chicago area or any MCOL area

like

Hi everyone! I recently accepted a new job with a Big 4 and am also newly engaged. I have a couple of concerns… the main one being that I may not have enough time off for 2022 to cover taking off for the wedding, honeymoon, and then a couple of other weddings where I’m supposed to be a bridesmaid. Do you think there would be any wiggle room with managers allowing time off, or is it generally pretty strict? (Continued in comments)

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal