{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Has anyone here experienced an offer being taken away due to negotiation terms? I got a PM offer after being told I was a “unanimous strong yes”. After sending a professional note negotiating compensation, WFH, and PTO benefits , the company calls me and says they no longer find me a good fit and asked me to decline. Like what???Like at least send a counter offer or have the decency to say it in writing. You’re encouraging women to not negotiate SMH. Deeply disappointed in Capital One", "post_id": "622a9ea5dfd31000257c2960", "reply_count": 1, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "5ae4a4f739e7cb001391ec8b", "bowl_name": "Consulting Exit Opportunities", "feed_type": "bowl" }
null
like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Disappointing, but not unheard of. How was their offer determined? How did you determine what to counter?

Related Posts

I have been selected for HR round of Zee entertainment enterprise , what salary expectation I can ask for SDET -1 role?

like

Why do recruiters ask for salary expectations?

Why don’t they say we’ve got XXXk?
The last recruiter to ask me this, I said I wanted a salary commensurate with a creative director. And…👻

like
like

Are any digital agencies forcing employees to return to the office yet, or has the industry, being digital-oriented, bucked the trend? Seeing an exodus from people at our clients (I'm on the agency side) where the company is forcing employees back, but the digital teams find the request irrelevant and are just leaving for fully-remote jobs.

like

Hey guys. I feel like Target is trying to low ball me. I have over 5-6 years of experience in Supply Chain. I applied to a Senior Inventory Analyst position and they gave me $82500. I thought there would be some room for negotiation but they’re making it seem like I have to accept that offer. What are your thoughts on this salary?
I also want to state I live in Atlanta and under the job description their salary range for Colorado was $65k-118k… what are your thoughts on this?
Thanks!!

like

Anybody else posting vacation pictures?

like

Hi ladies, I hope all is well. I’m currently working as an operations manager and I’m looking to find a remote position. I’ve been applying to many companies but I’ve only had 1 interview. I made it to round two but they went with someone else. If someone company is hiring can you please send me the information or link. I’m a little discouraged but trying to stay positive. Thank you beautiful ladies and have a great day. 💕

like

Sr. Product Manager/BA role salary in NYC?

like

Thanks for starting this bowl. One of the things I find challenging is making small talk with coworkers about holiday plans etc, when you’re forced to explain that you’re not spending holidays with your family. They then launch into some “well-meaning” advice about life being too short and me only having one family. It’s hard to resist the urge to point out that this was not a decision I took lightly, and that they are severely out of turn. I’m tired of smiling and nodding 😒

like

Hello there! I have been interviewing with Amazon UX Designer role and I wanted to understand the salary range for the L6level. Can anyone help?

like

What’s a good ACD salary in ny? Talking to hr tomorrow about going full time and am assuming I’ll get lowballed

For folks starting at BCG (experienced hires) in August, is there any indication as to what the first week(s) of orientation and training is like? I.e., remote vs in-person (if in-person, which city), etc.
My SO is convinced she can’t make our weekend plans due to these trainings ..

like

Looking for an entry-level job in HR/Recruting in the DMV area or remote, does anyone know of anyone who is hiring?

like

Does PwC India provides any Food card reimbursement (Sodexo card or similar) and is there any WFH allowance?

like

Since May I’ve been playing rash whack a mole and docs only said: not fungus, not psoriasis, here’s cortisone. The cortisone cures the local rashes but at this point I’ve applied it almost everywhere on my body for the P3M and once an area heals another flares up with a slightly new version. Did anyone ever experience something like this? Initially thought combination of work stress and this crazy heat but I’m on pto now.

like

I've always had a 401k but my gf doesn't. Is there a way to invest pretax? What products are available?

What would be the in-hand salary for the below salary break up??
Any idea fishes??

Post Photo

Anyone know of any hiring remote jobs in Maryland?

like

As a woman, I must say, the most startling change in this WFH new normal is that I’ve now seen 100% of my male colleagues on my team join video conference calls in their boxers. No judgement or anything, just a huge change from the people I usually spend Mon-Thu with.

funnylikeuplifting

How bad is it if a woman doesn’t wear any makeup at work? I do have spots and light acne on face (obviously depending on my cycle time) but I hardly wear any makeup. It’s usually just an eye liner and light lipstick. Whenever I wear makeup (I don’t know how to do make up and I just use BB cream mainly) I get more acne. That’s one of the main reasons (other than not having to wear a bra all day) I hate going to work and found WFH much better. contd..

likehelpful

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

So newsmax is the new fox news and fox news is liberal now? 🤔

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

I'm into Salesforce dev, quite curious abt the product based firms. What's the type of work we have there, timings, work life balance, growth opportunities, new learnings, up to date with latest features etc.
I'm working in a Consulting firm and hope to switch to a Product based soon. Not sure if it'll be a good idea. Got 7 years into Consulting in Big Fours.
Can someone help me with the difference between Product based / Service Based / Consulting Firms based on all above mentioned parameters.

likehelpful

Need some ideas for successful fundraisers you have done in your office. All proceeds are going to a charity. Open to all suggestions!

There’s very little stopping me from eating Pringles for breakfast, lunch and dinner. My sanity is hanging by a thread

likefunny

Reset your mind and restart your life!

Post Photo

How many maximum meetings can we ask for in arrange marriage setup to decide he/she is the one we can go ahead with?

like

What would you guys chose?
Current job at a growing agency where I’ve been expecting a raise in position since 6 months but my boss quit and i have no leads now
Vs.
New job with start up agency, senior position but same pay as old job

I’m soooo confused!

likehelpful

TFW SapientRazorfish likes your comment

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Equity Research vs. Investment Banking. The former sounds like a deeper dive into the company whereas the latter seems to be more backing into a valuation. Thoughts on the skill sets gained in each?

like

Best resources for some starting to prep for PE
interviews?

like

Tech sales, enterprise level, acc manager roles... how many rounds of interviews? Could a company
be playing delay tactics due to insufficient applicants in summer period if interviews are now a week or so out in last stages?

like

Hey moms. Getting anxiety lately bc of my postpartum weight. I tried so hard and lost 30 pounds in five months but stuck in the last 10pounds to get back to my pre pregnancy weight. How do you guys manage to loose the weight you gained during pregnancy? Body also changed so much the shape is different. Sometimes I feel it’s not so much about the weight bc 10 pounds couldn’t be the only reason that I cannot fit in most of my clothes!!

like

Have Mekanism and R/GA shut their Chicago offfices? I heard some horrible news.

like

Is there a chance to move from EY technology to consulting?i feel i am scammed into joining this vertical

funny

Anyone done a learn Spanish / do yoga retreat? Ideally Latin America over Spain - any recs? Thanks!

like

I have a interview for a product specialist position at Facebook.

Does anyone have any insights on how the final case is like? Looking for tips on how to prep!
Facebook Deloitte

likefunny

Anyone from BCG org strategy here?

like

Where can i find the best mortgage rates? I only asked on here since i know our people are smart and find the best deal 😂

like

They do exist

Post Photo
likefunny

Does anyone have any alternate resources for question banks? I’m re-writing in a month (scored 680) and have now completed all of the Manhattan guides and GMAT Official Guide (2018) questions.

like

Additional Posts (overall)

Why is LinkedIn not in FAANG?

funny

Should I leave Deloitte Consulting for Palantir?

likehelpfulfunny

Is 20-30% and a title bump enough to go back to industry?

like

Why is leaving for Microsoft not seen as good as FAANG? I’d argue Microsoft is probably better than Netflix at the minimum

like

Hi all - Indeed (the job site) is hiring across various teams - many of which are well suited for ex-consultants. DM me if interested in connecting to learn more.

like

Is $130k base good for a product analyst in a SF (no bonus, still waiting for options)? Currently 2 YOE at $120k in MCOL city

like

So... are you shaking hands at your interview?

funny

How often do companies you interview with reach out to your current firm/team/managers about your performance?

(Wondering if I need to take this into account as I start recruiting for tech jobs)

like

What are the best consulting firms for marketing and/or sales strategy work?

like

Anyone else not interested in FAANG?

I get that these are some of the top companies of our generation, but that doesn’t inspire me to run there. I dislike FB’s data situation, Amazon’s tech bros...

likeupliftingsmarthelpfulfunny

Are promotions harder at FAANG companies? The companies seem more flat than consulting.

like

I’ve been applying to jobs for the past two months primarily on LinkedIn - got a few interviews but nothing great. I have my MBA, 7 years in big 4, and now strategy in tech -trying to break into a Director strategy position in the tech space. Am I missing specific skills? Am I looking in the wrong place?

like

Do strategy roles in banking pay well?

like

Hello, is there anyone who can elaborate on interviews at Google? A google recruiter reached out to me about a Program Manager position and I have a phone interview this week. Any tips? Thank you!!

like

Any company recommendations I should pursue for corporate development roles in Atlanta?

Non-Computers engineer with 11 years of IT strategy and systems implementation experience and an MBA, presently work for a consulting firm. Looking for growth and change in same or similar line of work. Target compensation advice greatly appreciated, TIA!

like

Consulting to SWE: has anyone made the switch? Is the work more interesting/how does the work differ? I’m trying to make a decision for this purely considering the nature of the work (ignore money, WLB, etc). Considering a boot camp but want to make sure that I’m making a good decision before I decide to go down that path.

like

Been looking to leave my job for a while but haven’t gotten any hits. Any advice? Reached out to my network but it feels as my network isn’t in the right spot. Looking at strategy consulting

like

Consulting 🐠s who made it to FAANG, how do you establish a connection with the hiring manager during interviews? I always find it difficult to make small talk or give an impressionable response..contd

like

Hi All.. Currently working as Data Engineer and planning to switch to Amazon or Microsoft or FAANG companies. But I heard a lot that Amazon has terrible wlb. Is that true for most of the cases?
How is the work culture?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

New to Fishbowl?

image with Fishbowl logo and arms reaching out for a handshake

Already have an account? Log in

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Messaging rates may apply

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal