{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Has anyone been denied H1B after receiving a RFE? I just received one and uscis basically wants to know how my job is related to my education.", "post_id": "598a6c2ca10fa5001606b149", "reply_count": 11, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting" }

Has anyone been denied H1B after receiving a RFE? I just received one and uscis basically wants to know how my job is related to my education.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Consultant 1 - you know the new proposal is just that right. It will take many years before it becomes a rule.

like

Strat&: how are you working based out of Toronto if there's pretty much no S& here? I heard they're trying to assemble the team, but nothing concrete so far...

like

I got denied last year because my job wasn't engineering based

S1 did you get your visa this year then?

Best of luck OP.

I'm working out of the Toronto office

My gf didn't make the lottery this year :(. She's excited for the new immigration rules where the lottery goes away. It may not help others, but it helps her for sure.

Yes

Yes... Did not happen to me but happened to a friend who triple majored. Didn't turn out well for him unfortunately :(

M1, it's still better than the current system for people in her position. She will wait less time for any proposed changes than she will by reapplying year after year while completing with tens of thousands of Cognizant and Tata sponsored applicants.

I don’t disagree with you C1. But I’m just stating the obvious- it won’t be passed any time soon - at least not in the current president’s term. Much bigger 🐠 to fry than this. If we want real merit based immigration, Better look elsewhere like Canada 🇨🇦.

Related Posts

Want to invest in real estate in NYC, but I'm currently still on F1 OPT visa, is it worth it?

like

How can you get Deloitte to apply for green card? I started in 2019

likehelpful

Anyone getting denials on H1B extensions? I just got done with 3 yrs on H1, have I-140 & still got deniedon extension. Idk if it’s the lawyers screwing up or if it’s just the current administration...

like

Hi All, I am currently on L1 visa and would like to travel to Dubai during the first week of July. Can you let me know if there will be any restrictions to enter back to the US?

like

Do employers need to do Labor test for the green card process if they employ you as an experienced hire and they initiate day 1 green card applications?

like

Hi folks, How much time Accenture takes to get back with written offer after verbal confirmation ? It would be great if someone can share their experiences with timelines from verbal offer to joining date including visa process . TIA,

like

Hey guys, which country/city are you’ll booking H1-B visa stamp appointment dates? Are you getting any appointments for this year?

like

I haven’t even finished the final round with the company and they are asking my passport for visa purpose already…why do rush? (Not in the states) Also I am in the process with mbb.

like

For those on Conditional Green Card: My lawyers have filed for the removal of conditions (I-751) about 3 weeks ago but I haven’t received the application receipt yet which automatically extends my green card’s validity for 18 months. My current green card expires in 2 weeks. If I don’t receive the receipt by then, do I need to be worried or as long as the I-751 was filed before my card expires I’m okay?

like

McKinsey & Company - are you allowed to start work with your H1B transfer receipt notice, or do they ask you to wait for an approval?McKinsey & Company

like

H1B visa 🐠: how do you file your taxes? Visa kicked in on Oct’18 and no I-140 approved yet for context. Can we use TurboTax and the likes or do you use something else?

like

Once I get my H1B issued, how soon can I apply for a greencard and how long does the process take from application to receipt of the greencard? For reference, I’m born Canadian (I think birth country plays a factor in this?) and is it better to apply through my employer or apply on my own?

What's the latest that bachelors H1b receipts come out? Firm lawyers have advised waiting till end of June

like

Does anyone applied for a NAFTA Visa (Mexico-Us) ? Is the process difficult ?

like

My H1B visa (stamped) with my old employer is valid till September 2022, do I still need to get my new H1B stamped if I go visit my family in December? I am also married to a US citizen but we haven’t started the Green Card process yet.

like

I had an H1B stamping appointment scheduled for November, just got an email cancellation. There are no others until late next year, is there anything I can try at this point or should I just sit down and cry?

like

Anyone with green card process experience at KPMG.Kind of torn in between, there was no indication earlier that they may file for me and i went ahead applied for Canadian PR, now in a dilemna whether

Any dangers of quitting on H1B approval email/online status and not the physical notice? Manager pushing to put my 2 weeks in but lawyers are saying that sometimes online approval maybe incorrect

helpful

Hi Fishes I’m getting an international transfer from EY Abroad to EY US. Has anyone submitted documents on INSZoom for L1 visa? How long did Visa team take? I feel the visa process is way too long. Please share any first hand experiences. I signed my offer letter in August, submitted my docs last week on INSZoom. Anyone in the same boat?

likefunny

For a friend- anyone with experience getting h1b with law degree (passed texas bar) do companies sponsor in that field?

like

Additional Posts

Protiviti Senior Consultant salary? 3yoe. Protiviti.

like

Anyone exited to shipt? Details on culture, comp, and growth opportunities?

like

Anyone who came back to consulting after moving to an internal role ? I know a ton of people who moved internal and are happy with the choice but haven’t heard of anyone come back to client facing rol

Interested switching from consulting to ibd. What are the best resources to prepare when applying? What type of modelling/technical questions can I expect aside from the ones provided by biws? Thanks in advance!

like

I am in interested in a role in the HCM practice at PwC or an HR role within IFS. I would appreciate a referral or just to learn more about your experience. Thank you! 😊

like

Don’t you feel that your focus has decreased by WFH? What are you doing to increase it?

like

Any good ideas for a health tech product/ SaaS offering etc? If one has I would like to listen and join the cause.

What are some befits of having CFA level 1 certification? (Regardless of my background and industry)

likehelpful

New joiner in a few weeks…Does MBB allow expensing for overtime meals when working from home?

like

Guidance coming out next week on mid-year compensation review. Wonder how many people this will push over the edge who have been holding out the last couple months in hopes of a raise.

like

Hi does anyone know how is it to work in Divestiture advisory services ? How is the culture, hours, salary and promotions like ?

like

Would you rather stay in a niche that you’ve been doing well in, but you happen to find not too interesting, or try new areas and risk not doing as well? Ive been in pharma analytics for the last 4 years, receive good client feedback, good raises / promotion and have learned a lot. But I’m not sure if I want to continue in pharma long term.

likehelpful

What is the target comp range for an audit director with 10 YOE if moving into industry? SF bay area. Any thoughts would be appreciated, thanks 🙏

like

Partners, what would be a typical monthly pension check be for MBB / Big 4? All firms welcome.

likefunny

What's everyones bonuses like? Share the number if you're comfortable but if not, then give us an idea or ball park it. What are the conditions to get your bonus?

like

If you join a new employer on h1b transfer receipt, do you still get paid (getting pay stub)?

like

Didn’t get the interview call from Ross. One school down. 4 more disappointments to go.

like

Current CTC - 6L. Accenture has offered 10.4 with 60k joining bonus. Designation - Sr Analyst. Is this too low? I have 4 yoe

like

MBB FAANG Networth

likefunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal