I don’t have many years of of experience on paper (graduated college 5 years ago) but I constantly get told that I operate at a level far above my title. My art partner left to be an ACD somewhere else and she wants to recommend me as her partner, INSISTS that she knows I can do it (and she isn’t the type to exaggerate). Anyone have advice/perspective on the different between years of experience, output, natural ability, and whether or not it’s ridiculous to even consider this opportunity?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Is she the only one to say this, or have you heard it elsewhere? If you haven’t heard it elsewhere, I’d be very cautious and get feedback from others you can trust before even letting her make the recommendation.

If you have heard it elsewhere, it might be worth pursuing but ask a lot of questions about what you are getting into. Natural ability is wonderful and when paired with fresh enthusiasm, can result in great innovative ideas and creative work. But lived experiences, like how to balance your work load as you get more demanding projects and start to manage people and how to deal with office politics, etc. are all learned at scale - and there isn’t really a ‘natural ability’ jump that would happen there, even if your work skills are giving you a jump up the ladder. And it might even be worth acknowledging that in an interview - saying ‘I have the skills for the job, but I’m aware I might not have as much experience as you’d normally see at this level. As part of being successful in this role, I’d like to work with you to set up a plan for leadership training/mentorship/etc. that aligns with your longer term goals for someone in the role.

like

Anyone in your agency can leave and go get a bigger title and a bunch more money. Titles and salaries are inflated. But if you chase title and salary to aggressively eventually you will be obviously over titled and you will begin to operate below what your title suggests. So what would you rather be? someone Who functions above your title or someone who functions below your title? At every level there are a lot of things to learn and they are things that you can’t appreciate until they are on your plate. You’re talking about a two title job I think there’s a lot to be said for keeping that to a one title job.

like

Thanks everyone! We ended up agreeing I would come in as a Group Copy Supervisor, but still get to work with the partner who wanted to recommend me. For better or worse at my last agency they tended to heap responsibility on whoever was able to handle it so I actually do have experience managing multiple brands/people/politics—to the point that my partner said this new role she is in “feels exactly like what we did at X Agency but I have a team to support me versus it all being on my shoulders.” I’m really excited!!! It feels like the perfect compromise because I really do acknowledge the experience gap here.

likesmart

Just do it. But be prepared to learn on the job. That may mean more “work” than the work itself. Don’t be the person who gets promoted too soon and takes out their incompetence on everyone else.

like

Being an ACD (at most places) is more than your creative skill. Do you think you have the experience to be objective and still motivating to a team. Can you manage and execute work while still being present in basically all meetings. Sometimes the biggest short coming with someone promoted too soon is that they can work as one but haven’t had the time to build their skills that would be passed to others.

like

Do your best to observe what Copy ACDs do at your current agency. Do you think you can do those things? Varies by agency but likely overseeing multiple brands, supervising multiple writers, being responsible for driving creative concepting, tactical planning, other big creative efforts on these brands, and also helping run pitches and presenting at them from time to time. If you feel like you’re ready to do all these things then go for it, but be honest with yourself about whether you’re prepared to operate multiple levels above where you are now if you have reservations that you’re going to be in over your head.

I became an ACD with 6 years of experience and I haven’t struggled a ton. I would say go for it, but be prepared to be overwhelmed at certain points.

Related Posts

I need to grow my professional network, I feel lonely and little bit stuck...How did you find your mentor?

I lateraled after two years of bad reviews and failing to be promoted to the next class year at the firm I summered at. When I lateraled, I was brought on at the class year that matched my graduation year but was unsure if I had what it took to be a biglaw attorney. I had my annual review yesterday and was promoted (and received nothing but positive feedback). Sometimes it isn't you.

likeuplifting

Asking for a friend, he graduated from med school but wasnt able to match and has been out of school for ~7 years, what are potential career options? It it worth trying to get back into medicine?

like

Having a tough time getting a Product Manager interview. I have 3.5 YOE in technology implementations for a startup (my client). First 2.5 years were spent building my clients software, most recent year has been as a project manager for them. A lot of what I’ve done in last year overlaps ProdM responsibilities but I recognize it is a change. Am I reaching too much for a PM role? What are other roles I should consider to try to position myself to break into PM? Thank you for your help 🙏🏼

like
like

Can anyone tell me how to learn .net for beginners? Also pls help with me the tech skills that I should focus on while learning the .net technologies and pls suggest how to go about the preparation such as courses or YouTube or anything as such!

.net developers pls help!

like

Landed my first PM role (growth) - any course/resource recommendations on how to be successful in it? Most posts I’ve found are catered with resources on how to pass interviews etc.

like

Can anyone suggest best courses for ML engineer? I already have 2 yoe as a data scientist.

like
like

Anybody with Big4 exp made the switch to salesforce as business architect recently? What does this job entail and qualification needs? The jd says “extensive” big4 exp

like

I have been doing business analyst work and i’m interested in doing consulting on the side. Other than Upwork, where are some ways to find online gigs I can do remotely to skill-up as well as make additional income?

like

Are there any roles in Big 4 for Computer Science majors? Not looking for tech strategy or implementation etc which don’t need hardcore CS skills.

like

Just got off the phone with a recruiter who asked me what year I graduated from my MBA program and college and effectively told me I was too old for the role. I do have the 1 year of experience they asked for in the job in question. It's just that I have all this other experience in things unrelated to the role or things I want to deemphasize in my next role. Is there anything I can do? I only list the last 8 years of experience (as it's most relevant) and don't have my graduation years listed.

like

I’m looking to transition to a new role with more responsibilities and higher pay of course. I’ve been having a lot of trouble recently, and frankly it’s made me feel very down. I haven’t been able to get past initial recruiter screenings or first round interviews. I have almost 2.5 yoe as a BA and PM as well as a mba but I just can’t get a new role. Any advise or tips would be appreciated.

like

Hi All,
Anyone from Deloitte.I need some information on the Assistant Manager PPM role .Please support if possible

I have an accounting and finance background and looking to change careers. I’m exploring product management. Can anyone suggest resources for product management? Is there anything I need to know before moving in this direction.

like

Hello Fishes,

Currently I am a Tech Lead in PHP technology and I have total industry experience is 5+ years. I want to switch the career to Blockchain developer. Can you suggest how to start and which cities of India have job opportunity regarding it? And also what would be the CTC?

like

Anyone with any positive stories on life after consulting in industry? Feeling very lost at the moment on my entire long term plan but know consulting isn’t going to keep me going for too much longer. Any success stories would be appreciated.

like

More Posts

I currently work in real estate but am not enjoying it as much as I thought I would. I’m very interested in being a data analyst though! I’m just curious where to start? I have no prior experience or schooling.

likehelpful

1.5 year experience in PV, PharmD as well. Looking for PV Scientist Role or any wfh opportunity, any insight or advice would be appreciated!

like

Advice for someone in IT Audit looking into pivoting into a career in cyber? I have about 1 1/2 years in IT audit and have worked on a couple of cyber assessments/cyber program transformations. Feeling a bit lost as Cyber is such a broad career. Since my experience has been mainly in GRC should I look into other Big4 cyber consulting practices or should i go a different route. Thinking about going after a cyber certification before I start applying but not sure how much longer I can stay in IT

like

Any thoughts on the 75 Hard challenge? I’ve started seeing it circulate on social media again and I’m interested to give it a try (I do better working out and eating well in a framework). But, I’m not sure I love how rigid the program is - seems like it could be setting you up for a bad relationship with your diet and/or exercise.

like

For those who have done the Maldives or Bora Bora - what are your thoughts and advice?

like

Multiple openings EY

Post Photo
like

Is it ok to wear sport coat/blazer for interview requiring professional dress instead of a suit jacket? I don’t currently have a suit with me.

like

Looking to apply to a top 15 MBA to transition to IB/PE with 4YOE in risk consulting + CPA + masters in Accounting. I’m wondering if my graduate degree + CPA can demonstrate enough academic rigor to waive the gmat during the application process? Any thoughts?

like

Feel really conflict about getting an mba, currently make 120k at Moody’s as a credit analyst (I am 28 and been working here for 5 years now). I want to break into tech (not sure what role, I think either a product role or strategy). Do ppl think an mba is worth it for me? And do I need an mba, or not really?

like

Pls DM if interested

Post Photo
like

I want to do low / no carbs but trying to figure out how I can hit my minimum calorie intake.. so what healthy fatty food can I eat without going crazy on carbs?

like

My two dogs are trying to help me get some likes so I can send DMs for any entry level strategy consultant roles.

Post Photo
likeuplifting

What would be ideal salary for i grade with 11 years of experience at BNYM corporate IT BU?

like

Anyone from EY parthenon Dubai who’s willing to chat and guide me on the process there.

like

What is a good ratio of billable hours to total hours?

Obviously the "ideal" is 100%, but as the junior attorney at a small firm, I'm do the guy taking all the prospective client cold calls, and it can seriously cut into my day.

My goal has been to spend at least 75% of my time on billable work. Reasonable?

like

Someone I matched with, is pushing me to meet the next day. I don’t like to meet super soon unless we know each other at least for a week and now she is mad. How do you deal with pushy people?

like

Is it normal for brand side to be less process focused? Genuinely think agencies I’ve been at prior had to function like an assembly line in some way for accounts to be justified. But I liked this, holds everyone accountable.

Brand side seems so “chill” but like too chill.

like

I have an offer to join Visa Inc Bangalore location. Need help to understand the policies and work culture and yearly hike and other details Anyone working at @visa please help me on this.Visa

like

Anyone ever denied a reimbursement for not using amex to pay a hotel bill?

like

Who needs American Airlines system wide upgrades?

like

Additional Posts in Pharma and Health Advertising

Other than trial and error and general experience, what have been your best resources for learning about industry rules and regulations and advising clients when they make requests outside of that?
All my clients have regulatory and legal experts in house, but I find that sometimes hierarchical politics and upper management can stop them from fully embracing that role. After watching the parts of Dopesick relating to the ad agency, I feel like it wouldn’t hurt to brush up on my knowledge… TIA!

like

When the job application asks if you can work nights and weekends.

Um, so we're at that point of the relationship already!?

funny

Can I get a like if you’d rather be compensated for staying where you are, rather than make a buck by jumping to a different ship?

like

Gathering some research for a brief: what do you miss the most about being in the office, if anything hahaha

like

Has anyone made a separate tab for their pharma work in their site index vs including with non pharma work on the homepage?

like

Hiring account roles from AE to Director. HCP and DTC offerings (including tv). DM me for more info.

What are people’s thoughts, opinions, whatever on AbelsonTaylor?

like

Recently got an internal promotion to Assoc. Strat director and thinking I got shafted on compensation. What’s the going rate for NYC these days? 7 years experience, 5 in pharma. 135-140k?

like

Is it better/more fulfilling to be on the agency or client side? Why? (I've only been on the agency side so far.)

like

Thoughts on jumping to a small independent agency? I'm leaving a small-ish agency where I was only working on one massive account, hoping to get more exposure to different therapeutic areas and more interesting projects.
Had offers for bigger name agencies as well, but went with my gut to the small agency. Mistake?

like

Any agencies we know of that have tried or are planning to try bringing remote employees back to office? Is there any way around it if you don't want to?

like

How do you feel about digital strategists in pharma given how complacent pharma is about advanced digital? Should this be creatives job?

like

Creatives who have done launches - how do you present your work in your book? Doubt anyone wants to see all 25 or so things I worked on but want to show the breadth.

like

I'm an SVP/strategist with 25 yrs exp., but only 3 years in healthcare. I'm being recruited for a GSVP "account leadership" role (i.e., not on the strategy team) for two big unbranded campaigns. It sounds great, they know my med/reg comms exp. is very light, and I think I can do the job, but: Is there a real future for me on the account side if, at GSVP level, I still haven't done much meg/reg? Would this be the end of the line for me, with limited mobility because my expertise is too narrow?

like

Thoughts on accepting a copy position at Harrison and Star? Can’t get a read based off online reviews, but I know the people I’d be working with and really like them.

like

What's the medical writer salary range in the US? Is 100K about right?

like