{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Hi, I recently received a job offer of 100k that said their base cap was 95k, should I or can I counteroffer, if so to what would be reasonable? And I've been interviewing with other companies as well and this company isn't my first choice. Can I accept/counter the offer as I see if the companies (of choice) will give me an offer?", "post_id": "61e441afc0a1a2002a61dfe2", "reply_count": 23, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "553769a790f5eebe1d2a0f92", "bowl_name": "Finance", "feed_type": "crowd" }

Hi, I recently received a job offer of 100k that said their base cap was 95k, should I or can I counteroffer, if so to what would be reasonable? And I've been interviewing with other companies as well and this company isn't my first choice. Can I accept/counter the offer as I see if the companies (of choice) will give me an offer?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

What I would do personally is counter offer. Ask for $125k, ask for a sign on bonus and request a hybrid work situation or completely remote if that’s what you’re looking for. Will this job require you to move to another city? Ask for moving assistance expenses to be covered for. Advocate for yourself and ask for more because you deserve it. If you don’t ask, you’ll never know. Never settle!

like

Hey not sure where you are interviewing. I’ve never heard such a low cap, especially in todays hyper inflationary environment. Please keep looking and don’t fall for this. You deserve better.

likefunny

Aim for 135k base at least

like

You can always counter offer. The question is always whether you are willing to walk away.

like

Would this be a step up in your current salary? If this is only a 5%-10% increase on your current salary and it's not your first choice and you would potentially get other offers definitely take some time to think about it. It's also harder in my opinion to negotiate salary once you have accepted the job and move within the company vs. when you are joining and new. Is this also a promotion or a lateral position move? Lastly what industry is this? Range varies across tech, CPG etc. so I would also think about that as well. 7-8 years is a good chunk of experience OP, so unless this offer is a good step up from your current employment I would take a step back.

like

Never thought about a sign on bonus! I'd have to read up on that. Thank you!

You also could ask for time to think about it but they could also walk away. Do you expect another offer in the next couple of days? I wouldn’t ask for more than a couple of days to think about it. If you could (and you think it may change), say that you need to talk it over with someone and you will let them know Tuesday (but only if you expect other offers by then). If you ask for too long they will think you are not serious and move on.

like

Ahh, thank you! I appreciate the advice

Why bother even countering unless you plan to accept? One advantage of reasonable counter is that they will take time to get approval which buys you time. Sometimes they will ask if you will accept if they come back with approval.

like

I would accept because the benefits and culture is good. They just weren't my first choice. A recruiter brought them up, and I thought, oh why not, let's try it out with an interview and it went better than expected.

like

What’s yours yoe?

like

7-8 years - Accounting/Finance of that 4 years is Financial Analyst

So what happened?

Yes! I completely agree. So weighing options to see what works. Thank you! :)

Related Posts

I have interview scheduled for Business Analyst in Udaan. Can anyone give me some idea on what I should prepared for in first and second rounds?

like

Hey, did anybody here get that CD/CW job at that upstate NY agency? They interviewed a bunch of folks about a year ago. Anybody get hired? Finger Lakes region is all I remember about the agency.

like

Please shoot me a message if you are interested in case study interview partner!

like

Anyone from Gartner can provide the interview process? I’ve had interviews, in the following order, recruiter, team panel, and hiring manager. Everything has been promising and I’m feeling confident about it so far( at least from my perspective). It’s been a little over a week since the interview with hiring manager and last communication with recruiter. My anxiety is high not knowing who what to expect next.

like

Are there any Assisted Living RESIDENT CARE DIRECTORS here? If so, do you mind sharing what your yearly income is and what the challenges are for you in this position? I have an interview for this type of position and would like your input… Thanks in advance…💕

like

I’m an audit senior right now, and am looking at other opportunities. One of the companies I’m most interested in is actually my client that I’m on year round. Does anyone have any experience interviewing at their client? I believe i’d have to be pulled off the team during the interview process, which seems like a huge headache... I also don’t want to burn bridges or put myself at risk for a lay-off if they know I’m looking. Anyone have experience with this? TIA!

like

Senior associate on the Pl side doing complex lit. I got an offer from a major defense side firm in NYC… that fell through because of conflicts. Finding it difficult to get any interviews at this point. Was the prior offer a fluke or have you seen any senior associates successfully hop then V?

likesmart

How would y’all approach applying to an agency’s “General Application” posting (ie. the role isn’t named, you’re just submitting your resume)? Any successes? Strategies? Should I cold email the recruiter/HR person in addition?

like

Hey all, I’m at B-school and trying to make a decision. My goal is MBB, unfortunately struck out after receiving 3 interviews for internship. I did however land Kearney. Need to decide if I should accept or recruit outside consulting. My plan is to rerecruit in the fall regardless. My issue point is that I’m sponsored by Deloitte and accepting will invalidate my sponsorship. Is Kearney that much better than Deloitte where it’s worth it? Or should I try a new industry

like

Let's say you were dinged without interview in R1 but improved your test score significantly. Anyone have any idea if they may reconsider you for R1 if you sent the new test scores in?

like
like

Does anyone still go in person to drop off resumes and apply for jobs? Since we now live in a digital era, do you believe it is still effective or should we just stick to applying online?

likesmart

I had an interview with one company and worked with a recruiter to get it. The interview went well and I got good feedback from the interviewer. I was told by my recruiter I’d get 1 more interview and to be on the look out. A little more than a week had passed and I heard nothing, even with a follow-up email. Is it bad practice to reach out directly to the person at the company who scheduled the interview, as opposed to waiting on the recruiter to get back?

like

Just got Booth interview invite!!!

like

Interviewed at Credit Suisse on the 8th for an operations position. Had two interviews both went phenomenal. Checking interview status and it says “interview” rather than in the past I’ve had “further evaluation” so trying to find out what this means. I understand this might be self explanatory to some people … but could anyone break down what this means as an external job applicant ?

like

Is anyone attended Amazon QAE interview ?

like

Any AWS TPMs that can shed some light on interview process? I have my first round of phone interview in a few days and would love to hear some tips, questions, experiences.. thanks in advance!

like

Country wide, everybody in my company is applying to the same bschool. Essentially same competitive pool. This will be fun.

like

Hi Whales, My profile got shortlisted for Application Engineer 3 role at Amazon. Looking forward for any advice / tips for the interviews and anything I should prepare in particular. I will be having 4 rounds of interviews. Also, what should I expect in terms of compensation and what should be a reasonable number to start with? Kindly advise. YOE - 2 Years CTC - 8 LPA Amazon Amazon India

like

If you don’t hear back from an internal recruiter for over a week past an interview, are you ghosted?

like

Additional Posts

Maybe we should implement something like automatic posts refresh? I got a notification about "someone like mypost" but it isn't displaying at the post title...

like

Ahh it is posting but into middle of feed as opposed to top.

like

Beyond 2 lines the text in each post card is cut off. I wonder how many lines in the comment section?

like

Post for comments

like

Top top post!

like

How much does everyone have in 401k/retirement accounts and savings? Please state your age! I’m trying to figure out how behind I am

like

What's the most absurd thing an analyst has done on your teams? Looking for some laughs.

like

I am anxious all the time.

like

Country wide, everybody in my company is applying to the same bschool. Essentially same competitive pool. This will be fun.

like

Flight from Santiago to São Paulo - I have never seen people struggle so much with overhead luggage. We are departing late because they can’t figure it out :)

like

Connected with and reached out to a recruiter via LinkedIn. Stupid me later noticed they have their email listed on their profile. Should I wait and email so I don’t appear annoying or go for it?

like

What is the salary for managers in Hong Kong and Singapore

like

How to keep a marriage (with kids) sustainable with a job like this? (would appreciate honest advice, no jokes)

likehelpful

Just sent an email to c. 70 people on a global project, and getting a wave of OOO messages back. Soon I’ll be able to say « Piss off I’m on holiday » in every language on Earth 🌍

likefunny

How much does everyone give their doormen/women as a Christmas bonus?

like

What is your biggest career achievement to date?

like

How to lose 15lbs in 3 weeks? Can it be done?? Currently 193...anyone got tips/tricks? Lol

likehelpfulfunny

new mgr (with whom I have not connected well with since she took over a month ago) just gave me grief about being away from my computer for 2.5 hours Friday. No mention of the 15 hr days M-Th though

like

Dumb question — has anyone ever cried in front of their boss (very strategically) because there would be potential to negotiate something you want?

funnylikesmart

Senior Managers at Deloitte are some of the most disrespectful human beings.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal