{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "I'd love to hear about what people are doing to stand out in providing feedback for candidates who made it to the final interview stage but did not make the offer.", "post_id": "61508db7802fe9002b921b13", "reply_count": 1, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "5682e6afd55b9e0f00fce669", "bowl_name": "Human Resources" }

I'd love to hear about what people are doing to stand out in providing feedback for candidates who made it to the final interview stage but did not make the offer.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Honesty and transparency

Related Posts

I’ve been a nurse for 10 years in Boston. I have a few years of sales that involved a lot of travel. Looking to step away from bedside nursing and get back into sales. I’m also a bit discouraged with my earnings and the wife wants to go down in hours to spend more time with the kids. So far I’ve applied to a few Novartis jobs and the interview process has started. Any other companies that you would suggest? I figure leveraging my medical knowledge would be best but I’m open. Thanks guys

likehelpful

I had six hours worth of Zoom interviews with an AmLaw100 firm on Monday and Tuesday last week. I haven’t heard back on anything yet - when is “too” long to have not heard back and when should I reach out to their in-house recruiter for some kind of update?

like

Hi! I want to exit out of consulting with almost 4 years under my belt. I’m mainly looking for product manager roles but debating going into SWE (after studying). I’ve applied to so many roles externally but rarely get call backs. How can I increase the number of interviews I’m getting or be seen as a competitive applicant?

like

Anyone ever boomerang back to EY? how many rounds of interviews?

likefunny

Submitted NYU R1… how much lead time is there usually between when interview notifs go out and the actual interview? Any rec on when to start prepping for interviews and how? Thank you!!

like

Thoughts on maven clinic? I have the final set of interviews happening soon. I know that it has achieved unicorn status, what does it mean for company stability and also future prospects for me?

like

I have cleared 2 technical rounds in Wipro.Its been 2 weeks since i completed the technical interviews.The HR told i will be having a salary discussion.Does wipro take this much time for salary discussion?Wipro

like

Interviewed for a senior strategist role and as we were griping about how clients can be, I said “oh yeah well the dream job is to never work with clients again right?!” And the recruiter just got back to me that “the role requires client interaction so that’s a dealbreaker”. I feel so dumb for getting comfortable during an interview to joke like that.

like

What are some great questions to ask during an interview with a Manager and Director? It is healthcare related if that helps.

like

How much time is reasonable to request for take-home case study interviews?

like

What are the evaluation metrics for phone case interview at McKinsey? I’ve been reading reviews about being failed despite sufficient preparation. I have sufficient time to prep (2 weeks) but am finding myself underprepared at this point.

like

Hi all! Will any kind fish be willing to read my resume and give me feedback? I’ve been applying to different position but haven’t had any luck. Someone mentioned it is too specialized but I would love that a new set of eyes could read it to make it more appealing to consulting recruiters. Would really appreciate it :)

funnylike

What’s the best way to prep for an interview day? What’s the format usually, with a Big4? Curious...

like

Don't think I did as well on Kellogg interview as I hoped 😞 it's my top choice by far so feeling a bit disappointed

like

Got a rejection from Harvard and was feeling kinda low for days and now got interview invites for both Booth and GSB. My Stat is on the lowwww end 710 (V:37,Q:50) so there's hope for everyone! Don't give up just yet because of your low stats!

likeupliftingsmart

Have an interview for an SAP Level 10 (I think if not 9) role for Accenture Federal? How much should I expect the offer to be?

How often do you feel that you’ve nailed an interview, and then gotten an offer? Alternatively.. How often have you gotten an offer despite what felt like an “okay” interview?

like

Haven't done this interview stuff in a while. Interviewing with Deloitte onsite soon, should you wear a suit during interview? Charcoal grey + white shirt + tie work?

like

Deloitte- when I’m applying for a position, do I need my referral to send me a link? Do they apply for me? Or do I apply on my own and just let my referral know?

like

Those who have interviewed for HBS thus far - how was it?

like

Additional Posts

Had anyone at PwC had babies 14 months apart? Any limits on parental leave with the births so close together?

like

What is the parental leave policy at your firm? Please include: (1) size of firm; (2) location of firm; (3) how many paid weeks off (from firm - not state/fed); (4) other perks, such as ramp up/down time, etc.

What is the maternity/paternity leave policy at your firm (in the US)? EY is 16 weeks for both. What is the ideal amount of time for leave in your opinion?

like

Best Big 4 for real estate tax

like
like

I have the chase sapphire preferred and just realized it’s not the reserve... how much am I missing out on?

funny

TFW when your SM announces to the team that your manager is leaving the project while the manager is out on PTO. -_-

like

Agency Idea: The Ginger Group. Redheads only. You should see our Diversity and Inclusion page!

likefunny

After the whole diversity and inclusion push from my firm, I decided to try to create a Jewish group especially given all the anti semitism in the world. I sent an email to HR in beginning of august. It’s now almost September and no response (this includes multiple follow ups). They say it usually take 1-2 days to respond to emails. Hypocrisy?

like

EYers is it appropriate to ask your counselor for LOR if you’ve recently switched and only known them for 6 mon? Other option is a manager who i work with on and off on my current project for 8 mo..

like

Panicking and need some guidance. Currently on a project where I serve a SME for a specific system for overall gap analysis across modules. CAL however has somehow looped me into leading discussions in areas I have no experience in. Fortunately there is time to buffer and align expectations on Monday. How could I convey being extremely uncomfortable with leading the discussion and also save face? Only caught wind of what was actually happening when I digged into the invites provided

like

Need advice! I have been for Acn for very long but resigned recently. I have not started on the new job yet. I felt happy when I accepted the new job. Recently, anxiety is creeping up on me. Self doubts like Have I made a wrong decision to quit? Maybe I should have waited for the performance bonus? Will the new job be too tough for me to handle? What if the new work culture is bad? What if I do not excel in the new company? Maybe I should retract my resignation?LOL Continued in the comment...

like

Genuine question: What are the most common exit options at Google BizOps? (1) For internal transfer to PM, those teams seem to prefer to hire Google engineers. (2) For internal transfer to Chief of Staff, why those teams don’t promote their own Strategy & Op folks? (3) For BizOps internal promotion, there are not many Director positions. (4) For leaving Google, I don’t know where people usually go… Please share your thoughts / correct me if I’m wrong. Thanks!

like

Anyone left consulting for project management? Do you mind sharing your experience I.e., pay cut/ raise, work/life balance, stress/ anxiety level, overall level of happiness? Thanks Fam

like

How often do people in REPE travel?

like

Transition to the big 4 or very small boutique firm? Looking to move due to being pigeonholed in BA work, low pay compared to the industry, and just generally needing a change. I passed all interviews for a boutique, 30 person company. They are preparing a formal offer and final call for this Tuesday. At my lowest ask, it’s a 15% pay increase. And I will be able to stay more of a generalist, doing more senior work. I have a Deloitte interview tomorrow for a SC position. Continued

like

Currently looking for jr copywriter job, but I’m seeing mostly copywriter jobs that require 2-3 yrs. My other option seems to be an internship. What’s the likelihood of a jr copywriter position?

Got married too early (6months) with a narcissist “love bomber”. Didn’t know what love bombing was, never had dated a narcissist before, and I thought I had found the one. I’m 4 months pregnant and

like

I had a Zoom idea I’d love to see. Wouldn’t it be great to have the option to only allow your zoom class to see the host (teacher) and not everyone else? Lots of my middle schoolers don’t want the camera on because they are embarrassed and don’t everyone looking in their house. They honestly don’t need to be looking at everyone else.

like

Any ideas on fun team bonding events/games to improve culture in a new remote tech startup? Very small team with long work hours, we are trying to build a people culture but hard because we can’t see much of peoples personalities through Zoom meetings much.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal