I am trying to decide between 2 offers, BDO vs. KPMG. KPMG is offering about $4k more on base, the extra $1,200 in reimbursable items, and pension but Big 4 brings WLB fears while I love the time I've spent at BDO, everyone is great and I can't recommend it enough.

The big selling point KPMG is pitching me on is the MADA program. I really want to get my Master's and BDO doesnt have a set vehicle for that. Has anyone gone through MADA?

BDO assc. offer in hand, KPMG intern offer in hand.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Not saying this just because I work at KPMG, but I would go with KPMG. You’ll be struggling with WLB no matter which of these two you choose. Might as well choose the one with a bigger name and higher salary. An internship is basically a full time offer as long as you don’t f it up.

Also don’t know much about MADA, but since KPMG will fund it, go for it. It won’t hurt you to have that on your resume.

like

There is no guarantee you will work less at BDO. It’s all a roll of the dice with clients. Get the big name first then figure out what makes you happy.

I really feel like you should take the Big 4 offer. There is such a big difference in career options with the stamp of approval of Big 4 on your resume.

If you join a smaller firm you will find an uphill battle later on going through recruiting processes. I know a lot of hiring conversations at my firm (now working in industry) start with we need someone with big 4 experience. When I am hiring, I pretty much throw out anyone that isn’t big 4.

If you hate the big four, you will have no issues transferring to a smaller accounting firm later.

like

The exit ops have been on my mind in addition to MADA. My end goal is to go private and boutique for myself (after 5-10 years in PA) instead of going industry. Big 4 is a great place to learn from the best and to learn fast but is the Big 4 stamp super important for niche work under my own shingle/LLP with a J.D.?

I will say my WLB in Big 4 hasn’t been bad. Sure, we have bad days and weeks and even months sometimes, and there are certainly times when I know not to schedule anything due to busy season, but overall I feel like I have flexibility. I’ll let you know on pay in a few months lol.

From my experience the higher up you get (manager here), the more you see people working smarter not harder and setting boundaries. Harder to do when you’re a staff/senior. However, in terms of the people who are always working and have bad WLB, in my experience it seems to be people who do this to themselves. Perfectionists, can’t move things along, screw around, don’t have a whole lot going on outside of work so they choose to work a ton (then complain), workaholics to begin with, etc.

like

Big 4 - that’s an investment in your future.

like

I’ll play devils advocate. I started my career with big4, but found that it was probably a better idea to start at a smaller firm. The reason, you get more diversity of work earlier on, which lets you decide what you are really interested in and what you want for your career. You can always go to big four later on if you need that stamp of approval. At big four you will get really good at doing certainly things, but it likely will be a niche area. WlB really depends on the group you are in and the clients, it can be good or bad at both.

like

That's one of the big reasons I haven't signed the KPMG offer. The flexibility BDO offers is wonderful in addition to the fact it feels much more relaxed.

Sure busy season has been busy, I am such a nerd I had nothing better to do so I picked up FT hours during spring break; I was learning a ton, they needed the work done, and I really wanted to see the office at night when people were stressed. Not once have I seen anyone get overly bent out about things. People's schedules are essentially there own; any issues get reviewed, discussed, and fixed without any unnecessary craziness; everyone is insanely helpful with interns and each other, they share knowledge, accept input, teach and learn constantly up and down the rank line. It's a great team where everyone puts in work and noone is in each other's ass, honestly it's probably one of the healthiest teams I've ever worked with. If it wasn't for potentially getting my Master's paid for I'd have signed already.

like

Which team would you be joining at each firm?

like

Tax at BDO and Audit at KPMG. I'm open to either for different reasons and have already considered the Tax v. Audit question, both would allow me to do either.

Additionally, I'm a non-traditional student, very very early 30's with prior work experience in a few different fields. Finally got around to getting my 150 this year. I know it doesn't make a huge difference but I'm not walking into this a green eyed 21yo thinking I'll be partner in 4 years. I can find work outside of PA, I'm choosing to be here because it's the best place to learn and I love what I do.

Having experience with both, I think it’s overrated when people say they require big 4 experience. The people who are saying that are the people who CAME from big 4. At a smaller firm, you get way more differing opportunities and have to juggle a lot more varying clients. While you’d still get great experience in big 4, the midsize firms get some of the crappier clients (just being honest) which honestly you learn a hell of a lot more on them some super clean cut Fortune 500 company. The skills you learn are invaluable from working on clients like that. Especially since it sounds like you’re wanting to start your own practice or do your own thing down the road? The clients at a midsize firm would be more your niche than big 4. Just my two cents!!

like

Absolutely agree in some ways big four is a lot easier especially with clients. In big four you get like four big clients and everything is usually pretty well organized with processes in place. Smaller firms you get like 25 clients with less processed in place/ you create the processes and really get in the weeds of things.

Related Posts

Are BB also hiring like crazy right now, or is it just M? And if I started at my current place like 3 months ago and let's say I get an offer from a MBB, would pivoting be frowned upon or be considered "burning bridges"?

like

Looking for your career advice! I currently work as a Content Marketing Manager but would love to move into a Head of Marketing/Marketing Director role. What would be your best tips to make that move? I assume it will take time of course, but I'm wondering what/where I should invest in terms of my training and next career steps. Thanks!

like

How as a 45 year old man who has been a day trader for 20 years with a 3 year stint as a true financial advisor aka IRA series 7/66 with jpmorgan plus series SIE, 65 82 99 go back to a regular 40 hour week? I’m just tired of trading looking for something new! What are my options? As an RIA and banking with JPMorgan I also had onboarding expertise with certification in anti money laundering specialist

Recently Store Managers have been offering me jobs from different locations but same company in my town. The company is T-Mobile. It’s going to be my first job. I have a couple questions for any former/current employees. Is it better to work for T-Mobile, metro by T-Mobile, or a third party T-Mobile? Any difference in benefits or wage? Thanks

like

Networking question here. A retired partner at the firm I used to work out reached out to me recently about attending an afternoon during the week (b4 4/30) with one of his long time clients. The partner and I have kept in touch since I joined my new firm and I feel like his invitation is a great networking opportunity since the client (who I have worked with before) is on a number of boards. Torn as how to request off as an S3. Could materialize to nothing but could be good for reconnecting.

like

Not in investment banking. However, my new role requires familiarity with income statement, dcf, accounting, comps etc.,. Is the Wall Street Prep course recommended to get up to speed on core financial topics and related excel work? Thanks in advance.

like

Are all large healthcare provider organizations (big health systems) messed up? In terms of poor senior leadership, no accountability, poor support to their leaders, mismanaged, etc.

like

Can anyone provide insights into Corporate Finance Institute’s Financial Modeling and Valuation Analyst certification? Worth it?

like

Hello. I’m currently working in management consulting at a Big 4 and considering switching to cloud outside of my firm. I have no cloud experience, so starting from scratch. Considering starting with AWS practitioner certification, then Certified Solutions Architect - Associate, plus getting some practical experience by being staffed on cloud projects at my firm. What job and compensation can I expect in the market after this? Any other skills you would recommend to be more competitive? ty

like

What's a reasonable amount of billable hours for a first year? How do you adjust to not having much free time?

like

Hello,
I graduated in June with a dual BSBA in healthcare management and humans resources management/organizational management. I have 12 years experience as a medical assistant. I'm having trouble finding my first job as a healthcare manager. After submitting so many applications and receiving so many rejection emails I've become frustrated. Any advice anyone can give is greatly appreciated.

like

Is Salesforce professional services a lot harder than big 4 consulting?

like
like

Why is it so difficult to make the next career move within your OWN company. I have over 7 years of experience across multiple departments and yet an external company is more willing to give an interview to select roles than your own home company for the same role internally!!

Where is the loyalty in that !!??

like
like

Hello everyone!
What would you choose between P&G, pwC and a small consulting firm for a data science internship. The three positions are based in Paris and in data science, I have to take a decision this week and I'm completely lost :/
I don't have any clear idea about what I would like to do after (sometimes I think about a phd but others I prefer consulting...)
Thank you so much for your help

Has anyone transitioned from an insurance company (I’m currently with Anthem/Elevance)? I currently work in Medicare/Medicaid quality (I have a BS in Health Education) and wanting to make the switch into a consulting role. Looking for advice and/or leads. Thanks!!

like

What is the health insurance coverage at Google? How much deductible and copay?

Hi everyone,

I’m currently looking to build a career within the ESG consulting and strategy space. I am in a career transition phase and have a tax consultancy background from a Big 4 for 5+ years. However, I believe I have gained some skills that are transferable to ace at ESG consulting as well. While I am still in the process of upskilling myself and gaining the required knowledge, could you help me with referring my CV or with some leads? 

like

More Posts

PwC give this last week of Dec as holiday every year. Does any of from CHWTIA has same policy?

Is there any vacancy for the post of full stack developer or senior software engineer in WALMART Chennai ?

Hi All, I am currently a Data Analyst with 1 year of experience and pursuing a masters in Computer Science (expected to graduate 5/2023). I am looking to transition into an entry Data Scientist role (preferably remote or Philadelphia, PA). Can someone refer me or let me know who is hiring?

I can provide my resume if needed.

SD🐠🐟 How is everyone holding up? My Fiance and I are volunteering with Team Rubicon tomorrow!

Hello Folks,

Often a time we see posts where people asking How much would be my In hand Salary given XYZ CTC.

Can we have this thread and share ours.

24LPA, In hand 1.45(Tax Declared 80C,80D)

like

Know of any app used in pune to rent car/2-wheeler for some hours/days?

like

Even though we're busier than ever during COVID, I feel less burnt out than I usually do. There's something pure about our work and contribution in this crisis

like

Any one received offer from Walmart recently or going to join soon?

like

Moved to SD recently with wife without a lot of friends, would someone be down to grab a coffee or drink?

Hi my IBM sharks !
With reference to creating a tax saver FD for tax exemption under Section 80C for FY 2022-23, what is the last date by which we need to create the Tax Saver FD and upload it as investment proof on IBM Tax declarations portal?

I know that in December we need to upload the investment proofs, but do we need to get the Tax Saver FD created before that?

like

Damn I have availability for the rest of the week but I’m crying at the thought of reaching out. I just wanna study for the CPA without any “what are you working on” pings. I know I know I’m terrible.

like

Time for new carry-on...
Briggs & Riley OR Away ?

Welcome any recommendations!

like

Hoping for some advice on how to properly leverage another job offer to help make another company pull the trigger on you. I’ll explain: I’ve been interviewing with Company A for a month now and have met with GC, CFO, creatives, and today the final round with HR and CEO. I have a good feeling they will extend an offer but it’s not a slam dunk. I think I’m top 2. Company B has extended an offer but one that I’m not really considering (moving to a new city/not enough money). Do I mention this....

like

Have a blessed day all. Last night my pet passed away, I put him up in a hotel/boarding at the adoption center. Since California is a hotspot for COVID-19, I flew back to my parents house (lower

like

Hi everyone, got an offer with EY’s Business Consulting group earlier this week. Was wondering what the typically salary ban was for a Staff 2 in a major city? They offered $90K but was curious if this was on the lower or higher end? Going to see if I can get more but would appreciate any input. Thanks!

like

the new GM SuccessFactors NA who is now touting the importance of DE&I at SAP is the same person that while at Oracle stood in front of 2000 Oracle employees and made a very derogatory comment about the LBGT community.

like

Hello, any experiences by H1B holders going to the open and allowed countries like Mexico or Turkey and coming back into the US?

likefunny

Any recommendations on things to do when in the Philippines?

like

What companies actually allow their consultants to use National for rental cars?

like

Hello, I have an interview scheduled for the position of Product Manager for Mumbai location. Could anyone please help me with details like culture/benefits and pay at ICICI?

Additional Posts in Compensation, Salary and Bonus

Does anyone know how much is the compensation for external recruiters? I have seen some of them worked in accounting before which makes me wonder if the comp is better. Like do they get big commissions for each placement they do? Just wondering…

Salary check; going into S2 year, CPA, MCOL city, IT audit @ 95k. Is this low?? High?? Still haven’t gotten word on my bonus for the year.

like

Looking at this W4 to adjust my withholding DOWN since my wife and I always get more back on our tax return than we want and would rather have the money now. I only see sections that will INCREASE my withholding? What am I missing? Is adjusting withholding down not an option? FYI I don’t work in this area so let’s keep the insults to a minimum lol.

like

Anyone at RSM doing transaction advisory can share thier salary as a Senior? Looking to leave industry but a few people I know have been switching over just curious to know if it will change my mind lol. Chicago market would be great

like

How much starting salary should we expect at EY for a manager role in data analytics with 12+ years of exp?

like

Anyone know the TC for internal tech product manager in Mega funds(Apollo, Blackstone, kkr) 7YOE

like

Anyone know manager 1 salaries in NYC for Tax (BTS)

like

I’m making $110K in the Bay Area. I’ve been working at a non-big4 firm for 6 years without a CPA. I was told I was receiving this salary so I wouldn’t even consider another offer. Any insight into whether this is actually a good salary is greatly appreciated.

likehelpful

I've been looking for salaries for various position with Big 4 assurance, but information is all over the place.
So after some research here, reddit, goingconcern, glassdoor, etc. I've put this info together:

!! The salary grid below is for Big 4 Audit, HCOL (NYC,SF), gross amounts without bonus !!

Of course they can be higher or lower by a few k's on each position depending on impact tier, but I tried to look for average amounts.
If you have information please post it so we can update.

Post Photo
like

Does anyone know what A2s make in SF? Trying to see if it’s worth a move. Thanks in advance.

What does Chicago Tax Comp look like now days?

like

NYC Tax Senior Manager...any idea what the market rate is for a heavy SM in NYC? I am thinking about relocating to NY for an opportunity. Currently out of the state. 12+ years experience.

like

Question for Clifton Larson: what’s the salary for a first year tax associate?

uplifting

What % raises did you get when getting promoted from Mgr to SM for those in public accounting? Trying to gauge what I should expect when I’m up for a promotion.

like

ITS or Transfer pricing comps?

like

I’m currently making $55k as a financial analyst in higher education. ( 5 years of experience & graduating with MBA this July 22’) I’m trying to get to a senior FA role making $80k+ and I’ve been hunting for a job since Nov. 21. Any recommendations on how to negotiate salary during interviews or get a job offer during interviews?

like

Anyone know much about the raises at EisnerAmper in audit?

like

How much does Senior 2/3 in Big4 make in SoCal? Federal Tax

like

What’s the salary like for a valuation associate position at a PE fund like Apollo? If the TC is 120k+ I’ll quit pwc right now

likehelpful

How much does a newly promoted Senior Manager in Audit make in HCOL - San Francisco/New York ? Is $150k reasonable or is the range higher?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal