{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "If you have an offer at two firms - is there a way for them to check with each other and what comp would be? I mentioned the name to both of them as they’re competitors but curious if they can fact check it", "post_id": "5fc99b525766d5002a634f9d", "reply_count": 9, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting" }

If you have an offer at two firms - is there a way for them to check with each other and what comp would be? I mentioned the name to both of them as they’re competitors but curious if they can fact check it

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

They have a live Teams meeting always in among the recruiters at all those firms

like

I think your company is just left out. Probably using Zoom. (Do I really need to footnote /s?)

likefunny

Nah, lol. You’re good.

Nope’

No way to check your specific details, but most of these recruiters have a pretty good idea of what the ranges are at their closest competitors.

It’s illegal for companies to collude on fixing salaries. I would think that any hint of doing so (calling each other) would be non-compliant with policy.

Related Posts

Moving to Houston next year. What kind of salary range would I be looking at as a consultant or senior consultant at Deloitte in the Regulatory Risk group? I’m a CPA with PA and industry experience.

like

Anyone knows what the salary range for People Analytics Advisor role at BP (the oil company) is? I have an interview coming up and I don’t want to negotiate myself out of an offer. Trying to do research on the role and the closest title I can find is an HR data Analyst. I wanted to know is those salaries were comparable

like

Any other juniors in baking get a sizable salary bump recently (within the last few months) as a “market adjustment”? Is it getting more competitive for big banks to retain juniors?

like

What kind of projects and clients does Strategy& have in Toronto? Also does anyone know the salary range for a manager?

like

What is starting comp range for a deal advisory/transaction services associate? Senior associate?

First year analysts, what was your starting salary and signing bonus?

What is "valued contribution" in EY GDS and what is percentage of hike/bonus?

like

Can anyone share the salary range of a Tax Manager in B4 in Toronto Canada? I just want to have an idea before I decide to submit my application.

like

Does anyone know the pay band / salary range for senior engineer developer / full stack developer with 9 yr experience ?

like

Do any other firms have variable bonus based on $ collected similar to A&M? I know Big 4 doesn’t but curious as to others.

like

Thinking to take a job in Deloitte, but how much should I ask of salary? (Currently I am getting paid 92k) Also how's the human capital group??

like

Current salary: $93K New Offer (hedge fund) :$110K with 10-20K bonus. Take it or leave it? I am going into my second year as a Consultant.

like

12lpa fixed, take home salary will be around? I utilise full 80C but live with my parents so no HRA.

like

What’s the general consensus on product manager roles at McK/BCG? I see them posted pretty frequently but am kind of missing how they fit in the overall ladder/comp etc.

likefunny

I make $240k in a corporate strategy role, was offered a senior manager role at Strategy&, should I accept? Assuming median year end bonus would be a ~20% total comp increase.

likefunny

Does anyone know the salary of a Senior and Lead at BCG Gamma?

like

Anyway I’m getting a comp call if I started two months ago lol

like

I work at a boutique (currently ~14 bankers and 10 back office roles). Joined in august. Since august, 3 senior bankers (MD / VP) 1 HR director, and now 2 analysts have left for great opportunities. To be honest I’m happy and like my role, plus it’s too early to think about switching firms already. I am now the only analyst left, we have another one joining in January. Any advice on how I can leverage this for comp discussions at the end of the year?

like

Hi All, Can you please give some idea about the salary expectations from Accenture for AWS devops position of 3+ yoe. I am having a offer letter from TCS(8 lpa) for same role. TIA🙏

like

Considering leaving for another firm job, one year in. Thoughts? New position would be a better practice area fit and would only work with clients in the industry I want. Currently it’s about 60% of what I’d like. Also, current firm seems to be stagnating with low hours to go around. I’m worried about not making hours, missing my bonus, and low professional development. Comparable on prestige & exit options and would be $5k less. Just worried about burning bridges and leaving “too soon.”

likehelpful

Additional Posts

like

one of my biggest personal accomplishments this year was telling my team that i’m taking a day off for a mental health day. i know that doesn’t seem that big, but i’ve always felt guilty for wanting to take a personal day for my mental health. i’m fortunate enough to have a team that is receptive and understanding of it.

likeupliftingsmarthelpful

Constantly being asked by my manager to put together trackers/draft emails to the client with action items/instructions on how to complete. I send them to said manager, and then they (cont.)

like

Has anyone ever heard of someone living in Asia while continuing to work remotely for an American company that’s based entirely in the US? I know someone who is being allowed to work from Asia for 3 months during this pandemic. I’d love to live in Asia long term. Wondering if remote work could include worldwide.

like

if I just don't show up at the client site, would I get fired immediately? Would I get severance?

like

I am getting married in Decemeber and am on H1B. I wanted to work from India for a couple if weeks to reach my utilization target since its my promo year. Are we allowed to do that? If yes, what is the process? Otherwise i will have to take pto for a month.

like

Can anyone provide information on compensation at Manatt?

like

This might sound like a silly question, but I genuinely want to know. Aside from the government, are there any companies where attorneys are expected to work a 40 hour work week and are paid $170k-180k or more?

like

Is FRM or CFA a better certification?

like

One of my favorite things about our profession is that we are our own small-businesses no matter the collective size of the law firm above our name on a signature line. Our careers are complex, multifaceted, and malleable. Is it a tough profession? Sure. Is it worth it? Certainly.

likesmart

People who left during clawback for signing bonus: Did they ever come after you?

like

Any advice in how to take advantage of a broader market short squeeze? Retail investor here but looking at Tesla with record $20B+ shorted whilst CEO hates shorters and everyone is holding in anticipation for earnings, potential S&P500 inclusion/ETF buyin and big announcements this year/amazing future

like

Views on ADL as a place to work esp in Middle East? Culture, leadership, pay? Evaluating an offer as Manager at ADL

like

As a heads up. If any of you are interviewing at Facebook and were planning to leverage their offer to negotiate at another company, they will recall their emails to you with any offer information as soon as they think it’s a no. I told them I was not interested 2 hours ago because it was an exploding offer (even though I haven’t finished negotiating my other offers), and the email is already gone. Thankfully I took a screenshot as soon as I got it.

likefunny

Got an offer from a really small consulting firm that offers no health insurance or 401k match. Otherwise the firm seems like a great fit and something I’d love to be a part of. What are some things I should consider with the lack of benefits? I’m thinking I should negotiate a higher offer to make up for it? Thoughts?

like

Any updates from Deloitte on H1B 3rd lottery ?

like

So I’ve finally booked a good amount of PTO and got it approved. I’m stressing about taking the PTO. Is this what peak burnout/consulting feels like?

likehelpful

Recently changed jobs and we are going to start using sage. Has anyone used the program before? Any insights regarding the accounts receivable or collections process?

like

EY 🐠, sorry for the noob question but does the firm mind if I get and use a Delta Skymiles Amex instead of my corporate one? Not in tax or audit practice. Just really want the miles!

like

What is being an MD at A&M like: 1. What is the leverage ratio? 2. Owner or a salaried role? 3. Compensation range? 4. How often do you hire laterally at this level, and from where? Thanks in advance.

likesmarthelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal