{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Has anyone successfully negotiated a raise after being passed over for a promotion that you deserved? Leadership was supportive but was passed over because firm results weren’t great at the time.", "post_id": "5e29a1fd11e7dc002a1726bc", "reply_count": 0, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "58f0df008ad7250010f8c590", "bowl_name": "Compensation", "feed_type": "bowl" }

Has anyone successfully negotiated a raise after being passed over for a promotion that you deserved? Leadership was supportive but was passed over because firm results weren’t great at the time.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Related Posts

So I have a moral dilemma. I requested a raise a month ago. It was finally approved. Within the last month they’ve offered 3 others counter offers AFTER I requested my raise. In that time I was interviewing elsewhere. The job I want is about $5-7k more than my raise request, but the benefits and bonuses are significantly better. Is it frowned upon to get a raise and then leave 3-4 weeks later? I don’t feel valued knowing others got a raise after I asked, and much quicker (less than a week).

like

Uk fish. Level, raise, bonus - go.

Asking for my first raise after a year. Any tips?

like

How do you deal with toxic masculinity in the workplace? I work with a lot of great people, but there are a handful of men that are so aggressive and downright sexist. I have had my boss blame me for small mistakes he’s made and refuse to discuss my performance or a raise. There are also men outside of my team who tell me how to do my job when they do not understand marketing. Is any of this remotely normal, or should I cut my losses and start job hunting?

likehelpful

I work at a traditional actuarial consulting firm on the heath benefits side and don’t really find the work very interesting. I’m kept by short term promise of a nice promotion, and competitive pay. I’ve recently started thinking about a next move, but am torn about which direction to go in. I’ve pondered a few options: working at a traditional carrier, switching to a different kind of consulting, or non-traditional work. All of my connections are in consulting not insurance, anyone have advice?

like

Salary Question - I am the director of digital marketing at a start up agency. I understand start ups usually pay less, but right now I am only making 30K/year with hardly any benefits. I feel stuck in my job because if I leave, the whole thing would most likely fall apart. I also love my job, I love my company, I love everything about it, except for that fact that I only make 30K/year. I know now that my worth is way above that. Any suggestions on how to ask for a raise?

like

What is percentage hike for Manager to Senior Manager promotion due to job level change (excluding annual hikes)?

like

What’s the best firm that pays well for Forensics in ATL. currently at KPMG. Trying to get a pay raise that’s not peanuts.

like

What are some of the larger % base salary increases for a promotion to manager that you have seen/experienced?

like

Been working for a year at my position. First full time gig programming. Even got interns and a raise. Still have no clue what the fuck I'm working with or doing.

likefunny

Got a 15% raise this year with promo to SC, bringing me into the low 6 figures. I'm happy with the large bump, but wondering how much I'm still leaving on the table by not looking elsewhere? 4 YOE, primarily federal, implementation, transformation, and tech projects

like

Tcs
Hi Everyone,

My friend is waiting for ITA Promotion his manager told that the Promotion for this quarter is still pending its not rolled out,

Anyone here have any information regarding this or anyone got promoted in this quarter Q12023

Thanks in advance.

like

Pay cut or raise going from consultant role at big consulting firm to health venture firm?

like

How do you ask for a raise?

like

If I say "deep learning" enough times, do I get a promotion still these days?

likefunny

Help me settle a debate. Is a 15% raise request too much for an employee who has been with a company for 3 years? (Only one raise of 10% in 2020.)

like

Hey Recruiters, Happy New Year!

Given that some or most of us will be getting raises soon and with our horrible inflation last year, what would be a fair raise % to anticipate? 5% , 10%?

Also, can you counter* a raise/ask for more assuming you did very well?

like

What will be the hike percentage for ITA promotion?

likefunny

I started as an intern then offered a full time job of £18k salary. In a year I’ve impacted this company so much and ensure to land & secure 2 big clients and more.
My boss said I’ll have a raise to £25k this year but now got messaged with offer £2.5k raise now and another after seeing some month when I was expecting like £28k so I’ve asked for a meeting this week cause that just pi**ed me off. I Don’t know what to do, I do love working there but sometimes I feel like being taken for granted.

like

I need some advice. My role has some HR responsibilities and therefore I have some access to company data. My review is coming up, and I plan to ask for a raise. I feel like I provide a lot of value and I’m a good employee. However, bc I have access to that data I also know that I’m making less than other employees and there is a large gap between my pay and other directors. How do I go about brining this up without being unethically about the my knowledge of this data?

like

Additional Posts in Compensation

Polling question: Career is personal, how would you describe the value of a career? Especially as a black woman in corporate America?

like

Hi Fishes,

On Saturday 6th August I had two technical round with LTI (L1 and L2) and my L2 round was pretty good but I haven't received any update from HR. Anyone can please let me know what is the recruiting process of LTI...Please !! @LTI

like

Any tips for reducing bloating on the day of an event? Or just buy some major spanx for this dress 🙈 I thought I was being careful with how I was eating for the past few days but apparently not enough

like

What’s Your Favorite Scary Movie?

like

I work in education based HR, and I don't particularly want to go to high on the totem pole, but to be more competitive (I didn't start in HR), what certs (if any) do people suggest in public school HR? We get professional development days off, and I'd like to figure out what's best for this industry?
Any suggestions from other Education based HR folks?

like

What’s the most you’ve gotten paid if you dipped after 2 busy seasons? Wondering what pay range I should expect if I follow suit.

like

Hey Jr Art Directors in Salt Lake City I saw this in my LinkedIn feed and thought I would share. Good luck! 🍀

Post Photo
like

Is Bonvoy Boundless card worth it? Currently they are offering 100k bonus points after spending 5K in first three months.

Accenture folk: what are your thoughts on today’s Leadership Summit?

like

Is everyone excessively leaving at the Big 4 across the board or is it just PwC? Seems like everyone is leaving or searching.

likehelpful

Bumped into the reversed Or Blanc in Zürich last weekend.

Post Photo
like

Any insight to working at Momentum WW? Work life balance?

like

Hi Fishes,

What does the Day 1 look like at JPMC ? Is the induction on Day 1 ? I've been sitting idle since the morning completing a few onboarding tasks, however the HR and the onboarding teams are non-responsive. Is it normal ?

like

Hi friends

How is the interview process in Wipro for the lead role. It is a tough or manageable one.

Does anyone know or heard Maxxton Company, how is it?

like

This bowl has unified now that the divisive election is over.
Perhaps this is a sign of how things will change in America too. The right will leave altogether and unity will be had for those who remain.

likefunny

I currently use adp platform, reach out to me. Bill 6314129500

Hi can anyone involved in Republican politics DM me? Would love to help out in re-electing the Governor. Also would love to get involved in Denton County. I don’t live in Texas yet but would love to start making connections

likefunny

Working in IT industry from 2014. Aimed at growing my career towards coding(Java) but ended up doing only Digital Asset Management projects and have good average working experience in Java. To aim my career growth towards coding what should I plan?

like
likefunny

Additional Posts (overall)

What’s the range for C and SC at Deloitte in the Operations practice?

What are some of the larger % base salary increases for a promotion to manager that you have seen/experienced?

like

At 5 YOE I’m around $140k and work no more than 45hrs/wk. I’ve loved the WLB and don’t mind the fact that I could be making more at a commercial focused firm. The time is worth it to me. But I have to wonder - how many other opportunities are there to break into the high 100s/low 200s in consulting while staying close to 45hrs?

like

What are MBA offers looking like for 2019 start date ?

like

Thoughts on switching to industry with a decrease in title, but increase in salary? Moving from a senior consultant to staff internal auditor. Is the jump in pay worth a lower title?

like

How expensive a house would you buy/feel comfortable buying? TC 350k (California). 700k NW (300k liquid / saved. 400k in retirement). No other debt. Pretty moderate lifestyle currently (on monthly take home of 11-12k (from salary only) spend about 5k a month (incl 2500 in rent) and generally good about lifestyle creep lately so can plan to keep spending (outside of the house / mortgage) down. Thoughts? Thanks!

likehelpful

What does a senior associate, AVP and VP at a 20bn + PE (eg TA,Cerberus,...) make all-in?

likehelpful

Pre-COVID, what are the avg, median, max, min stats for annual salary raises at Deloitte?

like

With recruiters, if you are being asked expected target salary, do you mention expected base salary or overall compensation?

like

Many of you work for companies where sick time is taken out of vacation? I thought this was an old thing but just seen an offer written like this....

like

Expected salary for PWC senior associate Financial Markets Transactions in DC/NYC?

like

What’s salary progression for Deloitte S&O? How much is your salary post undergrad, 2 years out and 3 years out?

like
likehelpful

During the pandemic wfh times of about a year, would you consider moving from SF to TX. No real reason to stay in the city. Wondering if the monetary returns and hassle of moving are worth it

like

Any recent Accenture offers? I’d like to know what to look for in terms on sign on and base for sr analyst 6 YOE and I’m post MBA 4 years. A little background, I am coming from a completely different industry and expect the pay cut but possess a lot of relevant experience. TIA

like

Considering going to D as a SM in their Human Capital practice, what should I expect for compensation? I have a master's in organizational management, 10+ years consulting in OCM, PM and Practice Lead

like

I received an offer from PWC - consulting services as follows. Is this competitive or should I negotiate it?
- Manager level
- DC based (non-government work)
- Commercial Transformation

$175K base, $15K signing bonus, up to 25% performance bonus

Thoughts?

like

Received an offer from a big4 for same role I have at my current firm (at another big4) that’s about 6k higher than current base salary. It’s less than expected, but is it worth it for a higher base?

like

How much did everyone get in LTI/stocks with their bonus?

I got 8k RSU to vest over 3 years and I don’t feel impressed.

Also got double that in options but idk how to value that

like

Uber fish with vested stock options. Did you get impacted by the Uber price drop after the IPO?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

New to Fishbowl?

image with Fishbowl logo and arms reaching out for a handshake

Already have an account? Log in

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Messaging rates may apply

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal