I wish everyone could come together to protest against the electoral college, that’s the real enemy

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

This is very simple

Keep the electoral college, but distribute the delegates based on the distribution of votes in each state instead of winner takes all. So all the small state fans and constitutionalists get their way but we basically have a popular vote

The narrative of electoral college favors small states misses the point. Electoral college emphasizes the importance of swing states not small states. Hence, Florida.

Winner takes all is not in the constitution. It’s just a policy that states instituted over time. Nobody can reasonably defend winner takes all based on any reasonable political theory. It meaningfully disenfranchises voters of the minority party in hard red and hard blue states It’s stupid policy, but no state will give it up individually because they worry others might not.

Hopefully Texas flips blue in the next 4-8 years. Then republicans will start taking electoral college reform.

If you want to get rid of small state over-representation, support the abolishment of the senate. That’s the truly undemocratic element within our government.


But senators have zero to do with population and we're never intended to be equal to a percentage of the population. That is the house.

You are basically saying that the systems need to change because having a bigger population means a state should have a bigger voice in who the president. The is partially true but the senate makes shore population alone doesn't eliminate certain states voices.

No one advocated for a change when the popular vote getter also won, then you didn't care, but when you don't win then you want things changed. Maybe you should have asked for change when Barack had all the house and senate and have a wide popular appeal.


1) so it seems you have an issue with some states having a minimum number of electors. Why do you have an issue with a system that guarantees regardless of population disparities that a state at least has some voice?
2) if a state wants to do that they can as you said two states already do. But what is sounds like you want to push for is the federal government saying how a state should do its elections.

Recent IconRecent

I disagree. The idea that the simple majority rules can be very dangerous when it comes to the head position. Saying 51% can remove the rights of 49% is a slippery slope.

It takes a whole coilition of different states, rural, southern, metropolis to win the presidency now.

The argument a president can with the electoral college with 23% of the popular vote is true but only the most perfect situation.

Plus let us remember the USA was designed to be a union of states not just one big territory. The person running for president should have to win the state, not just the big city.


Conflating what the government can do to rights and the electoral college doesn’t make sense. Any system that lets 51% do something to the 49% is the same with an electoral college, except sometimes it’s the 49% doing it to the 51%.

Electoral college is a bit weird for those who already get like 1/10th the senate voice with voting. It’s hardly ideal to both be irrelevant for POTUS and take a fraction of the voting toward your senator.

Flip side to current situation (Trump could win even if he loses vote by 5% possibly) is if Texas can go blue, there are situations that if somehow Florida went blue, realistic chances Ds can win future races with as little as ~40% of the vote. You may see a Florida Democrat picked for POTUS by 2030 for this map situation.




True confession- we wouldn’t be having this conversation if Hilary won.


You do realize you were the one agreeing with SM1 that this only came up as a topic of discussion because of HRC, right?

The real issue here isn’t the electoral college, it’s that voter turnout is shockingly low

Why? Because there were 20 million more VAP but only 5 million showed up. So don't tell me it's from people who are jaded at 18

Yeah sure. So candidates would only go to CA, NY, IL and FL to campaign. Forget everyone/everywhere else

PWC1 great question. Because reality is they do not only pander to those states you mention. The policies suggested do not overwhelming benefit one state at the expense of other states. Where as if it was populous city vs country, then you would see different.

TOTALLY, 100% DISAGREE. There will be a break-up of the Union if that happens. We are a collection of United States. We are NOT provinces. The protection of less populous states is extremely important, and probably the most important tool to protect against majoritarian over-reach.

I love when people say "the founders didn't consider it" as if they were dumb and uneducated that the United States could grow...


Related Posts

Is there any opportunity for mechanical design engineer having 10 years of experience and doing mtech and currently working in tata technologies

Fellow pup parents.
SO has been working in person and I'm slowly returning to work. We got our pup when at least one of us were full time home.
Our boy is a year and a half old and we're comfortable leaving him home for under 4 hours at a time.
Any recommendations for pet sitting resources?
We don't have friends at the moment to leave him behind for the day and we really don't want to impose.
We would likely need minimal attention to take
him out to pee and get him back to rest.


First time on a treadmill desk. This is life changing.


Anyone have experience working at a market research company? Thinking about making the switch


How do you overcome a rejection by a company?


Does anybody out there feel like their practice area in big law is truly fulfilling their “calling?”. I.e. you aren’t there just for the money and you feel like your true self at work despite the grind?


Hi, folks I am working as market research analyst at a startup company for last 9 months. Currently I am feeling work is kinda boring and also there is no scope for growth and learn new things in the company.Is it's better work at the same company to gain some experience or leave company and join MBA course so that I will get better placement in big companies where I can learn new things.


is 175K too much to ask for an ACD position in NYC? what’s the range? i want to ask for as much as i can, but still within the realm of reality.


Recently i joined cgi but the project does not ses much good as per tech stack.Is there anything I can do in this case.I am tagged to this assignment but project has not yet started.Please help me with issues?

Thought I’d post here hoping for a referral. I’m looking for a Director of Product Design position at a tech startup. Anyone know of anything? Happy to send my resume/portfolio if you want to see some of my work before referring.


Recommendations for a west coast recruiter specializing in tax positions? For someone in biglaw who wants to go in house.

Vanguard or Fidelity for a Roth IRA account? Which one offers best value, account management, and research options? Looking to move away from Edward Jones. Their commissions and fees are way too high.


anyone have recommended resources on how to parent?

Working from home on a client project. Need an LCA/Amendment?
P.S. Already got LCA for local office location.

Trying to apply for another position at the same company but my boss told me explicitly that if they find out people on our team are looking for other jobs, they will stop giving that person raises, promotions, bonuses, & access to opportunities. I have spoken with the hiring manager for the new position and he just asked me if I have notified my current manager. Not sure how to navigate this tricky situation. Was hoping to interview before having to tell my manager that I am applying. Ideas?


I have accepted my offer, and my Joining date is on July 25th... Meanwhile I have submitted my document & BGC check also completed & onboarding auto generated mail received for formal welcome comunication

Later, I haven't received any further communication from HR,I even tried contacting them, unable to contact them

My question
1. How to I contact EY GDS Kochin team for any queries, is there any contact number/mail id ?
2. will I be contacted by HR before joining?, If yes, when?
3. WFH or WFO?


Is anyone familiar with Zarwin Baum? Looking for insight on work-life balance, climate, salaries, bonuses, etc.?


Has anyone thought of creating a digital course for consultants? What topics would you take a course on if you were beginning your career? Networking?


Which Islamic mutual funds do you all invest in the US?


Has anyone interviewed at Q advisors llc in Denver?


Additional Posts in Confession

Do the add-ons used in higher-end gas station car washes actually clean better as they're marketed, and are they worth the extra cost, or are they just supposed to do make you "feel" like you're getting better product, when in reality it's a similar wash to the basic product, just with some scented/colored soaps and lighting to make it feel higher quality?

(yes, I got the extreme wash lol)

Post Photo

Where the heck is this machine right now?!

Post Photo

I have four rounds of interviews for an entry level position. This is ridiculous, I am wondering what’s the process for a senior level job 🤔


Cheated on my ex here and there throughout our 2 years together. When covid hit, I broke it off after a few months bc we couldn't see each other for who knew how long and it was causing a lot of fighting. I realized soon after I love and miss her but now she's already with another guy. What should I do to get over it? I've tried hooking up with random girls but none of that helps fill the hole she's left in me 😞 idk if I'll find anyone as perfect as her again


Went to NY for the night. Someone broke my friend’s car window and stole my bags. My work laptop was inside one. Yay me 🙃


Earth is hell. Happy New Year!


I know I took out the loans and I should repay them and I’m normally fiscally conservative and against giving out free money. But I am hoping student loans get completely cancelled. It would greatly boost the economy if people do not have them hanging over their heads. However, forgiving what is currently there won’t help long term if the predatory practices around student loans aren’t fixed along with soaring tuition prices and salaries for administrators.


What’s the meaning of life? How are you creating value to the world?


I've been working at my company for three years and I don't know half of the consulting acronyms that are used on here lol


For Father’s Day, I told my parents about my plans of being a single mom 😂 my life is going well


I start sweating in a stressful meeting. I could see my shirts getting wet but not the face fortunately.
Is it normal guys?


Wtf. Had to collect 230 data points manually. AMA


Hi, it’s me again. This day is too funny. 🤣

At the mall. Just bought a hair iron, off a hair stylist who told me that before I leave… to call him so I can sit on his face.

He threw in a free hair mask and hair serum. Both full size. 😅


Might be unorthodox but why should a woman forego her own last name and keep the man’s? In terms of offspring, women contribute equally if not more so I don’t get why their own last names can’t be passed on. Just a thought


The older I get, the more bitter I become


A certain personality from the singles bowl dm’d me and I can say for certain there is a reason they are single. I thought about leaving the chat several times but kept it going just because the crazy was pretty funny.


How many divorces deep are you?


I ate too much and I can’t sleep


God I am terrible at saving money


Would you end a relationship if your parents do not like your other half? Obviously you have your fair share of problems in the relationship and your parents see that you are not growing financially and simply watching getting stuck in the same spot. My parents don't like her because I have child that she had problems with him because they do not get along at all. She has a son and I do get along with him attend to his boxing practices I would drop him off to school everyday. What would you do?


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone


Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or