{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Hi 🐠 two offers — would love to hear any insight:\nOffer 1: Walmart senior product manager: $200K base; $50k bonus, $40k stock vesting 4 years, $40k stock each year (vesting 4 years), $20k signing. TC YR1= $280k Offer 2: pre-ipo start up product manager, $145k base, $55k bonus, $40k shares, $15k signing. TC YR1=$225K. Work at startup is more interesting and greater WLB but not sure if the $$ makes it worth it. Thanks!", "post_id": "60e86b4fae5170001dc52c44", "reply_count": 31, "vote_count": 4, "bowl_id": "5ae4a4f739e7cb001391ec8b", "bowl_name": "Consulting Exit Opportunities" }

Hi 🐠 two offers — would love to hear any insight: Offer 1: Walmart senior product manager: $200K base; $50k bonus, $40k stock vesting 4 years, $40k stock each year (vesting 4 years), $20k signing. TC YR1= $280k Offer 2: pre-ipo start up product manager, $145k base, $55k bonus, $40k shares, $15k signing. TC YR1=$225K. Work at startup is more interesting and greater WLB but not sure if the $$ makes it worth it. Thanks!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Depends on your goals and background in Product. I noticed Wal-Mart is bringing you in as a senior. Do you have previous product experience? Depending on the structure of the team, that may be more or less challenging If you do have Product experience, was it at a large company like Wal-Mart or in a smaller environment? This could make your work load as well as likeliness to ship and time to ship a product very different

Hard to say without knowing series of the startup but if you think it has real potential I think the startup could give you more learning opportunity and ability to leverage for future roles (Walmart product isn’t the most highly regarded). However if you’re unsure about the success of the startup, I’d go Walmart.

Recent IconRecent

More WLB at a start-up? Doubtful.

likesmart

Did I say I was responding to a question you asked?

Would you mind sharing your YOE?

like

4 years total and you have been offered a 200k job at walmart? That’s pretty amazing

Wal-Mart.

like

How did you land a pm gig?

like

Implementing a product essentially and everything that comes with it.

like

Options at startup are pretty low. What Series are they?

What’s the location for Walmart? Bentonville or can you be wherever?

Until I quit

like

Good ol' Wally World.

I would recommend pre ipo start up if you think they are good at what the do. You will make more money down the line if they go public

Option 1 looks better

Is it Jet or Walmart?

Do you havr to move to arkansas?

No

Location?

Related Posts

Two job offers, one has a TC of 130 and one has a total comp of 154. The lower TC comes with RSUs that are hard to value as the company is not yet public. Both jobs would have similar enjoyment levels, which would you take?

like

Hi can anyone share insight into Bain’s M1 salary, bonus, and profit sharing? In early talks for a potential lateral -1 YOE move. Chicago office in case that matters.

like

Does Citi really go after your sign on bonus after you quit? Pre tax and pro-rated or pre tax full amount regardless?

like

Does anyone know how much of your check gets “comp’d” when your PTO balance is finito?

like

HELP NEEDED: Just got offer for Deloitte HC as SC. I'm from a target MBA with a little over a year in consulting. What's the comp of a second year SC? Want to benchmark offer

like

Have an offer in hand with 50% hike, non big4. KPMG is willing to retain me at 30% hike and I want to stay with KPMG. If I accept this 30% hike will I be eligible for bonus and increment which is rolled out in Oct (Start of new cycle)? Also pls share your exp. post you accepted a counter offer from yr current firm, were there any issues involved?

like

Interested in hearing more about the strategy work at Deloitte, re- culture, work, and compensation from a POC POV. Heard a couple folks say Deloitte is the way to go, but would like more info. Thanks

like

First year big 4 MD here with a question... ...if you beat your metrics by say double or triple or more, is it true that bonus hits a diminishing return and incremental sales or managed revenue don’t really impact VC?

like

What were the performance bonus %s of salary for SA1s across tiers this past year?

like

Looks like the practice is selling lots of projects nowadays. Do you think they will make bonus decent to keep people?

like

Just found out I'm getting a 4 and promotion to Senior for advisory. What kind of raise / promo bonus can I expect % wise?

like

Hi folks, Recently received an offer of 7 CTC from LTI in grade P1(not sure what it is), in RPB BU(Repurpose Bench). Wanted to know more about this business unit. Also how much is the deduction and in hand salary

like

Frequent travelers: I got 6k miles from AA as automatic compensation for a 6.5 hr delay, JFK>CDG. Genuinely have no idea whether that’s good or if I should ask for more. Thoughts?

like

What is the typical TC and signing bonus for principal at BCG PIPE / AP at Bain PEG?

like

Does anyone have ballpark idea of salary for a Deloitte Boomerang Manager who had strong performance in prior tenure (2s at YE, every year)?

like

I’ve been through 5+ weeks of interviews with a company that will IPO next year and they did a bait and switch on me with the offer: it was advertised as “Head of” and then during the offer-walk-through-meeting today they said “oh btw we changed the title to ‘Senior Manager’ for this role”. They offered me a salary I made 4 years ago as a manager. They offered stock options with an exercise price TBD 1 year from now…which is when they’re hitting IPO. Is that normal for stock options?

like

MBB salary broken down by level or year into the job from undergraduate please?

likefunny

Normal base/bonus salary range for Healthcare Manager at PwC?

like

Anyone familiar with Coinbase’s comp amounts / structure for non-technical people?

like

Additional Posts

Moms out there wfh with a nanny that have an infant any suggestions for them to keep entertained? Mine is 10 months and I need some ideas for sensory play or just new fun activities for them

like

While switching companies, can we get the H1B visa transfer approved and still work for the old company for 2 months?

like

Two job offers, one has a TC of 130 and one has a total comp of 154. The lower TC comes with RSUs that are hard to value as the company is not yet public. Both jobs would have similar enjoyment levels, which would you take?

like

Anyone left for / looking at leaving for work in public health / health equity?

like

Has anyone been offered a status buy-up for 2021. ~$1700 short of United 1k this year and think my travel will increase a good bit starting next year. Think it could make sense, especially given the 2021 thresholds

like

Hi can anyone share insight into Bain’s M1 salary, bonus, and profit sharing? In early talks for a potential lateral -1 YOE move. Chicago office in case that matters.

like

All, We have opening for Automation tester, Java full stack with springboot, react js. 4 to 8 years. Early joiners preferred. Project Location : pune but location is not constraint DM me if it's matching and willing to join TCS. Don't ping me if incase you just want one more offer for negotiate. Thanks

like

How do you think our industry as individuals or agencies can work to help those who are most impacted by the virus and its consequences? Not all of us can work from home :(

like

Any tips when preparing for CSCP?

like

Would you rather have 3 Chase UR points or 6 Marriott Bonvoy points?

Thoughts on an exit to MaRS?

like

Boutique looking for referral to MBB/T2 (Australia) happy to discuss background and even just thoughts on profile. Just under 4 yoe, looking for better opps to work with industrials, energy and fin/pe

like

I have a case study for a direct lending role coming up. Does anyone have any insight on what direct lending cases are like?

like

Anyone want to refer me for an FDD position? Currently an A2 with the CPA exam done.

like

Maybe a long shot, but anyone know of any Epic projects or customers hiring now/soon? My client ran out of money and isn’t renewing any consultants.

like

For folks who have 360, CK, or GS, what was your EQD and EQM?

like

Anyone work in the KPMG Miami office? If so, what's the culture like?

like

TFW you wake up, see no work emails, and immediately convince yourself you're about to get fired.

like

16 weeks and so worried all of the stress I’m under is going to hurt the baby. Between work, my own scary (non-pregnancy) health stuff, the pandemic, my mom (who is a widow and lives alone, basically isolated by choice due to covid) is having health issues, and pressures to keep billable hours up, I’ve been having complete breakdowns. Today I spent almost the entire day crying and now have to make up the billable time this weekend. I really worry abt what effect this will have on the babe.

like

In a nutshell what exactly is MBB looking for when they say “fit with their culture”

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal