{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "I have a student who did nothing the whole term, but passed the final exam with a 79. Should I pass him?", "post_id": "5ef7673de746e4001aa84524", "reply_count": 324, "vote_count": 134, "bowl_id": "5c751b9f2f6b98001bc666f8", "bowl_name": "Teachers", "feed_type": "crowd" }

I have a student who did nothing the whole term, but passed the final exam with a 79. Should I pass him?

likefunnyupliftinghelpfulsmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I am going to relate with personal experience here. When I was in school, I was light years ahead of my classmates in the subjects that interested me. These were related to History, Civics, Government, and basic science. I also showed a somewhat natural affinity with the English language related to sentence structure and usage, causing me to develop an expanded vocabulary. The only thing is, I was bored with the routine work and most of the time I wouldn't even do the homework. I would read several chapters ahead of my classmates because I could also read very fast. This would frustrate my classmates and teachers because I would then sit in class and read library books. It appeared that I didn't do anything but then I would do very well on the tests related to the subjects that I liked. Eventually, my choice to not apply myself to all of my school work caught up with me and caused me to not score well in my high school grades. Perhaps the student learns differently like I did and creative ways to keep the student engaged need to be developed?

like

I proudly teach elementary special education and have the same returning students. I get to have my students for up to 5 years if they start with me at TK. Students with exceptionalities (not disabilities), have the capacity to learn and absorb content without producing work. Non-sped students have those abilities as well. I've been completely astonished to see so many of my students making leaps of progress amidst distance learning for almost a year now. Non-readers and emerging readers are reading now. 👏🏼 They're engaged and anxious to participate. Like many of you, I've been exposed to the home life of my students during 'unmute' time. Tragic 😔 If some parents cannot give their child a space and environment to learn in, how can I expect them to even do my assignments? I rely on the relationship I have with my students to get them to do what I know they can do. Pass him because he passed the final and has absorbed your content. He's shown knowledge. Some students aren't even learning anything at home; he has. Unfortunately, not all of our students have the support or environment that exists in the 4 walls of a teacher's classroom to produce work. As educators, it is imperative that we do not forget that.

likeuplifting

Relationship with students is absolutely the key to their success! I love the fact that I have my students for multiple years and yes all of my students I consider my children. In my experience most students long for the teacher that thinks of them as more than just another student. They long for the teacher that sees they are more than they appear to be. All students need us (teachers) to believe in his or her abilities to become someone extraordinary! Every student has the potential to exceed greatness and make awesome contributions to our world! We just have to believe in them so that they can begin to believe too!

like
Recent IconRecent

You need to think about that student. Some students, there are a few, they don’t need to do work and they just do well on tests. If they know the information and they know the information. are you grading on the work done, turned in, or whether they know the material?

likesmarthelpfuluplifting

Reading this, a thought came to mind, that it is important to know the material, but also to a lesser extent, it's important that a student is willing to do work assigned, like when they get a job. So a small portion of the grade can be related to work done. Thus they can never get an A if they were uncooperative to not do work assigned, but could potentially get a B for knowledge grasp?

likesmart

Might as well...this school year was a big joke! LOL

likesmartfunny

If that student genuinely passed the test no cheating, then they have the knowledge whether they studied the teacher's lesson or they just know it. Are you grading them on the work they did or whether they know the subject?

like

Some classes in college gave the option to take the final exam before classes began and, if passed, would enable the student to receive credit for the class without attending. Pass the kid. Congratulate him for passing the exam 💕

likesmart

What are you grading? Compliance or knowledge? If he fails isn’t it ultimately a behavior grade? Also, what’s a 79% a C?

like

Absolutely!

likefunny

The student was able to pass the final, so that means they learned something. But I think we don’t know the whole story. Depending on the subject and whether the other assignments that were not done, things that build knowledge to pass the test? Were they completely unrelated? Do you think they cheated? What is the “thing” that makes you feel like they didn’t earn a passing grade? Also what were the objectives and requirements for passing the class? In the end, with just the information you gave it sounds like they passed and you can enjoy your summer!

likesmartuplifting

THANK YOU

In my opinion, our job is to make sure our students receive an education and can be a productive person in society. If they passed the test then they learned the content. If they didn’t do the work, they didn’t need to prove they knew the work to themselves. When that student gets out into the real world and has demands on them and doesn’t follow through they will learn the hard way, but they will learn. I would give them the passing grade.

likehelpful

Do you want to stand by your principles or save a lot of problems from entitled parents and hope you sleep at night?

likesmart

Those decisions are out of my pay grade.

funnylikesmart

We were told that NO student is to fail during COVID-19. I had 4 students with grades varying from 18-32, they all passed with a 60. I was forced to “give” them a passing grade.

likeupliftingfunny

I was asked to pass a student with 8% because at 14, she was pregnant, covid and everyone felt sorry for her. She didn’t do but 8% of her work. I did not pass her. How could I ? Others worked their butts off and did pass.

like

The 79 means he has acquired the knowledge needed to pass the course. He passes

like

I understand your frustration! My administration is backing us up! During the semester, I called home and I bent over backwards to help my virtual students. I am failing a student with. 68 average. I was worried I would get some flack. I went to an administrator prepared. I advised number of missing assignments and late assignments. She told me to stop worrying. That kid earned that 68.

likeupliftinghelpful

There are 18 weeks in a semester. If you give 1 assignment a day, that's 90. Even if they have a day off, 4 days a week would be 72. Are you suggesting that students should only be held accountable for 2-3 assignments per week?

likeuplifting

Yes! Please. It’s a pandemic! Everyone should pass period.

like

Yes. Student showed mastery.

like

I conducted pre-tests to my level 1 foreign language students in an all remote learning format this semester. I told my students that the pre-test was for no grade. The average score was 75%! In a pre-test?! With that average I might as well just start teaching them level 2 content! I have conducted the same pre-test in my in-person classes for the last 10 years and the average was never above 15%. To those here who recommend "not to asumme anything" I would say it would be VERY naive not to! To those who say that this student "acquired the knowledge to pass the class", I would say "No s/he didn't!". Students are cheating shamelessly in this virtual online environment! My recommendation to my colleague here: don't give students a multiple choice test or exam that they can Google the answers for. Create skill-knowledge-evidence-project based assessments with rubrics that delineate clear expectations where the students have to show work, effort, creativity, and above all demonstrate the set of skills that you expect to see achieved in your test/exam. Make your students work for it! Make them realize that Googling their way up to graduation is useless and that US teachers are much smarter than that!

like

Well said. The kid may well have googled their test answers for 10 minutes and went back to his x-box for the rest of the night. COVID teaching has been a struggle for all of us, but are still supposed to be teaching, even if it is life skills (aka working) above content.

like

Did the student demonstrate that they mastered the learning objectives? If so then yes you should pass them. The grade should reflect their level of understanding content material.

like

If your test is truly designed to prove mastery of the curriculum then you absolutely should. Assignments are designed as practice to assist in mastering the curriculum. If you think your final isn’t a great measure of mastery then that’s a different story.

like

Best answer yet!

I didn’t fail any students for the final quarter, regardless of work done. It was a hard choice for some students, but ultimately I decided that I didn’t know what their home lives were like, what they were dealing with at home, or what.

likeuplifting

As long as he didn't cheat pass him...

like

Yes

like

I put all the grades in the computer just like the student earned them. If the student passes, great. If admin wants to pass them (which usually happens), that's great too. I don't pass or fail students. I just put the grades in. I believe in giving all students the grades they earn because life and the workforce is a lot about showing up and doing the work. I feel I am doing students a disservice if I give them grades they don't earn. With that said, I often let students redo work they did poorly on. I teach Math and simple mistakes often cause students to miss problems. I want to give them every opportunity to pass while taking responsibility and doing the work.

like

So you really aren’t a teacher. You are simply a reporter.

Related Posts

What strategies do you have in the classroom to combat chronic whining?

like

Anyone use edgenuity? I'm starting Monday with students, never been trained, no guidance. Don't know how to set expectations if I don't know. ice breaker ideas? I'm not in my classroom.. media center.

Do you think your building or classroom is ready to go back to school?

like

Do you think your building or classroom is ready to go back to school?

like

How have you used plickers in the classroom? Is this a daily part of anyone’s lesson?

Post Photo
like

There are several children in my classroom who keep having tech issues. How can I support them without taking away from instruction time?

like

Today I attended a two hour triennial (virtual ) ppt meeting in my own classroom with no sub. I thank God for ear buds, Mike mutes, and my fantastic staff. Did I mention that I teach a self contained class of students with multiple disabilities and complex medical needs. Anyone else ever have to do this? I was never so glad for 3:00 in my life!

like

My daughter will be finishing school and in her own classroom for the first time this fall! I'm getting ahead of myself but I'd love to gift her a big basket of things (tools, supplies, etc) she'll need, especially the stuff that she might not think she'll need, along with just some fun things to help her settle in! I'd love some ideas of things you would've loved to receive when you were starting out?

like

Which would you want? 1. a principle who stays out of everyone’s way and not too engaged in classrooms, people are not too sure what’s expected, and little issues staff brings up don’t get addressed. 2. one who is engaged, presence in felt around the school more, you know what is expected and little things get addressed.

likehelpful

Are you required to come into your building? I'm teaching vitrtually, but 2 days a week I'm required to come into my classroom.

like

I don’t understand dismissal anymore. When I was in K-12 as a student, everyone was dismissed at the same time. Now we have to dismiss the students in “waves.” Having students hanging around a classroom waiting for a bus to be called is just asking for more opportunities for bad behavior. Why does it have to be this way?

like

How do you set up your classroom? What can you tell me about how often you use instruments? What do you do to make them accessible? Thanks so much.

like

Are you required to come into your building? I'm teaching vitrtually, but 2 days a week I'm required to come into my classroom.

like

Can someone explain to me why we aren’t just moving to a school system where 1 teacher can zoom class to 200-300 students like a college lecture hall? Why are we bothering with stuffing kids into classrooms

funnylike

I can't wait to go back to the classroom because....

likehelpful

What are some of your favorite beginning of the year activities for creating a sense of community in your classroom?

like

Elementary teachers are famous for spending a lot on their students and classrooms. Is there anything comparable in Middle and High school that teachers spend their own money on?

likehelpful

What are some of your favorite classroom organization supplies? (Bins, pencil holders, etc.)

like

Who else is nervous about returning to the classroom after our students' covid exposures over winter break??

likesmart

I’m a new 3rd grade SDC teacher on an emergency credential — had never stepped foot in a classroom before last Tuesday. Can anyone offer advice/resources for lesson plan development? Thanks!

Additional Posts

This is looking great!

Post for push testing

like

But once again not posting

like

What are some good companies to work for in Dallas?

Any data point for slalom program manager position comp?

like

In addition to the safety video, everyone should have to watch Jim Jefferies plane etiquette video prior to takeoff

like

Some recent thoughts..! With all the technology and access to our work related stuff even on our phones and other gadgets, do we really ever get off work.??

funnylikeuplifting

Who here has pushed back on weekend work? What was the result?

like

Just screwed up an interview with Apple - but it’s Friday and I can drink my sorrows away, so that’s a win right?

like

Advice for Analyst interviewing at BCG? I’m Canadian and applied to US location.

like

So grossed out by nasty old man (triple my age) at the client site. He came over to where I sit to discuss an issue and his hand "accidentally" falls on my lap! I just got up and walked away

like

[Help]Ex-manager with S&. Was on a passive look out and took a call to take up an industry strategy role on the east coast. 4 months into the profile, feeling anxious given I am now getting calls from MBB firms and have seen a few past S& colleagues jumping the ship. Current role looks promising but unsure if I should have waited. Salary hike ws similar to MBB with better balance Could be shallow thinking around peer comparison but can't help it. Anyone in the same boat or had been - Thoughts?

like

Thinking of moving to a city with a much higher cost of living. Deloitte does not adjust salary at all, right? So even though I live in Chicago, I make around the same as my NYC and SF counterparts?

like

I've heard this rumor and doubt its validity... No one at McKinsey makes slides in PPT. They draw it out on paper, send the picture to an overnight design team, then wake up to beautiful slides.

like

As an associate I feel like I voice some pretty good ideas, but my seniors brush them off only to do something similar down the line. How did you get more senior people to take you seriously?

like

Has anyone here ever pushed for a mid-cycle promotion? I just lead/landed a project that was a huge step-up opportunity for me, and am hoping to apply to b-school in the next round (before next cycle’s promotions would be announced and go into effect). My firm’s done this a handful of times in the past so there’s enough precedent to work with, I’m just not sure how to start the conversation without coming off as pushy or demanding.

like

Just got an offer from Deloitte. Been a great time at Accenture. Time to move on. Senior Manager role

like

did lek give out retention bonuses last year? what were they and to what levels?

like

Sorry to be asking the same question... What is the typical salary range for new PI Senior 1?

Someone please tell me why I spend $400 on shoes ruin/scuff them with less than 3 weeks cumulative wear?! Fuck

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal