I’m going to save a lot of people a whole lot of pain and time.

THIS is your rubric for weighing offers:

…McKinsey > BCG > Bain
…EY > Deloitte > PwC > KPMG
…MBB > FAANG / MAANG > Big 4
… Big 4 > Lower tier consulting companies (e.g., Accenture.)
… Industry C-Suite Executive > Consulting
… Consulting > Fed, state, local Government (all levels)

You’re welcome!

Post Photo
likefunnysmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

This is lovely BS

likefunnysmart

I mean the only time we talk about mck it’s always to roast their ethics

like

At OP, you are more than welcome to feel better than me, but please have my comments turned around before the next steeco, tks!

funny

Absolutely!

like
Recent IconRecent

Deloitte > Harvard > Accenture > MBB > KPMG > Tier2 > Big 4(-2) > Tier3

Source: Fishbowl, a Glassdoor Company; Glassdoor; POOMA Pro Database; McKinsey & Company analysis; Public Information

funnylike

I added pooma as a new source so not exactly the same

like

Somebody give this man some work to do 🙄

like

Cries in low rent consulting 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣.

funnylike

You should’ve kept it😂😂😂

funny

Really don’t think we should be generalizing this way. At the end of the day - we should encourage people to choose what works for them - that sets them up well to be successful and fulfilled. These forced rankings and cookie cutter choices are the reasons for people getting depressed and becoming dissatisfied with their jobs

likesmart

McK2 obviously wasn’t a part of the hiring decision for OP. Well said

like

OP the kind of guy to only talk about work at happy hours and on dates

likefunny

Except this is worse than talking about work…

like

Why is EY top among Big 4?

like

@P1, OP meant EYP and not EY. Apologies on OP's behalf

Why do people care about this so much lol I work at KPMG and get paid very well I could give a F if it’s not top tier 😂

like

A little.

In the US by far especially for mba recruiting Deloitte > PWC > EY > KPMG

like

Source: McFirm analysis

likefunny

Apparently McKinsey’s recruitment quality fell

likefunny

Some guy who sold his crypto for $100MM after living in his parents basement for 29 years > any consulting job

likefunny

Uhhh you forgot tier 2 (OW, Kearney, LEK, S&, etc.). B4 is really tier 3

like

Why the heck is faang lower than MBB?

like

I would say that makes sense coming out of b-school (which is an additional 2+ years on top of the time it takes to make partner), but even PM salaries can make around that much with a similar level of exp (9 years of consulting vs. 10-11 years as a PM) and much better wlb. If you’re a data engineer or a data scientist (common tech exit after consulting at least at D), you could stand to make more. Technical skills will always trump general consulting skills in terms of comp, no matter at what level.

So Deloitte > Accenture… according to you?

like

Of course

And it’s not according to me, it is according to objective analysis and fact based reality.

funnylike

Wow that world seems overly simple. And very US centric 🤠

like

Meaning I live 3 days longer than you. Not well played😭

like

You think mckinsey is top? Not in South Africa - we don't like people who enabled state capture

likefunny

I would say something about South Africa, but it would be a violation of Fishbowl community guidelines

like

We really didn’t ask for this, I want my time back

likefunny

I’ll send you an invoice

likefunny

As a BCGer I can agree that Mck > BCG. Lets stop bsing ok.

funny

Agreed. That’s among the few bits that weren’t lovely BS.

like

Related Posts

Did anyone recently receive an offer letter from deshaw hyderabad?

like

What is the hierarchy structure in Bank of America for Investment Banking division in India?

like

Hi guys how's work life balance in EY India in technology line? What is the average working hours during normal times and peak season? I would be really glad if someone can help me with this! Thanks!

like

It’s funny how it’s only big 4 consultants selling right now🤷🏿‍♂️

Looking to make a change from Canada (Toronto) to Dubai. Any thoughts or Big4 Cloud Consulting roles in the ME? Deloitte is generally the global leader. Any thoughts on Digital/Cloud Transformation in MENA?

like

Hi fishes, how many days will it take for wipro to release fnf settlement from last working day??

like

Just got a job offer as a bench applications analyst. Looking for an insight into the company! TIA

like

Hi,

Hows the mastercard joining process? Is it virtual or we need to be present at base location?Thanks

like
smart

Any thoughts on Strategy& and their life sciences team? How is the reputation in comparison to Life sciences focused places such as LEK, ClearView, ZS, IQVIA, etc? How is the WLB? And what is the compensation for a senior associate?

like

What is bench policy of mphasis?

like

How is mphasis jpmc client

like

What’s the salary range for Manager role with 14 YOE .NET in PwC AC Bangalore?

like

Hello All

How's job security, work life balance, work pressure, work environment & Salesforce testing projects at Brillio?

like

Hi,

Any idea about the C&SP department in comcast? working culture, WLB and all..

I was selected in Comcast for a developer role.. Will Comcast provide work from home?

so if anyone knows about that please share your thoughts.

like

Have a formal offer at Citi for 120K as an AVP in the NY office. Currently making 92K at my current role where I feel there’s not much room to grow anymore. Is this a fair offer? I currently WFH pretty much full time at my current role which has been amazing, but it seems like Citi would require me to be there 2-3 days in the office per week - and this is something I’m very hesitant about. Thoughts on how to approach this?

like

Hey Guys, does anyone know if jp has plans to call people to office full time from next year? I have my joining date as 1st November and want to know if they’ll continue with the hybrid model or no?

Helo everyone, I had an interview scheduled with Cognizant on last week of Jan 2022 but due to technical error in Verification code I couldn't join interview lobby. I reported the same to the HR and I was told the interview will be rescheduled. Now there's no update from the HR. Could you please guide me how can I proceed or any email address to which I can inform to take the rescheduling process further.

Thanks in advance

like

More Posts

Hello, I'm a business analyst in retail banking domain, currently holding an offer at IBM, Virtusa and NTT DATA out of which the highest package is NTT DATA. Virtusa and IBM giving the same fixed component whereas in addition Virtusa provides 10% variable
Kindly suggest which offer to take up and suggest me based on your experience

My YOE : 5.5 years

As three of them provides me the same roles, not able to decide which one to go-ahead with

like

Any thoughts on PIC? The stock rose significantly in after hours on news of XL fleet merger. Does it still make sense to invest in it at ~$18?

like

Is it wise to buy a home now with high interest rates in nj or would it be wise to just wait and see? Looking to buy a house in central NJ

like

Can’t wait to move to Dallas area. Flower Mound is likely our first choice. Getting out of Chicago for better schools without dominant unions, low taxes, and better public safety

like

Hi,
I have got an offer from JPMC and I have another counter offer . Just wanted to understand if there is any probability for the JPMC offer to be revoked if I am renegotiating with them? Also, how many days before my LWD should I ask for renegotiation?

like

Hi,

JPMC call candidate with 3 months of np for interview and expected CTC for 3.6 years of experience with techstack as java fullstack?

Hi NYC female fish! Room available in our apt for 12-month sublet beginning 8/1. Midtown east (57/3) in doorman elevator laundry building, $1350 monthly rent. PM me if interested!

like

Need advise. Looking for a bar to watch FIFA finals. Vive la France!!

likeuplifting
like

Amazon Bangalore Hiring for EM

Post Photo

Hi Fishes,

Please help me out with the below query on Salary.

My Current CTC is 11.21 LPA (9.6 Fixed + 10% Variable)
Domain: Salesforce
Total YOE: 4
Relevant in Salesforce: 2.5

I have an offer from Optum (UHG) for:
16 LPA Fixed + 10% Variable + 2.5 Lakhs Joining Bonus

Can you please help me out whether this is a good offer as per my experience.

like

IDFC FIRST Bank

I got an offer from MBRDI and IDFC first bank.

MBRDI is giving x and 1.5 joining bonus

IDFC it's giving x + 5, 3.30 Varible and 1 joining bonus..

Which one should I join?

like

What is the best way to search for remote job openings in the IT sector in Canada provided you already have a PR and everythg is legal

like
like

I have been working as technical customer success manager from last 2 years and worked as Business analyst for 1 year. In total I am holding an experience of 3.2 years. I am good with SQL, Advanced Excel, Google Data Studio, Tableau, Google Sheets, Power Point, Jira, Asana etc.
I am looking for a remote opportunity for the role of Data Analyst / Business Analyst. That would be great if you can help me find any such roles.

like

Just started at A.T. Kearney. Which benefits should I be taking advantage of?

So… 3.5 year relationship came crashing in Jan due to covid depression, work burn out, lockdown etc. We have stayed in contact and recently he has come around to apologizing and considering getting back together. However he also revealed he started seeing someone casually 4 weeks ago and technically is cheating on her by meeting me for coffee and to discuss this. I’m upset that he’s dating others but shouldn’t be right? I mean, I did the same. Still hurts though. And I told him to sort that out

like

Is there any chance we can change the domain we are working in?

like

Hi all🖐️
Recquired assistance regarding job referals for python developer. I tried much, But unable to get single interview to prove myself.
Please help me out🙏🙏🙏

like
like

Additional Posts in Consulting

is $500 for a used aeron good or should i keep searching?

like

If I just chill on the bench for long will I still only get fired at the end of the year?

like

how do you resign an offer and what are the consequences? i’m resigning for personal reasons, never thought this would happen to me. help please

likehelpful

Any book recommendations for philosophy, psychology, and business? Or any book you read last year changed your values? Going to fly international, gonna read it on flight. 😍

like

Houston downtown JW vs Westin.. Thoughts?

like

EY fish - when you are laid off, is it immediate the day you're told or do you get a little warning?

like

Is staying for 18 months as an experienced hire long enough? Want to move to a new location out of my region for personal reasons - don’t care about industry vs consulting

like

I’m currently on pace to be just shy of having enough stays/nights to keep Hilton diamond for next year. Would there be any red flags if I were to stay in one hotel mon/tues and a different one wed?

like

Working at Deloitte soon! I read the benefits but I’m still a student and don’t really understand what benefits are good and just mediocre. Is the benefits and rewards at Deloitte ACTUALLY good? Any tips to maximize on the benefits? Advice for a new grad hire plz 😭

like

When putting in notice, do you set up calls with your MD and manager separately? Or both on the same call?

On the beach for a short bit so no meetings set in a usable timeframe. I have a good relationship with both but they usually aren't on the same calls. Oh, and before anyone says to do it over email, and I've already decided to do this over a call. So let's leave that out of the way.

like

Working for Deloitte. To preface I’ve been an FTE at large insurance/healthcare companies for over 10 years. In process of interviewing for a “Senior consultant role” location TN recruiter is asking for salary but won’t tell me what range is. Can someone provide me a ballpark figure working in cloud. Also would you consider this a step up career wise? I’m currently a EUT Architect

like

What industries are good for stability and lower stress?

No snark, please. I’ve had some health issues come up and was told to find a lower stress environment.

like

EY, I got my Roth IRA contributions set to max (30%). Does Fidelity automatically lower the % and stop contributions afterwards once I reach my 2022 limit?

Also at Deloitte, I had a couple thousand contributed in the beginning of the year. Does EY's 401k keep track of that as well towards the limit?

funnylike

Definitely not a fan of Westin's "Eat Well" proposition. I'm working in the room at 2:00 AM and the most appetizing menu item is a cold turkey avocado and arugula wrap. I just want a burger and fries!

like

What do you do when you’re on the bench and your next project starts in 2 weeks?

like

Bucks in 6.

like

Hey 🐠, what are your recommendations of books, articles, or practice tips to improve communication, both verbal and written? Want to be stronger at running meetings, pitching ideas, writing (cont’d)

like

Bench time done right:
Camper van + cell signal booster + (nearly) unlimited battery power + National Parks pass = gorgeous “home office” views

Post Photo
like

Say new joiner bonus is $10k and you're paid 1/12 of this amount each month beginning on your start date. Then you quit after month 6. Do you have to pay back Accenture the GROSS amount of the bonus?

like

Top consulting firms right there!!

Post Photo
funnylike

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal