{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Help evaluating an offer: 1 YOE out of undergrad in T2 consulting, new offer is ~125-140 base, 15-25% bonus, 1 time signing bonus. Should I be negotiating for more or is this fair? HCOL city.", "post_id": "5dd480a22cddad0024755c7e", "reply_count": 11, "vote_count": 5, "bowl_id": "58f0df008ad7250010f8c590", "bowl_name": "Compensation" }

Help evaluating an offer: 1 YOE out of undergrad in T2 consulting, new offer is ~125-140 base, 15-25% bonus, 1 time signing bonus. Should I be negotiating for more or is this fair? HCOL city.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

uh, that's really good for 1 yoe with no mba

like

Industry offer in New York

like

Financial services internal strategy

It’s directionally correct

like

Firm, industry, city?

like

What firm are you in?

like

For a role in industry, this offer is equivalent to post-MBA level. With a comp range that wide, it may be tough to negotiate the higher end of base/bonus with just 1 YOE but definitely a great offer. Congrats OP.

like

Is this an offer in consulting or industry?

What industry??

Related Posts

Can anyone help? Does anyone know what a fair ratio is for the amount of money you bring into a company VS the amount you should be paid (i.e. salary + commission)? I work for an IT partner / Tech company, and from outbound cold market selling have added over 40 companies to our books, which over the last two years has generated €850,000 revenue, and will likely be in excess of €5 million in the coming years. What do you think I should be earning?

like

I just took a 60k salary cut to get experience in a new category. Also not working with a-holes. That’s a plus.

likehelpful

Senior Producer salary ranges in Boston?

like

Hi All, Need some help deciding an offer for IT Audit Senior Internal Auditor Role 1. Job A - 90K + 3500 Fixed Bonus + Unlimited Leaves Industry Based Role 2. Job B - 84K + 12K Joining Bonus + 20 Leaves Please help. Big 5 Consulting Role

like
like

Anybody know what a fair salary would be for a data analyst/data scientist who just had his Master degre and has 1 year of experience in data analysis field and 5 years of work experience in total.

like

ConsultingHumor’s Instagram page (364k followers) did a massive compensation survey for top consulting firms in the US and internationally. Several thousand respondents with base and bonus salary for all the top (and some smaller) firms. Can be used when negotiating your next raise or to see if you want to jump ship to another firm. You can download the full spreadsheet of data at consultinghumor (dot) org

Post Photo
likehelpful

Senior Associates/Consultants, what was your performance bonus last year? Just started as SA post MBA and am trying to establish my bonus expectations.

like

Got reached out to by a recruiter at McMaster-Carr. Looks concerning from online reviews, but comp package appears to be amazing. Is the horrible culture just for management trainee program? I would not be going into that. How are other groups around the company? Also interested in hear total comp for folks with ~1 year experience if possible. Thanks!

like

How do the few firms remaining in the AmLaw100 that have not matched market base compensation or bonuses justify not doing so at this point for at least the traditional NY/CA/DC offices?

like

How long does it usuallytake to get promoted from associate to strategist? Also, what's the salary bump like?

like

Looking for some advice on making a career switch. Currently in FP&A for a fintech company making $80k a year with a 10% bonus and options that are exercisable when the company goes public. I have been with this company a little under a year. I just received an offer to join a boutique consulting firm that would draw on my current financial and technical experience. Compensation is $100k a year with a 20% bonus. I love my current company, but is this a no brainer? Should I ask for a counter?

like

% salary saved (incl. retirement), age, location? 42% / 24 / NYC

like

Does anyone know the bonus range for a OT&T consultant 3 rating?

like

I know I should be grateful for my job but I am really sick of constantly feeling like shit and inadequate. What else can I do in the city to make about the same salary? (3rd yr associate in Jan)

like

What is the base and total comp package for a fund controller at a small PE shop? HCOL

like

Evaluating two offers in tech. I live in Atlanta and was offered 155k salary and 122k RSU $10k sign on No annual bonus. Another tech company offered $170k and 165k RSU WITH 10% annual bonus but it’s based in California. What are y’all’s thoughts, I hadn’t planned on relocations but could if it’d worth it

like

How does one start the negotiation process with company that made a new offer? I have the comp details from them but it’s below what I’d be expecting for 2022 TC if I were to stay in consulting. Additionally, the base offered was lower than what the external recruiter i was working with had shared. Should I bring that up or go straight to the negotiation?

like

When do you ask about salary in the process if you’d be relocating? HR is calling today to schedule in person interviews. Should I ask now or wait until I’m there? Don’t want to waste anyone’s time...

like

What is the average salary for a workers comp defense attorney? I know it’s on the lower end but I just lateraled because I wanted a better work life balance. Took a pay cut but don’t mind it right now because I am a mom. Just curious what average salary is and what potential salary is for a partner or senior associate.

like

Additional Posts

If it ever comes to that, would you give up your Indian citizenship to become a US citizen? Or would you just stop at the Green Card?

like

Sad scenes out of Kabul gives anxiety about facing ATL on Monday morning a bit of perspective.

Post Photo
like

If I begin a fully remote job in one state and move to a different state. Obviously I’ll notify my job as there shouldn’t be any issues but will they adjust my pay if I’m move to an area that pays less?

like

Hi! Everyone, I am a PhD turned consultant with 2 years at big 4. I was wondering if there are openings at MBB that I can apply to? I am a molecular biologist by training and do life sciences consulting in the cell and gene therapy domain.

like

more accurate title for recruiters: Resume Farmer. Especially since Covid

like

Is it possible to take sick leave during notice period in IBM?

like

Does Bain have their first and final round interviews scheduled within the same week?

like

I have applied to many internships in advertising specifically. One of my last choices post-interview got back to me before the others and I need to turn in a decision. Is it acceptable to accept a job offer but if one that is better comes around to revoke it (within a reasonable time)? My other options won’t be giving me an answer for another week.

like

Currently at EY senior 3 up for promotion to manager just interviewed with Deloitte and people seem great! Salary increase is amazing… is this a good decision hmm… you guys tell me. I have no issues with EY but my salary is not what I would like it to be and when I promote I don’t think they will come close to offer from Deloitte.

like

Would love your thoughts on an offer - $140k cash and $20k equity at Series B for Strategy role. Current 3rd year at MBB making $200k, and really don’t mind my WLB. Would you take the offer?

like

Happy Wednesday! I am trying to plan with our AP and climate lead on what we can do in distance learning as a school wide event. I suggested we still host our multicultural club assemblies on zoom for the school. Anyone have experience with zoom assemblies to promote a positive climate in DL? Thanks!

like

Has everyone that's been getting laid off been on the bench? Or were you guys actively on projects and got surprised come CRT?

Hello my friends! Advice on how to get / find an ugly Christmas sweater? First timer here! Also, any holiday desserts you recommend making?

like

Hi everyone I attended interview at amazon at october ,on a loop interview of 4 rounds .my fourth one was scheduled but interviewer didnt turned up on the day i have been told it will be rescheduled but till i didnt get any update i have tried through mail and call no response ,so this means am out?

like

Saw a post recently about wlb being worse at a startup than consulting. Interviewing with an unicorn which is expected to ipo in may be 5 years. So trying to get an idea of what the consensus is based on folks who have already left. Role is semi-technical- solution architect.

like

Anyone share the total comp for global supply manager at Apple? Base + bonus + RSUs?

like

Prefacing this with the disclaimer that I only started several months ago so maybe I’m missing something Definitely was interested in the “consulting lifestyle” during recruiting but I think if I were given the choice I would do remote forever with a big reason being that I think I have more time for stuff I like. If I have downtime now I can ride my bike, go hit golf balls, cook, whatever which would not be options if I were traveling or even just working in an office. Thoughts?

like

How long does H1b visa transfer to another company take in regular processing? Based out of NY. Thanks!

Saw exited out being used. Coached out is already neutral enough. Just interesting that we don't call it what it is. Released, fired, let go

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal