Hey fishes, need some advice please -

I'm an undergrad (tier 2 engineering college) working in consulting for the last 2.5 years. Was underpaid so decided to pursue MBA.

Sudden turn of events led me to secure a 200% hike at another consulting major. They're paying 18lpa + bonus which I think is also the pay offered at premier b schools.

Now I'm really questioning the ROI on pursuing an mba as the tradeoff is BIG (1.7-2 cr spread over 10 years). Calculation below (feedback appreciated) cont

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Dnt go for an MBA if you are comfortable with your current work ans industry. BTW it also depends on your years of experience.

Less than 3 years: Stay
Around 4-5 years: You could do an executive MBA from IIM A, B, C only if you are not interested in your current work

like

I loved my tech work. But didnt want to leave an opportunity from IIM. I was in this exact same dilemma :)

Be sure, if everyone commenting NOT to do an MBA has even purused a ivy league mba (IIM-A/B/C)..
Its utterly myopic to think that pursuing an MBA is all about a package u earn..! It's just a by product btw!!

1. If you don't pursue, you'll be the one who will face mid life crisis once you're 35.. You're young for yourself, but a burden to your firm...

2. MBA from top 3 institutes will give you peace of mind and value, where you can tackle sudden misfortunes..

3. Value in your firm - the kind of projects you will work on... You will have amazing career transistions..

4. Most importantly, the peer group and the network of yours - trust me - you'll never ever get in your normal life, here you will get to live to 100-150 of guaranteed future leaders...!

If you want to know more, ping me personally..

- IIM - A Grad, been there & done it!

like

@author. If you're already earning well then yes, it only makes sense from top B schools (Old IIMs + ISB)

PS: IIMB grad here and I totally agree with Accenture 1 above.

like
Recent IconRecent

Following this thread.

like

Anytime..! Reach out to me personally - if you need any more info 😇

Here's a different though I can propose-
Go for the new job. Don't persue MBA now.
Post MBA salary would like to be around 15-20LPA fixed and bonus.

Have a good career for 3-5 years at this new firm. You'll raise by position and by salary in this time.

At around 6-8 years of total experience, look for options where leaders do MBA of 1 year (exec MBA) without leaving their job. Research on this.

Or

Go for executive MBA from CLG like instead or Stanford/Harvard. It's your way to get into C-league positions earlier than others.

Things to think-
At 6-8 years exp, your priorities will not be same as today. Family might play a key role for your decisions.
If at all you wanna go for MBA now, make sure the clg is in top 5.

like

Your YOE is in the sweet spot for a 1yr MBA from India. But make sure it is from one of the older IIMs. PGPX from Ahmedabad is at a different league. The remaining 4s are more or less the same.

MBA won't be a good decision in your case. You were able to secure 200% hike that shows you have potential. You switch to a start-up in a year, you'll be north of 30L with Stocks. If Startup does well you'll make money alongside.

Plus you will get a balanced, less stressful life. MBB jobs are extremely hectic compared to an Amazon SDE or Startup coder earning the same. Your options to switch will be more.

In very long term (15 years) you may feel stagnant and feel MBA would have been better, but that's likely only if you had made it to top at every move after MBA. Plus you should may sufficient savings by 45, you may be happy living a stagnant life :)

helpful

So I hope to seek all your guidance on what are non quantifiable benefits of an mba from a premier B schools and do they outweigh the cost for me?

Calculation of mba cost:
2 years no pay - 36 lacs
Student loan and emi - 37 lacs (NPV)
Instead if I invest the emi amount elsewhere at 12% interest I can generate 1cr+ in 10-12 years.
So net investment would then be 1.7cr. NPV ~ 1.3 cr

Thanks a lot! This is very insightful

Hi
I am in a similar dilemma. Also may I know the details of the position you got this package at ?

Pls dm

MBA definitely gives you an advantage over the long term.

Let's say you land in a top 3/4 school and manage to get a job in MBB/ Investment Banking. Your salary will be easily in the north of 40 LPA after 3 years or experience.

Evaluate and see if you'll be in a position to make 40+ lpa in your current job after 5 years. The gap will only widen with time.

Ofcourse there's a risk that you might not land those dream jobs in campus, in which case you'll be back to 20-25 lpa.

But if you're confident, then you should go ahead and do an MBA.

Do not go for MBA. Do part time MBA later if required.

I was in the exact same boat a month ago. Good pay and loved the tech. So what I did was get a sabbatical to join back the team in a higher role. Best of both worlds. See if you can manage something similar.

To add, I joined one of the old IIMs for my 1yr exec MBA. Since yours is a 2 yr PGP, I would suggest leaving your current work to go for it. If you're in the tech industry, work should not be an issue even during the pandemic.

Hey , apart from MBA , what are the other part time courses that can help me to have me a better package ,.
Currently I have 4.4 years of experience
Can anyone suggest me ?

Related Posts

Looking to move into an Enterprise AE role, likely selling to companies 10,000-20,000 employees. Any idea of what typical salary range would be?

like

How’s everyone planning to use their YE bonus + tax return (if applicable) this year? Personally, I’m already maxing out my 401k, Roth, and have crypto exposure (mostly ETH that’s staking). Any other suggestions?

like

What is the average salary for 9+ years experience at C1 at Capgemini?

like

What’s the average pay for room division coordinator?

like
like

Hello all,
I am currently working as a data Scientist with overall experience of 5.5 years and relevant experience of 3 years. My current CTC is in the range of 11-12lpa (including variable).
What should my CTC as per market standards considering I have a PG degree in AI-ML from an recognised college?

like

I’m a physician assistant with interests in technology. I’m well versed in epic. I’m looking to leave clinical medicine, what kind of roles are available with epic?

like

Anybody work in the global corporate tax team at Gartner? Was recently approached about joining their team. Currently in M&A tax and curious if anyone has any opinions on that LOB at Gartner or reasons for / against making the move. Any compensation data would also be helpful for MCOL.

like

Emtec I am switching from automation engineer (python) to bigdata. 8 yoe and current ctc 13L. Got an offer from emtec inc for 18L. What kind of clients do they have? Should i accept the offer? Dont have any other offer yet but final round in 2 more service based companies.

like

Should I leave my first permanent job as a team leader of 4 DPs in a FMCG business (only been there for 4 months) to join a huge Tech business for a 12months contract?

They offer me 60% more money than my permanent role. Circa 2000 dollars every month in my pocket

However, I am worried if I accept the tech role and I do not become permanent I will be looking again for a job in 12-24 months and my CV won't be showing a managerial position. Won't be showing any progress.

like

Hi fishes,
Tomorrow I have been scheduled with pdm round. How should myself prepare for this?. Pls do help.
Also advise on the salary expectations. Yoe 3.2. Tech rpa dev. Cctc 4.55lpa. Offer - 7.5 lpa. Ectc with IBM 10.5lpa.

like

Hello Fishes, Can someone confirm what should be the grade and designation in HCL for around 17 years of experience?

Interviewing for a BDR position at Salesforce. Is there wiggle room to negotiate the compensation ? If so what do you recommend ?

Hi Guys, Any idea on the hike % for 2021 EOY appraisal for respective rating??
And also any updates on when it will be communicated??

Level 10.1 how much hike and vpay?

like

Hello guys,

I'm having total 7+ yoe (5+yrs embedded developer + 2yrs in FuSa automotive) Initially HCL have denied what I've expected for automotive FuSa and they have given an offer of 10LPA with a justification that my relevant experience is less, now I'm holding an offer of 18 LPA and asked HCL for a counter offer for the same position what do you guys think will HCL offer me this much?

TIA

Need guidance. I'm at a small industry org that hired consultants for a project but they weren't able to do a few things since they don't know code/Apex. How big of a learning curve is SF + Apex?

Can you guys advise me if a salary of 150 K CAD before tax is good for a 3 member family? It is in Quebec and we will be shifting from India to Canada with that.

like

Hello Guys,
Please share your valuable honest feedback. This will help me decide. This is first switch actually. If you know any thing about these two companies.

1. Koch Business Solutions (19 fixed)
2. Cerner (21 Fixed + Variable)

like

What is the range for a Strategy Director (10 years exp) at NYC agencies with a strong digital angle (Huge, R/GA, AKQA, Critical Mass, Big Spaceship etc)?

likehelpful

More Posts

Is it a red flag if they’re an associate?

smart

I'm really having a difficult time understanding how engineering is supposed to be really competitive, most of the projects I've worked on were in groups and there wasn't usually a clear "leader," we were just on a team

like
like

Has anyone used SoFi to pay down credit card debt? I am drowning in interest every month with my BofA card and getting nowhere fast. Would love any advice re: SoFi or paying off credit card debt in general. Thank you!

like

Hi fishes,
I am currently working as Branch Manager (scale-2 officer) in one of the leading public sector banks and have 5 yr experience in core banking. I am having 2.5 years experience in the IT sector on vision plus as a software engineer (before joining the bank). I have knowledge of core banking as well as good knowledge of banking tools like finacle, caps, imac etc. I want to switch to private financial institutions.
Any suggestions about such institutions and the domain for I can apply

How is Novartis Management Consulting Domain? I have got an offer for 20.5L

YOE - 3.5yrs

like

Can we use salesforce mobile for personal purpose like clicking photos and transfer it to another mobile

An aspiring CD looking for someone to take a look at my book it’s in the earlier stages! I’d love to get any feedback.

I need help, please. I’ve been applying to jobs for several months without a single callback. I am looking to stay remote, would anyone be willing to review my resume?

like

What are some good gyms in the city? I like to do a mix of cardio and strength, a pool would be nice but not a must.

like

Would you recommend the CVS test? I dont think I want to get it done due to the risks.

I have a Deputy CISO who constantly instructs us to not go to HR with top level compliance issues (because JP Morgan Chase frowned upon it). But these issues are pervasive to tone at the top and could cause non compliance. What should I do?

like

If You need a referral have Cyber experience and a clearance DM me!

like

anyone gonna buy any calls before market close?

like

Hey Fishes,

Is
ServiceNow offering full time remote option to new joiners? Anyone recently joined, how is the experience? ServiceNow

Day 9 - 40 push ups challenge ✅ ( 30 regular, 10 diamond 😤 and 10 extra inverse).

likefunnyuplifting

Based on true incidents

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunny

Hi fishers! I have offer and signed contract with Deloitte UK and my start day is in the beginning of April. I need skilled worker visa, and we haven’t applied yet for that. Screening and onboarding is in progress. Immigration team doesn’t reply since reached me out 1st time. How much time does it usually needed to go through the whole process? How many days take for visa to be approved since application?Deloitte

like
like

Additional Posts in Consulting India

My accenture job portal says offered but I could not view the offer letter. How can I see it? Can it be still revoked?

like

Hi All,
I need some urgent info,
I have offers with 2 organizations, wipro and LTTS (L&T). There is 2 lakhs difference between the two. LTTS has higher package.
Please suggest me which one is better ?
Domain: Automotive /Autosar

Hi All,
I have cleared all rounds of IBM, currently having 5.10 yoe, hr have already asked me share some documents and that I have already shared and salary negotiations have already done.. But she also shared a link to apply for that job code, but in that same day the status changed to " Your profile is no longer under consideration " . Can someone tell me why it is?

Any recent joiners in Infosys, can you please let me know the onboarding process and if it is virtual will they send any other email and how many days before DOJ will they send? Infosys

Any vacancy for transaction analyst (Non-voice) with 1+ year experience in Chennai.

Hi fishes,

I have 2 YOE as MS SQL SERVER and MongoDB DBA and currently looking for a change.
Also have cloud exposure like Azure SQL and AWS RDS.

If someone can refer me in there organization, it will be really helpful.

Note: currently serving notice period (60 days Left)

Thanks in advance.

Does ibm provide rejection mail or any mail after the interview?

After clearing all TCS interview rounds for the BA profile. HR shared the CTC breakup last week, even after accepting the salary breakup, I have uploaded all documents to the TCSibegin portal and all documents showing are verified now. Valid is a screenshot as well taken by HR on 29th June. Now they are saying " Not able to get approval from management for your profile. Hence will have to drop for now. You can apply again after 3 Months".
What should I do?This kind of thing from TCS not accepted

like

Hi Fishes,

Experience -6.3
Sap sd and S/4 Hana
Current ctc - 8 Lakhs
What will be expected ctc.

Please help.

like

Okay guys I am resigning today. Taking some time off to take care of myself. Definitely not returning to Deloitte. ✌️

likefunnysmartupliftinghelpful

What can be considered fair salary for Manager year 2 at big 4 consulting, domain, supply chain and operations?

Any hint?

like

Hello All,

I'm looking for an opportunity into accounts payable. I have a experience of 1 year & 10 months in Amazon as an financial operations analyst. It would be very helpful if someone could connect for a relevant opportunity.

like

Is there work from home policy even during non COVID times in Optum Which is better Optum or Accenture in terms of work life balance and job security
Accenture Optum

like

Hi fishes, How long it generally takes to become manager from senior consultant in Capgemini FS ? Criteria ?

funny

Any GMAT takers here? Would like to understand your prep strategy and reviews of prep materials like eGMAT, Manhattan etc.

Hi ,
I have joined HCL as Lead Engineer on 21st November 2021. So wanted to check about the appraisal cycle and when will I be getting my next appraisal.
and suggestions are also welcomed on working culture in HCL.

funny

Freshers are joining with much better pay than what I am getting and also got zero hike/bonus whatsoever this year. Is this happening everywhere or just at Deloitte USI?
Background: Working as an SFDC developer at Deloitte USI, campus hire, and completed my first year this August.

like

Hi Fishes

So if India will be launching it digital currency next year, I am curious which company is working with government to deliver it ? Who has these projects ? Will there be new blockchain ? Anyone already working on these, any one has any insights ?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal