I'm a single woman, and just woke up at 1AM to a random man (who says he's the superintendent, I've never met him) in my apartment. He used a spare key and seemed to be able to locate a water leak. So I think he is the super. I think this is categorized under an emergency, but is this legally acceptable? I am still shaking because I thought someone broke into my apartment and I was asleep.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Idk the rules but I highly doubt this is. Especially if you don’t have any missed calls and the fact that it’s 1am. Call your front desk asap or the cops.

likehelpful

I’ve had two incidents this year where water was leaking heavily from my ceiling late at night. And understand that neighbor downstairs hounding the super to ensure that the people upstairs were using their baths or washers properly.

And she said she woke up at 1AM. So let’s give the super the benefit of the doubt that he knocked and nobody picked up. Go ahead, accuse the man of being a perv, and cancel him. Tsk tsk.

As a Canadian M, it’s really eye opening to see how y’all feel about this. Maybe I’m crazy for trusting my building staff…

But now it makes sense why y’all like guns so much.

likefunny

A1 I'm from a country with one of the lowest homicide rates in the world and as far as I'm aware we don't have guns. I'm not American. I'd still be entirely mistrustful of anyone, man or woman, who was in my apartment, unannounced, at 1am. Hell they could be a cousin and I'd consider yelling at them to GTFO.

It's not just media. It's reality. The reality of women everywhere. Being followed on the streets for daring to wear a skirt (or just have long hair), being catcalled, being yelled at that I'm prettier when I'm smiling. We're constantly threatened and made to feel uneasy. That's why OP was shaking and sobbing upon finding an unexpected man in her apartment at fucking 1am.

Also, no one has seriously suggested suing anyone so stop with the "lol you kooky Americans and your frivolous suits and your guns!" -- that's such a weird and unprovoked take to bring to this thread.

likesmart
Recent IconRecent

the landlord just called to apologize. he agrees this is unacceptable and is changing my lock and adding a deadbolt to my door. argh, this sucks

likeuplifting

Omg... I am so glad to hear that the land lord apologized. As a married woman my jaw dropped reading some of the comments here as I was single once!!!
I travel all the time..I sometimes stayed at my home or condo alone.. I feel for you .. and I hope you feel calmer and safer at home

like

update: landlord switched out the lock, added a deadbolt and added one bolt lock thing that slots over the door manually from the inside. I'm contemplating filing a non emergency police report or something. Everyone is so apologetic and I don't wanna cause a scene but also like wtf?

likesmart

IRS is an idiot, there saved you all some time. Lol this thread would be done way faster if he wasn’t participating and trying to cause drama.

like

My super has keys to only one of my locks, and he rings the doorbell. This is not normal

like

absolutely need to report this one to the authorities. 1am while you’re asleep can’t be standard operating procedure

like

OP you can document everything, provide all evidence of failure to comply whatever and still lose. Scumbag landlords know the rules closely. You can even win the court case and still not get paid out because they know how to avoid getting the settlement attached to them. Best of luck though, hate these kinds of people

They probably should have knocked or announced themselves, but yes, leaks is something they immediately can let themselves in for because waiting can result in major water damage.

like

Def raise it to the building management/landlord. Even if nothing is preventing them from playing it fast and loose with emergencies, it also in their best interest to be more buttoned up about it. Can't make an urgent repair if your super is getting the cops called on them or dealing with supplemental locks and security, etc.

like

Call the cops immediately, I'm a guy and I'd run to grab the butcher knife if someone came in

like

No offense but lol

like

Call 911, let them come, say you are scared

likefunny

That is terrifying. A door chain is a must-have to prevent your landlord/super/any other rando that has a key from letting themselves into your apartment while you're home.

Also, pretty sure they need to give you at least 24hrs notice to enter the unit, but check your lease agreement to confirm.

like

The issue is that most emergencies don't come with a 24 hour notice....

Water leaks do need to be fixed right away in some cases, but they should never come into your apartment without contacting you. I’ve lived in 4 different NYC apartments, and nobody from the building has ever come in without asking permission. You should complain to management in writing.

likehelpful

It is acceptable in my view, as an emergency, but he should have knocked — loudly — and called you. Amd announced himself as soon as he opened the door. My company advises our staff not to do this unless absolutely necessary. You never know if a tenant has a gun who would think he was defending himself.

likehelpful

My lease says building people can enter without permission in case of an emergency (and a leak would qualify). BUT they are supposed to try and notify you first. Like ring your doorbell, knock, etc. It sounds like that didn’t happen which is unacceptable. I guess the difficult thing would be you can’t prove he didn’t ring your bell and knock, but I still think you should complain.

like

Omg I cant even imagine how scared i would have been if it happened to me..
agree with VP1, doorchain is a must. Had someone try to intrude my home trying diff key and so i got the chain the following morning

like

Yikes. I would have been terrified and possibly would have attacked them, hit then with something /called 911 etc.

At minimum 1) put something like this on your door today, and 2) call the landlord yo complain.

Post Photo
like

New fear unlocked… in all seriousness you don’t have a chain lock or something?

like

no there's no chain lock on my door. i should get this installed

like

Girl why you asking Fishbowl, call the cops

likesmart

This is why I deadbolt the door at night. Yes, a leak is an emergency, but they should be making a reasonable effort to notify you before just barging in at 1 am. I know all our building staff by sight and I’d still be freaked out if someone just opened the door with no notice while I was in bed.

like

I would file a police report

like

Master Lock 265D Door Security... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0002YUX8I?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share

This would get a man shot in most places.

Change your locks, report it to the police and buy pepper spray, and/or a weapon.

like

Related Posts

like
like

To my AM friends, I’m in a role that has no quote or commissions (due to supply chain issues). It’s more CS account management. There’s no pressure to sell. However I could switch to more of a “hunter” position and have a quota & commission. Which would you prefer & why?

like

How do you negotiate for more PTO? About to head into my first negotiations for compensation and would appreciate any tips!

like

What's your favorite example of a product that you don't understand how they even pitched it to the CEO? My current favorite is this bottle of water that says "lo cal." Hahaha

likefunny

Today Pfizer announced that trials show that their vaccine is 100% effective for teens ages 12-15. Do you think most of our students will get it for next year?

likehelpful

Persistent offer letter has huge component of Other Bonus, In my case it's around 8 lakh rupees... Anyone working at Persistent can tell?? If this is paid 100% or there are some terms and conditions around this?? Persistent Systems Limited

like

Drinking some goodies tonight 😋 cheers boys and girls

Post Photo
like

I have 10 minutes! I just reached over 100% return on tesla do i sell cost? Or hold

like

Hi everyone

I am looking for single occupancy near Pune office - ITPP/Kharadi
Will be shifting by Dec

like

Ideas for places in Asia for a 2 week honeymoon at the end of December?

like

Am I the only one feeling glad we didn’t get selected for a particular airline pitch?

like

Does NY state require payout of remaining PTO hours when you quit?

likesmarthelpful

I have my Masters in HR and my PHR but I don't think HR is for me, or I may not have the confidence for this role. I want to quit my job and live off my savings which can hold me over about 6 months, but then what??

like

How long should I wait to respond to offer letter?

like

Does anyone have experience working with whatagraph? Looking for easy to use dashboard plug in. Any recommendations?

like

Anyone here manage social media accounts for a federal agency? What’s your best client social media story, good or bad!

like

What’s the best company to work for if you are a highly cleared cyber security consultant? Asking for a friend with 13 YoE

like

I’m starting a new job with a TS/SCI clearance soon and it’s my first time working on a cleared program (worked on Public Trust programs before). What’s it like working in a SCIF? Other than the basics like no cellphone/tech, etc?

like

Can you negotiate a higher salary at a top consulting firm straight out of undergrad?

like

Additional Posts in New York City

Anyone here who can provide referral to the Bohemian or tell me if it’s worth a visit? Thanks!

like

Natural bathroom air freshener recommended?

like

Anyone interested in tickets to the NeedToBreathe concert at Pier 17 this Saturday at 6pm? I have 3 tickets willing to hear any offers

like

Does anyone know of a Rabbi that could perform a private wedding (like under 10 people attending) in the city? Not part of a temple yet and not sure if we need to be part of one to ask a Rabbi to give blessings

like

Anyone a member of soho house? Is it worth it?

likehelpful

Best neighborhood to move to now as a single female? I’m in Flatiron/NoMad area now, but looking to move into something bigger yet still in walking distance to work (in case I have to go back).

like

I'm looking to leave NYC and have someone takeover my lease. Details here:

- true 1 bedroom @ 2790/mo
- one time $750 cost for lease takeover
- lease goes through middle of Jan
- market price for same apartment (2 floors down) is mid 4k so this is a steal
-mid July, but date is flexible

Let me know if anyone is interested before I go to wider market

like

If I leave my couch/mattress on the sidewalk will I get fined?

i need a reliable bicycle and don’t want to spend a treasure. Any recommendations?

like

Moving to New York with a golden retriever. Should I consider Manhattan or Queens? How do I carry him in the subway?

like

Where should I go to watch football today and hopefully meet people?! 

like

Anyone have a tattoo artist (preferably Manhattan based) that does good copying of hand writing? Want to get my dad's sign-off traced for a tattoo

like

Best day time place to meet single men between ages of 30-40 on Sundays? Maybe a bar I could just sit at solo and hope to get approached. Recommendations?

like

Everyone outside and inside is wearing masks again. It will take years to get back to normal. 🤦🏼

like

Any advice on where I can get a decent used car? Probably won’t be looking to purchase until about mid April and already have parking/insurance with current (inherited) car, just that I’m giving it away and need something new.

Never bought a car before so it’s all a bit daunting. Also open to a new car or leasing, just trying to be practical

like

We have been in NYC for a little while with kids (2/4 yo, we are 33 yo) and even if we are financially well-off, it feels like we can’t buy a house for our lives. We are in the legal industry but potentially could work remotely forever.

Anyone found a city they love outside of NYC where buying a house is doable? We love the diversity we can find in NYC (food, international communities). Any recommendations of cities to look at? Not interested in suburbanish settings.

like
like

New to the city, what’s the best way to find a doctor (GP)? Looking at ZocDoc and there’re a lot of options - what are the parameters to look for? Any tips from locals (e.g. what’s the best hospital affiliation to have, best education, etc)?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.