I’m an MS Management Student graduating in June 2023. I applied to over 40 positions within the Big 4/MBB and even with extensive networking, I haven’t heard back from any really. I have an offer from a pretty well-known but less prestigious Consulting Firm, but I’m wondering what my chances even are of going Big 4/MBB if I’m not a campus hire. Will they even consider me for an experienced hire a year or two down the road if they showed no interest this time? Any advice welcome!

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I've been told applying for more than 4 positions (some firms 2) can red flag you in HR systems and hurts your chances. It might just be heresy, hopefully someone from HR can step in and confirm/deny

smart

You should take the offer you have.

helpful

Sure. In fact, you might have better chances once you've got some actual real-world experience under your belt. By the way, Big 4 isn't the be all and end all. You might find you do well and enjoy working at other firms instead.

uplifting

I'd think you'd be a more enticing hire with experience at any prestigious consulting firm. You're less green than all other college grads applying at that point. Think of it as a marathon, not a sprint!

uplifting

@BRC I’m pretty sure I’m going to! I just wanted to post on here since I’m new to the community and thought someone might have some advice for my future endeavors.

Would u mind sharing the name of the firm or some other info? “Well known but less prestigious” can mean different things for different ppl

A1 It’s with Slalom as an AC

On that note, how is Slalom’s reputation within the consulting industry?

To work for or the product they produce? I've heard great things about their work culture. Can't say I've come across clients that have used them in the past but my field isn't one they are a major player in

SA1 Thank you so much for this. I have honestly loved the recruiting process with Slalom and am really excited to potentially join their firm. Not even planning an exit soon after, just noticed a lot of my peers having a bit more luck than me with Big 4 and thought I’d ask :)

Thank you all so much!

Give it a shot, OP. After all, it's not all about the experience. Sure you will have a higher chance, but don't let it stop you from applying.

Related Posts

How is it like to be in firmware domain. How is the growth, work life balance , benefits and pay. Should I remain in this domain or make a switch to software developer.

Do people intentionally delay or hold of their own promotions to avoid more work and pressure at higher levels?

like

Does anyone have the 2020 SHRM books for sale or to borrow? My job won’t contribute towards my certification. I’ve already paid for my test. I have the books from 2015 but I’d like to study from the 2020. I tried finding them online to purchase but sellers of affordable books aren’t responding.

exit opportunities for someone who got a good gpa from a well known school and a cpa who thought they would be doing something cool while building a foundation for a fruitful career but got stuck on state/federal claims and related government work instead? or is a full restart needed?

S1 at B4 now but looking to do something more traditional (?) that will provide opportunity in finance/accounting and not something ‘risk’ oriented that will pigeonhole me.

like

FDD people who are not interested in pursuing the partner route, what would be the best title to exit? Senior/Manager/Senior Manager?

like

I have worked my way up in Insurance for 4 years but the 1st year being an intern/front desk/admin and was promoted twice and now an account associate helping my AMs/AEs manage our Producers' books of business. I was recently approached by a big brokerage for a Client Manager position. I have imposter syndrome and don't think I am qualified because I dont know insurance coverages/mastered what a business would need for a particular industry (continued in comments..)

like

Hey everyone happy Friday ! I just wanted to ask for some feedback on my resume to see if it’s qualified for any positions within the financial world especially for back office only because I’m having a hard time finding a new position that is willing to give me the growth and development i need. I am open to all the advice and networking thank you!

Post Photo
like

Thoughts on Asset Management as a career path? What are the pros/cons?

like

Many in my MBA program are hyper grade focused. Do grades matter that much post MBA for future job opps at all? My approach has been to balance academics with relationship building and practicing exec presence and for me, pivoting to a new industry

like

Hi All, what should be the years of experience to get Software engineer II A designation in Bank of America ?

like

has anyone made the jump from hospital administration to healthcare consulting?

likesmart

Hi everyone,
Past the first meet and greet-interview, now scheduled for the next one- any idea what to expect considering I am transitioning from a clinical focus role to a non clinical focus role as an Business Analyst.Any feedback will be highly appreciated.
With thanks!

like

My remit quadrupled+ in a recent re-org with no increase in pay/promotion, my new director is new to the company and was zero help, and I was passed over for recent promotion during the comp cycle. The new director essentially began shutting me down any time I ask for clarity in my career progression. Now they have taken credit for the project I’ve been building over the past year+ without giving me props whatsoever to higher ups. What is the best plan of action here?

like

FAANG
Hi, is there anyone here who has moved in a non-tech FAANG role in the US under TN visa? Or as a Canadian citizen? I would really like to know how did you guys manage to get the job

like

Has anyone gotten an offer from MBB and is willing to give me a case? Pls DM

like

Plan to go to B-school in 3 years (1 year out of UG now). Long term goal is entrepreneurship. Have offers at a MBB firm for a generalist consultant role and at FAANG for a strategy role. FAANG offer is slightly higher (though both are a 50+% bump on my current comp). Both would have me reset to entry level. Which one should I take?

like

What are similarities of product management versus portfolio project management?

like

Anyone make the exit from B4 to external recruiting for an agency? Like Robert Half but smaller. I’m talking with one now and am considering it since I like the commission aspect. What is it like / how tough is it?

likefunny

Hello! I was wondering if someone can explain the difference between PM vs. PMM, and tips for non-PM/PMMs in making a transition to the industry. Are there preliminary skills I should acquire before applying? Any info on day to day and salary will be helpful! Thank you :)

like

You always hear mgrs/sr mgrs switching to industry to become a controller, but do controllers ever come into public accounting as a sr mgr or anything else??

likefunny

More Posts

Hello Guys,

I have an offer from Cognizant for 29lpa with a JB of 1.75l on top . I am about to get the offers from timesinternet and LTI.


Can someone suggest which will be a better opportunity for me.

Also how much should I ask for to Timesinternet.

Had communicated with LTI for 33lpa fixed.

like

Hi Fishers,
I have offers with CBA - x salary and Citi - x+3.
Please provide your valuable suggestions on which one to choose.

like

I completed all rounds of interviews with capgemini. HR took all the documents about 10 days ago. However, offer letter is not yet released. HR stating that she is waiting for client project confirmation. Anyone faced such delays ? Ans what was the final outcome?

What are roles and responsibilities of staff engineer at visa inc

like

FINALLY saved up enough for a Leica kit - I was very excited for the CL - but the shop suggested the Q2 as a really great travel camera, and now I’m not sure what to get. Anyone here shoot Leica? I’m looking for a simple to use, compact travel camera. I love the lens -swap on the CL (one day want to own an M and SL kit) - but the Q2 has me thinking…

Anyone using your tv as a second monitor these days? Any advice on doing this wirelessly or without a giant HDMI cord going across my living room? I tried chrome cast and I don’t want to just mirror my screen, I need a dedicated second monitor. Thanks!

like

What title for this job description?
I want to switch roles from a creative director who oversees all aspects of the company’s creative (marketing campaigns and brand building mostly; also production, performance marketing ads, product design, managing design team) to focusing 100% on building our brand, educating both customers and employees about our value prop. I hate managing people or logistics and scheduling. What would this role be called? Do you see it as demotion from CD?

like

So my spg points and nights have still not merged with my Marriott account. Anyone else having this issue?

I am A2 in PwC AC Bangalore in Management consulting - I want to shift to US office due to some reasons. Can anyone please elaborate the intercompany transfer / internal rotation process? Like where to apply? what are the requirements?

likefunny

Hi all,
Anyone working in Nineleaps company Bangalore?
Please share your working experience? Hows the working environment and about work life balance?Nineleaps

like

Can I get H1B visa stamp annotated with (future employer) while I serve my (current) employer’s notice period?
I have a job offer from Meta and awaiting my H1B transfer approval notice. I have never received an H1B visa stamp before. I want to work from India (& get H1 stamped with Meta based on offer letter+approval notice) during my notice period, followed by 2 weeks of unemployment, and start my new job at Meta once I return to the US.

like

When does the pain go away after a hysteroscopy and HSG? I’m 30 hours past and still in quite a bit of pain on either side of my abdomen.

Anyone on pros and cons of A&M PEPI group?

like

Has anyone traveled to Switzerland and used Marriott points? Best area to stay? Traveling with a total of 3 and only hotels in Zurich allow for free stays with only points as others charge extra

like

Best NorCal getaway ideas and activities for September? For a local and a serial visitor.

like

How should I pivot to Wealth Management as a Credit Analyst for a commercial bank? I’ve worked as a credit analyst for about a year after graduating in finance last year. I also interned at a wealth management firm while in college. Any advice is appreciated!

like

Question : I want to change career from a support engineer to sales. Is that possible ? I have 4 YoE in technical support and want to change to sales.
Any ideas where to start, and what positions I should be looking for given I have not worked sales before ?

like

Previously a Customer Success Director and Project Manager looking to pivot into Cybersecurity. What’s the best role/certification to aim for? Any companies willing to provide OTJ training?

Any audit senior 3 and 1st year managers here? What positions are audit senior 3 and 1st year managers leaving big4 for?

like

Can anyone provide insight on the Salesforce Program/Project Management team in Atlanta?
Found a role and am curious to learn more

like

Additional Posts in Career Advice for Students

McKinsey & Company How likely is McKinsey to rescind an offer if there's a recession/downturn before my start date? Received an Associate offer with a start date early in the Fall. But I'm worried about the offer being rescinded due to the ongoing McK scandals/issues and a potential recession in the making (which may prompt them to freeze hiring and/or renege offers).

Has this happened to anyone before at McKinsey, offer getting rescinded due to economic/company downturn? A bit worried




McKinsey & Company

like

Does anyone know the starting salary for an engineer at Leidos in MS?

like

Roland Berger boston or chicago office?

like

Technically, I'm not a college student anymore because I just graduated in December. I am having trouble finding jobs within my field (Communications with little experience in marketing). I've gotten plenty of interviews, but none of them have made it past the first formal interview (phone screening then interview). Any advice?

like

Any thoughts on large companies vs boutique firms? Have offers from Accenture Strategy and The Chartis Group but am having trouble making the final decision. Interested in healthcare consulting but not sure if I want to commit at this point.

like

I am moving to Bucks County, PA in a few months after my graduation. My dream is to open a bookstore but for now I want to find a job in one. Does anyone have recommendations for places hiring? Do you have a recommendation about interviewing for a bookstore job?

like

Thoughts about the Corporate Banking Summer Analyst Internship for Wells Fargo? Opinions about working for the company and how to secure an interview? @

like

I have a virtual interview with Tesla tomorrow for an internship position. What should I wear? This would be first internship, so I’ve never interviewed for a position like this and am not sure how to dress (especially given it’s virtual). Any advice is appreciated. Thanks!

like

Is it true that comp changes at some top consulting firms depending on how well your bschool is ranked?

like

Nothing on here for the Forestry industry. This app caters to do nothing managers it seems. :(

like

What’s the best way for new grads to go about negotiating salary? Also, what tools do you use to get a good analysis of what salary you should be making comparable to the local job market?

like

Hello! Currently struggling with what to do career wise. I have been set on medical school my whole life, but recently I’ve been exploring other careers such as law. Anyone have any advice on how to determine which career would be best for me? I have a 3.77 GPA and am getting a BS in Biology and Psychology. Any insight would be helpful!

like

Graduating in two weeks and got a job offer from Amazon for tech support specialist role, in job application they asked for expected compensation and i put 55k, and they offering me exactly 55k should I have asked for more instead, I feel like I might have shot myself in the leg there a little bit

like

I’ve been prepping for MBB for months but I know I’m still not ready. I’m struggling with staying structured and with creative questions. I’m really frustrated because I feel like I’ve put in so much work but I’m not where I need to be to make it. I know if I interviewed today I wouldn’t make it through.
Any advice?

like
like

Hey there! Can anyone give me a referral for Microsoft? Would be highly appreciated! ❤️

like

How is everyone getting Fall/ Spring/ summer internships? Are you all applying on the company website/ LinkedIn page. Networking to recruiters? Through college career center. I've been applying and not getting anything? Any tips or advice?

like

I’m currently working on my Juris Masters in American Legal Studies online. It has been stressful beyond belief!!

I want to go to law school but I found passion for education law and working in the government can I do that with this Masters or should I keep going towards law school?

like

I am interested in consulting, currently majoring in finance and minoring in math, looking for any internship for the fall. Suggestion for any companies/ internship programs to apply. What are my chances of landing an entry level consulting Job, if I don’t have any consulting internship. Any advices, dos and don’t. Thank you very much.

like

Is anyone willing to look over my resume to let me know if I’m qualified enough to be a consultant at Deloitte? TIA

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal