How much annual income do you think a family of 4 living in in NYC needs to live comfortably?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

For a family of 4 I’d say $250k would be the bottom range of not having to worry.

like

Leave NYC. Just do it.

If you gotta be in NY, move upstate. You’re not gonna get where you need to be in order to live comfortably in NYC for a long time on any Big 4 salary if you’re just now a senior.

like
Recent IconRecent

$200k minimum for manhattan

like

... consider living in jersey city or hoboken, maybe bayonne.. not too far from the city but is not as crazy

like

Depends on your definition of comfort.

like

Able to take vacations, save, kids in activities, eat out once a week

$2.5M 🥃

like

I was thinking $400k for a family of 4 cuz after tax, retirement savings, child care, and household expenses there would be about $100k for everything else to live comfortably. $200k doesn’t sound like enough to live comfortably in Des Moines, let alone Manhattan but maybe that’s me. I consider comfortably to mean living in a nice home, maxing out all retirement and college savings accounts, driving a decent car, going on at least one really nice vacation per year, and eating out at least 3x per week.

like

Holly shit y’all. I am supporting a family of 4 on 75k in Houston and we live like royalty!! I have student loans, debt, and a house. Not trying to hate here just surprised at the cost of living in NY.

like

I have lived in both Manhattan, the outer boroughs and the suburbs. There are certain pluses for living in the city but I am not overly impressed. I would take my backyard, leafy streets and easy access to the beach over Manhattan most days of the week. Of course I am older, and married with kids so things were different in my younger days. At the end of the day you get what you pay for and the convenience of living in Manhattan certainly has its price. I am happy my kids grew up in the surburbs.

like

Manhattan or one of the other boroughs?

like

Manhattan

like

I agree with the $400k comment. Forget about buying something under $1m. So rent for 3 room apartment can easily be $5,000 and up a month. You probably want to send your kids to private school which has college tuition rates. After that everything is so expensive and then you need to save for college and retirement.

like

Private school is a complete waste of money. It is true that students at private schools perform better. However, studies have confirmed that when you control for the education level and income of the parents, the difference completely evaporates. It is all about who is raising the kid, not the school.

If you take a kid in private school with parents that make $500K per year and each have law degrees, and move him to public school, that kid is still going to demolish the SAT, ACT, or whatever test you put in front of them. Why? Because the parents are likely very strict about making their kid study, prepare, etc.

like

I live inside the loop in Houston and for a new build, I paid over a million. Granted, I have 4500 square feet. However, I would think in Manhattan, a million will get you nothing.

like

Depends on how much debt (student loan/auto) you have. If you have 0 debt, 160k should be sufficient for living a good life in Queens / Brooklyn. Not sure about Manhattan and LIC.

I've been overpaying - putting $2500 monthly on mine alone since June... Only 1.5 more years of that!

If we are talking post tax... 200k is great. Pre tax is a different story...

500K

Related Posts

Hey There! What package can be expected for a .Net developer (Asp .Net MVC / SQL etc ) of 7.5 years of experience. [Currently at 19Lpa in HCL since Nov 2020.] Need some guidance before entering negotiations!

Hello everyone!
I’m currently working as an Optimization Associate, which in my company is a step above a project manager. Our team didn’t have a scope for the majority of my tenure, so I was practically doing E2E PM & process improvement for multiple teams. I’ve asked for an off-cycle salary increase (35%) because I’ve been performing at a higher level than my job entails far before my promotion to the role and I’m currently excelling. How likely would the company accept it?

like

Hi is the news about pwc firing employee stands truth ?
Joined back on July it’s scary please reply

like

#RestartWithInfosys for Infosys Consulting,

Eligibility: Women professionals who are on a career break, currently. Should have worked for 5 years before taking career break and should have minimum of 6 months (continuous) break in their career.

Roles in Management Consulting:
1) Senior Consultant
2) Principal

DM for referral

like

Just waiting until I finish paying off my loans so I can quit law and write fantasy novels. That is all.

likeuplifting

How is Publicis Sapient for SAP Hybris techstack in terms of projects, growth and wlb?
YOE: 3.4 yrs

like

Can anyone from Honeywell DM me pls. Need to know few things.

Anyone with reduced schedule success stories? Considering an 80% schedule but worried drawing the line will be hard.

Hi Fishes, I have joined Zoom as a Software Engineer for India team.

likesmart

Anyone still in this bowl?!!

like
like

Hey Fishes,

What is the average package for 8 years of experience resource in Progress 4GL(RDMS) ?
Any idea 💡

like

Elon musk is a Republican now … wow as if he’s the first rich person to switch parties 🙄

like

I have offeres from IBM, NTT , ATOS SYNTEL with same package...which one I can go with for better work life balance.

Domain SAP

like

The CSTA New England Conference is at UMass - Amherst on Saturday, November 12th

Corporate openings at top firms — NYC, Charlotte, Philly, Denver, Portland, Houston, Palo Alto, other cities. DM me.

like

PhD in Chemistry w/ 8 YOE. Now pursuing a part-time MBA while working as an R&D manager is a chemical company. I don't enjoy chemistry research anymore and want to try something else. I'm interested in consulting and think it could open doors for me to do something different after a few years. My main struggle is that I think I'm pretty old to make such a change (if I can get into consulting) ...not sure if anyone has a similar background that can share the insights.
Btw- M, 36, married w/ kids

like

My firm is virtual - all work done remotely in home office unless on client site. Haven’t traveled since mid October. It’s driving me nuts. What do you recommend doing?

like

Elite firm hiring in Private Funds, Fund Formation and Fund Finance in NYC. DM me. Some amazing opportunities in these areas (in NYC, Charlotte and elsewhere).

like

I’m looking to transition from an academic medical center to pharma or a biotech. I have about 8 years of clinical research experience overall — 7 years combined as a CRC (CRC I, CRC II, and senior CRC) and 1 year as a PM. I’m also recently ACRP-CP certified.

I’ve worked with many different industry-sponsors and CROs throughout the years, but many jobs I am applying to require experience at a biotech/CRO/pharma company. Would really appreciate any advice or referrals. Thanks in advance!

like

Additional Posts in Accounting

Tax SMs....why do we do this when the raises are 💩? No escape route?

like

When you actually shed a tear because getting into bed feels so damn good. #2moredays #waitno #3moredays? fuck it, goodnight.

like

How do you deal with failing your exams? I’ve been given another go, due to COVID-19, but this is will be my last attempt. I keep failing by literally a couple of percent!

likeupliftinghelpful

During the interview process how do I find out there’s truly work life balance, 9-5 job?

like

What are Tax senior salaries like in Salt Lake City?

like

What if our company paid us a nice bonus now if we are >100% utilized, then had a clause that we would have to pay it back if we left within 1 - 3 years. Something like this may resolve the retention issue.

likefunny

Limited at my current firm due not having CPA. I want to take a few months off to take the exams and then re-enter the market seeking a manager role ( 6 years experience) at a mid to larger size firm. Does this sound like a good idea or should I find a manager role at a smaller firm that doesn't require CPA? Any other options I should be considering?

like

My checking account is actually a clearing account 😱

like

Has anyone pulled their CA CPA license entirely? The rules are confusing. I have moved abroad and don’t need to maintain both a CA and CO license. CO is my original licensing state. More in comments..

like

Can we book personal trips through EY Travel Portal?

like

Do you consider yourself underpaid? Yes, our jobs suck most of the time but it has perks. I hear so many staff and seniors say they’re underpaid but there’s a lot worse gigs out there

like

Relocating to DC. Want to live in DC or Arlington. Where?! (1 bedroom budget between 2500 and 3000)

like

Thinking about working for two firms at once. One is a part time contract gig at a local firm, the other is a remote position at an out of state firm. Seems like hours would be same but much more pay.

like

Leaving as a staff.... thoughts? Am I a failure?

likefunnysmarthelpful

Which NE firms have nixed their internships for this summer?....looking for New England firms specifically.

like
like

Has anyone in this bowl been involved with ALPFA/been to one of their conventions before? Did you find it worthwhile?

like

Severely over budget on a project. I’ve never been involved in budgeting before. How do teams usually handle being way over budget? Has anyone experienced this before and have advice for knowing what to write off, how to explain to client, etc? Any advice is greatly appreciated. Thanks.

like

Tips for phone Interview...Pleaseeeee!...Should be 30mins long.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal