Has anyone reached out to the hiring manager to get feedback on their interview? This is after receiving a reject. I have had a slew of final rounds and I am constantly getting told that it was really close but they decided to go with someone else. Asking the recruiter for feedback isn't helping and I'd like to know what I am doing wrong so I can crack some interviews soon.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yes and I finally heard back after multiple failed attempts. I can’t say it was helpful though...basically that they didn’t dislike me and to reach out for future postings as they will keep me in mind.

likehelpful

Just send a polite email or LinkedIn. As long as you're direct, brief, and polite it can't do any harm imo. Don't take it personally if they don't respond, it might be difficult for someone to clearly articulate why they didn't pick you or they may just shy away from the potential confrontation.

likehelpful

In my experience sometimes there are just people with better experience or backgrounds pertaining to what they need. Ask for feedback but just keep pressing on amigo!

likehelpful

I am in the same boat! I felt very confident for a role and the progress of the interview. I had been communicating with the hiring coordinator directly via their work email and even phone calls. After the last interview, I received an auto generated email response saying I was no longer a candidate. I was baffled. Partly because I thought the interview had went so well, but mainly because what felt like a personal and friendly interaction turned to a generic and cold email. I reached out to the hiring contact by thanking them for their time and any feedback. Nothing. I reached out via LinkedIn to the individuals on my final interview panel and received a pleasant response. They detailed out why I was not chosen for the position and any anxiety was put to ease. It would have been great to have those simple remarks in the rejection. But I say, it doesn’t hurt to try!

like

This really helps. My most recent reject was for a panel based interview which I thought went really well and I was debating whether to contact the hiring manager or to contact the panel to ask for feedback. Thanks!

I would say yes if you have their email. I just had to say no to several people and would love to give them feedback because I was really hoping they would do well. Maybe they would take the feedback and apply it to their next interview.

helpful

I’ve asked but most of the time I don’t get any. To be honest there is only risk for them (or the company) to provide that information so don’t be disappointed if they say they don’t have anything to share

like

Thanks all! This has been helpful

No, that’s kind of a weird thing to ask for. It’s not always about you as an individual. Sometimes other people are a better fit. You can’t control that. If you got a good vibe from one of the people you worked with in the process, sure you could maybe ask for input but it’ll probably be specific to their experience with you and not something to learn from broadly

I politely disagree. :)

“Another candidate was a better fit and you can’t control that” — Absolutely this is possible. It could come down to someone else had a specific skill, industry experience, spoke better, had a friendlier persona.

“Feedback will be specific to their experience with you and..” — They can share feedback outside and within the experience with you. Someone else could have head greater experience with the current tools they use - less ramp up time. Maybe your start date was too far out compared to someone else with an equal fit. It would be honest and reasonable to hear “The other candidate had X years of experience within the industry.”

..”not something to broadly learn” - As a PM, asking questions continuously unlocks new findings and value. Even when it doesn’t, it never hurts me. Feedback could be that someone had a skill that you didn’t, or weren’t great at. Example is that many job postings will ask for SQL as a bonus requirement, but not a requirement. This could empower you to start learning. Or they could share that your take home assignment wasn’t strong for specific reasons - it will let you identify areas for improvement.

In the end, can you control their decision? Of course not. You could have been neck and neck with someone else, and all it took would be “x seemed happier and friendlier and I would enjoy working daily with them”. It’s up to the company to make those decisions of how they decide who they hire.

But in the end. Just continue to do your best, reach out for feedback, and improve where you can.

like

Related Posts

For anyone who felt stuck in an area of biglaw that they liked / were decently good at but had no intention of making partner yet also no ideas about what else to do, how did you get out? Are you happier now? I feel stuck and may stay forever out of inertia. Flipping through job applications has been relatively uninspiring so far. Any advice would be appreciated!

like

Currently looking for production planning role remote or hybrid.will be moving to Fort Worth Texas next spring!

I currently work from home, but it’s not a permanent wfh position. I just had my second baby, my parents live in the guest house and they babysit the girls for me while I work. My salary covers all expenses and I am able to pay my parents 1500$/month to babysit daily.
Eventually I’ll be asked to go back into the office. The office is 7hours away from my home….. ARE THERE ANY INSURANCE CO. HIRING REMOTELY?

like

Hey Fishes..
I cleared
Oracle interview PLSQL developer role.
What salary to ask? I have HR round @on Tuesday.
CCTC: 14LPA
YOE: 6.6 years

Oracle

My friend is in his first job out of college at a tech company. He started 3 months ago and is in a very toxic environment as well as has to commute/be in the office everyday. His title is “Inside sales” and his pay is very low(no commission), he does tons of work and is expected to stay late (no overtime) on top of the 8:30-5:30.
What is the minimum amount of time to stay at a role he absolutely hates because he needs to write it on his resume?Any advice to cope?

like

How do you respond if you’re asked ..why were you let go from your last position? If it was a personality issue with your manager ? Thank you.

like

Hi everyone! Tamy here
2020 college grad with a degree in organizational dynamics, alongside that I have my Google project management cert (still in progress).

So lately I have been applying for roles: junior business analyst/ project assistant/ project management entry/ project coordinator and have been hit with all rejections. It sucks but i must press on.

Now my question is, how the hell do i break into the work space?

like

Is a resume writer worth it? Thinking of getting one and wanted to see if it made all the difference. Currently have been applying since December and made it to only 1 final round but have had 3 recruiter screens and 3 HM calls so far. My only resource so far has been job scan where I tailor each resume.

like

Is there anyone here from McKinsey or BCG in Montreal willing to chat? Im thinking about applying soon, but I feel like speaking with someone who works there will help me assess if I would love working there (culture, types of projects, etc), and that my interest isnt solely based on prestige/reputation!

like

Any advice on how to break into a Financial analyst role? I feel like I’m getting more rejections than job applications I’ve submitted. Any help would be appreciated. Thank you!

like

I recently graduated with a bachelors in finance, and have recently got hired (5 months ago) as a financial analyst. Realistically I do FP&A for a company. I have realized I am not a huge fan of doing non stop spreadsheet all day. Am thinking I’d enjoy my career more by becoming a financial planner and getting my CFP certification. Maybe in the future opening up my own firm. Any advice on what career move to make next in order to accomplish this? CFP requires 3 years of relative experience.

like

Looking for a referral. I have a little less than 2 YOE, 10 of which being in FDD. I don’t have my CPA yet but I can sit. I’ve been in-charging deals for the last 6 months. I’m looking for a senior 1 role making 100k in SoCal. I’ll be glad to hop on a call with anyone before referring me.

like

Hello fishes I got offer from tech Mahindra but it's for six month contract and one offer from ncircle infotech which is small scale industry the role offered by tech Mahindra is software engg where's ncircle offers me machine learning engg with 9.50 and permanent role i m confused please guide me

like

What is a good Tesla TC for a Business System Analyst role 1.5 YOR + Master same major in Fremont?@

like

What is the benefit of using or working with a recruiter to find a role vs just looking yourself?

like

how hard to get a scientist position in San Francisco without PhD? I just have BS degree, 7 yoe, 3y in academia, 4y in pharma industry, currently in a big pharma, 2 papers (both first author credit) 🫤 been looking/applying but not qualified, no body gets back 🙁 please help

like

What is a genuine ask for a associate success guide role in SF, considering my current CTC is 9 LPA with 1.5yoe

like

To peeps who work for Elon Musk - what's the WFH situation? My boyfriend is interviewing for a job in Elon's company. He was told the role was on-site only. We're not sure we want to move right now and the comp is not really worth moving but the role itself is appealing to him. Do you think it's worth going through interviews and trying to negotiate working from home?

likehelpful

Does anyone have any tips on how to stay motivated when peers with the same role seemingly get away with delivering a lower quality of work? To be clear, I don’t mean that it “appears” they are doing less work, as I know the level of effort you actually see might not tell the whole story. More so, I’m finding it hard to just keep my head down and focus on what I’m bringing to the table when I see people delivering sloppy work and phoning it in as I’m pushing to be super buttoned up.

like

More Posts

Want to break into a tech focused fund, but have not worked with tech clients, how can I show my interest?

like

Hello! I’m currently a Administrative assistant now working at a major medical system in Baltimore. I’ve previously worked for 10 years as a medical assistant in a variety of specialties and primary care. Lately, I’ve been feeling a bit stuck as to my next step. Part of me want to go into management, another part is saying go get your RN, and the other is saying go into Social Work. I’m all over the place. Any ideas? And how would I be able to cross over to management?

like

What salary band should I expect for an experienced hire into a Strategy Consultant role in a T2 consulting firm High COL city?

Financial crime growing on West Coast. SM/ Director - Accenture or Genpact. Anyone can tell me more about Genpact in terms of culture and Salary versus Big 4 + ACCN?

like

My team at sweetgreen has 2 Senior Technical Program Managers roles to fill in LA + OC. Base + bonus negotiable but could be high $100s to low $200s. Equity is on top of that. DM me for a referral!

like

Hi, I want to learn how to build ETL pipelines with Pyspark and Azure. As right now i have experience in feature engineering only with SQL and Pyspark.

Can anyone suggest anything online from where i can learn and do hands on?@

Hey Fishes,
I have gotten an offer from
Infosys BPM with 15% variable. How much % of the variable can I expect to get? And, on what factors is it dependent?Infosys

like
like

Hi Fishes,

What is Pre-employment Medical Checkup a company performs? I got one offer letter, it says offer is only valid after bgv and Pre-employment Medical Checkup.

like

EY 🐠 - looking for advisory manager benchmarks. Lateral competitor hire, specialist experience, currently at $165k base,30% bonus, + $12,250 401k. Is $190-205k base for manager realistic at EY?

like

Can a Senior Manager who otherwise has a good reputation, get fired for bullying? If not, will this person still make it to partner? There seems to be a lack of transparency in firms around this

like

Anybody have a 5/3 bank mortgage? On my credit report, there’s a remark that says payment deferred, but I’m not under any such plan. It’s also showing certain months without check marks but doesn’t say late PMTs. Ive paid ahead one month. Any suggestions why?

likehelpful

Can anyone refer me. I have 7.5 years experience in Java, 1.5 years experience in Docker, Kubernetes, Microservices, Spring boot, Golang. I am currently working in product based company and which is my first company.

like
like

How hard are you guys working at Accenture? People often complain about hours at D but honestly I've mostly been chilling with the occasional spike on a sprint. Are people around the M level at A really grinding?

like

Anyone else feel like madame hooch from Harry Potter in busy season? Right after year end I'm just like, "all right everyone I want a nice, CLEAN audit" 😉

like

Hello!

I luckily won a scholarship from Udemy to obtain skills to help me prepare to become a product manager, but also have many transferable skills.
I am submitting my resume at many companies in hopes of making the career transition - can anyone here offer to review my resume from a product candidate perspective? I am willing to offer a $50 Amazon gift card for direction/ suggestions (I will make the direct edits).

like

Our team is about to recruit and we are trying to live our DEI values. Any tangible actions you can suggest to how we can widen our attractiveness to a more diverse candidates? Applies internally and externally. Thanks for any suggestions.

like

For those of you working in your physical office in nyc in IBD or S&T right now, do you have to wear a mask all the time? Or like only in elevators

like

Have a great Labor Day Weekend everyone! Cuz we all know post LDW, it’s going to be so robust like a MF!!!

like

Additional Posts in Product Management

Where should a data and insights team sit within a company org?

like

Anyone know a good source for healthcare SMB segment reports, software players, market sizing, competition, growth expectations and any research on personas?

like

As a new product manager what books should I be reading? I’ve already read Inspired but looking or more. For context, I’ve joined a series A start up and as expected there’s a lot to do and it’s very fluid. I want to be able to help the head of product as much as possible as well as provide some structure to how we work.

like

Need guidance on a chosing the right in-site/in-app Analytics provider.

Our organization is finally starting to invest in analytics and data based solutions. We have a we based platform that has a mix of modern Angular and React based code mixed with some legacy code written in Perl that spits out JavaScript. We have evaluated MixPanel, Pendo, Heap and are going to speak to Amplitude and Segment.

Could anyone who has experience with any of these tools mention your biggest pain points, please?

like

This group really makes me appreciate my situation. I am fully remote at a remote first employer who does not care where where I work as long as it doesn't affect my residency and pay in the territory I was hired. (ie working in Costa Rica and Mexico 6 months but need to be back in Canada ever so often to maintain citizenship status)

I have an offer at faang (400k +rsu), also fully remote but this group really makes me feel it's a mistake to leave.

Any faangs fully remote up for a chat?

likeuplifting

Can I get feedback on QA, do other product teams run their test scripts (non automated test scripts) past the business every single time they develop something? I am in a role where this seems to have become the norm and my perspective is that this is picking up the bulk of the work from the business that they should be doing UAT, if we fulfill the requirement we have completed our job?

like
likefunny

How are your engineering teams estimating user stories? I want to validate how my company is currently doing them. Let’s say when one user story is broken down into front end task of 3 sp and a back end task of 5 sp, then the estimate they provide for the story is 5 sp. Is that the correct methodology?

like

Anyone have any good resources/advice for data PM? Would love to hear experiences on what works for Data Science team structures specifically where the products are novel ML models.

like

We got a client request for a new feature that doesn't fit product strategy. CEO and CTO agreed to win the business, didn't consult with us before deciding. Need advice on reopening the discussion

Is anyone here a PM instructor at a boot camp such as Product School, BrainStation, General Assembly? What made you want to teach product management and how did you transition into becoming an instructor?

like

Morning Fishers. Question for all product managers: If I am interested in learning product development and becoming a product manager, how am I suppose to know whether I will be a good fit for this career? Such as personality, leadership. Are there any recommendations of great online classes to take?
Thank you!

like

Who is a PM here? What product/area are you focused on?

like

I have a non-technical background and am trying to make the transition into a product role. What positions are great from entry level/professional development and how did you prepare for such positions?

like