If you had offers from all three- McKinsey, Bain, and BCG, which one would you join and why?

likehelpfulsmartfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Was in this position. I chose Bain because I felt like I would really like the culture, and thought I might want to do PE. Two years later and I have loved every minute of it, headed to PE soon. Would choose Bain again 10/10

like

Entry level out of undergrad

like

Was in the same position. Chose Deloitte. Never looked back.

likefunnyupliftingsmart

I came here for this post. Thank you for your reliability.

likefunny
Recent IconRecent

Was in the same position last year, chose Bain and it was a horrible decision. Bain is not the right place for people of color. I feel like an alien here

likehelpfulfunnyupliftingsmart

I didn't even apply there because of the vibes I got from tbe employees while I was exploring the three firms. 4 TERRIBLE interactions with consultants from 3 different offices. They were not upright rude but there was so much condescension and pretentiousness that I would be looking forward for the conversation to end. Every time I'd tell myself that it is probably just that person and not the firm. 4 times in, I just stopped trying to like them and decided not to apply.

On the other hand, every little interaction I had with anyone at BCG made me want to work there even more. Mckinsey fell somewhere in between but much closer to BCG.

like

I personally clicked with the people at BCG significantly less than McKinsey and Bain, and was leaning towards McKinsey over Bain. At the time, during college fall recruiting and with my real start date still far away, McKinsey’s hardo culture and prestige were impressive and almost won out for me. However, I ultimately ended up choosing Bain, and I couldn’t be happier with my decision. Now that my start date is approaching and I’m seeing the job as my soon-to-be life instead of just a name on my resume, I’m realizing how much happier of a person I will be at Bain. All the jobs are prestigious and all will be difficult, so I think at this point, the most important thing to think about is where you would truly be happy

likefunnysmart

Artless

I was triple offered as well (post-MBA), in one of the biggest US offices.

I did not click with the BCG folks at all (no one felt like they had a personality there).

Bain vs. McK was a tough decision. Eventually my mentor (ex-McK) nudged me to Bain, as I was clicking with them by far the best. McK just gave off too much of a cut-throat vibe.

Been at Bain for a couple of years now and I absolutely love it. Hands down this is the best job I’ve ever had.

likehelpful

Hahahahaha sorry BCG 😘

like

BCG. Free healthcare and best business class policy

likesmart

It’s $5 copay 😊 Honestly, it’s an amazing policy - especially for anyone looking to have kids.

like

Chose McK, would’ve chosen BCG in retrospect

likeupliftingsmart

Auto promotion (dgaf about this career in general), much better expense policy and better pay at Asc/BA level

like

McKinsey because I can easily work internationally while having a home base in a LCOL city. I’m also biased but I think we get really cool strategy work beyond PE. That matters to me.

likefunny

They found some insults used previously and recycled them. It’s how they are trained

likefunny

BCG - seem more ethical as a firm than McK, also seems a more collegiate/less cut-throat working environment.

Purely based on hearsay.

likesmarthelpful

Worked for both BCG and McKinsey. McKinsey is more likely to put clients’ interests ahead of the firm’s (not purely altruistically, but in the belief that doing so will be in the best interest of the Firm long-term). BCG partners will do almost anything to make a buck. Forget ethics from either in Saudi, or course.

likesmart

Picked BCG. Can't say about the other firms but really love culture, people, work, etc.

I'd say go with the firm you have more friends at. That tends to be a good guide for where you'd have the best time and fit in best.

likesmarthelpful

Regarding LCOL sure.
I know ppl that were based in the LA office that didn't live in LA
Or people based in SF that lived in Arizona.

It's possible, not regularly done, but possible.

like

10/10 would pick McKinsey again. I’ll start with why McK - Unparalleled resources, solutions, and ability to make your career into whatever you want. My interviewers were the coolest and even speaking with Partners, I felt at ease as if we had been working together for a long time. I enjoyed their assertiveness and emphasis on leadership.

For why not BCG/Bain -
— In interviews, one of my BCG interviewers was super impatient with me and rude even though I navigated the case correctly. While this was just one interviewer it totally turned me off. Everyone else was pleasant and the recruiters were amazing. I will say I totally saw their commitment to diversity. I also heard their case resources and tools stink.
— For Bain, I saw no diversity (and decided that eventually may impact my progression) and didn’t see any investment in paths other than Associate Consultant to Partner. I like building things (e.g., solutions and technology), which Bain is not the leader for. Didn’t even pursue - I didn’t want to consult by any means necessary.

Again, this is my experience. All 3 are pretty insanely packed with talent and opportunity 🤷‍♂️

likehelpfulfunny

As an outside observer, the MB.....B thing feels real in terms of prestige.

But I'd still pick Bain over BCG due to the personalities of people I've met from both.

like

If I could pick again, I’d pick Bain

likefunnysmart

McKincest is a broadly known term for a reason too...

Listen to McK3 and reject them all if you want your life to be anything more than work.

likesmart

If I wanted to stay in consulting and was already at MBB, Id leverage the brand to get a better deal at a boutique

like

Got offers from McK n BCG, dinged by Bain. Heart picked BCG (e.g less competitive n intimidating people), Head picked McK (e.g. Prestige, Exit Oppo).

Kind of regretted it now, here is quite political (have observed that connection trumps competency), hypocrite (lots of kool aid people here believing that BCG is much more saint than McK) n insecure

Would pick Bain out of 3 but yeah it did not happen

likesmart

For more of what it’s worth, there are tons of insecure people here too 😊

like

Some anecdotal numbers someone posted from Australia of cross-over decisions:

McK won 60% of cross offers over BCG
McK won 100% of cross offers over Bain
BCG won 75% of cross offers over Bain

Keeping in mind that the exact percentages likely differ and that MBBs in Australia might have differences compared to their US counterparts.

likesmarthelpfulfunny

M8 - 🤡 . Plenty of people choose to avoid McKinsey arrogance. The C in our summer class that didn’t get an offer went to McKinsey, so that’s a validated “reject” you scooped up

My take is it -always- comes down to specific office, especially considering the marginal differences there are among MBB on average.

For instance, my understanding is that in NYC, McK is the place to be——while in SF, I consistently hear that Bain beats them all (both project- and cultural-wise).

like

I'd reject them all.

funnylike

Definitely neither. Go with Deloitte. MBBD of course

likefunnysmart

Please stop 🛑

like

Wish I’d picked BCG. Similar work and training, but without the cut throat sink or swim mentality. You kinda need endless grit and know how to play the game to succeed here, specifically our EM promotion process (get someone to staff you as an EM despite being an associate) is so much more painful than BCGs (get PL after 2 years if you’re performing well).

like

Deloitte

likefunny

Related Posts

Thoughts on Ben Shapiro? I just listened to his show for the first time and my ears are bleeding - I think the guy is a freak. Tell me why you like him please.

like

Question! I’m attending a fall wedding in England in a couple weeks so it will be a bit chilly - is it appropriate to wear a whitish/cream wool coat over my (red) dress? Not sure if the no-white rule applies to outerwear as well

like

Any experience with Asherman’s post-D&C for an IVF pregnancy? Miscarriage at 15 weeks from first FET, and saline sono today revealed a ton of scarring. Next step is hysteroscopy but I’m so anxious that this is the end of the road.

like

One of the women whose account I run has made a name for herself as a well-known wellness influencer. But, her life is a mess. I am not one to judge, and don't want to, but honestly there is a dark side to the socials. In a way, she's taking advantage of the fact that it's just screenshots of her life that she can curate how she wants. I know everyone is doing this to some degree, and there are redeeming qualities to SM - but at what point are we supporting something that's actually harmful?

like

any junior writers wanna work together and add some stuff to their portfolio? message me and I’ll send you my book.

likesmart

Bass cat says hello

Post Photo

Anyone downgrade from EB2 to EB3 recently? My priority date is Oct 2015 and wondering what to do and how long I can wait?

like

How do you ask for points?

like

After competency based interview with AVP and onsite Tech lead....what all other round expected for Application support profile ?

like

Hi, can anyone tell me if Luxoft is a good place to work? They offered me more than here in Globant

Have any of you done think tank work? How does it differ from academia?

like
like

How many points? This was my bedsheet at Westin. Also who should I talk to for points ?

Post Photo
funnylikeuplifting
like
like

Here's a question, I see that you can apply to jobs with just your resume, and there isn't an opportunity to include a cover letter. This astounds me because that's really where a business can learn your values and what you can offer them. Does anyone recommend a way around this? I thought about uploading a two page resume with the cover letter included. It seems a loss not to include that edge.

like

KL Rahul is biggest scam in cricket 🙂

Post Photo
funnylike

Anyone working in appdynamics??

like

What should I ask for Father’s Day gifts? So far I have renting an m3 stick, socks, and sleeping shorts

Hello All,

I hope everyone is doing well.

Is anyone here, who switched company from India to Germany?
Do they consider only German speaking candidates or English speaking is ok for them?
Also, anyone have experience with EU Blue card.
Can we directly apply for EU blue card from India if there is a job offer? Anyone got visa sponsorship directly from German employer?

I have seen most of companies need German speaking candidates.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

There is an echo when I speak on calls due to my home office being relatively empty. I added a carpet but hasn’t made as big an impact as I would like. Any tips

like

Does anyone here find the headrest on their office chair super helpful? I've never had one, and can't imagine it's necessary as I shop for a new chair, but want to make sure there isn't something I'm missing.

like

Rolling on to an "ultra high burn" project for a little while. Screaming in the office not a rare sight. Any general tips?

like

Hey fish, I need some guidance and advice based on experience. How does one easily transition out of consulting when work is 60+ hours a week? Finding a new role is not always quick, especially if you trying to move away from your current industry. Does anyone have recommendations for specific headhunters or other methods of finding a new role while working consulting hours?

like

Im being sued by my landlord for breaking my lease. (I didn’t break my lease. It was a constructive eviction because they violated the warranty of habitability) Does anyone know a good lawyer I could use in NYC? Thanks

like

Only 2 more days till Consultant Friday!!

like

Booz Allen Singapore office is closing. Riyadh has downsized. Abu Dhabi laid off all cyber employees. Are Dubai and Lebanon next?
How does this fare for the firm’s commercial and Intl ambitions?

likefunny

What’s your most important skill and why?

like

Are utilization targets (%) always based on 40 hrs/wk, I.e 90% utilization = avg 36 billable hrs/wk?

like

Desi Consultants!! - who all are thinking of hiring Sima Taparia (after watching Indian matchmaking on Netflix) for finding your future significant other?

likefunny

Anyone real estate investing? Looking for good podcasts /books/resources on non-commercial multi family in particular.

like

Facebook initial round to result timeline: it has been almost 2 weeks and should I send the recruiter a follow up email? Also do they use the application portal where you can check the status? Thanks!!

like

Summer travel anyone? Booked a trip to my beachside hometown for July back in February. Should I wait it out or cancel? This trip saddles July 4th.

like

This Indian matchmaking show on Netflix is ridiculous. Does this actually go on still?

like

I feel like I am getting more judgmental and a bit less compassionate as I get older. Can anyone relate, and any tips to help stop this way of thinking?

likehelpful

What are the best consulting firms for someone that’s looking to work in the aviation industry? Can be big consulting firms with strong presence in aviation or boutique firms. Preferably commercial strategy type of projects. US based. Thank you!

like

Ik it's not NYC or SF but the Chicago apartment hunt grind is getting to me 😪

like

wish i could go back to the time where my biggest stressor was taking minutes lol

likefunnysmart

genuinely haven’t accomplished a single task today & can’t focus

likeupliftinghelpful

Anyone have any first hand experience of seeing the benefits of putting Big 4 on resume?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal