{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "If you had your pick of MBB, which would you join? Running a very informal poll - like the comment of the corresponding firm below McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company", "post_id": "614ea1dd71cd1e001f329bda", "reply_count": 85, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "5d7901c370a602001eff88c8", "bowl_name": "All Things MBB" }
likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Bain if you want to use it as a stepping stone into private equity, else McK for most other functions and sectors given it’s reputation and (more importantly) greater alumni base. I’m sure there are plenty of sector/region combinations that BCG or Bain best McK, just don’t know which ones.

like

Bcg 2nd for both prestige and culture. Bain wins culture and McKinsey wins prestige. Depends what you value or maybe you value both

like
Recent IconRecent

BCG

like

Must be the money

likefunny

Bain

likeuplifting

McKinsey

like

Neither of above. Management consulting has outlived its utility. This what you see is the final peak before descent

likesmart

I think strategy consulting will continue demand will exist but overall demand would decline. Also whether MBB or a new player would capture future demand is a question 3 main drivers influencing these as per me: 1) Existing hot scale ups would become complex. However the overall spend on consulting by them would be less than companies formed in 1900s. A trend of spend of large companies formed in 70s,80s and 90s will will point us in the direction 2) new age consulting skill sets (data analysis with millions of lines; new medium of story telling; increasing implementation skills) leave MBBs open for disruption 3) Talent differential between industry and consulting getting reduced

like

Btw I would join Bain if given a choice; simply because I hear people are more fun there

like

Bain intentionally create this culture across the globe. I attended my pre-mba events of all mbb in Asia. Mck was with all undergrads, experienced hire, etc at a huge hotel room. BCG was at their office with some senior people speaking. Bain was with Bain alumni sharing at a hotel with drinks and chatting session. I would see it pretty representative of the culture (also from what I observed what kind of classmates choose which firm) .

like

Might be a hot take, but why do people pick BCG. I get people picking McKinsey for the brand, Bain for the culture, but what does BCG have going for it? Slightly higher pay?

like

Sometimes it’s good to be a silent second place. McKinsey gets way more negative media attention (no judgment as to whether it’s deserved or not), whereas we’re always referred almost as an afterthought. Yet — we do mostly the same work, similar culture, same analytic horsepower, etc… and have the same benefits (exit opps, pay, etc). I’m fine with that.

like

So.. how do we interpret poll results though? There are simply many more mck employees than the other two

like

Few things spring to mind. I’m not saying these are all unique to Bain, and there are definitely way more things 1) Local office staffing, so office and the people in it plays a strong role in your time at Bain. At the same time, real effort to unify culture globally so it really feels like one firm (this is defs what gives off the cult-y vibes to others I feel) 2) Fewer, bigger start classes to give you a strong group of friends and plenty of events for start and classes and offices to get to know each other 3) Formal mechanisms to keep wlb in check, or at least acknowledge and try to find solutions for when it’s bad These are valued and embodied throughout the firm (including by leadership). In a way the strong culture reinforces itself. People like working somewhere with a good culture, so they work harder to maintain it

like

Bain for work culture and Mckinsey for brand name.. so will get brand name first

like

Worked at both - smaller firm, so many more connectivity events. Event planning is taken seriously, and way more fun. It’s also here in McK, but bigger groups and feels more formal

like

McK. Had all 3 options

likefunny

Braaaah

likeuplifting

The Firm, the Group, and the Company.

likefunny

Bain for culture, McK for prestige

like

BCG for the memes

like

Option 4 - Doesn’t matter to me, they’re all the same

likefunny

BCG

likefunny

The Group

like

Deloitte …jk, BCG

like

BCG

like

Bain

like

The Firm, The Group or The Boys Who you got?

like

BCG

like

Related Posts

Verrrry close to my exit opp. I left software for software consulting, and 3 years later I'm running back.

like

So peeps, office opening up. What's your plans on moving to Mumbai? Knowing apartment hunting can be a real bitch, some are planning to go back to hometown in the WFH week. i.e work at office at designated week and live in temporary accommodation, and then travel back.

How much all-in comp to expect in program manager role at Uber in Seattle? ~2 years work experience.

like

Google contacted me via LI about a strategy and operations role. I saw on LI that of my 30 business school friends who work at Google, 0 are in S&O. Why do you think this is the case? It could be random chance, but is S&O low paid, or otherwise unattractive for MBA grads for a different reason? 🤔

like

Anyone ever heard of Exabeam ? Thoughts on company , culture, work? Principal security consultant. Thanks!!

like

Our firm is going to be hiring after 10/15! 55-65 hour weeks during busy periods. Primarily looking for seniors and up, but we will also consider experienced staff. Firm is located in Los Angeles but remote is also a possibility (I’m fully remote and so are a few others). Clients we serve are ultra high net worth, real estate investors, and the entertainment industry. DM if you’re interested.

like

Has anybody ever run an online store? I was thinking of opening one up but am curious how sales tax and all the stuff works?

like

Staying at an established middle market firm where realistic partner track is about 10 -12 years vs moving to big4 or MBB. Pros & cons of both?

like

How long is too long in entry level role/title with an entry level salary?

like

Can we talk about the “Rise & Grind” / “Hustle Culture” aspect that seems to be organically baked into our role as Producers. Of course, it is what it is to some degree- but I’ve realized, in order to do my job effectively, my rest & work-life balance is a MUST. How have you handled that? Or do you just power through?

like

Considering a lateral move from one big law firm to another in the same city as a sixth year. Has anyone in a similar position gotten a signing bonus, and if so, how much?

like

I work as an implementation consultant and my work is highly industry specific, utility billing for municipalities generally less than 20k accts. My position does not require any technical knowledge, only that I know the software well. As I look for other jobs (more just curious and not actively applying) I see that I am not a fit for much out there. I have no technical skills to accompany my IT degree because it’s been so long since I touched SQL. Have I siloed myself? Cont in comments.

like

Anyone hiring for a jr producer in California?

Many people are willing to take a down level from T2/big4 to MBB but would you be willing to do it for FAANG?

like

I'm in a position where I don't like the tasks that are coming with my next promotion, but I really love my company (culture-wise). I have no idea whether I should jump ship or not.

like

My firm is hiring. 12 attorney firm in the central coast. Above market comp, 1500 billable hours, great team and culture. Looking for business/civil litigators and general business attorneys

like

When did we start hiring staff that only do half of their job?

likefunny

What is referral bonus for an SM at EY or PwC?

like

Any Deutsch LA CDs out there who wouldn't mind perusing my portfolio? I hear you have some cw openings and I'd absolutely love to work with you and for Karen Costello. DM if so and thank you!

like

Any advice for someone looking to transition into a full HR Generalist role from Recruiting. I’m currently a Campus Recruiter with about 5 years of HR experience (Coordinator- Higher Ed). I received my PHR certification in September 2020 and sitting for my SHRM-CP in two weeks. I’m having a hard time transitioning into a full Generalist position.

like

Additional Posts

My firm doesn't have a set maternity/paternity leave policy at my firm and I'm trying to get an idea of what types of policies mid-sized firms in New Jersey offer to their employees. How many weeks of paid time by the firm (not FMLA) is the norm?

like

Up for partnership this year @ a big 4, however I have an offer in hand that doubles my Director salary. Should I take the sure thing or risk going through a vote with a recession looming?

like

Anyone from Accenture, PwC, Strategy&, or Deloitte in healthcare consulting (ideally analytics) from the payer side? Would love to talk as I’m interested in a few roles!

likeupliftingfunny

Has anyone left big 4 to pursue nursing? I am about to be promoted to senior but don’t think big 4 is for me long term. I feel like the work I do has little meaning. I’m almost 25 and wondering if it is too late to switch career paths. If anyone has experience with this please dm me! 😊 would love to hear your story

like

Anyone working for a small consulting firm that can share their experience? i.e workload, responsibilities, industries, comp, etc

like

Verrrry close to my exit opp. I left software for software consulting, and 3 years later I'm running back.

like

So peeps, office opening up. What's your plans on moving to Mumbai? Knowing apartment hunting can be a real bitch, some are planning to go back to hometown in the WFH week. i.e work at office at designated week and live in temporary accommodation, and then travel back.

EY - What is the maternity leave breakdown? 2 weeks prior to DD + X disability + 16 weeks parental leave + up to 3 weeks PTO? Is the usual 6-8 week disability/medical separate from the 16 week bonding leave?

like

If you have Priority Pass (lounge access card), can you enter the Virgin lounge at EWR if you’re flying United?

like

Can anyone give me a sense of the typical salary at EY Parthenon at the Vice President level? Base? Bonus %? Thanks in advance!

like

I'm getting a good amount of phone screens (guessing big 4 + CPA is getting me past the resume screen), but after that I'm honestly stuck. How do I frame risk assurance in a way that makes me valuable for financial analysis type roles? I have no experience with financial modeling, for example. I feel like I can BS about how I understand business processes, but then when it comes to technical knowledge I lean on "I'm a CPA" since the work experience sucks. Controls work is not very transferable.

like

Great planning ATL. Shutting down half the Precheck lanes 4 days till Christmas...

like

Even the dog has to wfh...

Post Photo
likefunnysmart

Anyone emailed EY Law even before they initiate the visa process to make it faster?

like

For vegetarian 🐠 on Keto, how do you manage meals when on the road? Any tips or sources? Current project in Chicago. Motivated by other 🐠 success stories to get into it and just starting out. 💪

I’m a upcoming graduate student studying Accounting, and I also have some sort of data analytics and programming background. Recently, I am exposed to the accounting advisory services which makes me feel that this is what I want. Can anyone gives some advices on both the interviews and what the career path looks like? Any thoughts or comments are appreciated!

like

How much all-in comp to expect in program manager role at Uber in Seattle? ~2 years work experience.

like

For a taxable account, is there any downside to using FZROX with a zero expense ratio versus a similar but more established low expense ratio ETF like VTI or SCHB?

like

Did everyone take a day or two off to celebrate the holiday? Does anyone feel pressure to work on the holidays? It seems like major meetings get schedules with no thought about the high holidays

First year audit manager bonus and salary in HCOL?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal