Hi guys need some advice on job offer -

Applying for Senior I
-Big 4 $90K plus bonus
-A top 10 firm $95k plus bonus

The HR from the top 10 firm said they have more WLB than big 4. But I think Big 4 has more opportunities than smaller firms. Which one should I choose? Thank you guys.

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I’m at a “top 10 firm” and was told busy season would be 50-60 hour weeks but it ended up being just as bad as, if not worse than, b4. This is tax so depending on your service line maybe there’s better WLB. I’d go b4 if I did it all over again.

likesmart

Yeah I’m
Big 4 and have 370 hours over standard this year. Multiple 90 hour weeks over last 4 months. Just depends on client. I hit my record this week with 117 hours and can’t see straight.

The money today is a very small difference, and work life balance will vary by team. In a vacuum WLB will probably be better at the mid size firm but it’s really impossible to tell without working in that group.

Exit opportunities may be better coming from big 4, but this will really depend on how much weight a hiring manager puts on big 4 experience versus a mid size firm. From what I’ve seen, your exit will depend more on your network, how well you network, your specific work experience, and how well you interview.

So conclusion, I guess, is that if you do well, you’ll win with either firm

likehelpful
Recent IconRecent

Unless the top 10 firm puts their hours in the contract, or offers overtime, the WLB is just fluff

likefunnysmart

If it’s the same job I’m taking B4

like

I always prefer to work for a smaller firm, as you have a much better chance of being seen, recognized and rewarded for your effort. IMO, Big 4 doesn’t compare to smaller sized firms, they’re usually ice cold and extremely cut throat.

likefunnysmarthelpful

Who are you working for? My dad said once “ Sometimes you are only one jackass away from having a great job”

Do B4

like

I would focus more on the path to promotion than the 5k difference in current pay.

like

Let the big four company know you have an outstanding offer with another firm and disclose the amount. Ask if they can match the offer or if they can do anything to compensate for it. I would say big 4 for the opportunity if you want to leave for industry.

like

Go for big 4. 5k more in job offer is nothing as compared to big 4 experience. You have long time to make more money if you at big 4

like

Top 10 doesn’t offer better WLB. There are numerous posts about this.

If you want WLB, go much smaller firms and hope for the best.

like

Tell the Big 4 to match. You’ll have more opportunities down the line to switch service lines internally, etc

like

You will never convince me that working for a client with a tighter budget, smaller purse strings, and messy accounting leads to better work life balance.

likefunnysmart

@bdo6 not for my clients. theyve been large companies on a fixed fee so we don’t really even track our time at all. its a huge luxury during your workday.

like

Depends on the top 10 firm and office.

In general Mm will be better big four in wlb. But it’s not saying much. It’s 60 hours vs 70 hours. Pick your poison.

Aside from wlb. Big four tends to have more toxic culture and environment.

But yes. In long run, big four will get you more exit opportunities.

likehelpful

Can you elaborate on "toxic culture and environment"? Assuming that you worked B4 before jumping to smaller firm, seems like a bad experience based on office or service line. I've seen loads of smaller firm's with truly toxic cultures and smaller size meant less opportunity to have a good experience if you had a bad tram. It's all relative and painting in broad strokes like this isn't helpful to anyone (or the profession).

Tell big4 to match or beat it and you’ll go with them. Don’t ask, tell them to match and you’re in. They won’t resist

like

Just depends on what you’re most comfortable with. Some people want the prestige and experience of working at big four on the largest clients. Other people are more comfortable in smaller office environments where they know more of the people who make up the firm. Either way you’re going to be getting paid well while gaining good experience. But as far as WLB goes tax is kind of just tax so I would not expect it to be much different between the two. I work at a mid size regional and my hours still spike up into the 80+ range around deadlines. Any firm can say 50-60 but if they schedule you more than that then it’s going to just fall on you to finish the work anyway. I do think that smaller firms may be a bit less toxic on average but it really just depends on the people around you in any situation.

likehelpful

I 've done both a top 10 firm and big 4 - if you want any sense of WLB you'll go top 10 firm. Hands down. Especially with higher comp its really not a question. If you really want big 4, do what those below said and go back to them telling them your top 10 offer and they will match it without a doubt.

likefunny

Unless you are one of the very few strange people who want to become a partner one day - go with big 4
Pwc 6 knows what’s up
You get lots of mess with little audit budgets in mid size
Yes, top 10 firms DO have big clients but by no means those are a majority of them
If your goal is to get 2-3 years and get out - might as well do so at a firm that carries that prestige
If you for some strange reason want to make it a life time career - you can consider going to top 10
But even in this case - there are plenty of partners in MM that actually started their careers at Big 4.
All in all big 4 is a better choice if this is a question of value (both pay and exit opportunities).
Just don’t be silly and not ask big 4 to match your offer

likesmart

Ask for $95k from the Big4. I am sure they will match.

like

What are the other benefits? Those could be a salary increase as well. I just took a job that give me free health insurance. That’s a $2500 increase to my salary from my last job. They also match 5% of my 401k contribution instead of 3% like my last job. Another few thousand. The bonus structure and potentially is also substantially better. The base is not always the end all be all.

likefunny

Top 10. I moved to top 10 and got a 12% raise plus 8% bonus my first year. Pay raises and bonuses are leaps and bounds above big 4. Also work life balance and advancement is much better.

likefunny

This is categorically not correct. At top 10, pay is generally lower, bonuses aren’t even close, and advancement and work/life are significantly lower than B4. I’ve worked both and have vast networks at both

likefunnysmart

Big4, for sure. A Top 10 firm is going to have the same kinds of time demands and likely less staff to support. When I worked a boutique (between B4 firms) the busy season was much, much worse.

And yes, more exit ops at B4.

likesmart

Related Posts

Hello.I have 2 years of experience in java support and little experience in java microservices development as well any openings please let me knw. Preferred work location is bangalore ready to work in java support and night shift role as well with good salary package..
Thanks in advance..

Hi All

What will be the inhand monthly salary for 16.50 lakh CTC(including 1.47 lakh varaiable) in LTI

Hi Guys,

I am holding offer from Publicis sapeint for Senior Associate Level -1. Any suggestions do I need to join Sapient after ZS if I am looking for work life balance along with work?

Please suggest

like

How do you guys feel about design tests during the interview processs? Do you think it’s effective?

like

What skills are required for Business presentation specialist role. I have given their online assessment 6 times and i always get 100% accuracy in it and my verbal is good too. I have 4.5 years of exp as Business Analyst and professional certificates in MS OFFICE not sure why i dont get a response back McKinsey & Company

likeuplifting
like

It’s very discouraging to continuously receive these rejection emails. With 9 years of supply chain experience, I am not sure why I would not be able to at least get an interview for entry level roles that require no experience. Not just this one pictured but others as well. I’ve applied to maybe 60 positions since May, both mid level and “entry” and no interviews. I’ve had my resume professionally re-written twice. Not sure where the disconnect is. Anyone else going through this same thing?

Post Photo

Is there a reason recruiters take so long to give you an update after a final round interview? Have waited for a month with one and was told I would hear last week (and didn’t) for another. Am I getting ghosted?

like

Does anyone know of any hospitality or tourism companies hiring marketing or field marketing folks.

like

Any idea about salary range for UI/angular developer with 4+ years of experience?

like

Hi fishes,

I am facing problem while uploading documents to
Accenture countdown portal.

I need to fill PF trust name and address along with date of exit but my LWD is in next week so I am unable to select the future date as date of exit.
I am getting mails like I need to complete all docs upload by one week before doj.
Is there any problem if I upload just before 2 days of doj.??
Has anyone faced this issue.?AccentureAccenture

like

Hi Fishes,

Any idea what will be the in hand salary if opting for new tax regime. TIA

Post Photo

Does anyone know what the interview questions are like for Workday HCM Consultant in Deloitte? Glassdoor doesn’t have much information.

like
like

So, a recruiter gave me feedback that my lack SPHR or SHRM-SCP is causing my resume to be knock out by AI and human recruiters despite my position and work history in Multinationals and being in Technology. They suggested that we put SPHR ( Lapsed). I let it lapse in 2017. What is your opinion? Plus if I were to take another certification - should I take SPHR or SHRM-SCP?

like

Hi Fishes,

2.5 years experience in Mainframe. Just got an offer from TCS for Systems engineering C1 grade for 7.5 Lpa. Can anyone help me with the breakdown and in hand in below salary. Also please advise if it is feasible to join TCS for the pay and grade. Thanks in advance.

Post Photo
like

I want to do a course in cosmetology aesthetics and laser treatment but I’m unsure if that will pay me well after completion. Can anybody suggest me if that pays well or not?

like

Can anyone share some insight into estimated comp package for a Manager in life sciences consulting with an MPH and 4 YOE at the firm? I’m promoting to Manager and have been successfully selling and delivering high quality work. I know have they have underpaid me in the past compared to new joiners at the firm and want to make sure I’m being compensated for the value I know I bring to the team

like

Hi! How much should I make as a dental office manager in DFW? I’ve been working for 15 years at the office and I would like to ask for a raise.

like

Hi friends,

I am new to Canada and applying jobs via Linkedin / Indeed in IB / Corporate Development / Private equity roles. However, no success so far. Had also gone through 3 rounds of discussion (without any opening) with a leading Canadian Bank. I have a few questions for you.

1. Should i start shooting my resume with cover letter on linkedin profile of IB Directors / VPs / Associates
2. What should be the frequency of follow up with bankers in the bank in which i had discussion already

like

More Posts

Anyone from Japan here?!?

What do you guys think about municipal finance

like

Hi Fishers,
Need your inputs please. I have applied for operations senior analyst in
CBA.It says Support ITSM operations. what is job role more about business operations or fraud, sanction compliance related. Please help. Any information will become a knowledge for me.

like

I am going to move to a well reputed organization from a budding startup after working in it for more than 2 years. What is the percent of hike I can expect if I was working below par in startup expecting it to grow and be part of the management when it would be big. How should I negotiate and put forward my point. Thanks in advance for your suggestions.

like

Does anyone have information about the role of a mediator? I’m trying to find valuable information online about what it’s like and what it takes to become a mediator of any kind and there’s so much space trash out there. Whether it’s in divorce or conflict management or elsewhere, I’m just seeking perspective. Any insight or connections would be appreciated!

like

Other than negative experiences, how did you know f͟o͟r͟ s͟u͟r͟e͟ it was time for another job?

Post Photo
like

Does anyone work for Instructure?

like

Is there a referral process for roles at Apple?

like

Help needed for Halloween costume!

What’re you NYC 🌈🐠 up to this weekend

like

Kinda bummed. I’ve been single for 6 years (I’m 31 now). I live in ptown and talk to guys in Boston on tinder. Was talking to a guy for about a week who is my type. I asked if he wanted to FaceTime tonight and he said sure but caveated that he isn’t into long distance (ptown to Boston) and that we would most likely stick to chatting. Idk what’s wrong with me. Everyone tells me I’m a catch but guys I’m attracted to are never into me 😭 just needed to vent

likehelpful

Auction starts in 90 minutes. Quick. Who plays in the NFL??

like

Any advice for a Level 9 - Business and Integration Arch specialist? Joining early April so any advice is welcome.

like

Not a bit.

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi all, is this bowl still active? I am a public health professional (MPH) and couldn't find much relatable on fishbowl. I am working for an INGO in the national team, would love to connect with fellow PHPs. Additionally, would require 11 likes on the profile for DM. Thanks

like

Can someone please describe how work life balance at Mastercard?
and how will be onboarding done as far as KT is concerned, for someone with experience range of 3-5 years

Looking to hire a Creative Director/Art Director - Digital for our Oakland office. Apply on the R2C Group website.

Hey Guys! I am looking for referrals at Goldman Sachs, McKinsey & Company, Visa & Mastercard Ready to help with referrals at Citi.

like

What's up with commercials nowadays? The ones I worked on back in the early 2000s were so much more creative. Maybe everyone is running out of ideas?

likefunny

How do you think this industry is being affected by inflation?

likehelpful

Additional Posts in Job Searching in Accounting

Any Accounting firms that are still remote? Dreading busy season travel

like

Have others found it hard to transition from Audit to Financial Analyst? All the recruiters I’m meeting with are telling me I probably won’t get an interview since they’re looking for someone who’s ready to hit the ground running.
It’s discouraging because I’m a fast learner, and from talking to my friends who are Financial Analysts, it doesn’t seem like what we do is so dissimilar.

likesmart
likefunny

I currently work as a senior accountant in Nashville. Is it possible to go to public accounting?

likefunny