{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "I have a student who did nothing the whole term, but passed the final exam with a 79. Should I pass him?", "post_id": "5ef7673de746e4001aa84524", "reply_count": 324, "vote_count": 134, "bowl_id": "5c751b9f2f6b98001bc666f8", "bowl_name": "Teachers", "feed_type": "crowd" }

I have a student who did nothing the whole term, but passed the final exam with a 79. Should I pass him?

likefunnyupliftinghelpfulsmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I am going to relate with personal experience here. When I was in school, I was light years ahead of my classmates in the subjects that interested me. These were related to History, Civics, Government, and basic science. I also showed a somewhat natural affinity with the English language related to sentence structure and usage, causing me to develop an expanded vocabulary. The only thing is, I was bored with the routine work and most of the time I wouldn't even do the homework. I would read several chapters ahead of my classmates because I could also read very fast. This would frustrate my classmates and teachers because I would then sit in class and read library books. It appeared that I didn't do anything but then I would do very well on the tests related to the subjects that I liked. Eventually, my choice to not apply myself to all of my school work caught up with me and caused me to not score well in my high school grades. Perhaps the student learns differently like I did and creative ways to keep the student engaged need to be developed?

like

I proudly teach elementary special education and have the same returning students. I get to have my students for up to 5 years if they start with me at TK. Students with exceptionalities (not disabilities), have the capacity to learn and absorb content without producing work. Non-sped students have those abilities as well. I've been completely astonished to see so many of my students making leaps of progress amidst distance learning for almost a year now. Non-readers and emerging readers are reading now. 👏🏼 They're engaged and anxious to participate. Like many of you, I've been exposed to the home life of my students during 'unmute' time. Tragic 😔 If some parents cannot give their child a space and environment to learn in, how can I expect them to even do my assignments? I rely on the relationship I have with my students to get them to do what I know they can do. Pass him because he passed the final and has absorbed your content. He's shown knowledge. Some students aren't even learning anything at home; he has. Unfortunately, not all of our students have the support or environment that exists in the 4 walls of a teacher's classroom to produce work. As educators, it is imperative that we do not forget that.

likeuplifting

Relationship with students is absolutely the key to their success! I love the fact that I have my students for multiple years and yes all of my students I consider my children. In my experience most students long for the teacher that thinks of them as more than just another student. They long for the teacher that sees they are more than they appear to be. All students need us (teachers) to believe in his or her abilities to become someone extraordinary! Every student has the potential to exceed greatness and make awesome contributions to our world! We just have to believe in them so that they can begin to believe too!

like
Recent IconRecent

You need to think about that student. Some students, there are a few, they don’t need to do work and they just do well on tests. If they know the information and they know the information. are you grading on the work done, turned in, or whether they know the material?

likesmarthelpfuluplifting

Reading this, a thought came to mind, that it is important to know the material, but also to a lesser extent, it's important that a student is willing to do work assigned, like when they get a job. So a small portion of the grade can be related to work done. Thus they can never get an A if they were uncooperative to not do work assigned, but could potentially get a B for knowledge grasp?

likesmart

Might as well...this school year was a big joke! LOL

likesmartfunny

If that student genuinely passed the test no cheating, then they have the knowledge whether they studied the teacher's lesson or they just know it. Are you grading them on the work they did or whether they know the subject?

like

Some classes in college gave the option to take the final exam before classes began and, if passed, would enable the student to receive credit for the class without attending. Pass the kid. Congratulate him for passing the exam 💕

likesmart

What are you grading? Compliance or knowledge? If he fails isn’t it ultimately a behavior grade? Also, what’s a 79% a C?

like

Absolutely!

likefunny

The student was able to pass the final, so that means they learned something. But I think we don’t know the whole story. Depending on the subject and whether the other assignments that were not done, things that build knowledge to pass the test? Were they completely unrelated? Do you think they cheated? What is the “thing” that makes you feel like they didn’t earn a passing grade? Also what were the objectives and requirements for passing the class? In the end, with just the information you gave it sounds like they passed and you can enjoy your summer!

likesmartuplifting

THANK YOU

In my opinion, our job is to make sure our students receive an education and can be a productive person in society. If they passed the test then they learned the content. If they didn’t do the work, they didn’t need to prove they knew the work to themselves. When that student gets out into the real world and has demands on them and doesn’t follow through they will learn the hard way, but they will learn. I would give them the passing grade.

likehelpful

Do you want to stand by your principles or save a lot of problems from entitled parents and hope you sleep at night?

likesmart

Those decisions are out of my pay grade.

funnylikesmart

We were told that NO student is to fail during COVID-19. I had 4 students with grades varying from 18-32, they all passed with a 60. I was forced to “give” them a passing grade.

likeupliftingfunny

I was asked to pass a student with 8% because at 14, she was pregnant, covid and everyone felt sorry for her. She didn’t do but 8% of her work. I did not pass her. How could I ? Others worked their butts off and did pass.

like

The 79 means he has acquired the knowledge needed to pass the course. He passes

like

I understand your frustration! My administration is backing us up! During the semester, I called home and I bent over backwards to help my virtual students. I am failing a student with. 68 average. I was worried I would get some flack. I went to an administrator prepared. I advised number of missing assignments and late assignments. She told me to stop worrying. That kid earned that 68.

likeupliftinghelpful

There are 18 weeks in a semester. If you give 1 assignment a day, that's 90. Even if they have a day off, 4 days a week would be 72. Are you suggesting that students should only be held accountable for 2-3 assignments per week?

likeuplifting

Yes! Please. It’s a pandemic! Everyone should pass period.

like

Yes. Student showed mastery.

like

I conducted pre-tests to my level 1 foreign language students in an all remote learning format this semester. I told my students that the pre-test was for no grade. The average score was 75%! In a pre-test?! With that average I might as well just start teaching them level 2 content! I have conducted the same pre-test in my in-person classes for the last 10 years and the average was never above 15%. To those here who recommend "not to asumme anything" I would say it would be VERY naive not to! To those who say that this student "acquired the knowledge to pass the class", I would say "No s/he didn't!". Students are cheating shamelessly in this virtual online environment! My recommendation to my colleague here: don't give students a multiple choice test or exam that they can Google the answers for. Create skill-knowledge-evidence-project based assessments with rubrics that delineate clear expectations where the students have to show work, effort, creativity, and above all demonstrate the set of skills that you expect to see achieved in your test/exam. Make your students work for it! Make them realize that Googling their way up to graduation is useless and that US teachers are much smarter than that!

like

Well said. The kid may well have googled their test answers for 10 minutes and went back to his x-box for the rest of the night. COVID teaching has been a struggle for all of us, but are still supposed to be teaching, even if it is life skills (aka working) above content.

like

Did the student demonstrate that they mastered the learning objectives? If so then yes you should pass them. The grade should reflect their level of understanding content material.

like

If your test is truly designed to prove mastery of the curriculum then you absolutely should. Assignments are designed as practice to assist in mastering the curriculum. If you think your final isn’t a great measure of mastery then that’s a different story.

like

Best answer yet!

So students are like that you think she or he not learning but they are this is your doing so I would pass him You a great teacher because this student was able to learn when you thought he or she wasn’t

like

I’m sure what you wrote is very important and I’d love the opportunity to understand but what you wrote is incoherent, I’m sorry. Can you add punctuation to help advance your thoughts?

I didn’t fail any students for the final quarter, regardless of work done. It was a hard choice for some students, but ultimately I decided that I didn’t know what their home lives were like, what they were dealing with at home, or what.

likeuplifting

I put all the grades in the computer just like the student earned them. If the student passes, great. If admin wants to pass them (which usually happens), that's great too. I don't pass or fail students. I just put the grades in. I believe in giving all students the grades they earn because life and the workforce is a lot about showing up and doing the work. I feel I am doing students a disservice if I give them grades they don't earn. With that said, I often let students redo work they did poorly on. I teach Math and simple mistakes often cause students to miss problems. I want to give them every opportunity to pass while taking responsibility and doing the work.

like

So you really aren’t a teacher. You are simply a reporter.

Yes! Assuming the final exam is an indcator of what you intended for them to learn. In my earlier years of teaching I would not have been able to see that tree through forrest. But I have since learned that many times daily work is really for those who need the practice. If said student understands enough to earn a 79 then by all means they should be pass the class. It does not address the issue of "responsibility" but is the grade intended to reflect citizenship or content?

like

Should we be assessing responsibility? Most teachers don’t teach it. They just mark students down for not demonstrating it.

Related Posts

The last show you watched represents the theme for your classroom this year. What is it?

likefunny

What is your max class size for the year? Is that number based on a virtual or in person classroom?

like

Warning! This post contains vocabulary that some might find offensive. Please scroll past if you feel it might disturb you. I was called upon to read aloud from this book "Allegedly", which has been given rave reviews, during a break between lessons in a 7th grade math class. I'm a former Marine and correctional officer so blushing isn't a thing for me. I read it aloud. I welcome all opinions and am especially interested in views in support of this novel, which would not have been my choice.

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Well, our district found a COVID loophole and are exploiting it. They get to determine whether or not we are considered a “close contact” or not with a positive student. And because they told us to “never be within 6’ of a student for 15 minutes or longer” (in a tiny classroom with 28 JH students), they’re justifying that if we test positive “despite their efforts”, it’s on us, not the district, so they won’t cover any medical costs or give us the Covid days off. Talk about feeling expendable.

likehelpfulfunny

My daughter just attended a new teacher workshop at a ROE. A Superintendent presented (not hers) and told this room full of new teachers, “Real teachers get to school at 7:00 am and go home at 8:00 pm.” Really?? As a veteran teacher of 26 years, I was appalled! Makes sense why new teachers are leaving the classroom in their first five years and why we have a teacher shortage in Illinois with those type of expectations.

likefunny

As a trans I struggled during this time of the year. My obligation to discuss how hedonist this whole Valentine’s Day is and how it celebrates disproportionately cisgender relationships without ANY regard of that impact on the non cis or transitioning or RE transitioning people. It’s important the feelings of those who are not sure of their gender status into consideration when planning group activity. Especially for students who have not decided to reveal..

likefunny

What do you all do when you are going through stuff (mental health wise) outside of the classroom. Teaching is a profession where you always have to be "on". What do we do if we are anxious/depressed?

like

What are some good foundations I can reach out to for classroom resources?

like

Hello Everyone, I’m was trying to help some of our secondary RSP teachers determine what they can do with their student’s during LAB/ Study Skills Class. Some of my ideas included: Work on incomplete classwork or homework, work on goals, study for test and quizzes, work on projects, goal setting for the next semester, organize google classroom assignments or practice for the state exams. If they are other ideas I would love to hear them! Thanks everyone

like

Do you consider your teaching a ministry? How do you do Gods work in the classroom?

likehelpful

What is your max class size for the year? Is that number based on a virtual or in person classroom?

like

Anyone use edgenuity? I'm starting Monday with students, never been trained, no guidance. Don't know how to set expectations if I don't know. ice breaker ideas? I'm not in my classroom.. media center.

“If you’re not sweating by first hour, you’re not teaching”, “Don’t let me walk in the room and see you a$$ sitting down”, “ You should leave everyday exhausted” just a few quotes from our new academic supervisor. I find these extremely offensive, but since this is a supervisor any advice on how to handle this situation?

likefunnyhelpful

Dry erase magnetic board We might be virtual and I would like to get an affordable, large enough dry erase board. Has any one used the panel from Home Depot? Has any one used dry erase paint? Stick on a wall with sticky back? Is there a place that's affordable? One that will deliver undamaged goods? I think I need to create a classroom in my house. I know most is on the computer if we are virtual. Just in case. Thanks

likehelpful

What are your school policies on classroom parties (ie: Halloween, Xmas, Valentines)? Given increases to absences, school closures & teacher planning days, any in-person instructional time with students is crucial. I think we should try to avoid activities that aren’t part of curriculum. The Vday party is set & will happen. I also don’t like that is held in morning instead of end of day. It’s held on a short day so combined with recess & lunch, 1 hr party is a lot to take away from class time.

funny

Has anyone tried using a QR code for classroom sign out? Has it worked for you or just become a pain?

like

Homework... it’s my worst nightmare in the classroom. I have to give it but have flexibility in creating my own policy. Please share what you give, how you collect, and/or grade!! THANKS!

like

tomorrow I begin my first teaching job, it is first grade and I have had no time to prep. School started almost 2 weeks ago I need ideas for classroom management and math centers. Any help?

This is my 7th year of teaching. I’ve been experiencing job burnout since my 3rd year. I know I need to do something else. I don’t think classroom teaching is ‘it’ for me. Did anyone else go through this? What did you end up doing?

like

Am I the only one who doesn't understand why teachers refer to the students as "friends"?

likefunnysmart

Additional Posts

But once again not posting

like

Post for likes

like

How does this sound?

like

Ahh it is posting but into middle of feed as opposed to top.

like

Another reason not to fly southwest: have the A1 boarding pass and there are 15 "pre boards".

like

Is it wrong or weird to want to find a easier job and settle down in a small city? I think I might be happier to do a 9-5 job, cook for myself and play some sports every day. The desire for success has shrunk significantly since I started working a year ago. Have you experienced similar emotions?

likehelpful
like

Do foreigners have to work extra hard in order to gain the same achievement in America? Or the government usually favors foreigners for diversity purposes?

funnylike

From a career progression standpoint how does this look Associate Analyst-> Consultant-> Senior Analyst? I’ve had 3 Jobs in 3 YOE and have accepted a Sr Analyst job in industry at a Fortune 50 in Corporate Strategy. The first 2 were in different areas but want to makes sure I’m showing career progression with this next move.

Best heels for walking/being on your feet all day?

like

Anybody ever transition from a mostly delivery role to a pure sales role within consulting? Pros/cons? What motivated your move? ~5 YOE in healthcare. Considering ACN but also curious for recommendations for other great healthcare-focused firms/practices. Thanks!

like

Project is asking me to travel the week my wife is due to have a baby or else get an exemption from HR. Is this normal or is my firm just not supportive? KPMG if anyone is looking to join.

likefunnyhelpfuluplifting

Recommendations for economical movers in NYC? Moving from a Manhattan mini storage location to another location in the city itself.

like

My carry on luggage is beat up and smells of vinegar and salt after many trips across arctic cities this winter. Manual scrubbing can only go so far. Best way to revitalize my withering luggage back?

likefunny

Anyone have a go-to resource for cracking strategy/growth case interviews? I’m not a consultant but the jobs I’m applying for all have case interviews and I keep falling short of them. Unfortunately I don’t receive feedback so its hard to improve… any consultants have any recommendations? Sample question could be: How would you 5x revenue in a new vertical (ghost kitchens) within 1 year?

like

Does anyone regret getting a Rimowa luggage set? I have mixed feelings about my current Tumi soft shell carry-on and suitcase, but can’t make up my mind on aluminum or poly

like

Just got moved to nyc office. Look to live in Hoboken or Manhattan?

like

Flying in airline with no status, just went from "awaiting seat assignment" to literally last row of the plane. WHY IS THIS HAPPENING TO ME #pleb

like

Can anyone speak to the expert path at BCG? is it well supported career path? Is a senior advisor role also on that same track?

like

Are any of the Indian firms on FB?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal