How much is a promotion % raise at your ad agency? ( yes, I know we are not getting them this year)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I mostly agree with CD1 (but I like math). Unfortunately when I used that strategy, the leaders came back with “usually we give 10% increases, what you’re asking for is a lot higher of a percent.” You should have a number in mind you want (not a percentage). Rather than argue the relativity of a percentage, I showed my boss the average someone with my title receives via Glassdoor, both for my city, our headquarter city, nationwide. I then highlighted the difference to my salary and the average for my job. While people probably inflate their salaries on Glassdoor and they’re mixed in with corporate salaries of the same title, it was enough for my bosses to come back to me with a better offer and less of an attitude tbh. They didn’t think I was being greedy when they realized they had been underpaying me.

Percentages while you’re already underpaid are bologna and not fair. Start with a number in mind, not a percent. My first successful raise request got me almost 20% (still not much because I was making peanuts) and my raise with my promotion got me ~20% up from there. I was hoping to ask again this year, but here we are.

like

There is no defined measure in advertising. Unfortunately most people in our business got into it because they tanked their quantitative courses in school. It’s all
about ‘feeling’. So use that.

In my experience I’ve received major raises when I was kicking ass (30% two years in a row) and smaller ‘bumps’ some other years. Some came with promotions, some did not. I used the same strategy each time.

What I can say is, never ever ask for a dollar amount. Keep the conversation qualitative and open ended. Speak to your VALUE, explain that you love it here and feel that you’re bringing great value to the team and WANT TO wake up every morning knowing your team values you too. And right now...you feel like your salary doesn’t reflect that value.

And here’s why this works. Your manager’s ‘unit of salary’ is way more than yours. They will use their own pay scale to add to yours. The person you speak to about your raise has a distorted scale of money because they make more of it. Use that to your advantage.

Let’s say you make $40k. A $15k raise is a $38% raise!! That’s a big jump. But your manager probably make $150k. That same $15k is just 10% of their salary. So to them $15k is relatively a lot smaller. When they start throwing out numbers in their head to present to the CFO they’ll present their version of ‘reasonable’. If you had just asked for a 38% raise you’d be laughed out of the room, right?! But 10%, that’s generous!!

Relative value is how you get raises in this business, not asking for dollar amounts. Starting a negotiation with numbers sucks the emotion out do the room. It becomes a math problem. No one on advertising likes math.

like

Related Posts

Experienced hire Manager here, informed before Christmas that I’ll be taking another lap but not because of performance (5/5 on scats and all operating at next level) or metrics (22mm in MR) but the only reason is I need more time in the “saddle”… During this time, I’ve been replying to recruiters and after a PPMD interview last week, I was offered an SM role at a smaller firm with a base pay increase of 45% (225k) over my current salary. Very much considering this… thoughts?

like

Edward Jones advisor with 30 million AUM and roughly 250k gross production. Been there for almost 4 years. Got an offer at Merrill Lynch to take over a 100 million dollar retirement transition plan in 5 years, or to join a 5 person Merrill Lynch team that manages a lot.

Pros to EJ: Have my own office, a year or two away from partnership, great office setting and client satisfaction.

Pros to Merrill: Bump in compensation, additional tools and services w banking, ability to take over assets.

likehelpful
like

A recruiter called and said I am a final candidate for a role I’ve been interviewing for. They told me they are thinking mid to low $60ks but when I originally spoke to them, they gave me a range of $58-$68k. Then they asked me what my salary expectations were and I was transparent and told them for the role and my experience $68-$80k was the range considering the role is essentially 3 jobs in 1. I told them I’m happy to consider the full offer. Should I be concerned they won’t offer me the job?

like

Saw this in another bowl so thought I’d do one here 😅
What was your approximate pay from graduating college up until now?

2020: $48k
2021: $50k
2022: $53k + 5% bonus

I am SCM analyst. Covid seems to have impacted the SCM industry a lot. Share if you’re comfortable and give a little background of your career journey / advice if you’ve been in the industry for 5+ years

like

Hi Fishes, what is the monthly salary for this? With 1.5L in 80c and 15k monthly rent and using previous employer’s pf. Please help.

Post Photo
like

Hi fishes,

I have the following 2 offers..

Cognizant- 21L fixed and 1.5L variable
PWC - 22L fixed

This is for a guidewire role.
Which is a better offer? What would be a good option for growth wrt role, salary etc.
Also, PWC claims to offer variable based on their fixed CTC based on the ratings.. is this true ? How much is the avg percentage given?

Thanks in advance!

like

Deloitte India Deloitte USI Infosys Accenture IBM Sun Life Financial

Hi All, please help is it deloitte offering 27 LPA plus variable with Manager role is good for 10 years exp in SAP background?
have one more offer from infy with 23 lpa +20 variable and Lead consultant role.

Both roles equivalent ? Which offer is better to join. Should I ask deloitte for more compensation?

like

Hello Fishes,
Thinking of applying to airbus
What is the approx package for a person with 4 to 6 YOE?
I come from mechanical background. Does Airbus consider that?

like

Hi Fishes,

Currently on Notice period need referral.

Will make sure your referrals are best used and not wasted.

Grinded Good amount of DS.

TC: 6L

YOE: 2.5

Highest offer: 20L(startup)

@Linkedin@Twilio@Apple@Zomato@Swiggy@Facebook@Uber@Airbnb@Cohesity@Navi@Mindtickle@Zeta@Gojek@Slack@Harness@Salesforce@Atlassian@Flipkart@Microsoft@Adobe@Salesforce@Twitter@Twitter@Intuit@GoldmanSachs@Curefit@ShareChat@Dunzo@Google@Paypal@Walmart@Ola@Swiggy@Oracle@DpWorld@Oppo@Hotstar@Instabase

like

hey, fishies! i got a dilemma. would you take an offer that’s $5k less than your desired salary range/expectations? (e.g. you say your range is $115k - $120k & they come back with $110k). but also this would technically be a $5k cut from your current salary, which is pretty much maxed out for its current title/salary band.

HOWEVER, i’d be moving from a midsized agency to a very prestigious agency, which also covers 100% of your healthcare premium AND deductible…

like

How long will it take to complete ITA promotion process after speaking with manager?? Do i receive any mail when it's initiated?

like

What’s the base salary at other B4’s (NYC, tax staff 2)?

like

For RSM Tax, what is the bonus %? I'm hearing it's fixed each year, so like 6.5%. Can someone provide some insight?

like

CD salary in NYC?

like

Hi Amazonians, Can someone tell me what is the expected salary of L4 Support Engineer - Tech for 3 years of experience. Amazon Amazon India Amazon Web Services

like

Received a verbal job offer on Tues. $5k short of what I had said was my desired range but still up from my current salary. We set up a call for Thurs to discuss further. On Wed they sent me all benefits info. Thursday on the call I asked if we could either increase moving stipend or get closer to my desired salary. They said no, and I asked them to send over written offer and I would let them know by Fri. They then email they are no longer offering me the position and repost it the next day:

like

I am going to be starting a job working in an academic laboratory at a school in Western NY as a lab tech, and was offered 32k salary. I have a BS in Med lab science and have been working in clinical research for the past three years since school. Negotiating them to go higher has not been very successful so I’m hoping to get a sense whether this is a fair salary for my experience? I’ll be cutting my salary more than in half from my job in clinal research but trying to get into PhD program.

like

What's the inhand salary calculation for below 2 offers(after tax)

1. 34 LPA fixed pay ( both employer and employee PF included) 12% of Basic. Total 3.2 LPA in PF deduction.

2. 36.5 LPA fixed pay ( employee pf 12% of basic and employer PF is 1800 )

My Deductions are
1. 1.5 lakhs 80c
2. 50k 80ccd
3. HRA - 22k p.m.

like

More Posts

Missed connection due to 3 hr delay . Flight was booked on same itenary . American airlines. i don't have a status currently. Next available direct flight to destination was 1 day later. Any points?

Do you ever conduct the hiring process for a research project? What do you look for in potential hires?

like

When leaving KPMG for another company, what are the payouts, if any? (Unused vacation days, etc) And is a 401k rollover required, or can you stay with Merrill Lynch?

like

Well that’s a helpful email, thanks HR 🤦🏼‍♀️😂

Post Photo
funnylike

Which platform is more valuable to pursue expertise in, AWS or Azure?

like

Thoughts on moving to a small asset management firm in Toronto to build and lead a data team? Will be reporting to the CTO. Thanks!

like

Everyone please be safe this weekend if you're going out on Halloween. A horrible tragedy took place in Seoul this weekend and nearly 150 people who were hoping for a fun night have passed away. Stay vigilant, drink responsibly and have fun 🙏🏾❤️

likehelpful

Don't hate me but Brookly style pizza >>> Chicago deep dish, any day, any time.

like

For those of you who got your MBA, did you see a salary jump after you received it? Were there other benefits that people don’t really think about that should be considered? And lastly, do you think an MBA is necessary to eventually land a VP level position?

like

One month into a new job and I can already tell it’s not for me. Is it too early to start looking for something else?

like

May I know the grading within Standard Chartered? I am applying for a job in branding and communication at SC UK

I am confused by the title, like Associate, Manager, Associate Director and Director.

And also, the salary range between Associate and Associate Director is so close. What is the market range in the banking industry in the UK?

like

Is it a turn off if someone from Hinge lives in Williamsburg and not downtown Manhattan? Too much of a trek and cheaper? I’ve seen people here say living in UES is a turn off because it’s cheaper and not as trendy

funnylikesmart

Can anyone suggest a really comfortable office chair? Struggling over here without one.

like

Asian fishies - best Strategy shops in Asia? Both to build a better book and work with people that can help me get better

like

Has anyone sought accommodations for your ADD?

like

What type of charges we can reimburse in PwC banglore??

like

Anyone hiring in Houston? About to get laid off from technology sr consultant role. Willing to travel as much as necessary (when possible)

like

Has anyone ever gotten two Research Simulations and passed FAR 😭😭😭

Any tips for free but good email marketing tools? Looking to create a budget friendly marketing strategy for a startup, I'm however only experienced with MailChimp

likesmart

If one of your direct reports has another offer, would you prefer they talk it through with you first or just hand in notice?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

What is the working culture like at Marcom (Apple)? Does it differ between contractor vs FTE?

like

Why do recruiters always want to talk on the phone?

Wouldn't it save us both time to just send me the job description and I'll let you know if I'm interested or if there is a match?

like

Fellow GoT viewers: GET HYPE

like

📊 Would like to hear on a scale of 1-10 your job satisfaction, and type of agency work you do (1=low , 10 high) for example; "7, Account Management"

like

How is GE as a client? Just got hit up for a new position at an agency and they said that they would be my main client.

like

In-house Vs. Agency? 1 Pro, 1 Con:
Pro- Wait out the industry apocalypse for next 3yrs
Con- Same client... everyday, all day

like

Could anyone speak to the differences working at a consultancy such as Deloitte digital, Accenture..etc versus an agency? Are salaries greater at consultancies compared to agencies compared to agencies? Is work/life balance any different?

like

My Thanksgiving: eating a takeout burger from Denny’s as it was the only restaurant open in this godforsaken town I’m passing through. Finished it off by watching the critically acclaimed «Battleship» at my hotel room. Anyone else have a Thanksgiving success story to share?

like

I really thought I’d like freelancing more. But finding it’s not for me. Especially with no official partner. Getting used to someone else’s ways of working is rough. Deciphering mysterious expectations. Not knowing where you stand. Miss settling into a job and going thru the awkwardness just once then focusing only on work there on in.

like

Curious how other people’s brains work.
When you get an activation brief, what’s your process for coming up with a solid idea?

Look for cultural moments that you can adapt? Look through award show books? Scroll YouTube videos until 3am?

I know that every brief and every idea is different, but I’m more interested in the process and what you’re creative routine is to get the wheels turning.

Thanks.

like

Thoughts about redscout?

like

In your review, do you actually list a particular % increase in salary you expect?

like

I recently accepted a new role after being laid off. I feel really blessed to have found a job in this climate. My new boss is wonderful! However, the role itself isn’t in the direction I want to go. I’m struggling with feeling guilty for continuing to job search. Any advice on staying somewhere for a good boss vs. switching jobs so soon?

like

Print Producers, what is the range of salary I should be asking for both full time and freelance in NYC?

like

It bums me out seeing how many of us account folks are bad at the job or don't understand where we help and where we don't. I think a great account prsn is an asset to any team, but there aren't many

like

How many agencies give cost of living/yearly raises vs just a “yearly bonus” ?

Can ya guess which one Barkley is?

like

I just had a creative production person ask if it was OK to scale an image 300% and have it print at 100dpi. 😳 Um no, no it's not...

like

Any suggestions for a home office printer that can handle the volume of image-heavy work we do?

like

I’m coming up on my one year mark and I want to ask for a raise but with limited new biz wins, a looming recession and client projects slowing up, does it make sense to ask? I’m also at a tiny start up shop and don’t want to come off as being greedy for asking…

like

In a twist, the states with the most people selecting "obamacare" coverage all went for Trump in the presidential election: Florida (1.3mm), Texas (800k), North Carolina, Georgia & Pennsylvania 😕🔫

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal