{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Hi, I recently received a job offer of 100k that said their base cap was 95k, should I or can I counteroffer, if so to what would be reasonable? And I've been interviewing with other companies as well and this company isn't my first choice. Can I accept/counter the offer as I see if the companies (of choice) will give me an offer?", "post_id": "61e441afc0a1a2002a61dfe2", "reply_count": 23, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "553769a790f5eebe1d2a0f92", "bowl_name": "Finance", "feed_type": "crowd" }

Hi, I recently received a job offer of 100k that said their base cap was 95k, should I or can I counteroffer, if so to what would be reasonable? And I've been interviewing with other companies as well and this company isn't my first choice. Can I accept/counter the offer as I see if the companies (of choice) will give me an offer?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

What I would do personally is counter offer. Ask for $125k, ask for a sign on bonus and request a hybrid work situation or completely remote if that’s what you’re looking for. Will this job require you to move to another city? Ask for moving assistance expenses to be covered for. Advocate for yourself and ask for more because you deserve it. If you don’t ask, you’ll never know. Never settle!

like

Hey not sure where you are interviewing. I’ve never heard such a low cap, especially in todays hyper inflationary environment. Please keep looking and don’t fall for this. You deserve better.

likefunny

Aim for 135k base at least

like

You can always counter offer. The question is always whether you are willing to walk away.

like

Would this be a step up in your current salary? If this is only a 5%-10% increase on your current salary and it's not your first choice and you would potentially get other offers definitely take some time to think about it. It's also harder in my opinion to negotiate salary once you have accepted the job and move within the company vs. when you are joining and new. Is this also a promotion or a lateral position move? Lastly what industry is this? Range varies across tech, CPG etc. so I would also think about that as well. 7-8 years is a good chunk of experience OP, so unless this offer is a good step up from your current employment I would take a step back.

like

Never thought about a sign on bonus! I'd have to read up on that. Thank you!

You also could ask for time to think about it but they could also walk away. Do you expect another offer in the next couple of days? I wouldn’t ask for more than a couple of days to think about it. If you could (and you think it may change), say that you need to talk it over with someone and you will let them know Tuesday (but only if you expect other offers by then). If you ask for too long they will think you are not serious and move on.

like

Ahh, thank you! I appreciate the advice

Why bother even countering unless you plan to accept? One advantage of reasonable counter is that they will take time to get approval which buys you time. Sometimes they will ask if you will accept if they come back with approval.

like

I would accept because the benefits and culture is good. They just weren't my first choice. A recruiter brought them up, and I thought, oh why not, let's try it out with an interview and it went better than expected.

like

What’s yours yoe?

like

7-8 years - Accounting/Finance of that 4 years is Financial Analyst

So what happened?

Yes! I completely agree. So weighing options to see what works. Thank you! :)

Related Posts

Interviewing at Twitch for a data scientist position, any insight into what types of questions they’ll have for the technical screen?

like

I have a PharmD, thinking about applying for consulting positions. What would the salary be of someone with pharmaceutical industry + clinical experience at Boston Consulting Group. I’m assuming I can start as consultant? If not, would it be possible to start as senior consultant?

like

I give up! After multiple attempts at applying for pharmaceutical companies.

Hey fishes, What's the ideal pay scale for business management analyst role in BIG 4. I had a interview call scheduled with @EY but they called at the last moment and cancelled the interview saying that they can't match the expected CTC. And can only provide CTC 12lkhs. My current CTC at HSBC is 14 lakhs for 3.9 yoe and i expected 17lkhs. Is my expected CTC above average? Deloitte KPMG EY

like

Applying for the greycroft associate role (consumer/ FinTech & InsurTech). Any application tips?

Hey Fishes, I have close to 2 yoe and currently switched to a company with 19L ctc. Now i got call from amzon for business analyst interview. So wanted views on this, is it worth giving interviews as i dont think they will offer similar or better package with this exp for BA role.. TIA😊😊

like

Know any interview coaches who can help me formulate answers for behavior interviews with tech companies? Last time the feedback was I didn’t use star format and answers were not aligned with the leadership principles so trying to make it right time this time. Please DM me if you know someone.

like

How do I get a job as an HR Generalist in a tech company? I’ve been applying for full remote jobs for tech companies but all I get is daily rejections emails. My current and past HR experience are in aerospace, restaurant group and mobile retailer. Is there anything I can change on my resume that lets them know I can transition well into the tech industry as an HR professional?

like

I am a recent undergrad graduate (engineering), have been working in consulting (ZS) for a couple of months, but would like to try my luck at MBB, specifically BCG. If I get a referral, how likely is it that I will get an interview? (Given that I have been in consulting for a couple of months and that I am not a student anymore that can recruit through campus)

like

How many interviews does Goldman Sachs take for Associate level in IB division? Also what is the average time (in weeks) between 1st interview and offer letter? JPMorgan ChaseMorgan StanleyGoldman Sachs

like

Is it true that if you're internal and you apply for a internal positions, They have to interview you?

like

This is a mini rant- 3 companies so far have given me glowing interview & resume feedback. I’ve been told I am the ideal candidate and I have “a tremendous edge over other candidates” But then, they turn around to try and lowball me and when I gently push back I get the “Unfortunately, we are going in another direction” email. I’m applying for software sales roles, shouldn’t you want me to push back on a shitty lowball offer? I guess the answer is yes - unless you’re a black woman

like

Who else gets mysterious extra interview rounds after doing well on one? Just a sanity check

like

Went in for a position at a top medical device company. During the interview my male interviewer asked if my “directness” comes off to strong to the doctors? He then asked the same question twice in two different ways. I asked if he meant “can I dim my light”. He said ya. I just said I know how to be strategic when it comes to my deliverance with whom I’m speaking to. I felt his question was misogynistic and quite condescending truly. I’m a woman in outside sales with a type A personality.

like

Got offer from IQVIA Bangalore. Grade 150. Is that a People Management role ? as in the interview they didn't clarify much. Currently I am a Team Lead. Have already accepted the offer and waiting for workday offer.

like

Hi All, Currently im working on cts having 1.8 years experience on etl production support. recently i have attended to one interview company name vodafone i have selected with 7 lpa in cts im getting 4.5. im confused to switch company or not im pretty new to the project in cts and i need to know this vodaphone they are mentioning like its vios(vodafone intelligent solutions). im not sure weather this is mnc or not. how was the job security. is it worthy to switch job. cts vs vodaphone?

Anyone got tips for interviewing for a Risk and Compliance role - Trust and Safety Google ? This is second stage interview. While I expect technical case study questions, I'd love to hear from someone with relevant/similar experiences. Thanks in advance.

like

Hi All, Have been reached out by a GS recruiter for Software Dev - SRE role.Any leads/help on the process and interviews would be appreciated.

Need help. Have an interview. What is a private equity analyst’s salary at BMO, Toronto?

like

Additional Posts

Hi all, I got an offer of ~19.5LPA fixed for a B7 role. YOE ~5. What would be the average hike and bonus payout at NatWest? How long would I've to wait for B7.2 and B8 promotion?

like

I work in clinical research and I’m under consideration to work for another research facility; however I hesitate because it’s a consulting position that can turn to permanent. It’s a huge pay increase (8-10 more) with benefits, PTO, etc. Any thoughts about consulting or temp-to-permanent jobs?

like

What happened to account folks supporting creatives? At this point they are all just another layer of clients. How can the industry get back to them supporting the work and stop being clients.

like

Same Boris. Same

Post Photo
funnylikeuplifting

Interviewing at Twitch for a data scientist position, any insight into what types of questions they’ll have for the technical screen?

like

PwC Toronto assurance: being offered a job as a transfer from the US. I’ll be transferring as a senior associate 1 (aka this is my promo year). I’ll be either tier 1 or 2 since I’m an easy promote here in New York. I was offered 61k CAD assuming I’m tier 3. They said they might adjust it if my rating comes in higher. What should I expect if I were either tier 1 or 2? Trying to minimize the salary reduction…

Curious -- were folks who were sponsored for business school by Booz or Monitor or Parthenon pre-acquisition still obligated to come back post-acquisition or were they allowed to leave without paying?

like

How much Barclays can offers to BA4 role in compliance domain if I have recently qualified with executive mba degree from IIM and have prior 3-4 years experience in the same domain .

So FAANG is now MAANG after Facebook got renamed to Meta ?🤨

likefunny

How much is your salary and position in Germany?

like

What are the nyc hours like for audit year round?

like

What’s the general comp for EM level at Strategy&? Assuming a Chicago or comparavle COL

like

I’m at the point that I start trembling every time I get an email alert. It’s the little things piling up that is getting to me. The to do list full of, “send emails to X about Y,” “follow-up re this,” “revise the 100 small things the baby lawyer drafted.” Tasks that might take 15 minutes to an hour individually, but all together it’s a lot. I’m the bottle neck. I’m the one who needs to move these things along. But there’s always something bigger and more urgent. Nothing’s ever FINISHED.

like

What platform is your school using for virtual learning?

like

There is almost nowhere to find reliable bonus information on Canadian firms. I’ve heard of year end bonuses ranging from 10-50% this year (not including Covid bonuses). Let’s start a thread posting year of call, rough billable hours worked and bonus as a percent of salary. 5 year call. 1850 hours. 10%.

Why do Minnesotans never leave Minnesota?

like

Recommendations for a Dallas weekend solo trip? Staying downtown with no car. Interested in touristy stuff, food, and nightlife

like

Jr. Art Directors or AD interns, my agency in New York is hiring a partner to work with me. Shoot me a PM with your book and I can give you more details.

like

anyone recommend any financial modeling courses < $5K that are universally recognized (I.e, training the street, Wall Street prep, etc). In a Strat & Ops role but looking to get Into M&A / CorpDev

like

Do we know if there is a sponsoring partner that oversees this benefit/ program that I could have more of a heart to heart conversation with? Not getting too far with the general email box and admin contact. From the benefit policy documentation, my understanding is that EY reimburses employees for surrogacy / adoption related expenses up to $50k lifetime. However, anything related to IVF or medical procedures has to go through insurance (also limited to $50k lifetime benefit). Continued…

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal