{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "I am a senior graduating soon with a technical masters (accelerated program) from an Ivy League. I have an offer for Facebook TPM and McKinsey & Company BA. McK first year TC is 75k less. Will McK increase the offer? If so, how much? \n\nAny thoughts on FB vs McK for PM opportunities later on?", "post_id": "60a3024d55af8d002a40c3a3", "reply_count": 1, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "5d27c2f046b581001b2fae8f", "bowl_name": "Product Management" }

I am a senior graduating soon with a technical masters (accelerated program) from an Ivy League. I have an offer for Facebook TPM and McKinsey & Company BA. McK first year TC is 75k less. Will McK increase the offer? If so, how much? Any thoughts on FB vs McK for PM opportunities later on?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

First off, congrats - not many people get the sort of opportunities you have been given. You decision will depend on your long term goals. If what you want to do is make things, FB is what you need. The only issue is whether you want to be at a company that is as vilified. If you want to get the business stuff first, McKinsey is one of the best places you could go. However, it's consulting and you'll be on the low end so you are more likely to be sent to a project in Poughkeepsie than Manhattan. as for money, you should squeeze McKinsey in a competitive situation - tell them you have an offer from fb. So both have ups and downs.

like

Additional Posts

Accenture 🐠 what kind of sign-on bonus and RSUs do you get at the SM level in consulting/strategy?

like

Moving from big 4 tech implementation to boutique strategy firm for huge comp increase. Long term goal is mbb. Would this move help or hurt mba admissions and mbb recruitment?

like

What are some certifications I can do which are hot in market? Have data background and in pwc consulting. Not very keen on software development or very technical courses. Is PMI or any other certification helpful? What are my options? Can anyone with similar background share some experience? For reference - I’m 3 years into consulting.

likefunny

Would you nicely say something to the little kid continuously kicking your seat on a flight or keep quiet?

like

I’m started to grow exhausted of all the “or” thinking. Politics. Culture. Industry culture. It’s like everything has turned into a sporting event in which you’re on the winning or losing team. 0 sum game vs additive and abundance thinking. Why not find the great things and add to it vs finger pointing and burning the whole thing down?

like

20,000 Bonus Miles! Okay Delta... I guess I still love you.

like

Has anyone taken the SHRM - CP exam, passed and received a bonus at EY

like

Is 97k way too low for an ACD role in NY?

Post Photo
like

5th interview, 20th rejection

like

Is it just me or is $245 off your paycheck every week too much for health insurance? I rarely use it.

likefunny

I recently moved out of my apartment complex 2 weeks ago and ended my lease early because I had to move for work. The leasing office calls me today and said they “forgot” to bill me for a $1200 rent concession I received when I first moved in (First Month free rent promotion). After looking the lease, I found the clause but I really don’t want to pay especially when they made the mistake on not billing me and are just now following up 2 weeks later. Advice? Ideas? Similar situations?

like

Anyone have mandatory PTO during the holidays? Our leadership is making us use PTO days if we don't have billable work between Xmas & NYE. I don't even celebrate Xmas, kind of annoyed

like

What kind of positions can you get at a Big 4 with a CFE?

like

Bicipetal tendinitis - which, it looks like I have been having for several months (first noticed 9 months ago), but did not realize it was lingering because I had not been lifting during Covid lockdown. Thought it was my rotator cuff, but PCP thinks it's tendinitis. Anyone have any tips or tricks for fast recovery, and approx timeframe from experience? Also any one experienced a misdiagnosis? Thank you in advance.

like

Only thing good about wfh is I can chill in my bed, watching Netflix and reading my book while the team thinks I am working. I have been working fully concentrated for up to 2 hours for the past 2 months and none can tell me anything cause they have no actual visibility that I am not working

likefunny

Can someone in assurance tell me what's the package a audit senior who is not a qualified CA or ACCA usually get?

likehelpful

Currently out on parental leave and will be putting in my notice. How much notice period should I give? Concerned to give 2 weeks as i might be asked to leave next day due to already out on parental leave. Thoughts?

like

Anyone done a cool payments project in Digital? Please share what you actually do on these? Is it business analysis? strategy?

like

Flight got cancelled. Currently on a 5 hour road trip with my manager and my client to make it to our workshops tomorrow #bondingtime

like

Hey guys... i have a question. I live in California and my apartment complex is pet friendly and they require a $500 pet deposit but I read that if I make my new pet an ESA (emotional support dog) that the deposit is waived. Is this true? Where would I get an ESA certificate? And does the leasing office have any defenses against me presenting an ESA certificate? Like minimizing my emotional disability or asking for physician proof of the emotional disability? Just trying to have my understanding straight before I put my leasing office on notice that I want a dog.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal