{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Hi, I recently received a job offer of 100k that said their base cap was 95k, should I or can I counteroffer, if so to what would be reasonable? And I've been interviewing with other companies as well and this company isn't my first choice. Can I accept/counter the offer as I see if the companies (of choice) will give me an offer?", "post_id": "61e441afc0a1a2002a61dfe2", "reply_count": 23, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "553769a790f5eebe1d2a0f92", "bowl_name": "Finance", "feed_type": "crowd" }

Hi, I recently received a job offer of 100k that said their base cap was 95k, should I or can I counteroffer, if so to what would be reasonable? And I've been interviewing with other companies as well and this company isn't my first choice. Can I accept/counter the offer as I see if the companies (of choice) will give me an offer?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

What I would do personally is counter offer. Ask for $125k, ask for a sign on bonus and request a hybrid work situation or completely remote if that’s what you’re looking for. Will this job require you to move to another city? Ask for moving assistance expenses to be covered for. Advocate for yourself and ask for more because you deserve it. If you don’t ask, you’ll never know. Never settle!

like

Hey not sure where you are interviewing. I’ve never heard such a low cap, especially in todays hyper inflationary environment. Please keep looking and don’t fall for this. You deserve better.

likefunny

Aim for 135k base at least

like

You can always counter offer. The question is always whether you are willing to walk away.

like

Would this be a step up in your current salary? If this is only a 5%-10% increase on your current salary and it's not your first choice and you would potentially get other offers definitely take some time to think about it. It's also harder in my opinion to negotiate salary once you have accepted the job and move within the company vs. when you are joining and new. Is this also a promotion or a lateral position move? Lastly what industry is this? Range varies across tech, CPG etc. so I would also think about that as well. 7-8 years is a good chunk of experience OP, so unless this offer is a good step up from your current employment I would take a step back.

like

Never thought about a sign on bonus! I'd have to read up on that. Thank you!

You also could ask for time to think about it but they could also walk away. Do you expect another offer in the next couple of days? I wouldn’t ask for more than a couple of days to think about it. If you could (and you think it may change), say that you need to talk it over with someone and you will let them know Tuesday (but only if you expect other offers by then). If you ask for too long they will think you are not serious and move on.

like

Ahh, thank you! I appreciate the advice

Why bother even countering unless you plan to accept? One advantage of reasonable counter is that they will take time to get approval which buys you time. Sometimes they will ask if you will accept if they come back with approval.

like

I would accept because the benefits and culture is good. They just weren't my first choice. A recruiter brought them up, and I thought, oh why not, let's try it out with an interview and it went better than expected.

like

What’s yours yoe?

like

7-8 years - Accounting/Finance of that 4 years is Financial Analyst

So what happened?

Yes! I completely agree. So weighing options to see what works. Thank you! :)

Related Posts

Any tips on interviews with PwC Deals? Transferring internally (xLoS).

like

Where are you applying for business school?

like

When you have interviews and ask one question and get a 15 minute response out of a 30 minutes time... 😓

like

B School question: Been at a Big 4 in tech consulting for 2.5 years. Promoted to level 9. Applying F2016. Better to stay at 1 firm all 4 years before school or switch jobs and excel at a new company?

like

Anyone know anything about McKinsey Implementation? Applying for a role with them and wanting to learn more than what's on the website.

like

What do you guys do when interviewing for a new job on a Friday? Tell the team you have an appointment or just hope they don't notice you're offline for 6 hours?

like

IBM Business Consulting for Insurance - any insights? Have rounds of interviews coming up.

How would one score an interview at McKinsey from a bit four firm? Background: regulatory experience

like

Do you wear your wedding/engagement rings to interviews? (Rings have connotations for both genders...)

like

Applying for India Business visa is a very frustrating process....😖😖

like

Realizing you have zero skills and no experience when applying for other jobs... Are there any jobs out there in PowerPoint design?!

like

How would I go about applying to other consulting firms? I'd imagine randomly applying online won't end up successful

like

If Donald Trump had an interview at Accenture .... He'd fail

like

Deloitte and EY, what are your benefits like? I currently get 5 weeks PTO and 100% match up to 6% 401K. I want to start applying elsewhere since I'm underpaid but base salary isn't everything

like

I hate the fact that I have to sit there until 1:30 am doing nothing just because my senior was procrastinating all day long. 6 hours spent applying for a new job! #priorities

like

Have people applied/are applying to grad schools? When would it be the best time to apply and how's the process?

like

Interview tomorrow. Does anyone have any go-to interview questions that potential employers like to be asked?

like

Recruiter just pinged me from Parthenon (EY acquisition) with an interview offer anyone heard anything about them? I'm a BA at Deloitte right now.

like

How important a factor is GMAT score when applying to work at MBB?

Interviews all day tomorrow. I believe hungover is the best way to demonstrate my consulting acumen.

like

Additional Posts

Can someone plz plz help me to join Amazon for fraud investigation team or legal compliance team. I looking since long back and tried to apply through career portal also but didn't get any update. Thanks in advance. Plz do help me.

like

Saw a post earlier about “Hearing about PwC and their PIPs”, Can someone elaborate? Curious of what’s going on haha

like

To keep this bowl productive, please post your questions here, PE is a small industry (by head count) in India, we’ll try to answer your queries at the earliest.

like
Post Gif

Hey.How much CTC should i quote to genpact for business analysis skill, YOE 8.1, reporting analytics, current offer 24CTC, lwd march 1st

like

Can anyone tell me who has done the 3 month business analytics course from ISB? Is it worth the time and money? Thanks in advance

like

How is PWC SAP practice in US compared to EY and KPMG?

likesmart

Burning out a bit. Wishing I had someone to talk to. Honestly, I’d love to just grab a drink with someone and smile.

likehelpful

Plans for collective disconnect Deloitte fishes? I have a long list of shows to watch and few short trips culminating in celebrating new Year in Gokarna . How abt you ?

like

I just wanted to reach out and let you all know I understand how tired and beat down we all feel at this point in the year. I’m feeling it too. I also know exactly how students can try us. What I’m working on every day though is to see my kids as God does… not the kids that know how to push buttons and drive me crazy, but as the beautiful lives they are, all deserving of the best we can give them every day. I know it’s not easy, but that’s what I’m working on.

like

Anyone working in Google as a Salesforce Application Engineer? Or Anyone happen to know how to get shortlisted/preparation strategy/ certifications needed etc etc.

like

Which big4 has the most good looking crowd in India. I have come across PwC Gurgaon crowd in elevator and couldnt take my eyes off😂😂

funnylike

Does anyone know the difference between an associate manager vs supervisor of clinical health services at CVS/Aetna?

like

The Macron campaign hack feels eerily familiar....

like

Looking to sell a barely used Concept 2 Model D rower......I live in the smyrna vinings area.....anyone interested please DM me.

like

I have completed interview & HR Round from the TCS, Even i agreed with the package negotiations. I am waiting since 1 week, i haven't received offer letter till now. Are there any chances of getting rejected after good HR round?

My husband is on H4 visa, and I can't see him just watch movies, play games, eat and waste time while I work and earn. I know h1b window is gone and h4 ead will take at least another year. Has anyone tried getting a job through a CAP-EXEMPT H1B, basically at a non-profit / university. Really want to know how this works and if anyone can guide me here. TIA.

funnylike

What did 50 cent do when he is hungry ?

What are your best hacks when it comes to improving productivity?

like

Any dry cleaners that can iron just the T zone in my shirts (collar and middle line where the buttons are)? Ill keep my suit jacket on and save tons on laundry!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal