{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "I was taking interview today for one of the candidate for my project. That guy already has 4 offers (220% hike) but he wanted to join nagarro because as per him opening in nagarro is more align to his skill set. (Asking for 250 %)\n\nI rejected him without any question. Reason\n\nI know he will be able to ans each and every ques and he might be a good fit for this opening but I know he will not join this company. (40 days left for his notice period)\n\nNot sure if I was right but it was worth it.", "post_id": "61043088a381230020568283", "reply_count": 148, "vote_count": 110, "bowl_id": "5f0372b0eecc0b001af4c310", "bowl_name": "Consulting India", "feed_type": "crowd" }
null

I was taking interview today for one of the candidate for my project. That guy already has 4 offers (220% hike) but he wanted to join nagarro because as per him opening in nagarro is more align to his skill set. (Asking for 250 %)

I rejected him without any question. Reason

I know he will be able to ans each and every ques and he might be a good fit for this opening but I know he will not join this company. (40 days left for his notice period)

Not sure if I was right but it was worth it.

likefunnysmartuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I understand, in today's market condition, prejudices people are blind. They will find ways to justify their point of view.

Where are passionate people will find ways to work things in their favour.

I have met few like these in my life. But the smarter lot made a offer which made sense to me and their company.

Like a one day valid offer, non negotiate joining date, joining bonus, etc. It's OK for recruiters not being aware of all these option. There are many other recruiters know how to work this options.

Tody market is changing very fast, if people don't change fast they will soon be history.

like

There are many things you have to consider here-
1. In technical interview you don't have to ask salary so that you can compare your own salary with that, it is a HR round talks and leave those to them- don't be jealous because he has the ability to get higher pay than you.
2. People go offer shopping because companies like your try to hire candidate underpaid by giving hike on current CTC rather than considering skills- terrible thing in IT industry with their old mindset.
3. You can't just decide that he will join or not, its your mistake as a company that you are unable to provide enough reasons, opportunities and salary to make candidate to join the company- reason being too many people to join in market and company take leverage of them.
4. You fail terribly as a interviewer/senior and clouded in your ego rather than guiding the young generation to right way by giving him the right reason.
5. Worst thing to show off here and saying it was worth it, like you have won something (may be your ego). You don't have any right when you can't help young generation.

Get out of your ego, work on your skills as a interviewer rather than being a judge.

likeupliftingsmarthelpful
Recent IconRecent

OP:It's for people like you that most of the employees are underpaid as per market standards. Please come out of your mindset. It is not up to you to decide your organisation would have given a 220% hike or not. Your job was just to interview him about the job. You failed miserably as an interviewer.

likefunnyhelpfulupliftingsmart

If you wanna reject then why select them for interview in the first place? Please get your requirements aligned with your hr so that they can filter candidates accordingly

OP decided to be judge jury and executioner while his job was to just interview. Probably OP is getting paid peanuts and crying in corner after seeing 4yoe having 16lpa. 😂 What's your company name again OP ??!!😂😂

likefunnyuplifting

Probably OP thought this will be like that linkedIn post to say story for moral values

funnylike

Thats why you shouldn't tell 4 offers.
You should tell just the highest offer.

likefunnysmart

Lesson learnt lol

like

Companies should not offer salary considering what he is getting currently... companies should calculate the employees salary on the basis of the skill sets and total year of experience he has. If someone in your company getting 20 Lacs for same skill set and years of experience then why not he should get the same salary. But the reality is all the companies are corrupt and have zero ethics. Government should make some law where companies cannot ask for current salary of the employees, they should just ask the expectations from the employees. Knowing our current salary gives them extra advantage in the negotiations.

like

There is no need for govt to take any action. These companies who are looking for cheap employee will automatically diminish when all their employee will leave for better options. And they will still be looking for the cheaper and leftovers.

likesmart

Seems u r jealous of the candidate... 😜
Ur job is to take the interview and not to discuss package in technical interview and reject the candidate on the basis of his salary expectations. Grow up!

like

This is going on everywhere, companies won't pay the expected salaries based on your talent, they will pay you based on your current salary or the offer you hold..
This is the reason a candidate has to go through multiple companies and collect so many offers..

Is it wrong to try and maximize your salary ? How often an employee tries to switch.. and all the stress and uncertainties which comes with changing organizations..before securing your first offer , which is already very difficult with 90 days notice..

In this particular case you can't blame the candidate or the interviewer as well...
Both are right in their own perspective..

like

He was tactless in my opinion. Should've told about the highest offer explicitly & not a word about other..😂😂

likesmart

If he was severely underpaid in his last job, this is totally acceptable.

I have seen people work for 3.5L for 3 years with good skills where they can end up getting 10L by interviewing at different places.

This happens because companies pay potential employees what they can least afford and not maximum. In tech, employees are having more grip more than ever before.

Context is needed to judge anyone and at the same time greedy people will always be there.

like

With 4 years I have 18 fixed as package. Let the company decide if they want to give the guy that much money, you are there to just judge his skills nothing more nothing less.

like

Do you guys discuss the compensation part in the regular interview process?
Have interviewed many candidates and its never a part of my job at an interview. Its best left for the HR round. Also its against the guidelines for most firms.

like

Correct

Kindly request everyone criticising OP to try & understand this -

The primary reason for rejecting the candidate was the number of offers in hand and days left in notice period and not the candidate's current or expected CTC.

With 5 offers & 40 days, chances of leveraging OP's offer for a better one was high. Would any one of you hire someone knowing that chances of that candidate joining is relatively low?

like

Totally agree with iOpex. If he had 1 offer and 20 days, won't there be still chances of him trying for other offer? In such case chances are still high 🤣

like

I don't know what's the deal here but I have seen people holding 11 offers 😂 so let the company pay him, its not like you are paying him from your pocket.

likefunny

🥂 to the guy who gets selected for this position & deserves this job desperately.

like

What was his current salary? I know 100-120% is common these days.....but 200+ seems too high

like

He was asking reasonable amount as per experience.
Why you ask and judge as per their current salary??
What if the person was already earning 15 then you would have given him 20+ happily, Isn’t it?

like

Unless you are CEO, It's not your duty to think if he is going to join or not. Let company decides. You just evaluate based on skills. Do only your damn duty

like

Policy differs from organizations to organizations. HR does not always decide these things. In deloitte usi there is a fitment assessment where this can be a ground for dismissal. Decision taken by the manager,not hr.

like

I realise this is frustating for some of you and it's my fault also that I didn't mentioned everything in the post because of word limit. So let me clear out couple of things here instead of replying to each comment.

First, I am not a technical guy and it was not the first round of interview. It was the final round. (I thought, everyone will figure out on their own because mostly salary discussion happened in the last round only)

Second, I am in this industry from last 15 years and HR or higher management has little faith on me so they have given me a power to decide whether to take someone or reject someone atleast for the projects which I am managing or leading.

So Let's end this here.. I am not commenting anymore in this post atleast ☺️☺️

Thank you all for your nice suggestion and comments

likefunny

I guess you did the right thing @Nagarro. Compensation should be proportional to your knowledge and exposure. I just moved to another organization and asked for that much I really deserves at this point of time. Unlike others I would have asked any number that currently i myself know I am not worthy of that.

Quoting a number is not a big of a deal but justifying that number while working in the project is, as whenever the project ends or next recession cycle comes then you(over-weight 😅) might be the first one to be axed from your titles.

It's a long journey, just control your pace guys.

One should always go for counter offer candidates when there is very less time for date of joining otherwise sale of offer letter would continue

like

This is standard (in current scenario) with most of the candidates.
Regarding right or wrong.
I would say,
it is a personal choice to reject him even though the individual can bring value to the role.

But if you feel you did the right thing then you were right he might have done more shopping on top of your offer.

like

OP: It wasn't your job to decide how much he should be paid , your job was to take interview. Let the HRs and management do their job.

like

Rightly said. Because of biased folks like OP people stay underpaid. This affects everyone’s earning potential. No wonder india offers cheap Labor.

likesmart

Maybe not...I doubt any company will give him more than 220% hike..There is a limit ..one cannot just go on grabbing more offers and hike..at this stage companies might just match his highest offer

like

20 to 90? Can you please share the details

And it was worth it???????? Your duty was just to send the profile to next level by mentioning his demand. It was business who would take the decision later. Who were you to reject him because he demanded his expectation?

IT is bad due to guys like you.

like

Related Posts

Anyone else feel like case study questions when you doing lateral moves is a bit pointless. I mean if you were mbb and you made it passed the gauntlet already why have to do it again

like

Mental health issues in our profession are finally being recognized. While mental health issues are not unique to lawyers, the profession and it's client service mantra present unique challenges.

like

Salary for an ACD in Atlanta with 4 years experience?

Thanks to the best client EVER for letting me take a 10 AM flight just because I really wanted to go home early today.

like

Anyone working in Accounting Advisory Services (FAAS/CMAAS/Etc.) has all the travel and client deadlines been hard on your families and significant others?

like

People who've interviewed at Google for cloud security/security Engineer roles, can you please help me out with what kind of open ended questions can I expect in the GCA round?

I heard that GCA questions are role specific.
Thanks in advance!

like

Human Capital Senior Consultant here. Finding I’m completely over Consulting and don’t feel connected/motivated. Any exit opps in startup/tech world for change management/internal comms skill set?

Promotions reduced due to covid and found out I’m being held back on my senior promotion (Canada). I’ve been on the fence about leaving for a while, and this may be it. Do you think it makes sense to take my accounting experience over to an FP&A role in terms of transferability? I feel like a lot of the analysis and excel / ppt skills transfer over, but it is a lit of tax knowledge to just leave behind.
I don’t care a ton about tax subject matter though

like

Lazard Hello I need some advice. Basically, I am a newbie to IB and I got a first phone interview for an IB Analyst position. It went great and I could feel it. They said there would a super-day. I would like to well prepare for this super day given my background is not finance. Where should I find appropriate materials to study? I may or may not be invited to a super day but I would rather be well prepared. Thanks!

like

Hi everyone! Is there a chance anyone could help me get a Referral for Amazon? I’m applying as an Associate Partner in Human Resources in Sacramento, CA. I’d love to connect. If not, likes are always appreciated. 👍

like

What salary range can be expected in Barclays for BA4

Current CTC 19.1 LPA
Holding offer of 27 ( 24 fix + 3 vp)
Tech stack :- Abinitio
YOE : 8 years

like

Interviewing with a company I’m excited about and they requested to have the next level (I believe final level) be pushed to the second week of January since they’re team is overwhelmed. I agreed and suggested times and am waiting to hear back. Meanwhile I had another company reach out this past week for a role I’m less excited over. They’ve already reached out for my final interview round this week. I already disclosed that I’m waiting to hear from a company I’ve been interviewing with. Cont’d.

like

Freelance Copy Sup hourly rate at a big shop?

Anyone work in industry/know of industry hiring?

like
likehelpful

What would people recommend, CFA or MBA to move from being a VP in a stakeholder facing position (internal stakeholders, essentially a Chief of Staff) on the tech side to the IB side of a BB? (Im under 30 so don’t mind taking some time to get there). Thanks

like

Partner/MDs: in which year of your partnership/role did you hit the $1M gross income? Would you mind sharing? I heard the average is Year 5-6 for Big 4/ATK/OW etc partners and Year 3-4 for MBB. Is that directionally accurate?

like

Current associate at BCG soon to make consultant. Have done well at the firm so far but have had limited opportunities in a particular practice area Im interested in due to geography and our firm’s presence in the space. Want to consider trying to switch to McK (much more dominant in the space). Do you think McK would consider interviewing me? What level to target?

like

Hi, I am looking for a referral in McKinsey & Company for the position of graduate business analyst . I did my one year internship in Deloitte USI , just got converted Analyst (FTE) in march 2022. It would be very helpful.

like

Is $68,000 a year a fair salary for a Senior Recruiter with 4+ years of experience? (+ Approx. $6k in bonuses)
Location: Orlando, FL

like

Additional Posts in Consulting India

I am getting depressed with everything - corona, protests, family and friends far away etc. I thought things will get better in June but they don’t look improving...

like

Can someone tell me the time required to process the Canada ICT work permit VISA from India with dependent (as Visitors)? We have done our biometric on 4th March 2022. Till now not received PPR. When can I expect passport request letter?

like

Y’all, planning a trip to Miami for a weekend. How’s the Eden Roc Miami?

Getting a good deal on it and want to confirm it’s a worthwhile property. Thanks!

like

Do I still get to use my earned vacation after two weeks notice?

like

Any tips for managing lows? I’m bipolar and find that I can get crushed / take things really poorly very easily. Wondering how bipolar people stay more balanced (already on meds)

like

Seems like every guy on notice period is getting a chance for on-site...
Where was this on-site opportunity when you have not resigned.....

likefunny

I am having a serious creative block for a logo design..... ughhh help any tips? The brand is creative, digital and premium. (It's a marketing agency) The brand name starts with the letter M.... I can't think of anything but M!! It's core values are freedom of creativity, fearlessness, bold. Etc...

like

How much does a Team Lead earn at Novartis?
It would be great if any team leads in the group can directly give the number

like

Is it worth getting the gentle birth app if you’re 5 weeks until the due date?

like

Wanting to try CBD to help. Anyone use it and have a brand recommendation?

like

Having trouble finding a Studio/1 Bedroom apartment in Lincoln Park/Lake View Chicago (budget: $1400 or below) that isn't a shoebox. Any recommendations on places to look at?

likefunny

Wanting to move to London from Canada. Looking to get insights, conversations, or referrals.
5-6 YOE. Have had some final rounds but no offer yet (details con't...)

What are some of the perks offered by morgan stanley?
TIA

like

what are different levels within SM at Deloitte in the SAP practice ? Where do external senior manager hires land ?

like

Your thoughts on Inclusion champion?

like

If your company doesn't match 401k, just makes a set contribution whether you contribute or not, what is the recommended order of retirement savings? Just follow the order everyone always shows just skip the first step of getting the match?

like

Hi All, cleared technical round with accenture on Monday and received email that "You have made it to HR round". Next day status changed in portal as below. Anyone else faced same issue and received offer letter after that??

Post Photo
like

How do you get opportunities to speak on panels? Is it based on networking?

like

Offered a promotion to Director of Client Services. Our web (developers and project managers) and digital marketing departments would merge and be run by me. We will hire another web manager and digital marketing manager (current manager promoted and doesn’t want to manage people) in a couple years. Wanted salary suggestions since I’d be covering 3 roles including mine. I have 16 years in marketing/leadership, 14 years in web dev. Current salary $80k. Wanting to go $130-145k.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

New to Fishbowl?

image with Fishbowl logo and arms reaching out for a handshake

That was just a preview...😅
Download the Fishbowl app
to unlock all discussions.

Download now

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal