I’m feeling discouraged by the research out there that shows that no matter how you lose weight, even if you do it the “right” way, it always comes back. Can anyone point to a peer reviewed study that shows weight can be kept off long term? And how to do it? Would love to have a little hope ✨

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I lost about 30 pounds ten years ago and kept it off until covid. It’s not easy, but it’s possible. You have to commit to changing your relationship with food, you can’t just “diet.”

likehelpful

If you fundamentally change your diet/lifestyle you can keep weight off. Are you saying people who lose weight the recommended and healthy way and have weight come back or people who do that and then revert back to their old habits? Because those are two different things.

Nota study but I was prediabetic and had high cholesterol - I was 122 pounds at my heaviest and after a few health issues was told I need to change my diet. Incorporated more vegetables and cut fast food 5X a week to only once every couple weeks or so and now I’m at 100 (been this way for the past 5+ years since the health scares). I don’t count calories or work out excessively but just going from eating utter trash to healthier made a huge difference

like

Echoing the above, the issue is that people “go on a diet” to lose weight and then go right back to eating the way they did before after they reach their goal weight. Logically, that’s going to make you gain it right back. There’s a reason so many people here recommend slow and steady lifestyle changes. If you want to maintain a different weight then you have to maintain a different lifestyle. Unfortunately many people start off in a way that’s too restrictive so they’re unable to do so.

I used to be 160lbs at my heaviest. I’ve maintained around 120 for the past six years. If I see the scale going up a bit then I know I’ve gotten to relaxed and readjust my habits. I’ve never even come close to getting back to 160 bc I eat in a completely different way and workout consistently. But it’s taken a long time to make this new weight a routine and perhaps more importantly it took a long time for me to lose it in the first place bc I focused on sustainable changes.

like

The issue is once people stop they completely stop watching their diet. I’ve heard good things about keto or IF. If you follow one of those 2 forever your fine. But you can’t just let go and not watch. People I know who keep it off, always watch and say ok weekdays I will be good and weekends I’ll eat what I want. When they see they are gaining weight they will start working out and give themselves a 10-+ pound space that they will not cross

like

I think every major long-term study of keto has shown that it doesn’t produce lasting results. Not sure about IF, but I’d expect the same.

Flexible, well-rounded eating habits are the way to go. Weight Watchers is great for helping to make lifestyle changes.

like

Small, manageable changes work best, specifically those that you are personally capable of holding on to. They aren’t magical “drop 20lbs in 20 days” or other nonsense but they work. For instance scaling back on empty calories (pop, chips, etc). One thing at a time works better than a whole diet revolution unless that’s something that would come natural to you. The various diet systems are ok but no one system works 100% for everyone because we’re all genetically different. Start small and keep moving :)

like

I think what happens is people think that “dieting” is temporary. To maintain a good weight, we need to make a lifetime commitment to eating healthy.
Once reaching goal weight, a person might think yay! I can stop dieting. So they slowly return to having a few drinks per week, a small bag of chips with lunch, a large milkshake or rich dessert once per week, a sandwich instead of a salad for lunch, or order a regular instead of skinny latte every morning. Any one of those choices, all else being equal, will lead to a pound of weight gain per month, not to mention the return of carb/sugar addiction. All five of these seemingly small changes could add 1lb of fat per week - or 50 lbs in a year.

Try Noom. It helped me a lot because it gets to the root of why one overeats. It’s psychological. It’s also a lot less complicated than our society makes it out to be. Don’t take in more calories than you burn, and realize that no amount of working out can undo a bad diet. It’s far more important to focus on putting nutritious food in your body that fills you up without weighing you down, and getting the mindset down that you and only you are in control of what goes in your body. I’m personally not a fan of keto because I enjoy toast and the occasional pasta or pizza dish. IF is good for this.

More Posts

like

If some was promoted via requisition then how many months later can he/she get the next promotion?

like

Mid-week wrist check! What’s on the wrist for hump day? GSWednesday for me.

Post Photo
like
like

Best boutique accounting advisory firms?

I'm over large firms but want to retain my speciality in technical accounting.

likehelpful

Can we reject an offer after laptop has been shipped to your home address? 😅

funnylike

I know staying fit can be difficult, especially as we get older, but I look up to my firm leadership and almost none of them have what I would consider a healthy physic… is this the life I’m headed for too?

funnylike

Does Uber have a very competitive company culture?

like

What are the career prospects for Talend ETL pl.

like

Babymoon ideas? Where would you suggest/what type of trip and what stage of the pregnancy? Wife is 11 weeks with twins for reference.

like

Hi All,
Is it mandatory to share the aadhar card and pan card details even before the interview or the profile to be shortlisted. Some of the consultancies ask for it, I wanted to understand your experience. Please let me know.

like

Hey is any Realtor or Listing agent or an Experienced persons free for the weekend for 3 hours quick job to get paid some cool Sum of $$? Then Quickly send a DM for more details .

like

Hello,

I am an instructional Designer with 5 YOE. I have two offers with me. One offer from TIAA,Pune and other from Infosys. Both the companies are offering same salaries. Please give your opinion and help me choose best of two.

Thanks in advance.

How does your significant other handle your relapse? I’m 5 years sober overall but relapsed / slipped recently and my spouse isn’t speaking with me. I know alcoholism is hard on loved ones but I’ll do your spouse cut you off? How to deal with it?

like

I can’t eat anything unhealthy without feeling like I need to work out more afterward to balance it out. This mindset has gotten so bad recently and I don’t know why it’s gotten so much worse

like

Something I used to do with my father before he died was fixing his home garden. Thanks to that now whenever I get a new property to sell I dedicate myself to fixing the garden before showing it, I learned to do it very fast and very aesthetically. Have you ever fixed houses by yourself to improve sales?

like

For consulting. If my base Location is Kolkata i will shift there right? I saw a thread we need to go to a functional office. I'm worried. I have already planned. I'm shifting next month

like

Any recs for new or under-the-radar finance blogs, books, programs, etc. to read/watch while isolating at home? I think I've read everything on my usuals list. Nothing to do but work more...

like

The SA that I was working with at one luxury store has been really unresponsive (5 days before responding; I’d always have to text first to check in). I ended up finding someone else at a different store who’s been amazing; do I owe the first one an explanation? Should I tell them I found someone else? Don’t want to jeopardize my relationship with Cartier or string anyone along, but not sure if there’s standard etiquette here.

like

Additional Posts in Staying Healthy

How much did you give up on alcohol in order to have a healthier life? At what age?
If not 100%, how frequent is it “worth it” for you to have alcohol at the expense of some level of hangover?

like

What time do you wake up and what time do you sleep?

like

Is there a real difference between a $150 and $1,500 office chair? Want to prevent myself herniating my discs but also get something sustainable and built to last.

like

I know staying fit can be difficult, especially as we get older, but I look up to my firm leadership and almost none of them have what I would consider a healthy physic… is this the life I’m headed for too?

funnylike

I can’t eat anything unhealthy without feeling like I need to work out more afterward to balance it out. This mindset has gotten so bad recently and I don’t know why it’s gotten so much worse

like

I found out today that someone I know (mid 20s), seemingly healthy, very active, etc. got diagnosed with cancer.

At what point / how do people even realize something is wrong? I sometimes get worried when I have random body aches or head aches now.

like

I recently installed a ballet barre in my basement and was curious if anyone knew where I could find barre workouts? I can only find at home ones that don’t require a barre

like

Are any of you also constantly tired despite getting an avg of 7 hours of sleep a night ? I wonder if it’s the job taking a toll or the constant flying

like

Hitting the early morning yoga.

like

I have been digging into health since I was 23 and 337 pounds. I am 45 and maintaining a 173 pound weight loss. The two most profound books I have discovered about the science of weight are Drop Acid by Dr David Purlmutter and Nature Wants Us To Be Fat by Dr Richard Johnson. I strongly suggest either picking up one or the other or both. I fished both via audio book and will be buying the hard copies to mark up/post it note and keep forever.

Post Photo
likesmart

Can you share your best smoothie recipes? I bought the Superfoods skinny protein powder & the green powder.
Would like to drink smoothie either after workout or a heavy snack replacement.
Want recipes pls

like

Will a pinched nerve under your shoulder blade, and elbow ever get fully recovered? Has anyone's? As long as I continue to stay working in tech on the computer, I feel like it's just gonna stay this way. Hate to even think this, but I feel like I might need to step away eventually. Even with PT for the last 3 years, I'm still in pain, numb and uncomfortable. On weekends now, I'm intentionally staying off the computer and my shoulder is less tight, but once M-F comes around, it's a cycle

like

Any runners here do pilates? Was thinking about doing solidcore to help strengthen up and wanted to know people’s experiences. Is it challenging enough? (Male, 24 y.o. for reference )

like

I eat healthy pretty consistently, but have also tried to cut down on calories in an attempt to lose weight. I see the weight loss SLOWLY happening but I keep thinking about food all the time and it makes me unhappy that I have to restrict my intake. Does it get easier to eat “less”?

like

I wish I could do a poll!
Neutral runner needing a bit more comfort. I love my ASICS DynaBlast but want to switch it up!
Brooks Ghost 13 or HOKA Clifton 7? 🏃🏻‍♀️
Thank you!

like

I found a group of online trainers called Transform4Ever started by Erin Dimond and a group of specialists on nutrition, gut health. I’m not able to find any reviews other than their website. Anyone have any experience with them?

like

One weekend of warm and sunny weather in Chicago confirmed my seasonal depression. Feel better today than have in 6 months. Have a great week Fish!

like

Who has the best corporate rate for Equinox in NYC and wants to refer me?!

like

There’s a Pasta Challenge in the hashtag MoskowitzCooks bowl right now. Winner gets a $25 e-gift card to Eataly! Last day to enter your dish is this Friday at 11:59 PM pacific time. Come join the fun! You might win! 😁

Post Photo
like

Which Fitbit do you have? Need to replace mine…

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal