I failed as a elder brother. After dad expired 5 years ago in India, i took responsibility of 2 of my younger siblings and got them married to good households (at least that’s what I thought).. just when I was thinking that I was able to fill my dad’s shoes and life was getting back to normal. Both marriages are falling apart. My sister is close to being divorced and my brother is planning to apply for a divorce. In both cases, a lapse of judgement from me and other elders who helped me with it

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Their life their choices. You're just a supporting tool.
You did your best based on your knowledge at that point of time. Let it go and be supportive to your siblings on their life choices

like

OP, my friend. Don’t put this on yourself. You meant well. And secondly, do you realize you are kinda thinking about this the wrong way as well? Divorce is not the end of life. It happens. You learn from it and move on. Is it easy? Not at all. Can you survive it and get things back on track? Absolutely. Our Desi society makes you believe you are a failure for literally everything they can find lacking in your life. So let them say what they want. They will never make you feel happy.

Go support your siblings through this tough time. Help them put their life back together. Stand up and protect them. Tell them it’s okay. And you know what- focus on how this will make you all stronger as a family. Your Dad will love you for it.

And please seek professional help if you have thoughts of giving up.

like
Recent IconRecent

Sorry to hear about this. Hopefully this is an eye opener for you about the toxic, disgusting traits of our desi culture. The whole concept of “buss shaadi karas do jaldi se chaahe kuch bhi ho” is a big pile of dogsh**.

All of that said: don’t ask your Dad to call you to him. Don’t give up on life. Sure your siblings are going through a rough patch at the moment; talk to them and give them the strength and will power to emerge from this and build a better future in life.

like

I am devastated. Dad always used to tell me - it’s a cruel world. None of the family members realized how protected we were. I don’t know if we can ever recover from this. Dad - You left too soon! This world is evil. Can’t deal with it. Please take all of us with you.

like

OP! I feel you! Divorces are pretty common in India. It’s just a marriage, imagine your sister and brother having to live with their spouses and being unhappy!

As I said, divorces are getting pretty common in India! Your siblings can easily find other partners if they intend to do that. Don’t be too hard on yourself, you did the best that you could with the circumstances you were in.

like

Life is unfair and people are bad but family is what keeps us together. I made many mistakes and fights with my wife but in the end she and my mom are the ones who support me regardless. I never understood the concept of immediate family in US where only your spouse and children are immediate but the rest are not but now I feel that maybe correct and include parents in it too. But anyone apart from those are not someone you can reply on. Hang in there and don't beat yourself up. Your siblings are adults who made their own decisions

like

OP - I’m genuinely pained to read this, and just wanted to give you a hug 🤗. Don’t be so hard on yourself. I’m sure you did your part with goodwill as the elder brother, and honestly that is all you can do. Sending prayers and well wishes your way!

like

OP - I am sorry to hear about this. I don’t mean to cross-question but are you sure these divorces are because of errors in judgment of character and not because of normal spousal fights that got out of control? If it’s the latter, there’s nothing you could have done about it. In the former case, while I don’t know your family dynamics, did you brother and sister not have say in who they got married to?

like

Yeah OP - I agree with SA1 above. I can’t imagine what you are going through right now but sometimes there’s nothing more that can be done and we have to make peace with that.

likehelpful

Op, better to get divorced than to be in toxic relationships. If not now, at some point they will thank you for your support. I hope and pray that you all come out stronger than before. Have faith, it will all work out at the end. And this has nothing to do with you.

like

OP-- you have done your part. Don't beat yourself up to this. The world runs this way

like

Well you did best , you don’t control everything so chill.

D2 - I am sure you meant well but to tell an individual who has lost their parent and has 2 siblings going through an extremely turbulent time to ‘chill’ is not right and if I may say, even comes across as very insensitive. OP needs help and guidance from folks who can tell him that sometimes there’s nothing more we can do.

like

OP - life is barely 2% of what you expect it to be and 98% what is destined … I’m sure it’s difficult for both families.. No point in blaming yourself and other family.. failed marriage doesn’t necessarily mean failed life.. it could be betterment of all people

Cheer up.. this is a phase and this shall pass too… nothing is permanent in this universe be it sorrow.. be it happiness.. be it wealth or life itself

If this was a situation, what would your dad do? Probably get some marriage counseling for your siblings? Do your best as your dad would and let the rest be in god’s hands.

OP, sending some warm hugs and positive wibes to you bud. Now please go easy on yourself as it’s not your fault as sometimes things have to happen the way they are.

Like everyone said above, you have played your father’s role and did your best for your siblings. But this is something that even your father couldn’t have controlled. Don’t blame yourself brother.. please stay positive

Op - don’t be hard on yourself! You/parents can’t and shouldn’t be responsible for managing others marriage. Your siblings are adult and they should be responsible for their marriages.

I grew up in a similar environment like you describe.
Divorce is bad, but not the end of the world. Its hard to comprehend why but divorce rate is much higher than what it is used to be, so cannot be completely attributed to yours or anyone's error in judgement. Its just a different world now.
You can only control you efforts( which you already did), but you cannot control the results.
Different people are faced with different challenges, some go through divorce, some face health issues, financial etc, there not one easier than the other and some have more than one.
Sorry I am going on here! but I feel the pain.
Keep your head up and your family together, you will find the courage to face and overcome life's challenges. Don't give Up, your dad will smile.

Lovely to see everyone’s supportive comments! I needed this today!

Feel better OP! ❤️‍🩹

You can’t predict marriage outcome. My close friend dated for 10 years before tying the knot and their parents were best friends since college. However, my friend got divorced after 2 years.

You did way more than what some other siblings would have done. 🤗

You are being hard on yourself my friend. There are so many factors to keep a marriage going and you cannot put all your blame on yourself.

Tough times never last…only tough people last

Related Posts

Hi everyone, first timer here. Having some issues w. our 4 yo being pushed around and bullied at preschool. He’s really sad and upset. He’s also super shy & introvert. Any advise? Pep talk? Discuss with teacher?

Anyone suffer relationship/dating problems during busy season?

like

My kids were really upset with me when I told them that my job as an engineer did not mean that I drove trains for a living

like

Anyone have a spouse who isn't in their field and feel like it would be more interesting if both of you were in the same line of work?

I don't know if this is a symptom of quarantining but I'm just bored by the day to day banter we share about our kids and family. There's no thought provoking conversation that happens and any initiation from my side just gets dismissed. We enjoyed watching TV together but I haven't had time to do that for the last few months.

like

So my fiancé and I are having a microwedding in Rocky Mountain National Park next year, and we’re working with an elopement planner.
She sent over a sample ceremony (intro, sweet poems + passages to be read, and example vows), and we read through it last night. I was reading it out loud while my fiancé made dinner, and it just hit me that this is really happening. I’m just really happy that I found someone who is willing to take a vow to spend his life with me and I’m so excited for that day :)

like

Been single for nearly 10 years now; completely transformed my life and cannot wait to finally share it with a man. Sharing out loud so it happens faster.

likeuplifting

So how do I make friends in Boston?

funnylike

How do you all ask parents for supplies without bagging them constantly?

like

Anyone have a good way to actually see younger (9/10 year olds) student work when completing their math problems in real time while teaching virtually. I'm struggling with knowing what/if they are doing at home. Holding up dry erase boards to the screen is hard and time consuming!

like

Making new friends pool side

Post Photo
like

Today I have officially made the decision to stop taking any and all cases that involve children. I feel like a huge weight has been lifted!! I just had to share with other professionals that understand. Yes, this will be a financial blow, but I’m fine with it.

like

After 2.5 years of long-term relationship, I finally find a job in my boyfriend's country and able to live with him in 2 months. I am always a cat person but my boyfriend doesn't get it. But he agrees we can adopt one once we live together. I was wondering what are the things that I need to make him aware of before having a cat to set the expectation?

like

Reached out to an ex after not being in contact for 4 years. Said “Hi, I hope all is well.” No response. Intention was not to get back together (we’re both married now), more to mend fences since we were good friends once upon a time. Was reaching out a mistake?

like

Thought would put this out there
43 M Persian/Syrian/East Indian Mutt - born and raised in East Africa.
Looking for a serious long term relationship - distance isn't an issue for now - willing to relocate/move. Looking to start a family (fur babies or adoptions are viable options) I know this bowl doesn't usually trend that way - but am thinking there maybe someone else out there that feels the same way.

like

My best work friend is leaving, how do I cope :(? They were by far the closest person I had at the firm. I’m happy for them and I know I’ll build the relationships I have with others, just sucks..

like

To those of you resistant to family cars - I’m a sports car driving, fast car loving, low to the ground kind of mom-to-be. (e.g. no back seat, no back doors). Obvi I need to get a new car but what isn’t too large, makes sense for a 3 person family (no more kids coming), while not sacrificing my need for speed and desire for a smaller/low to the ground/well handling ride? So far considering an S4 /S5, 3 or 4 series. Back doors seems to be a requirement for getting in and out of a car seat huh!🙄

like

Told a friend she did “monkey work” as a “junior pm” and she stopped talking to me for the foreseeable future. 🤔

like

December feels like a country song. Two dogs died on the 1st. A hard rain exposed latent roof damage and collapsed ceiling in two rooms. Stove, fridge and water heater all went out on the same day last week. Yesterday my spouse said they needed a break from the chaos through the holidays and left. Today a positive covid test. And 7 deals trying to close before year end requiring my full attention so none of the aforementioned can get any attention.

Associates, don’t let this become you.

likehelpful

Is HSBC client demand for work from office as my location is transferred from Kolkata to shivaji nagar without my approval or prior information? I have reasons to stay nearby my native place to take care of my parents. Please help me with this scenario.

like

Salam, I was in a 3Y relationship, it’s been few months, I live alone. Don’t have tons of friend so I find myself lonely after work. I burst in tears randomly multiple times a week and I cry out loud. I also have constant dreams of her most of the time normal dreams. I feel like I have little life left since I’m 39, I don’t have any direction in life. I try to pray 5 times and started to recite Quran. Any advice for me pls? I don’t have peace in my heart and I feel very empty inside.

like

More Posts

Has anyone experienced an exit where the newly emitted shares (primary) and shares bought by the founders (secondary) are valued differently? Is this common practice? What’s a typical valuation ratio? We have a potential investor who wants to structure the deal like this.

likehelpful

Hey guys! Looking for a male flatmates for a lavishly furnished house in Fortaleza, Kalyani nagar. The available room is furnished with ac and a single bed. Rest of house has appliances and furniture too.
Total rent: 52k
Room rent: 16k
Possession from August 1st

I’m a new grad hire (7 months) in the OCM consulting space. I’m passionate about change management and communication strategy. I've been reading, googling, and perusing anything I can get my hands on about OCM, including old OCM deliverables and our current methodology. My People Manager told me that OCM is a journey when it comes to understanding it and that a lot of that knowledge is gained through just experience. Does anyone have any tips they’ve gained in their OCM journey to share?

like
like

Hello Folks!!!
My Friend (Fresher) has an offer
from Persistent Systems Limited as a Trainee (IT Infra) ,They have offered 1.8 LPA during the training for 6m ,they haven't given any proper job profile after the trainee period, neither they have mentioned any sal increment or next job profile after 6 month ,
Can anyone help me understand the scenarios here if anyone previously faced the same ,or maybe an insider explain something more about it ?

Post Photo

Partner told us to be careful about sharing our salaries with each other. Says we may find out someone’s getting paid more than us but we don’t know what their production is like. I officially spat out my kool-aid.

likefunnyuplifting

Tuesday Wordle 325 5/6

⬛⬛⬛🟨⬛
⬛⬛🟨⬛⬛
⬛🟨🟨⬛🟨
🟨🟩⬛🟨⬛
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩

like

How’s the WLB at Shopee looks like for their strat team? I heard it’s a sweatshop

like

For those who have lateraled, how much did you end up billing in your last week?

like

Thoughts on including certificates like Prosci or SHRM-SCP in an email signature? I don’t like it right after my name, but I’ve seen some other alternatives (like putting the digital badge icons) - what looks the best?

like

Hello folks,

I am working as an AI/ML Developer for past two years leveraging AWS cloud. I have total experience of two years. I am looking for a change. Can anyone help me with the referrals?

like

MBA admit here and have to put down a deposit soon, having serious cold feet right now due to the covid situation and potentially having to start virtually. Would love any perspective on how it's been particularly socially and what your schools' outlook on the fall is

like

I have a MHA, MBA, and BSHA. I’m wanting to get into a supervisor or manger role but I don’t have the experience. Does anyone have any suggestions on how I dive in and start getting the experience I need? I live in Washington and work in Oregon. Also, anything using my MBA would be favored as well, this degree is not healthcare specific. Thank you!

like

I'm pretty early in my career and already feeling burnt out. I love what I do, and I'm happy to be here, but I don't honestly know if I can keep up. Does anyone have advice or has been through this?

like

Is anyone using Wonders ?

Anyone have to determine collecting consent- both affirmative and negative (obviously stop at the no)? Can not find any directive or recital in GDPR/ or upcoming ePrivacy to decide on this paradox! Ie. Collecting 'no's' is or could be an important record of stop/start consent.

Looking for case/precedent or thoughts!

Ever tried Googling or even searching legal dBases for consent? Man- I don't need spanking and consensual yes v no consents for sex!

like

Anyone consulted a psychiatrist for lack of work motivation? How was it and is it worth it? I'm in a slump and not performing at the level I want to. I feel I'm running on half throttle.

like

Anyone willing to share Tumi or Lulu discount codes?

like

Hello folks,

When do we get appraisal letter? On last day of month or it can be before last day also?

like

Good afternoon all. I've just started up a new company doing web apps, websites, eccomerce agency, branding and digital marketing. I was wondering if anyone has any good insights on how to get more leads in these areas of work?

like

Additional Posts in Desi Consultants

Hey hey all
Planning a destination wedding in goa this October.
Any tips or tricks on how we ensure not to get ripped off ?
2 days, interfaith (Catholic and Hindu), at a resort, want to keep it non flashy but classy, 150 people.

like

I feel like I’m one of the only American-born Indians who is actually religious and enjoys going to the temple

like

Has anyone has applied for a Chilean tourist visa with an Indian passport while living in the US? Do you need to go in person for an interview or visa stamping?

like

Ok, we talk about getting desi names butchered by videsis. We have an Anandraj in our midst. And at least once in a day, he is called Anda-Raj or Andha-Raj by desis (by mistake) 😆

funnylike

Canada thread - folks who moved up north can you share your last US city, Base + bonus in USD, Company, Canadian city you moved to and CAD salary, company? Challenges and successes?

like

As a person of Bangaldeshi origin, I am so glad we got free in 71. I see the different trajectories of the two countries and could not be more proud of my fellow Bangladeshi folks who focused on education, economic growth, independent policy and democracy as opposed to religious fanaticism, subservience to China and army rule / banana republic . The results in GDP growth, currency strength and rule of democratic law.

likefunnysmart