Has any senior been rejected for GC process because “you are not a manager yet”? How do you deal with it?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

From my multiple back and forth with V&I, the problem is not that you are not manager yet. The problem is they are probably trying to file the PERM under manager and they only initiate the process when you meet all manager requirements.

Ask if you can initiate the PERM under your current Senior title but I believe if you do this
1. There is higher chance of PERM failure since seniors are much easier to find, unless you are in a highly specialized SL
2. You cannot be promoted to manager if your PERM is senior until you get to a certain stage in the GC process - if not you’d have to re-do the perm.

likehelpful

Totally agree with this comment. If you're in a common SL, forcing for a senior PERM could be risky especially with backlogged PW requests, PERM approvals, EY recruiting procedures, the speed of EY Law, a higher failure rate given how easy to find minimally-qualified local candidates to do a senior role

like

What level senior are you? In a similar position

S2 as October

I thought some people said they file after two years sometimes

I wish such people can talk about their experience here lol

You should be ok to be approved for GC.

Didn’t get it lol. Did you?

I can’t wait till manager that’s ridiculous

Time flies by fast. suck it up for a big reward. Otherwise, you may just go to tech companies if you can't wait

I am an experienced hire with 4 years experience and going to my s2 in October. I’m supposed to be eligible for green card process in October so I’m hoping I don’t hear any issues since that’s what they clearly told me after a year I am eligible. Who do you email to see if you will get through?

Masters degree is for filing EB2 - manager level job req requires 5 yoe with a bachelors or 4 yoe with a masters (but this also depends on your specific PERM so ask your &I team)

like

Hi OP, did you reach out to them? I am a senior 3 with 6 years of experience and also a master's degree. I am in tech SL... Hope I won't need to be a manager before they apply

Related Posts

What benefits do I get if I become disabled during my service?

like

Now people understood why there are 10000+ promotions in Wipro. They promoted more then 7000 employee to C1 Band and now they are not paying anything to them as variable pay for this quater. Congrats to all
Who has promoted C1.

like

Guys, I got retained for 14 LPA from 9.5 LPA 1.5 yrs back..I'm now receiving offers for 20 and above. Is there any way my pakage can be raised with my current job itself(work environment here is good)?? Not sure if dropping papers and getting retained will give a nad impression on me..is there any fair way of increasing my package.

like
like

Anyone joining or joined HCL tech in Kolkata location recently? How is the requirement currently? Is it work from office completely or hybrid model? Thanks!

like

How difficult is it to get an onsite job with only 2 years of experience?
Tech Stack: .net, javascript

like

How much does a manager at an IB make? Like around what?

like

What are the pros/cons of moving from WPP to IPG? I can’t give specifics about which agencies but I’m curious in a general sense about benefits, compensation, career growth, culture, etc.

like

22 starting my first job. What are the benefits of an HSA?

like

Hello,
I graduated in June with a dual BSBA in healthcare management and human resources management/organizational management and two associates degrees in business and arts. I have twelve years of experience as a certified clinical medical assistant.

I'm having trouble finding my first job as a healthcare manager. After submitting many applications and receiving so many rejection emails, I've become frustrated. Any advice anyone can give is greatly appreciated.

like

I am looking job change in Quality

like

I have my Sloan interview tomorrow! Any advice??

like

what is the next speculative stock/crypto to buy? after dogge, I just want to buy very risky assets. FWIW, I'm not putting my savings in, just a bit of disposable income - my daily starbucks coffee.

likefunnysmart

Does accounting pay well? And what are the skills needed / what does your work week look like? This bowl made me realize I know nothing about this industry as I don’t know any accountants and went to liberal arts undergrad, but it seems pretty big from what I can tell.

likefunny

Planning Europe trip in summer for about 10 days. Any itinerary recommendations? First time visiting the continent. Prefer cities over countryside, but not strongly. Thanks in advance!

like

I am in a period of growth in my role (in house and getting more exposure to top management) - im grateful for it but I also have constant anxiety during and after work hours. Does anyone who’s been in a similar position have tips for riding this wave? Hoping it’ll get easier.

like

Really want to unsubscribe to Cuddly, but seeing all the unfortunate animals just breaks my heart. I don’t make a lot but don’t mind giving; it’s starting to get a little out of control though. Remain subscribed? Unsubscribe to those emails?

funny
like

Spent my first day of PTO trying to get a PS5. In the end I emerged triumphant!

like

For a career in Ar/vr/ interaction design what’re the pros/cons and which one would you go with?
1. MFA Interaction Design @SVA
2. MFA Media Design Practices @Art Center
3. MFA Design & Technology @Parsons

like

Additional Posts in Global immigration

Anyone who recently ported their H1-B extension to premium? Any issues faced? I keep hearing that it’s not advisable

like

Is L1A or L1B the only route to an EB1C greencard?

like

Hi all! To qualify for an L1A visa, do you have to be a senior manager / executive level or does it work as long as you’re a manager? I just moved out of the US because the H1b lottery didn’t work out for me, and I’m thinking rather than spending 1 or 2 years in my home country and go back as a senior, I’d much rather work here a bit longer, get that manager title, wait a year, and then go back as I think that would be the fastest route to green card..? Any thoughts/advice? I’m from 🇰🇷 :) TYI!!

like

EY fish, anyone get the V&I survey today? Seems suspicious that they want our anonymous feedback; never seen such a survey before in all my years with the firm. Would appreciate your input.

like

Hi fellow 🐠,
I have a valid I797 till September 2022 but my I-94 is about to expire in Sep 2021 and i have travelled internationally last year and i see the I-94 printed on my old passport in line with my VISA stamp as Sep 2021. Would i be out of status in September 2021 and how can i avoid it? I have reached out to the local CBP office and they mentioned it is in line with my VISA/Passport Expiry.

like

How long does recruitment process take at Deloitte?

like

As an H-1B holder, can you travel outside the U.S. while your employment-based green card I-485 immigration petition is still pending? Are there any risks to the green card application (or the H-1B)?

like

All those waiting for GC and feeling stuck at your current company/roles, what would you pursue once you have your GC?

like

Is the process of changing offices on H-1B cumbersome? I’m planning to change my location in a couple of months and wanted to know if it’s as simple as changing address within the same city

Deloitte fish, for those who got selected in the h1b (seyfarth), how does the process to file the petition look like? They asked for my docs 2 weeks ago and never heard from them since. They dont reply to email or update the portal either. What should I expect now?

like

I have been on a local project since my last h1b extension which is till 2022 - also got my visa stamped and have a valid visa till 2022. Deploying on a 5 month travelling project next week for which

As H1B holder, have you ever done secret side hustles or projects?

Which company has optimistic figures for H1B sponsorship?

funny

For Canadians / Mexicans - can we get FP&A or FDD jobs with TN accounting visa? For context I am in FAAS and I got this with the TN, wondering if I can move to industry with a TN

like

What’s are the best crypto’s to invest in? I currently have Solano, ADA, Shiba… I have $1000 to put on my wealthsimple (nothing too crazy).

like

Hi, how does a h1b transfer work? my current visa expires in 2024,but I’m on my first 3 years. If I do a transfer now, will the expiry date be the same? Or will it be 3 years out from the approval date of the new transferred h1b visa?

like

I planned to visit home this winter but just heard from immigration team that they can file i-485. Given it might be complicated to travel, would you still travel? Not too sure how long I need to cont

like

Anyone traveled to US on B visa and then changed status to L? The company has sponsored L but embassies in my home country are closed for stamping.

like

I’m honestly so stressed out about my h1b transfer that I can’t focus at work. Case filed under PP 9/6 but still haven’t heard back about anything. No tracking nor receipt. Is this normal?

like

Got an offer from a different company. Do you think it would be possible to leverage that offer in order to have EY expedite the PERM process? (Currently 3rd year with the firm, told to wait 1 more yr

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal