How do you combat or call out racism when it comes from your professional superior? Yesterday a JUDGE made a racially charged comment after argument about a certain ethnicity and college admissions.

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’m not a litigator so don’t have an answer for you, OP. I wish I did. Can you speak to a more seasoned litigator in your firm?

To the other posters: why does the comment and context matter? Are there contexts in which it is ok to make racist comments from the bench? I hope not. Do you think your judgment of whether this was racist is better than the person who heard it? Is it relevant whether it was part of the official proceeding vs after one hearing ended and another began?

OP’s statement on its face seems to me to call out the kind of structural racism we are all concerned about. Assume it was the worst racist comment you can imagine - what does OP do?

like

Thank you Partner 1- I’ve posted the comment below. Your assessment is spot on though; I am asking for help based on the litigation associate/ judge dynamic, not an assessment of whether what was said is actionable. Posters would learn well to follow your lead.

Have to hear the comment and the context

like

Let’s hear the comment.

like

Let’s hear the context of the comment.

like

I think your approach depends on the judge. Is this a judge you know well? Is it a judge who simply needs to be educated, who may not realize that the comment is racist? Is the judge open to being educated? If yes, I would privately let the judge know. If not, is there a more senior person in your firm who could have the conversation? If the judge is truly a lost cause perhaps have a conversation with the chief judge in that district.

like

Thank you for this thoughtful advice. This is a very old judge who is likely not open to be educated. I do not have a personal relationship with him.

To all who asked, the judge was making small talk with an attorney in the room about the college program his son was admitted to. He referenced a specific school and said:

“My son wasn’t accepted to {college program} because everyone they let in is {ethnicity}. They’ll apparently let anyone in who’s {ethnicity}.”

Everyone in the courtroom, judge included, was white. In the elevator afterward, opposing counsel told me how aghast he was as well.

Related Posts

like

Partners- looking for advice, or maybe just perspective. I still have trouble letting go of the details and taking personal accountability for things that are probably “minutia”. This ranges from...

like

Are project managers directly hired for a project? Or they have also to find projects and give client interviews to get one??

like

Hola friends! Help our friends in India or any other country's friends to get a job in Singapore.

like

Any commercial strategy folks on here?

like

Hey SF @salesforce folks 👋 wondering if anyone can weigh in on an offer I received for Bay Area and whether I can/should push for more. Role is senior manager in biz ops/strategy. 190k base, $65k RSUs over 4 years, bonus non-negotiable at 15% and no sign-on bonus. Thanks in advance!

like

I’m really struggling mentally. The understanding of how insanely busy and overwhelming it will be because of this COVID-19 crap is giving me severe anxiety and panic attacks. I want to leave so badly but no one is hiring right now. I don’t know what to do. I feel trapped with no way out.

like

Hello 🐟,
Does Infosys Bangalore have transport facilities? What is the general timing they will provide transport facilities, TIA

like

Virtual graduation for our med students...poor guys. We'll celebrate on the other side of all this!

like

So I had a first interview this past Friday at a company that I had previously interviewed with and made it to the final round last month. They decided to go with an internal candidate after it came down to me and him. The current role is more senior, and was one I was asked to apply for by the hiring manager, whom I also met with during the last set of interviews. I emailed the recruiter to f/u on Friday and still have not gotten a reply. Should I be concerned?

like

Hi Fishes,
Please suggest on
Mastercard vs TSYS pune
Skill: Java Developer

like

I’m new on a beat. What are your top tips for sourcing in a predominantly virtual environment?

like

What’s the corporate way to tell a guy to “figure it out yourself, I’m not your personal Google” 🙄 this AD keeps asking me questions that are literally his job to figure out. My recent fav was him asking if I can summarize my copy for him so he can find an image. READ IT YOURSELF. THATS YOUR LITERAL JOB SIR.

likefunny

What’s the best or worst place to work in Portland right now?

like

Hi fishes,

Recently I got an offer from Cognizant with a CTC of 11lpa..Can I ask the recruiter to make it 12lpa now without another offer in hand?

Thanks in advance

like

What’s better, working for an M&A advisory group or doing M&A transactions in banking? I honestly have no idea what the key differences are.

like

Anyone with leads / opportunities at your respective companies in Digital Marketing? 8+ years experience here across various aspects of digital (content, seo, ppc, automation: salesforce pardot, marketo, etc) Currently a manager at an Agency in BC, Canada. Looking for a consulting / agency kind of role!! Appreciate any help! Much thanks!!

like

What's the next disruptive technology? (Not blockchain...)

likesmart

Any idea about how the work culture etc is at the Herjavec group

like

Barclay's providing Free Food ??

I heard from my friend they are providing in Noida.

Is it applicable for chennai !!!

like

Additional Posts in Law

2nd year associate working in employment law at a big firm. I think I might want to make a move into HR eventually. Has anyone done this? Is it tough to find job opportunities? How much firm experience should I get first?

like

After you’ve pulled an all-nighter, how do you get through the next day? Caffeine? Exercise? Take a nap? Quit early?

like

Looking to make a move. Working with two different recruiters (I reached out to 1, the other reached out to me). Each ask what else I have in the pipeline? Do I tell them abt other firms Ive met with?

like

If you could do a regular job outside of the law what would you do?

like

What unexpected specialities have you all picked up along the way as a junior? Somehow I became the go-to guy on tax assessment appeals because the other guy went in-house.

like

Which books would you recommend to a product counel for tech startup about strategy, management, and leadership?

like

I’ve gotten great reviews and great work from my firm. One partner I just hate working for, though. She micromanages and sometimes it feels like she’s trying to embarrass me. Any advice?

like

So stuck. What do I do? I joined this firm a year ago (4 yrs exp total) to grow/get more court/client exposure. Then 2 more-experienced associates were hired, pandemic, & all cases are divided between the other 2. I have no defined tasks except deficiency letters or the odd pro bono case. Boss claims it's mentoring. I still need to meet bill req.

Last wk Boss said I'll do more & my work was good, but today said I can't 2nd chair bc I don't have experience. I'm doing less now than my prior firm.

like

My current job does not give me opportunities to write legal memos or briefs. I am applying for a different job and do not have a current writing sample because of this. Any recommendations on what to do?

like

Thoughts on Paul Weiss - corporate?

like

For the litigators...do your state courts use electronic filing similar to ECF or do only some counties/parishes use electronic while others are stuck in the olden times. If not, what do you think the refusal to adapt comes from?

like

Leadership advice for young associates?

like

I’ve been in house my entire career (6 years) and I am thinking about transferring to big law. I feel the experience would sharpen key skills and compensation wise would work out better. Has anyone made this transition before? Is it too late?

like

Are there any firms out there that are open to attorneys retooling (switching from plaintiff to defense in the same practice area) for laterals? About to start my fourth year. Looking in the southeast region (AL, GA, TN). I do L&E but am willing to do other areas where I get caught up to speed on management-side L&E.

like

I have to fill out a background check form for a position and it asks if I've ever been discharged from a job. Does getting "the talk" --i.e. being told your future isn't at the firm as a senior associate--count as being discharged? Any thoughts are much appreciated!

like

How much pro bono do you typically bill per year? Have you been called out on it?

like

When you’re about to give notice but they are bringing you on new client project’s…. Sorry…

like

Any good podcasts about the practice of law or lawyering?

likehelpful

For small firms - What was your billable rate in 2015 and what is it today in 2022. Please provide your practice area too, if possible!

like

Just interviewed for a “JD Required” position and at the end of the interview was told the starting salary is less than I could be making as a legal assistant. 🧐🤔

likehelpfulfunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal