Atheists in Consulting

How do atheists feel about the universe coming to being out of nothing? How does 0+0=1?

funny
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon
works at

So my humble opinion is that we simply don’t know. I’m also ready to accept that my known concepts of space and time may not be meaningful when answering that question. For example, I’m ready to accept that there is no “before” the start of the universe, and that time started with the Big Bang. It’s frustrating not being able to comprehend that. I’m also ready to accept that there the Universe was a quantum event, and came into being just because. When matter and anti-matter collide, they can cancel each other out. I’m ready to believe the reverse might be possible. What I do need to see though, in every single case, is evidence. What I can’t believe is the concept of a God....

Reaction Icon Like
like
Arrow Icon

How do the religious feel about God coming to being out of nothing? How does 0+0=1?

Reaction Icon Like
like
Arrow Icon

Sounds good! Personal message me or type here if you get some time to explain.

Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

I'm comfortable with "I don't know." I don't need a god of the gaps. a gap, BTW, that does indeed get smaller and smaller every day as we endeavor to learn more because some people aren't satisfied with, "... because God ...". I'm still okay if it doesn't totally close. I'll never fill it in with magic.

Reaction Icon Like
like
Arrow Icon

I love this debate - entirely what was missing from the forum (or you get caught up with the hysteria of religion)... Look, I don’t say you’re wrong - because I don’t know and I wouldn’t presume to know. And that is the thing - until we know, philosophical arguments can only get you so far. Religion once stated that thunderstorms were messages from God, now we know about weather patterns. Religion once said the earth was the center of the universe, now we know about heliocentricity. Religion once said that illness was linked to sin, now we have microbial theory. So, as science progresses, I think the religious ground decreases. I think it will only be a matter of time before we can give a definitive answer to the origin of the Universe. I just hope it’s in my lifetime:)

Reaction Icon Like
like
Arrow Icon

This is the classical Cosmological argument - I’ve seen William Lane Craig make it a number of times and it’s also prominent in his book “Reasonable Faith”. It’s easily refutable - primarily by knowledge of physics - quantum events don’t need a cause, they just happen (one of a few reasons). When you say “this thing that pushed” it assumes things without any justification... I get the philosophical side of “everything that exists must have had a cause” but we know now that (and again it’s not natural to understand this) that this isn’t true!

Reaction Icon Like
like
Arrow Icon

I don’t think that line of reasoning works. You are making the “nothing fallacy” that Lawrence Krauss has been accused of, where you define nothing as something other than it is. Nothing is nothing and nothing more. If you bring in quantum physics, you are bringing in “something.” So when you say quantum events don’t need a cause (which is only true about some levels of quantum physics), you are talking about quantum physics AFTER it existed already.

Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

So if we look at the beginning of the universe we find that space-time and matter have a beginning at a single point, and all in the same moment. The question is, what caused space-time and matter to come into existence? I think this is where the two answers above come in - “I don’t know.” And they’re right to an extent. We can’t know what they are, BUT we can know what they are not. Namely, “space-time and matter.” Otherwise we are saying space created space, matter created matter, and time created time. But of course that’s nonsense. But if whatever this thing is that pushed space-time and matter into existence cannot be “time”, that means it’s “timeless” (eternal), and if it’s not “space” then it’s space-less (infinite), and if it’s not “matter” then it’s immaterial (???), which are three words to describe the, frankly, supernatural. Food for thought.

Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

if laughter makes me childish I'll stay a child forever. I laugh at what I find amusing. I guess you missed the part where I said, "okay seriously"? I said I don't know and a will not make up stuff without evidence. what you described is not a logical fallacy. look those up. what you described is a logical inconsistency. you had no logic, you had leaps of logic. time to timeless ... and eternal? please. no one is actually saying the universe sprung from nothing except theists that want to try to have this debate by talking about something coming from nothing and use it as some way to prove their point yes I've had this debate before. I'll admit I haven't heard your woowoo before, but it sounds a lot like Depak Chopra's word salad. I'm not the one who was talking about time and no time, that was your assertion and I don't have to reconcile it. when push comes two shove you are trying to use logic to prove something with no evidence. logic is the first place to start to form a hypothesis. but then you need evidence otherwise it's just so much talking proving nothing.

Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

It’s not exactly 0+0=1. According to second law of thermodynamics the entropy of a closed system will keep increasing over time. Big bang is a misnomer that gives the impression that there was an explosion from which time and space came out and before that nothing. However, since the space is ever expanding it must have started from a minuscule point. However, this is where we lose track and physics fails. That doesn’t mean it came out of nothing. Also, I am comfortable not knowing the answer and would rather wait and hope that I have some answers in my life.

Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

OP, since you’re looking to discuss based on definitions, laws of physics, and logical theories, can I ask what your definition of “god” is?

Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

great appeal to authority. what is his evidence for such fact? fact is we don't know and we have limited evidence from which to form a hypothesis. we have no evidence or reason to suspect what came before our observable universe was anything remotely sentient. we are then still left with the question of it's origin. we are still left with the question what do you mean by supernatural? that word alone has the premise that there is natural vs supernatural as if there is some binary choice that must be made when classifying the things we observe. if we see it, feel it, measure it, or by any other means confirm a thing, is it not then natural? is something supernatural if we cannot confirm its existence?

Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Related Posts

Any good certifications I should be working on now that things have slowed down? Google? Amazon? Trade desk? Excel focused? Really anything

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Anyone interested in an outstanding cleaning lady? Mine has been working for me for 8 yrs. High work ethics, trustworthy ( she comes to my place when I’m gone). Fluent in English.

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

I really need referrals and job leads. I worked in Project Management for L&D. Really missing my job. Id be so thankful!

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Navigant (Now Guidehouse (Formerly PwC Public Sector))

likefunny
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Advisable to invest in properties (land, apartments, etc) in India, given the political tensions?

likehelpful
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Relatively new to the firm, what’s the maximum PTO one can accrue in TOL?

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Whenever I press Enable Content, Excel crashes (and does an infinite loop). I can’t seem to break link the cell that is supposedly linked to an external source. Anyone know how to solve this?

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

American-raised Indian M here, but have always dated outside my race. Can’t tell if it’s truly preference, or if I am subliminally telling myself to avoiding dating my own people 🤔

likefunny
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

F. 29YO. Trying to decide if I should get a car or a house first. I feel like if I get a car, it will put me in more debt (with a carnote) and then I have to start over with saving for a downpayment on a house. Thoughts on which is the better investment?

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Anyone know if Strategy practice is hiring? Trying to make a switch from my current practice. Have already practiced case interviews

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

This doesn't get enough play, but law firm structure is so much better than corporate structure. It's not full employee ownership, but better than external shareholders

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Who is shut down? What is your district doing? I would rather go into the summer than lose 5 weeks.

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Bonus and promotion season is cancelled. (UK) D cutting partner salaries by 25% to try and retain jobs

Post Photo
like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

So my dad is out of a job any may run out of money in few months. Anyone have any good approaches to this situation with parents / tactful way of helping them?

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

(24M) Help on finding a career path ? I graduated from Boston University with a degree in comm w/ a concentration in advertising. Ive been in the industry for almost a year as a media planner, and have generally enjoyed it. My biggest issue though is the money. I didn’t go into the field expecting to get rich, but it would be nice to not live in poverty...Im considering going back to school to get an MBA in marketing as I feel this will complement my work experience and UG degree. (cont.)

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

I messed up at work today and just generally having a crappy time due to working remotely. I’m working Asia hours while being in the US. One of my teammate constantly interrupts me and is slightly condescending during our meetings, even with the client. It doesn’t help that I’m living up to the Asian stereotype and has a softer voice. While I’m happy/grateful I have a job, I would like some advice and support in dealing with this project as I’m literally counting the days until I can roll off.

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

The college affordability crisis is almost entirely driven by schools and pop culture creating the desire for kids to live on campus and have a “college experience”. Most of the costs have nothing...

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

For take out (you drive to the restaurant and pick up), if you tip the restaurant, what service are you tipping? For picking up the phone & packaging?

funny
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

One of the most frustrating things is having the partner “de-prioritize” your deal. They stop responding to questions, take forever to review things you’ve sent them and act annoyed when you try to follow-up. Does anyone else experience this?

like
Reaction Icon Like
Arrow Icon

Download the Fishbowl app

That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what’s it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Sign in here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview