{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Hi everyone! I have 3 offers:\nA: Tier 3, NYC, Base - 100k, Bonus - 20k\nB: Tier 1, Baltimore, Base - 110k, Bonus - 10%\nC: Tier 1, Dallas, Base - 95k, Bonus - 10%\n\nWhich one would you pick and why?", "post_id": "610336ac41849b0021ceacce", "reply_count": 19, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "5fdbeef07748c5001ae5543a", "bowl_name": "Career Advice for Students" }

Hi everyone! I have 3 offers: A: Tier 3, NYC, Base - 100k, Bonus - 20k B: Tier 1, Baltimore, Base - 110k, Bonus - 10% C: Tier 1, Dallas, Base - 95k, Bonus - 10% Which one would you pick and why?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Option B clearly

likehelpful

Go with Option B. Baltimore is boring but DC is nearby. Dallas isn’t any better either. 100k in NY is not comparable to the other 2

like

I would disagree. As somebody who lives in Maryland and spends a sizable amount of time in both DC and Baltimore they're both very easy day trips and unique cities with their own activities and opportunities. Amtrak and Marc both run frequent trains between the two cities and therebare several highways directly connecting the two. Honestly, I find the lack of pretentiousness of Baltimore refreshing, so regardless you would just need to find your scene.

Option B by a mile

like

Option B

like

C. Baltimore is a terrible place to live. Seriously (been there).

like

What roles are these

What are the factors you are considering? How much do you care about the city?

All are Risk Associate and I am indifferent.

Option B is the best given the prestige and lower cost of living compared to NYC in Option A.

like

Personally I would make options A and C negotiate based on option B. Don’t say what city they are in. Once numbers are all equal - I’d personally choose Dallas.

What are you optimising for? Total “cash”? As cost of living varies GREATLY across these 3 places, same goes for tax Do you want MBA? What’s the best brand for that?

You can live like a king on $121k in Baltimore

Cost of living should definitely be a huge factor since salaries are roughly +/- 10K diff in base

Go with the location you prefer to live. The money is insignificant at entry level. Long term growth / future prospects should also be a factor. It's extremely hard to give you advice based solely on the comp you present.

I’d personally go for B

Option B

Current work in Baltimore making $120 and lived in the city for 5.5 years. Happy to chat if you have questions about the city, cost of living, etc.

Related Posts

2y @ boutique strat/intelligence firm. F500 clients. Promoted from analyst to SC. Base only 80 comp 15-25%. Looking for recs/referrals nyc startups in customer success roles/strategy.

like

What’s the base salary for Strat Consultant (L9) with 3 YOE at Accenture London? Looking to relocate but need to know I’d be able to live comfortably.

like

Any idea what is the approx salary range of C1 band at Wipro for sap consultants?

like

What is the typical base + bonus range at Citi for SVP and Director level (Institutional Clients Group)? Recruiter refused to provide any compensation range for given roles.

like

Can anyone please share the comp package of senior accountant/FA role at Amazon at Seattle for recent offers.

like

Any idea on how much salary can I quote for Associate Business Consultant role in Refinitiv? YOE-1yr I've a HR discussion today evening. Inputs required please!!

like

Q for my friend.. she’s newish to flipping her own houses and is a contractor. She bought an investment property and is going to do the work on the house. Is it better to pay herself a salary during the work from the investment LLC to herself as the contractor, or just work for “free”? Either way the money is coming out of her own business.. just wondering for tax purposes

like

Good starting salary for a junior copywriter out of college?

like

Anyone else ever feel a rush of inferiority sometimes? The thoughts of “I didn’t get promoted as fast” or “my salary is lower than theirs” or “they found a better exit opp”

likehelpful

What are M salary ranges at accenture in T2 city?

like

Are bonus percentages released next week for deloitte consulting or is it just rating decisions?

like

What is the salary range in NYC for a full-time senior copywriter in pharma with experience of 6+ years? Been freelancing and may now move over to full-time.

like

Are EY Promotion Bonuses locked in on October 1st? Or October 15th? I’m wondering if a newly promoted Senior leaves the firm between October 2nd - 14th will they forfeit the Senior Promotion Bonus...

like

Anyone work in corporate strategy here? What is the approx compensation range (base, bonus, LTI) for a Senior Director, Corporate Strategy at a F100 firm?

like

For people who are familiar with work culture in Tokyo, how much embezzlement takes place? I see a good number of Japanese people on Instagram buying Bentleys and such. I'm confused how they can do so while living in a high COL with, on average, lower salaries than in the US. With the scandal at Nissan and how many executives were found to be stealing money from the company, I wonder if this is some unspoken secret about doing business in Tokyo? Unless their comp curve is extremely steep.

like

Canada Comp Thread 🇨🇦 SALARY BONUS FIRM (Optional) YOE/LEVEL REGION OR HCOL / LCOL

likefunny

Is 35k a good sign-on bonus for B4?

likeuplifting

How expensive a house would you buy/feel comfortable buying? TC 350k (California). 700k NW (300k liquid / saved. 400k in retirement). No other debt. Pretty moderate lifestyle currently (on monthly take home of 11-12k (from salary only) spend about 5k a month (incl 2500 in rent) and generally good about lifestyle creep lately so can plan to keep spending (outside of the house / mortgage) down. Thoughts? Thanks!

like

If anyone is interested eliminating the IFs in their employee model practice let chat. I’ve been consulting advisors for the past 10 years on ways to dominate the IFs. Doing so creates consistency leading to focus and focus equals growth. What are your IFs - comp- product push- flexibility- compliance restrictions ????

like

EY kids, has anyone ever negotiated with the partner during the annual compensation conversation? If so, how did it go?

like

Additional Posts

What's the typical salary difference between a mid-level CW vs. senior CW in NYC?

like

Got selected to a project where location is not same where I am joining, when manager said lets see when office opens after WFH will they ask me to relocate ? consider it as banking project

like

Left PwC about a month ago. I cleared my expense buffer on Concur before leaving and then submitted any pending charges using the form issued by HR. However I still have an outstanding balance of 1K

like

Bay Area fish... Anyone working in FiDi live in South San Francisco, Daly City or even further south (Burlingame, San Mateo, etc)? Would you recommend it? Thinking about things like: commute time (office, airport), cheaper rent, more boring areas, cleaner/safer, etc.

like

How can we see the breakdown of SPG point earnings (welcome gift, tier bonus, etc.)? Post merger, everything is added up as one transaction.

like

Starting work next week. Likely WFH the whole year. I have a standard morning routine that I would like to try to keep. What’s a reasonable time for me to start working? On the other hand, what’s a reasonable time for me to log off? Say I come to good stopping point and I fall asleep around 9:30pm. But then something happens at 10:30pm and i’m asleep… would partners be pissed? Just trying to navigate some potential issues. Any advice would be great!

like

Anyone here ever worked with a vocal coach? I need recommendations for a lesson or two before auditioning for a pseudo professional chorus group...

like

So I’m interviewing for a media position that’s a bit more digital-heavy than the position I’m in now. anyone have tips on how to succeed and impress my interviewer despite not having their desired amount of experience?

like

Is transferring 210K Marriott points to SW for companion pass still going?? Or have they ended it

Just got let go among with half of our creative team.. Can I be honest about this when interviewing for new positions?

like

Just initiated a 401K rollover for a very sweet couple, both aged 63. They both spent the last 17 or so years working at Wal Mart. Not in corporate, but in regular ol' stores.

like

What could be more annoying than getting put on a project that has no chance of seeing the light of day? Working the weekend on it.

like

How is non-MBB consulting viewed in the big scale? Looking into exit opps, but people keep acting like I’m giving up gold by trying to leave, yet I feel like almost anything is better than here

like

Flew Delta Premium Select from DTW > PWG on the new Airbus 330 plane. It was the best experience I’ve ever had, worth every penny 👌🏻

likehelpful

Hi, Has anyone got interviewed for Hadoop+Spark+Scala profile in Capgemini???

Anyone working in Deloitte, San Diego, willing to refer me?!

like

Seriously I have been single in Seattle for 2 years. The crazy thing is, I even had LDR with a dude in Boston while living in Seattle. I had bf in San Francisco before too. Is Seattle dating scene so bad?

like

About when should I start prepping for interviews? I submitted H / S last week but havent been able to focus on interviews yet

like

Anybody have renters insurance experience due to damage from their building? So not their fault? My building’s pipes burst and did some damage to my apartment unit. Luckily minimal damage to my property but replacing a few items. Anybody dealt with this before? Wondering how I deal with insurance—is it my renters insurance or do I work with the building’s insurance? Also already getting reduced rent for the month.

like

Just learnt FIL is in ICU under observation after contracting Covid. He has other pre existing conditions. Just became citizens this year and haven’t gotten around to doing the OCI card yet. Any guidance in how to get emergency visa or travel to Hyderabad would be greatly appreciated! Are there special flights & quarantine rules?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal